I was a frequent reader of Taleem o Tarbiyt till my graduation and this podcast reminds me of the feeling i get when I go to buy a new magazine every month with pocket money. Real golden days of our era.

That's why we need to hear from educated people from different backgrounds, the guy is giving a different perspective to life that we were unaware of and some wouldn't even understand what he is saying. Like the noise level thing which exhausts you by the end of the day which you don't feel when you live abroad with lower noise levels.

اردو کا پاکستانی معیشت پر کتنا گہرا اثر ہے۔۔۔۔ اگر نظام تعلیم اردو میں ہو جاتا ہے تو اس کا اکانومی پر کتنا اثر پڑتا ہے۔۔۔ کمال وضاحت کی سر رضوان سعید صاحب نے۔۔۔ تازہ ہوا جھونکا ہیں ایسے لوگ ❤ خدا انہیں کامیاب کرے اور ان کے معاملات میں آسانیاں پیدا فرمائے آمین

It was a kind of really good conversation. I like his thoughts and sense of explaining questions from different perspectives. Although he lived 10 years of life in the Western world, still his thoughts are giving importance to our culture, language, and education system. These kinds of personalities should be given space in our country for improvement. Thankyou Junaid bhai for this conversation.

Salaam from Canada, Very fruitful conversation. I really appreciate all the efforts of both gentlemen. Keep up the good work!

Love you Junaid Bhai. Happy to see you choose great topic of learning and education. Why do people make negative comments about such such serious issue. The progress of any society depends on the progress of education in that society. Education is the milk of that lioness, whoever drinks it will roar. Love from India🇮🇳

This should have been more than 2 hours. We need this kind of conversations.😊

What an amazing insight about publication business.... I am also involved in same work. I have worked with Rizwan for Kifayat Publications and had a wonderful and professional attitude from them.

I really liked this episode! I am from the land of Urdu (Western U.P.), it's always good to see how far my land has had influence on. Haha. Also, since most of your viewers are from India maybe sometimes ask your guests' opinion on what they think of the Indian system as well(?); I would have personally loved had Mr. Rizwan Saeed talked about India as well when he was comparing the education systems and the school curriculums around the world.

Please do another podcast episode with him. A longer one. I felt so glad finally someone discussed Issues of publishing industry. As an aspiring book author, Please ask the following questions: 1 - Total readership in Pakistan of books other than curriculum and its comparison with our neighborhood countries and whole world. 2 - What are the complete steps to get a writer book published in this country? 3 - is there anything can be done on the public's side to build reading communities and libraries in Pakistan? 4 - As much as I know, there are publication houses in Pakistan too, such as Oxford University press, Liberty, Vanguard etc. Are these publishing houses going into loss? 5 - What's the best business model for any publishing house in Pakistan's context, for publishing English books other than curriculum Thank You

Excellent and sensitive topic .This topic is closer to my heart . As an educationist, I have been advocating it throughout my entire career. It is the dire need of the hour to be indigenous and honour our language .

One of the best Podcast, Juniad Bhai please invite SAHIL ADEEM on your podcast.

I think this episode must be at least 2 hours, I learnt so many things from this episode, love you from india

Good choice of topic. Looking forward to the video! - Big fan from India

Reading Culture is mostly absent in the Indian Subcontinent, more so in vernacular languages In the USA, Andrew Carnegie and Rockefeller ( "Robber Barrons" of 19th century USA) were building public libraries and Cultural centres across the length and breadth of the country (opera House et al) to burnish their image in society, One thing for sure, these changes in culture happen top down rather than being bottom up Elites here are mostly uninterested in these things

Pakistan has more than 70 languages. The language hierarchy is: English first, Urdu second and then the indigenous languages. English and Urdu are already thriving here. We need to give official recognition to indigenous languages and start teaching our children in their mother tongues as recommended by UNESCO.

Such an informative, amazing podcast it was. Thank you junaid bhai for inviting him

Can't wait for the end of the year! I will be shooting my vlogs in Pakistan 🇵🇰 ❤ your VLOGS 🎉 INSHALLAH

always supports you. great podcast ever your big fan from delhi india.

Rizwan sahb ap k mission ko ALLAH kamyab kary. Ameen ❤❤❤

EXCELLENT COURAGE, THANKS.

سعید صاحب سے میرےاچھے تعلقات تھے، میں خود پریس لائن سےہوں۔ فیرئیرمارکیٹ میں میری بھی شاپ ہے اورمیں نےان کےلئےکام بھی کیاہے۔ رحمان صاحب کےبھائی ریحان سےبھی ملاقات رہی

Such an important and relevant conversation. Let’s share this with our friends and communities and beyond. Listening to this with my daughters. Onwards and Upwards Rizwan!

