subscribe if you enjoyed! i have a VERY fun video coming out soon :D

i like to think that dreamXD, an all-knowing god, does NOT know that jack is alive i think jack defying the rules would make him invisible to dreamXD, prolly thinking hes dead even tho he aint

I doubt Kristin would let Jack manifold become a god of death

This was very interesting- but I don’t understand how you always have a theory for dsmp. Like, how are you ok so creative? Truly amazing and you never fail to entertain!

Well the DSMP characters are very complicated so l don't feel like there's gonna be a "100% evil villian that ruins everybodys' stuff and frick their moms while they're at it" type of character again but still, what an interesting theory!

I saw the title of this video and just went: “Yeah. Jack Manifold. Really, did no one else figure that out earlier?” My reasoning (before watching this video) was as following; Jack Manifold keeps being left behind. He’s the ‘loner’ of the SMP, the ‘weirdo’. And what do those people grow out to be? The worst villains. It’s just like Fundy had said: ‘If I can’t make people smile, I will make them cry,’

When I first saw the trailer, i couldnt figure out that it was Jack's voice due to it being distorted, but after i found out that it was Jack, i thought that a big arc is coming which involves him, and as we see each person's line in the trailer- destruction is guaranteed no matter what. And when you mentioned them being related by death, i instantly thought of him not following the canon life system. Finally i can understand lore a bit more, and i cant wait for your future theories!!

Jack has the right influence and views to be a God of Death, I can see that.

This theory is rly great! Keep making banger mr Animagiacian

Yeah, no, Kristin would never let someone as Jack Manifold to be the God of Death. Because she is one :) But I like this video!

Quite the dilemma but I feel like Karl will choose the Egg. If Ani's theory about the In Between is true, then everyone was killed already. Karl by the point that he has to decide will know that it's inevitable that they're eventual deaths will not be peaceful. But, no more people means DreamXD will only function off of the clones. Karl is his only power source. I guess it depends on what learn about DreamXD and his goals in the future but I can see Karl choosing the egg because it's such an uphill battle, especially with the carnage going on in the present

Any dream SMP member : uploads anything that has _any_ connection to Dsmp lore for 10 secs Ani : OKAY HEAR ME OUT- **proceeds to talk for 45 minutes**

it would be interesting if "the other side was a reference to hell" and it would be funny if corpse played the role as devil

I actually have a theory as well... Whenever you make videos you're right so they have to change the lore around it

Dream: ''God damn it, Animagician! How many times should we re-write the plot because of you?! Wilbur, start writing!''

My child just finished watching Karl's stream and wants to share a theory/info !SPOILERS AHEAD! At the end, in DreamXD world, DreamXD says something in Standard Galactic. I translated it and it says, "L DO YOU KNOW SHINIGAMI LOVE APPLES". 'Shinigami are gods or supernatural spirits that invite humans toward death in certain aspects of Japanese religion and culture. Shinigami have been described as monsters, helpers, and creatures of darkness. Shinigami are used for tales and religions in Japanese culture.' (copypasted from Google) . DreamXD is a Shinigami. I don't know what the apple means yet (maybe a god apple?), but keep an eye out for lore relevant apples on the DreamSMP. Also, DreamXD brings up that another time traveler existed and they had memory issues like Karl. The only character other than Karl with memory issues was Ranboo, who, what do you know, died as a direct result of Dream. TLDR; Keep an eye out for important apples and Ranboo was the other time traveler. :]

i’m only 2 minutes in but something just clicked in my head and i have no clue if it’s explained in the video but here we go. i’m dream’s video he said something about how if no one knows you’re dead and you get revived you were never really dead. jack died and got revived and no one knows that. my brain just exploded-

Honestly I do hope Jack gets some spotlight, he's already an interesting enough character, he just needs a chance

Imagine Dream and Willbur going out of ideas and than just watching Animagician for Lore advices

I think I know what Karl chooses to do. I think that he decides to continue time traveling. We see that there are many clones of Karl in the In Between, but none in the Other Side. This leads me to believe that Karl decides to sacrifice himself to save his friends.

Only a min into the vid and dang, can’t wait to see how we got to that conclusion, I love Jack’s lore so I’m excited 😆

Wow. Seriously blow away with how you tie all the loose ends together. Amazing job!

After everything, The real villain was actually.. Animagician 🤯

Wait if Jack is Death, and Sbi is cannon, and Death is Philzas wife, then Jack is cannon Tommy and Wilburs Mother? I pretty sure that’s correct.

I never thought the words "screw you energy" would be used together

Jack deserves to be in the Lore more! Good for him

I really liked this theory! I do have one question about it tho, if DreamXD likes to have repeated deaths, why does the death book he made perma kill someone?

