I often think the best way to fix my music is to turn off my DAW, stop writing, and throw my PC in the bin. 😂 Then watch some more of Guy’s videos, learn some more, and then plug it back in and try again. And again. It’s a continuous learning process. Grateful for these sort of videos, I learn so much!

I’m always very impressed when people who are very capable of producing something great deliberately and intentionally produce something convincingly rubbish

Very useful, as always. Thank you. Users of Cubase (and, I believe, Studio One) would benefit greatly by marking the chords with the "Chord Track", instead of the Marker Track. This would allow them to have their midi notes coloured as "chord note", "scale note", and "neither" (or something like this). An optical aide for their ears.

My biggest problem: I buying gears, apps and virtual resources - but not using any of them, just looking new gear.

It's always so encouraging to watch Guy doing what he does best ! Keep it up Guy !

I prefer chord track in Cubase. Anyway you did a good job with Arnolds tune 😍

Sorry for Arnaud, but I had a big laugh at the beginning 😂. But you turned it into a majestic tune quickly. Well done mate 👏

Orchestral Bootcamp is back and the new term starts soon. Check out our 8 week course with live events and feedback here: thinkspace.ac.uk/

I hated composition in school and at college. Now at 40 and thanks to advancements in technology Ive grown to love it as a hobby. I think if I had Guy as a teacher I would have fallen in love with it mind!!! 😂😂😂

I do that through-composing thing. Guilty-as-charged! So this video is extremely welcome! :) Now I have some ideas for how to go forward and actually make something better. Also: that tip about using markers to indicate where the chords are is *genius*! Thank you! :)

Thank you Guy, you always inspire us to continue on with music making when we just feel like quitting. Wish I had this kind of training and input years ago. Plus you are very enjoyable to watch.

Great little video here! One of the best pieces of advice I ever got if you want to wonder off in the melody which in some situations you might want to do is to make sure that the melody has the same rhythmic features as the rest of the piece. In fact doing this gets you 50% there. So way if you do decide to go somewhere different it still gives a sense of "okay i'm crossing the road but we are still on the same road going to the same place". In fact in genres such as Jazz, Reggae, Funk and blues where there is a infinite number of things you can play over a progression the feel and rhythm of whatever you are playing is the anchor that keeps the music from falling apart even if you go off and play some crazy scale or wonder off to something not in the key.

I feel like doing bad music is your guilty pleasure , Love your channel thanks for all the usefull tips

I can’t hear accordion without thinking “Paris”. You should have worn a beret and green-screened yourself in front of the Eiffel Tower. Nice work salvaging that piece of music!

I'm so glad to stumble upon your channel.. I recently started entered the world of writing music and now I have a lot of great content to gain insights from here is absolutely incredible 😊

If there's only one takeaway from this video is writing in the underlying chords on a marker track. I feel absolutely lost without this, no matter how simple the progression.

I do my best work when I stop thinking and just let the music flow through my hands onto the keyboard. What's being taught here requires some thought+inspriation+experience. I am working to blend those elements - and make it sound like something that creates an emotional experience. Thanks Guy - your work consistently impresses.

Good video Guy, and it reminds me of two things - know the rules (the difference between discordant and pleasant), and know when to break them (the difference between pleasant and interesting). I think your video focusses on the former, and that's important, because you need a solid base. Anecdotally, I use Studio One, which has excellent chord, arranger, and marker tracks for marking out parts of your song. Great for those of us who work in a more 'traditional' (i.e. not necessarily right or wrong) way.

This is an actual person that Guy deals with all the time... It's me, I'm that person, my music is nothing short of a life altering experience, above and beyond any criticism. I won't even send it in for review, as I don't want to risk literally exploding your mind. 😁

Don’t quit your daytime job just yet Arnold!😊

Love seeing the creative process with the technical bits thrown in. Lovely melody. Thanks!

Superb Guy, thank you very much for sharing. I liked the piece but you highlighted the importance of working together very well here. What I think happened is that Arnold liked his accompaniment then he was thrilled that his melody was starting to fit nicely with the accompaniment but was so overcome with joy he then went on a tangent and that's were it became unstuck. Wrong notes were played and there was no care because he was still reeling with that feeling of oh wow I've created something. I see this with a lot of new bands. They have a great idea there all enthusiastic but they loose track of every one else in the band and all just start pushing forward in their own zones of bliss now oblivious to playing together with any harmony or unison. I liked how you pointed out the timing and removed the random which let's be honest Arnold were blooper notes. But many thanks to Arnold for sharing. I really liked it Arnold. What you could do is take what Guy shared with you, still keep that change you originally had but expand the piece to have an accompaniment that changes with your melody later on. As Guy mentions there are great things happening but there all happening at once oblivious to your wonderful accompaniment. It just needs to be adjusted with the rest of the accompaniment changing when it's time to use the other half of your original melody. Essentially that change was to soon and sounded out of place because of it. That and the blooper notes caused the main issues. Also note how Guy ensured timing on all parts to be in time with your accompaniment. Again, thanks to both of you for sharing.