Thank you junaid for giving us such a lovely and insightful conversation.

Thank you Junaid bhai for this amazing talk. ❤

Loved the guest. He needs another invitation.

Sir Please make another Podcast with him He is highly educated and he deeply understands the Pakistani Mindset Brilliant Podcast Incredible ❤❤

It's like he is talking our hearts ...so on point and convincing ...but really need to find solutions and implementation..

I hadn't heard this inspiring and unboxing realities about education system before listening this podcast. i think our teacher should listen this podcast.

We need more conversations like this.

That podcast was really amazing, I learned a lot from it. But the sad thing is that it has only 44K views. I don't understand why Pakistani people prefer watching pointless daily vlogs over informative and knowledgeable content like this... Anyway, it was a really good podcast, and I'm grateful that we have mentors like Junaid Sir, who are knowledgeable and create great content. Thank you so much, Junaid Sir. ❤️🤝🏼

Your podcast's are the only knowledgeable thing in pakistani KZfaq community ❤

Thank You Junaid Akram for inviting educationalist on your show.This is the very first time that I have shared this podcast with my friends and family for the highest number of times. I thoroughly enjoyed listening to every second. I’ve put across my recommendation to you via your Insta account specific to education topic, hope you give it a thought! May you have more strength to share with us many more!

Great discussion Junaid, really eye opening!

*in Data coding India ranked top 4th place where as Pakistan is placed at 4th from last* *Biggest difference in basic education in Asia*

The lack of Reading Culture is also very less in India .. 🇮🇳

Nonihaal used to have special editions on occasions like “Khofnaak Number” which focused on specific genres of stories. Taleem o Tarbiyat was really good. I love reading “Us” magazine that was aimed at youth or teenagers. In the 90s era , we read Inspector Jamshed series or Imran Series etc.

Good Episode but seems too short. Really hoping it would continue for long and even at the end it seemed like rush end by Junaid.

Allaah SWT in se bhatpoor qom ke liay khidmat len aur qubool kerain. Asaani farmain. Like minded log inkay saath jorain. Achi tarbiyat is so evident.

What a talk ... what a discussion 👏 ❤🎉.. but podcast was too short .. wanted to listen him for long .. I was dropping off my daughter at school and (while driving) the podcast started and TBH .. even i had some important work to do but i wasn't able to discontinue this podcast.... Rizwan bhai is a Gem ... all that discussion took me in my childhood when we used to read books Naune'haal, Taleem o Tarbiat etc ... 100% agree with Rizwan bhai thoughts.. Though it'll take time but we need to revive our language and curriculum... Learn from the examples of Germans, Turks, Ianians , Korians, Japanese etc.. They have the education in their own language but they are developed nations and competing the world .. im not against English but our education system has to come up with some solution and work with these brilliant n talented publishers like KIFAYAT 👍.. Lots of Love from Australia 🇦🇺

Uff very very true ye bhai to meri awaz ban gae Allah in ka bhala kare hamre bache to bs maths na parhao bs baqi jo marzi karwa lo or science subjects ko to hum ne English ki trha aik brand bana diya

Too much interesting

Behetreen Podcast!

Very fruitful information and yet can relate to all after assessing what really happening in school system.

Very fruitful sir, Disperately need it.

Bhetreen podcast ganju bhai❤

Can you make another podcast with him , this conversation was attractive and knowledgeable

That’s my chachoooooo ❤❤❤❤

Urdu hamari hi language hai , toh hum hi kamayenge

Great work 👍

One most significant point is the Single Self sovereignt curriculum 📚💥📚

Is it just me who think the podcast ended abruptly. I was enjoying it great episode overall.

sir urdu was born in India koi pakistan se copy nhi kr rha correct your information

Junaid bhai, plz do more podcasts on such topics

As always, great Podcast and look forward to more episodes

One of the best podcasts. Appreciate your content.

