And ROTS cgi wasn't bad by any means. This might be the best animation for a show I've ever seen

BronicornDude I was legitimately thinking the same thing

First four were also great

Currently it's not known when that takes place nor what planet it's on, it could be hoth for all we know and it could be after the rebels had fleed from the planet in ESB

@@Supersonicspyro Actually, judging from his lightsaber and his red lenses, I believe this takes place in between the first Vader Marvel comic series and Rebels, closer to RotS, where it would make sense for him to go looking for surviving Jedi and Ashoka.

@@Supersonicspyro It's not Hoth. It's the moon the Venator crashed on. Hoth is always icy, while that moon has seasons it seems.

a star wars movie with a post credit scene sounds pretty baller

Episode guide on starwars.com says years

Oh yeah yeah x3

Same

It rhymes

@@somename2803 And not only that, it shows how brillant was Palpatine with his plan. He obviously knew that Maul would try to lure Skywalker to Mandalore, so that's why he ordered his own kindnapption mission to lure Skywalker to "rescue" him and then order him to kill Count Dooku.

Me too and it was A good End for clone wars but order 66 was not so good as i toughz

Same

@@GGStrategicStudies I really want to see Lost Missions 2.

Cody Tschopp me too.

@@goldedrag111 having all of the episodes we could have gotten, like Boba vs Cad Bane, Yuuzahn Vong Scout Ship scouting out the galaxy to see if they are able to invade, not sure how they'd fit Ahsoka teaming up with Jedi and coming across an old sith temple underneath the jedi temple on Coruscant now but yeah, I would love to see a show that covers the inbetween for clone wars and rebels, show how Rex, Wolffe and Gregar all came to be together and remove their chips

pretty much yo!

You fool this guy has 70 alternative devices!!

Darrin Jones I wonder if every channel I watch is run by him then.

@The Eyes Of A True Demon well at least the mandalorian was a success

@The Eyes Of A True Demon when vader said "then you will die" this was my reaction: lie down, try not to cry, cry eternally,

Alex Souster no the movie is shit

Alex Souster the writing and the some of the actors is shit

Alex Souster It could be reworked and have a better script written. It was a good idea, but the storytelling could’ve been done better, and overall the dialogue and acting could be refined as well. The prequels had a solid idea, but poor execution the way I see it.

Fire Nation Soldier definitely

Yes and no.... It would be better if their was some thing in the clone wars after the event of 66 that explains what happens to the Bad Batch, Echo (since he doesn’t have his chip nor does Bad Batch), how Ashoka found a Grey Jedi and how the clones found each other in Rebels

I have a playlist of other people’s videos on my channel called “SW3: RotS Extended” that has the movie + Siege of Mandalore + deleted scenes + novel scenes and other stuff to make it feel like a big ass Clone Wars episode, if that might suit your fancy 😂

I wanted to see ROTS redone in the clone wars series tbh

@@morsecode980 where can I get this

I’m trying to edit it and can send it to you if ya want

@@josephwohnoutka7492 yes please

yay lol, I did that just for you then :D

How did you do the Aurabesh glitches into the Alphabet? I would love to know how you did that.

I'm sorry to be the turd in the punch bowel, but I really kind of hated that. It goes very much against the grain of traditional Star Wars, the style of which both ROTS and Clone wars adhere to. That effect much more than the switching between live action and animation, really takes me out of it and feels fan-y. Nor do I think that the addition of the clone wars material would make the story too hard to follow that such location subtitling is necessary.

I thought it was a nice touch that the letters in Mandalore were done in the style of the title card from _The Mandalorian._

It really does turn an already sad movie into just the most depressing thing ever

@@carlycrays2831 Order 66 never used to bother me, seeing the 501st storm the Temple never used to bother me..but hell..after TCW, I felt like bawling.

