Thank you - I accidentally clicked on this and was thinking "what the heck is this"

Charlie T yeah

Me also from USA watching this because of Take That

***** I am sorry that I did not get any of your references but the One Direction bit. Considering, One Direction was so heavily produced that each of the boys' identity were manufactured to suit what the band needed at that time. But heck, they were one of the most, if not the most, successful bands to come out of a talent show. I wanted this show to produce this boys that they will either hit the mark One D left or even hit a higher one.

***** Is Curtis the one acting like the big brother of the group? I love that guy. Well, good for him then. I do not really know any behind the scene happenings. Even if it was on-screen, as I have told you, I care about the music more than the person singing the songs.

Exactly my thoughts x_x

I saw the show theband at the weeknd it was brill

They have talent in singing but lack the dancing skills of the original Take That

Five to five lack the dancing skills of the original Take That members, they dance and move like the Southlife

same omg

Excuse me them bands are so good but Take That are better

***** I do not really follow the boys individually, rather, as a band. Considering, yes, they are more theatrical than most any other shows like this. But look at the members of One D now, Harry will be acting for Christopher Nolan, Zayn's output are more emotional and raw that his One D days seems more like him acting a role. Soon enough, you will see Zayn acting on the screen as well. To say, a better alternative to theatre as it reaches more people. I hope Ryan Murphy asks Zayn to act in one of his TV productions just like that of Gaga.

I hope so. I love at least two of the three groups left.

Not easy to sing in the perfect Take That blend!

Not easy to sing and “dance” the way the original Take That did

Thành Trần it only takes a minute, it could be magic, relight my fire, pray , and shine .Obviously all of them by Take That ;)

Thanks so much :D

It only takes a minute, Could it be magic, Relight my fire, Pray and Shine

No, I beg to disagree... Why upstage the contestants when they were honing new talents and they aren't doing their own show/concert. He just knows whenever to give his all and when to give way to others to shine. That's what you call professionalism.

@@kayedeloyas8304 that’s called a deluded answer and also pure speculation. What I said, especially as a singing coach, is objective fact. Have a nice evening :)

@@gagletdeluded? I based my reply on what I've seen and heard of Mark's performance. What's horrendous sounding there? You mean how he finished the song? A true singer doesn't have to be specific and uniformly sound with all their songs, they can do whatever voice calisthenics they deem right whenever they wanted to. All professional singers and coaches do that. They don't always stick to the original. Here in our country where voice and singing talents searches were like a norm. That change of vocal placement is what you call "eargasm", an originality of a singer he only can do. Or maybe you're not just a fan of Mark's unique voice and music. Can't blame his style...it's alternative pop rock, not just your typical pop ballad like Gary's. Most of APR singers are often downgraded because of their unique style and sound which is not your typical pop ballad or pop rock which most people prefer. The daring, avant-garde spirit of the music was too radical for the conservative audience" Those alternative pop rock when you try to understand their lyrics, they have deeper meaning that they convey to listeners than those of pop ballads that are more catchy.