شکریہ جنید۔ اس پوڈ کاسٹ کا موضوع بہت اہم ہے لیکن زیادہ گفتگو موضوع سے ہٹ کر رہی۔ بات کتابیں چھپنے کے زوال سے شروع ہوئی اور پھر درسی کتب، نصاب، اور بچوں کی تربیت کی طرف نکل گئی۔ رضوان سعید نے بالکل درست کہا کہ اردو ایک بلین ڈالر انڈسٹری ہے۔ جو کام ادیب آن لائن ایپ کی شکل میں ہم نے شروع کیا ہے وہ دراصل پاکستان کے بڑے ناشران کو کرنا چاہیئے تھا، لیکن اس کا وژن محدود ہے۔ اس وقت اردو کے ایک سیلف پبلشنگ پلیٹ فارم کی اشد ضرورت ہے جو کہ اردو کے ایکو سسٹم کو فروغ دے سکے۔ شکریہ۔ فصیح الدین (ادیب آن لائن)

such an informative podcast!

junaid bhai i love your chennal and your views always very good.. i want you to take my comment in a positive way.. yes humhara har cheze mai pichey ja rha hai per kuch jaga acha b hai plz positive chezo per b video banaye.

When Living in Karachi I was greatly impressed with the India published Computer and Computer Science Books. They were marked as funded by Great Britian for use in India only. Very cheap, but very good. I never thought about this undercutting your Pakistan Publishers. Kinda sad really and I never had a clue. Thanks for this interview.

One can clearly see the difference between Indians and pakistanis in these comment sections of your videos. On one hand we Indians are here appreciating your good content and the worthy knowledge it carries while on the other hand you have your own countrymen making fun of the podcast and being ignorant as hell.

Reading books is one of those things that can’t be replaced by any social network platform, OTT or gaming. When you watch it’s before you but when you read, it’s inside you. It’s much more intimate, it happens in your brain. You feel the author and get a sense of their thoughts behind the book. Language isn’t a barrier for people not to pick any books in their native language. It’s mostly because of lack of content. I am a sucker for fantasy, scifi and progression fantasy. Gimme a good progression fantasy novel, I'd even learn Russian for it. Just because someone likes reading in English doesn’t mean they’d only study foreign literature though there’s nothing wrong with it. I read Ramayana and Mahabharata in English and read P.G.Wodehouse’s books in Telugu and English. I don’t agree schools to have Urdu medium or even Hindi medium. Even with so many English medium schools, the level of English people can speak/write here is so so. Besides one of the major reason for MNCs to hire us south Asians and not others is English. Ditch English as medium, kids will struggle in their careers and studies. What we need are institutions like Goethe Zentrum that promote language. Make an institution, fund writers, make plays on the books, skits on the book, have reading contests, things like these needs to be done. Not pushing down one language down the people's throats. Like India, Pakistan is also diverse nation with different languages and cultures. Sadly they have been suppressed and neglected so much. Pakistan or India has been there only for 75 years or so but our languages and culture thrived for centuries even with all the foreign conquerors.

This Podcast is among one of my favorite podcast of yours Junaid Bhai ❤ Thanks for giving such a wonderful content 😊 Learnt so much things about the education and schooling. WAITING FOR SECOND PART ❤ PS: Please bring the second part of this soon

Hi am shaqi from Amrica that's great episode ever ganji bhai

Soon 1 million in your channel

Allah sehat zindagi day ameen Have a nice day

I use to read gogo and nonihaal in my childhood and teenage life...

Shukriyah.

One of the best podcast I've watched

Why promote negativity about Pakistan always? I live in Canada and let me tell you its not easy you should be encouraging students and people there on how gain skills online and make their life better with smart investments so they can make Pakistan a better country. I live in Canada most of the Pakistanis are living in poverty paycheck to paycheck so it's not glamorous and most of them are not getting jobs easy compared to Indians. I am learning web development in Canada so I can get skills and experience so i can come to Pakistan make a company to make the country and myself prosper. Pakistan Zindabad

Wonderful podcast.

Your podcast are very different I think you are playing your part in developing awareness keep up with the good work.

Sir ap ki teachers training ki baat bari maze ki lagi yahan to local private scls ka ye haal ha k abhi jis bachi ya bache ko matric k papers dilwaen jaen ge usi ko next play ya nursery ki yecher rakh liya jata ha or sab se maze ki baat us bechari ko English to kiya urdu b proper bolna ni ati

Amazing episode

Pakistanis Universities don't even have their own curriculums?? 🤔

Great work. Reading, sports and traveling ( I am blessed enough) remains my hobbies. I enjoy them but as my hair have started to gray I have realized all the positives it sprinkled in to my life and character. It’s sad to see this trend dying in my cousins and younger generations. I have started to see that with wisdom of books the tendency to sell out to populists and ill meaning agendas is tremendous

اردو کی تعریف تو کی مگر انٹرویو کی شروعات میں اردو میں پوچھے گئے سوال کا انگریزی میں جواب دیا ۔ ویسے انسان نفیس معلوم ہوتے ۔

It was so good listening to this podcast

Sir I agree with the point k problem are teachers not students but at many places in sindh specially I have seen the self seated student who comes on daddy money in universities they don't study and since the system in universities is ratta fixation they easily get the degree so what's the difference between that guy who spent 4 years chilling and ratta pass and the one who understands the concepts very well and teachers do prefers that ratta boy and for you info I am a who has dealt with that system in sindh. Did intermediate from here and got into that entry test centre paradox and in university circle. How will you change that in Pakistan this rotten system which easily frustrates a creative mind.