After the first episode of season 2 came out this might be a possibility. Karl was introduced to “DreamXD’s World” which connected the inbetween with the other side and Karl was told he’d have a choice on where he’d like to go and that both places have a demigod or overseer of that place and with the other side being the one karl chose Jack could possibly be the overseer of it since there’s a big theme of fire which Jack is also known for

extremely awesome video as always!! definitely think some of these things are going to be canon in literally 2 days lol

hi! i hope you guys are having a nice day/night!

That maze looks like the sunshine institute from MC story mode. If you didn't know, the sunshine institute was a prison built by an admin in the story mode

3:17 Oh boy. I know that feeling too well 🤣

imagine jacks just the canon robot of himself LOL

At this point i think that the DreamSMP members come to this channel for ideas

Your honestly the only thing keeping me interested in dream smp at this point, keep up the great work!

While personally I don’t think c!Jack would be _the_ God of Death (Kristen already kinda has that role last I checked, though I don’t remember if it was directly stated), some kind of demigod of death would be plausible. It would be surprising enough to the viewers but also kind of a “Damn that makes a lot of sense” thing. Here are some of my predictions for this Tales episode * Have to get out of the maze by a certain time * There are mentions of all the characters that had lines in the teaser (Billiam, Ran, Ranbob, Jack?) * Jack is the creator of the maze * There’s some big monster * Memory loss (not just for Karl but all the characters) * _they come up in an elevator one at a time with no memory of their past and a little bit of supplies only to find themselves surrounded by four huge walls of stone and four entrances to a gigantic maze filled with dangerous creatures and traps-_ Bonus points if their names are written in blood on the wall /j

the theory of jack being the god of death is amazing makes sense and gives amazingness to jacks character but there is one thing you missed mumza. wasnt she the canonical goddes of death (as told in lore by Philza to Ranboo) it would not make sense unless jack either is a sort of "child" or "minion"of mumza or they both could be of some type of race of death creatures i dont have anything to back this up but it would be pretty cool right? if im incorrect about mumza being an canonical character please do tell cuz then this shit can go in the trash

This is a really solid theory! You always get me hooked with these

In George's dream the end crystals were already broken, right, could that have anything to do with the lore?

Jack has had it bad, dream escapes, everybody hates him, and his best friend has "betrayed," him. I feel like this theory is right but also Jack could possibly work with the egg. Also side not what happened to red skeppy?

still can't believe they would write a story so complicated. its sounds incredible and really interesting tho

i totally see what you mean! and im sure Jack actually does has some importance to the future of the smp, maybe he really is the true villain of the dsmp

There is just one problem with this, Bad said that the egg gets power from people losing a canon life, not necessarily completely dying

YOU NAILED THIS! IVE HAD A SIMILAR THEORY FOR AGES IM SO HAPPY THAT YOU MADE THIS VID FRRRR

I just got into the whole smp lore a months ago, I've been struggling to keep up with everything ever since oh my god thanks so much for this!!!

the theorys pretty cool, im not really into the dsmp anymore but your videos are pretty cool (at around 4:14 i find it cool that you can see an outsiders episode [unrealted lol])

ANIMAGICIAN YOU PREDICTED IT YOU MADLAD

So then Mumza has all the power as she is DEATH.

It was just so epic to see Animagician was right after watching The Maze. How?? I love your theories ( **ehem** well it is not a theory but reality now) Ani!!

I love your theory’s. You are the best

Great video, I'm a little happy that some of your theories align with mine

Great video! You pointed out things from the trailer that I didn't see! Also, where is the Best of Animagician 2021 video?

if the inbetween really is from the future, then karl is from the future too, explaining the other karls running around in one of the episodes and why he goes to the white castle after every time trip

4:40 I believe that there has been a time where Karl went to the future. The one with Ranbot seems to be in the future. Seeing how he says that the themed rooms are based off of leaders from the *Past*, Leaders who were Karls friends.

This man should be on the dream smp for the hours of watching these streams and just making these theories. Great video :)

I feel like the theory about dream killing everyone and making the whole smp an ocean is kinda far fetched because I think he’s actually going to die to Tommy or Sapnap by the end of lore.

You hooked me on dimensions. I have a lot of theories on that

Omg the way you literally predicted jack being the overseer

These theories are legit fire

Around 8:35 the music sounds like the home Depot song... I've been on the internet too long

Jack is an overseer but I doubt its actually the character jack. Its just a demigod version of jack like dreamXD is the god version of dream. If you watched the new video where karl goes to dreamXDs world you would understand

THE MANIFOLD GRIND DOESN’T STOP, HES NOW A GOD 👹

Well, you were half right.

yoooo you were right!! Jack is the an overseer of the other side. Also I translated the gibberish DreamXD said in the new Karl stream of the Tales of The SMP, it says "L do you know shinigami love apples". Its a weird thing. It's in the anime Death Note aswell. Dont know if this is a coincidence tho. Jack is also the overseer of the in between

Theory:The leader of The In-between is the future version of Karl trying to stop himself from time travelling

The writers who didn’t make up anything, but see this video: WRITE THAT DOWN, WRITE THAT DOWN

7:40 Wait a dam minute Doesn’t the vindicator thingy in woodland mansions turn blue sheep red? Or the other way around? Maybe I’m grasping at threads but what if it has something to do with/in a mansion???