It really does. I’m making my gf watch SW chronologically and order 66 hit her a lot harder bc what the clones and Jedi like Kit Fisto and Plo Koon meant to her

Danny Cali why do you think so? Feel like it’s been established since 05 that the film takes place over a few days to one week. One example of why this is the case is that they used the same pregnancy prop for Padmé throughout shooting- two babies would grow a lot in a few months

Ya although the timeline seems a little bit loose, (especially when Padme seems to suggest she's just realized she's pregnant at the beginning) I agree think RotS is actually better if you assume it's not more than a few days. Would Obi-Wan really take weeks to locate General Greivious? Would Anakin by spying on the Chancellor for months? I overall prefer the Clone Wars Retcon.

I kinda like that it takes place over a few days. Everything happened so quickly with the Jedi masters all scattered. Once Grevious is dead, it’s where the shitstorm comes suddenly and everyone is caught off guard.

Christopher Lai well how long did it take the US to find Osama Bin Laden... a long time or how long did it take the Allies during WW2 to get to Hitler finally. Those things take time. The scale of the clone wars took over 3 years up to the beginning of the movie. It makes sense the movie takes longer. It just doesn’t make sense to me that Anakin is happy and giving Ashoka lightsabers and then a week later killing younglings. It would make more since if he saw Ashoka then went back to courasant and was given that assignment to spy on the chancellor and Anakin did that but spent a lot of time with the chancellor(much of it being off screen) over the course of many months which led him to choose him over mace windu and everyone else in that moment.

You can't compare like that. They have hyperdrive, bio-scans and whatever the information the force gives them. If it were really months, I doubt the council would not act against the chancellor. Also, they put themselves in a vulnerable spot by scattering the council to different planets. Palpatine probably took advantage of the scattered council, Yoda in Kashykk and Obi-wan not with Anakin, to bait whoever's left in coruscant to arrest him.

iTzRichards AKA i was not privy to Kathleen’s plan. Turning Star Wars fans against it, genius

Because Dave Filoni is not a studio executive.

GameStation3 he should be though

@@lunarian9877 I don't think he'd be capable of it.

@@gamestation2690 Forget capability, it would interfere with the work he is giving us. The quality would probably lower, even if only a little bit.

And just add Clone Wars movie into Episode 2 Attack of the clones(after ep 2 is done of course). And it is perfect. I really mean it. Maybe I am wrong. And also battle of Coruscant from Clone Wars 2003 into Episode 3. Perfect story

Biggs2Loose link?

Biggs2Loose Thanks!

it's totally fucked. I just went for the spread it out as much as still makes sense with the cross-references - so the pacing is half decent during a watch.

@@MrRazNZ We have no idea how long Ahsoka was hiding. In the show, it was like 2 minutes for pacing but we don't know

@@MrRazNZ I think she buried her sabers as Vader had his legs cut off personally. As Anakin "died", Ahsoka "died" too.

Well wasnt the Vader scene like a year later

I think it makes sense to prioritize the pacing. The audience should be treated with some respect to put the pieces together and imagine different scenes running at the same time.

And the time when Ahsoka and Rex were finding the bodies and giving the proper burial might took place the same time as the duel on Mustafar

They didn’t use ahsoka hearing Anakin Cut windu arm off. WOULDVE lined it up better

@@primecoconut4204 That could actually work if you were trying to edit the two things together.

Until episode 8 and 9 ruined it, tbh 7 feels decent after I saw 8 and 9

it's fine, Ahsoka and Maul sense it 'after' it happens.

MrRazNZ I’m pretty sure Ahsoka senses it as it is happening

yea pretty sure both maul and Ahsoka are sensing it as it happens or a few minutes after cool video but I think it may be off on some points

Agreed. You stuffed up a few times. But I was really enjoying the idea of this video. Also, Ashoka's decent on Mandalor occurs the same time as the attack on the Invisible Hand.

Ahsoka timing is when she sensed Anakin chopping Mace's hand off That's when everything began

Plus 2003 clone wars clips that fit cannon and bad batch ep 1 stuff

Or, right after Obi-Wan leaves Mustafar.

It's Obi-Wan...? It's shown in the film that Kenobi is the first, what's your argument for Ahsoka?

