Well, I enjoyed reading your comment, and in my opinion, you are the best commenter on KZfaq!!!!!!!!!!! Josh

Hi, Francisco! I agree, this chapter is scarier in the book than it is in the movie, I think. Gollum is really a terrible creature - because of the Ring, of course. And thanks for the vote of confidence on the voice. It was fun to do! - Josh

Thank you, Emilio! I'm glad you are enjoying the story. And I really enjoyed doing the interpretation. I tried a mixture of the gollum from the 1977 animated film "The Hobbit" and the 1978 animated film "The Lord of the Rings". - Josh

Oh, I'm so happy you found the channel! Bienvenido!!! Spanish was three second language I learned. Thank you fort watching!! Josh

Marcelo, thank you so much for your comment. Yes, this chapter is longer than most. This encounter in the story is very important, not only for the story of the Hobbit, but also for the Lord of the Rings - Gollum is a central character. I agree that this chapter was more challenging than others. The nature of the chapter - the riddles, the rhyme of the riddles, the descriptions - where much more difficult for me to edit for beginners. I felt they were important for the story. That is why I prepare the text in English and PORTUGUESE, for you to be able to study it, understand it, and review it. If you could, could you please tell us what made it more difficult for you? That way, in future chapters I can be more careful to edit them for beginners. One more thing, this graded version of the book I made is not for ZERO beginners - learners who know very little English. This version is for beginning learners who have some basic knowledge of English and how it works. This graded reader will be more challenging than some, but I hope it helps you learn!!!!! Thank you again for your comment, and in English!!!! - Josh

I hope you are enjoying the story! - Josh

You are very welcome, Oksana! What a great name you have!! Josh

Thank youuu😇

Flattery will get you everywhere!! It makes me so happy simply that one person has liked it, and recognized the sounds. I put them in because I would want to hear. Thank you again, Elmira. Josh

Oh, hello in Iraq!! I’m right now in the process of preparing to produce The Lord of the Rings! In the next few months I will begin please be patient!! Josh

Thanks a lot 🙏🙏

Thank you for so many ❤️ ❤️❤️ ❤️! Josh

Thank you for the applause! Josh

Thank you, Jorge! Josh