Thanks, Guy! Yes, it was very basic - but most of the problems with composing really are that simple! I found this extremely helpful because I would have had to listen to Arnold's piece numerous times before I could have told you a fraction of the specifics to why it sounded as bad as it did. If I have something turn out poorly, now I'll have a little checklist to objectively run through to see what went wrong.

Thanks Guy, definitely something I was struggling with after Bootcamp. Hopefully will help.

I love these sorts of videos! I would say thought that I'd love to see more of what you're doing on the piano when you're improvising

The biggest problem I have with my music is that I get sober the next morning ...

By having two time signatures underneath and aligning the melody notes with pauses and changes in note length, you can hide a polyrhythm within the melody. OR If you stick to one time signature or a couple of time signatures, emphasize the off beat notes for a syncopated melody. OR Keep it simple and predictable. They're all good depends on what the picture is accompanying the music.

The biggest problem with this channel is, that it always leaves me with a feeling how much there is I still have to fix ;)

Arnaud had me laughing through this! Good video, thanks. I absolutely second your opinion of a marker (or chord) track, I find it hugely useful when needing to figure out where a melody should go next.

Thank you Guy for good tips and tricks.

At last someone talks about the real problem with the music.. Thanks.👏

Thanks for sharing, great advice, kudos! I still remember the advice my music teacher once gave me, he said, "As a beginner, compose freely but stay in one key, and only change into another when you outsourced the first one." and on the matter of melodies and harmony, "studie the works of Mozart, as he wrote great tunes."

thank you that was quite eye opening, now I need to go revisit stuff and put this into practise ❤

I like the Big Ben citation of the last clarinet intervention… lol… Thanks for an other fun vid!

I love you Michelmore 😊

It's me. Arnold is me

Glad you're ok

Good demonstration from bad to good. I wanna be so bold and add that when producing music, one should always be willing to evaluate the choice of instruments a while into the project. Time to evaluate the squeezebox :). It's a very hard instrument to fit with others at times, and it's obviously entirely subjective, but I'd see if there was another instrument that would do the piece more justice. :)

When particle physicists write music. Smashing bits together

I take your point about the melody...no breathing spaces. But there is a certain (simplistic) "niceness" to it. I would love it if rather than completely redo the melody, you could suggest ways of modifying the Harmony to suit the (slightly adjusted) tune... 1.31 OUCH!! A mis-typing, surely lol

Music composition is no different than writing. Your first draft will be crap. It's in the revisions that it will improve. Even the "jams" have some degree of working out =]

lol..hahaha...You make my day Dude. You are talented and also a good actor.

Sound advice as always but, again as always, I come away with a highly persistent ear worm. However, I think I've found the solution, and in future I'll watch your videos with the sound off😁 Might make things a little more difficult to follow, but at least I'll be able to whistle me own tunes for the rest of the day🤣

Thanks Guy 😎🤗

0:38. Brilliant. Arnold reminds me of Grytpype-Thynne, the notorious cad from the Goons :)

i'm a fan of the click, actually. it has my support :)

Awesome, Wish you could fix a track of mine one day too, love you, Guy! :D

The key (pun intended) thing with music for me is its similarity to mathematics. It is about patterns. That first melody was dire indeed because, as you rightly point out, it was meandering about and going absolutely nowhere. The important thing being that I could HEAR this and know. I often find myself just noodling about and I almost always find myself repeating patterns of notes that sound good to my ear. I then find myself thinking "how can I rearrange these patterns of notes to make interesting variations?" I'm pretty sure a lot of the great composers did this very same thing. A good example for me being a theme (pattern) in the 1st movement of Mahler's 1st Symphony where, as I hear it, I automatically find myself singing "Ging heut’ morgen über’s Feld, Tau noch auf den Gräsern hing" from his "Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen". You then hear Mahler playing with this pattern a lot for the rest of the movement. Mathematics - patterns of numbers. Music - patterns of notes. Not that I could ever put myself in the same league as Gustav Mahler, whose work I admire enormously.

Ha this made me chuckle!

Hi Guy. Do you ever review the works of followers? If so, I'd love your feedback on an idea I followed through to completion. Its radical by your standards. SciFi sound a whole story.

En general, creo que bien tocado no sonaría mal lo primero, excepto el compás 8

Hey Guy, just wondering why you switched to the Arturia keyboard over the NI keyboard?