Mac Darf argument? It ain’t no argument, it’s just a thought. And we don’t see Palpatine say execute order 66 to Cody till anakin starts his march towards the temple with the clones

yeah, jesse said that they were on special orders from lord sidious to kill ahsoka

She was on priority list but Rex resisted long enough to give her a chance to escape

I'd say Obi-Wan was the first one Sidious targeted because he was Anakin's master and could defeat him. Ahsoka was second because she had a close bond to Anakin as well and Maul was with her. Then Yoda and the council members followed by the rest of the jedi.

you got it mate.

Trenton Miller actually that might not be a horrible idea....it would fix the CGI and add voice lines that were never there....but I highly doubt it’ll happen sadly🤧

Spying on your history it would be amazing but your right I wound probably happen 😢

Trenton Miller tbh the clone wars art looks pretty realistic itself so I wouldn’t complain if someone just decided to drop ROTS with clone wars season 7 as a diff part of the movie

Spying on your history I totally agree

@@Dontcrybebetter yeah and don't have to see George's crappy wooden dialogue.

mega.nz/file/2nxA2CqY#tsELqXByhYUn1x8GX07N0QmccyE_WXQNO_h3PbPrXCQ here you go boss

Siddharth Subramanian I sexually identify as someone that thanks you for being the 🐐

Membersonlyvolume69 It’s my pleasure

@@siddharthsub MVP, thanks hoss

yeah agree there are a few more 'creative' places that shorter, more specific video edits could play around with. For this full watch-through I just opted to not break it up too much and try and spread the events out as much as possible so as to not have 20-30m of one before a short scene from the other. Am thinking of doing a more creative take on Windu death/order 66 and possibly an idea around intercutting ObiGrievous fight with AhsokaMaul. All require a lot of work/time however which I'm short on atm!

@@MrRazNZ I've always felt like that scene at the end where Vader, Sidious, and Tarkin are overlooking the Death Star must have taken place months or even years later because the construction looks too far along, but they had to put the twins being placed with their adoptive parents at the end of the movie to just give it a little bit of hope. I do think The Clone Wars epilogue where Vader finds the wreck is years after the Death Star scene. Honestly, I think it's possible that TCW epilogue takes place as late as during Rebels, after he's already sensed she's alive, though most people seem to interpret it to mean that him picking up the lightsaber is his confirmation of her death. I remember hearing in behind-the-scenes stuff that in the original RotS edit, Padme died, then Vader emerged in the suit, as two completely separate scenes, and chronologically, that makes more sense, but for emotional impact and storytelling, the birth/death/suit was spliced together. It also doesn't make much sense, chronologically, that the Yoda/Sidious fight was at the same time as the Obi-Wan/Vader fight, but again, for storytelling and pacing reasons, it made sense for it to be spliced together. Likely the Yoda/Sidious fight took place hours before the Obi-Wan/Vader fight, since Obi-Wan had to actually leave Coruscant to get to Vader, while Yoda only had to head down the street, and it would mean that Sidious would be on his way to rescue Vader that much quicker. I agree, I think it would be interesting to spice together the Maul/Ahsoka duel with the Obi-Wan/Grievous duel, and I think there are a lot of ways you could edit the Windu death/Order 66/Ahsoka's conversation with Rex, etc. Your edit is amazing! The great thing about the two separate, but intertwined, stories is that a lot is left up to our interpretation, and I think Dave Filoni likes it that way.

@@MrRazNZ I watched all of siege of mandalore and RotS yesterday and my only issue was it kind of kills the emotion in the clone graves scene because there's still like an hour left of RotS after it.

yeah haha it's a little janky - I just wanted a subtle way (not split screen comparison) to honour the attention to detail the CW crew put in recapturing the animation in a similar way.

@@MrRazNZ Thats the way I saw it, Good job my dude.

I thought that was the best part

Thought it was the best part lol

I agree, it was the best part of the video

no problem mate

Im Thanos look up rotssiegeofmandalore.edit on Instagram he made it

Thank you sir🙅‍♂️🙅‍♂️

I'll take the entire stock

Thanks!

Glad you enjoyed it!