I'm excited for Tales from the SMP season 2 to start so we can get some more information

@Animagician do u or anyone else think Ranboo was born coz Dream used his Revive Book for the first time on an Enderman? Coz, remember wen Dream used it on Techno he first had to punch/draw blood from Techno before using it? So maybe Dream used his own blood for the activation and then killed an Enderman for the actual reviving, hence the Green eye and blood plus half white and half black skin :-).... just a theory ive been holding onto... i may have mentioned it somewhere in someones comment section last year but yeah, i still think its the strongest argument for Ranboos existence and connection to Dream and y he can hear Dream as a voice in his head and lastly, y he has such a strong attachment to Dream, allowing Dream to somewhat control Ranboo at times even from inside the prison, making Ranboo risk his life setting off TNT while Tommy was visiting Dream amongst other things.... Just saying, maybe its worth looking into :-)

I probably should've watched the whole time travelling lore before, i'm a bit confused :,D Great Vid anyway

Can we just take a moment to appreciate the qulaity fo this video, like its so amazing!

Jack is the god of death, but he got trapped in a cage by a dead endermen

I got very excited when i heard ran because i have a theory that hes a time traveler as well.

Watching this video when I just should sleep is just even better than watching it at day-

I believe Connors gonna have his lore with it. Not just cause he tweeted, but since the cowboy Tale, Karl and Connor were the two not dressed as cowboys, cause Karl is a time traveler. What if Connor is too?

TBH That Maze makes mes me think of Outsider SMP .... I know it's not it but IT'D BE AN EPIC CROSSOVER!!!

We Need more ! 💕💕

I watched this like 5 days ago and i must say... UR THEORY WAS RIGHT ABOUT JACK BEING A GOD!!! Well not fully sure but I did see in the in other side world that Jack appears to be a demi god

There is actualy a smp for maze runner its called ''Outsiders smp'' and its pretty cool to see it now in the trailer (even if they did not meen outsiders smp)

Jack is one of my favorite characters in the dream smp and seeing this theory makes me happy :D

Loving the orchestral Home Depot theme

I have about 10 different theories for Karl but one that I think about the most is that the Inbetween is a place of death and that the Other Side could be a hidden place of peace or life, but it was overrun by the Egg. And the Egg is what corrupted and made this place another area of death. Like with the flowers that are shown with the places, the Inbetween having black wither roses and the Other Side having white tulips. Also when Sapnap was asked to put a name in the Book of Death, he put in Johnathan, and one of his characters in the Tales was named John. Normally John will be short for Johnathan, so another theory is that Sapnap will one day find out how to mess with the future people using the book. When DreamXD spoke in his first language, I reversed it and it sounded like " For he killed my child--ery " almost sounding like he was say two different things at once. Even if I'm right or wrong, XD still sounds like he were to speak in the same way as the Egg Also anyone else see the trailer and thought Outsiders?? No? just me? mkay

0:51 Ah yes. Every single character: Dream, Technoblade, and Ranboo.

4:47 as soon as I saw this image I automatically said "are you a gun with legs, or are you legs with a gun ?"

you got the jack is (somewhat) god of hell theory right

Evokers can turn blue sheep into red sheep or vice versa this may have something to do with the egg

i love that medieval home depot theme remix

Note: this would also make sense with Jack’s origin be the blazeborn

I just realized that the orchestral version of the home depot theme was playing in the background lol

Oohh im exited to see how this ties into the tales stream on friday OoooOoooiieee

I’m calling it here and now with you all as witnesses. The episode is called “The maze” it will be inspired by the maze runner books (similar to Outsiders smp). And they may make another one tied to this later , so something like a total of 3 . Maze runner; this one. Scortch Trials: A possibility Death cure: Another possibility with a name something along the name of , Death of the Memories (IT SOUNDS COOL, SHUT)

BRO YOU JUST SOLVED IT! JACK MANIFOLD IS IN THE LATEST TALES I CAN'T BELIEVE IT

Animagician… you were right about jack manifold…

Man. Looks like even jack manifold dying can’t stop that jack manifold grind.

Have you done one about ranboo being the other time traveler dream xd mentioned in tales of the smp (the maze?

The lore is the only thing that still keeps me coming back to this SMP. I hate literally everything else

Kinda sad its over. so entertaining and lore full

This theory has like a special connection to the time traveller ranboo theory especially the choice part at the end , maybe ranboo couldn't choose beacuse of his hatred of sides so dreamXD had to kick him out and like took away his memory of time travelling? Maybe that's why it was hard to say that the last time traveller forgot

The maze from this trailer looks exactly like this one maze runner smp (i think it’s called outsiders smp) just a thought

hes been overlooked for too long