4:33 Thomas Newman disagrees ;)

It's not dissonance. It's a feature.

this must be a advertising joke 😂😂😂😂 no one send you that crap 😂😂😂 a solo part from an harmonika-no way 😂 but i liked it. great vid. you are a great entertainer

First time I've seen the sunglasses of complacency!

Sorry, could not watch this video all the way through. Drove me crazy!

The problem is clearly that Arnold either don't have a good ear or education of harmonies. The clashing is easy fixed to modulate the left hand (piano) arpegio to fit into the melodie. But darn we need to come up with more chords than 2 or 3 .. those are hard to remember 🤣 Maybe a psychologist or pills against split personalities would help too .. lol Always a good day when Guy posts a Video 😘

You're a damn evil genius! Poor Arnold! 😂😂😂

Off to do some corrections now. I may be some time.🤔

Worth noting that when you move the tracks to add the intro the markers are all off. 🤔

The progression reminds me a bit of Hello Again by Neil Diamond.... sort of. If you cover most of one ear and hum a bit. lol

3:49 I need to work on the "good cop" voice tbh🙃

Great 👍

Good vidéo.

How can i send my music in for feedback?

Most "modern" people have the newest plugins and expensive sample libraries but they produce a LOT of boring garbage... You dont need much to compose great music! Its way better to compose at first with piano e.g. and check if it works.

There's another problem. The lead sound is quite strident and not in tune with the piano. Flute or clarinet might work better.

I just can't get onboard with that first critique of the non-chord note 😄 Like yeah I hear the dissonance, but it sounds interesting on piano. The rhythm and sound pallet are boring enough without trying to avoid any kind of dissonance. It's more just the instruments and rhythms and decays and voicings combined are so done to death that they sound cliche' and childlike.

kudos to you for committing to the whole sunglass swapping thing

are your sure it wasn't composed by the great Les Dawson?

I know whats wrong.... Accordian to my analysis, it seems to me.....

It's not wrong, or disharmonious - it's just more advanced harmony! It's more Jazz, Guy!

Wow. How you made that 'edible' is amazing.

sounds a little bit like carol ann's theme from poltergeist, the piano part on it's own

Melody should work if they had a rhythm and pattern.

Needs a bass line.. 👍😎

1:02 was it Arnold Schwarzenegger ? 😂😂😂😂😂😂

I'm sorry guy but I just don't like the sound of the acordion. I would be hard pressed to fit that into any mix. The sample sounds horrendous. To my ears it's been sampled wrong. It's out of tune

Alright, I already know the drill with these videos...

"Carling Black Label".

Please post more rubbish music it does wonders for my confidence.

this clueless lack of taste happens with composers that input notes direct on computer but never play them on keyboard, but principally those who never readed enough music with an instrument

I think Arnolds biggest problem is that he sent in MIDI files instead of audio. 😂

Would love to get your take on the 3 body problem theme music - kzfaq.info/get/bejne/adCgfsdemdPFnoU.html you can hear it's breaking some rules in a clever way, but I'd love to understand what the composer is doing. Thanks guy!

Not easy for a pro to write a really dodgy piece of music .. well done Arnold 🤣🤣

OK, the main theme isn't fine with chords on left hand. You teach to share a piece of music in little successive regions, one after or above the other. For a few musicians like me, it's not natural. I don't know musical theory like you, and it's exclusive to english musicians : In France, I don't learn music with A, B, C, D, ... notes but with do, ré, mi, fa sol, ... . We do not say 1/4, 1/8, 1/16 but croches, double-croches, ...For stranger musicians, english notation is not easy, it creates difficulties because before playing a note, it needs to think "A is la, B is si, G is sol, ...". It needs more thinking transposing. And imagine for an indian or chinese musician with different tonal scales ! Even in Ireland, it is different : the uillean pipe has his own tonal scale as in Spitfire Labs free instruments . Otherwise, a lot of musicians sometimes prefer playing, recording only a main region on one track of many minutes. Why not ? I know and listen many of them in their own KZfaq channel. And you know, it's in the same time easy and difficult. After recording other tracks, it's easier and shorter to change a few notes or the volume, or the modulation of some tracks to make a fine music, surely different of your. You have your method to erase the problem, but there may be other ways ... Thank you.

A harmony that isn't right is not a harmony... if you know what I mean. 😎

That is not, by any means, my problem dude. I’m great at specifically that. My problem is these clickbait titles that are meant to get people to click out of fear that their skills are not “good enough”. To be honest I think this is beneath you and your quality. Looking forward to more positive titles like “How to approach one of the most common difficulties in writing music”.

😂

Guy, as a clarinetist, please don’t use this clarinet))

It's really easy to make stuff sound off. And it takes a brain to fix it :`(