Quality content 💥💥💥💥

Official Language Pakistan ki English thi baki Sindhi, Punjabi.... languages log bolte the to kya jarurat thi Urdu ko North UP & Delhi se utha ke Pakistan ki national language banana ? Local languages pakistani low samjhte h & Ab Pakistan ko Urdu se bhi dikkat hone lagi h kyonki Pakistani ant & culture ko duniya India se jod ke dekhti h kyonki Hindi & Urdu lagbhag same h... Pakistani apne culture ki identity hi banate rahte h jabki khud apni languages hata ke imported language apne upar daal Li..aaj Pakistan me Punjabi bolne Wale India se 4 times h fir bhi Punjabi ko Pakistan se jod ke nahi dekha jata jabki Bangladeshiyon ne Bangali ko apni language bana liya...

Always Good to see your videos sir... I would like to request for your Insights and Opinions on the 'Stock Market' and 'Early Age Investing' as it is in high boom in INDIA. The Youth of both the countries being socially conscious, it would be quite a insightful video. Thanks 🇮🇳

Please Mr. Sardar Daniyal Nasir - (Chief Executive Officer of Portsea Games) ko bulaye apne podcast p

There are alot of talented animators planning to leave Pakistan

36:03 well said sir.

Plz do more on books 📚

34:00 thank you for speaking it so "loud". i always irritated and annoyed by loud noises here in pak. while driving we even keep the ac on during winters because we can not bear the noise out side...

We Pakistanis must work on being taught in our native languages like Punjabi, Balochi, Balti etc. given the right conditions, children can learn up to 6 languages by the time they are teenagers or adults so it won’t be a daunting task to create a trilingual Pakistani society which is fluent and literate in native language, Urdu and English. But the first step to achieving this would be to recognize that although the narrative sold to us is that Urdu is our national language, it is not the ground reality. Every Pakistani must realize his/her right to be given world class education in his/her native language. Not knowing English / Urdu should not be a barrier to achieving big inside Pakistan. Secondly, information and knowledge must be translated into native languages to be disseminated into every household. The child is more likely to absorb the content and carry it forward.

Well that's the thing isn't it Pakistan has not been publishing any resourceful material for the past 70 years.

Good discussion, but you can not force people to leave their culture (sindhi, punjabi etc) and just focus on Urdu.. we should have focused on elevating our cultures rather than making a mix of foreign languages (Urdu / english)

I must say junaid shortened this podcast. Could have been bit longer. He cut his conversation so many times . I am huge fan but this one was different

Bad editing and chopped down into the wrong places. It seems the guest said too much which was not aligned with ganji's version or he was too afraid that people might take it the wrong way

Ye angreez hai ya Pakistani . No urdu Why????

👍👍🤞

Kifayat publisher💥❤️🌹💥

Idhar bus ek hi company ha full enjoyment mode pa ha

Sir❤️❤️❤️❤️

Junaid Bhai please ek podcast Dumb tv k sath kren they're doing really well for poor people and for humanity. Kindly unky sath ek podcast krenn

Books are best friends ♥️

Hmare yaha kaha jata bhasa manav bikas ki pehli sidi he.mijhe ni lagta bollywood me jada urdu he.ha he par mujhe ni laga.kyuki ki bo ham hindi hi mante he or ni bhi kyo ki ye hindustani bhasay he sab mili jhuli.ab ke dor ke bollywood ko dekho to isme har trh ki bhasa sekdo i dian bhasay he.or isi se bollywood bana.or iske gane adhure he kisi bhi ek bhasha ke sath.ise aap sundar khoobsurat rydm banate he.usrdu slow he likh ne par bolne me lajabab.hindi sharp he tej tarrar.ye boli se bhi pata chalta indian tej or satiq bolte he jabki pakistani mujhe esa lagta halke.kafi time lete mene jahatak net par vdo dekhi he.isme aam logo me urdu sahi ni pahuchi pata ni kya baat he.parapne ye sab mis kiya aap hindi se bhi pakistan ko bahut kuch de sakte he.