BUFF CARNOOOOOOOO

I love how this video is more in-depth and retrospective than most political discussions

I love Para, but you're so right. It's not fun, even though it's so beautiful. Hoping for a strong return when the recode drops. The fall from grace is right. Diablo is great. One of my favorites.

I have huge respect for you for putting dilo high up, in literally anygame, movie and irl its my absoloute favourite, my little hooting baby

32:18 If there were no apexes, sucho would be the apex.

Pachy is actually really fun in my opninion. It just should be faster to deal with big predators's ambush speeds.

I feel like Tenonto will be the new Para, I really love Tenontos design, best horse dino boi

"I think maia is the best dinosaur in the game." Yes, thank you! Love playing maia and a good maia can fuck up half the carnivores in game.

I feel cerato, dilo and giga are very skill based and btw remember when the isle buffed the giga and it could face tank trikes and rexes...those were the days

Poor Cerato and Para, they’re my favorites ;~;

Sucho as true neutral is probably the best description for it

Good work on this video dude! Very creative way to go about this.

I have many things to grumble to myself about this vid, but they were all fair from your expeirences, and I can see why you put things where they were, not that im a dynamite player of the isle anyway

Giga is op his trot is super fast and his turn and stam are really good really only rexs make it down but giga can kill rex if you see it first you can tail ride it

Sucho needs to be waaaay bigger it was actually Just 3 metres smaller than t rex

dibble is the best.

Thank you for your videos Pesky I do enjoy them. I have been watching The Isle videos for a few months now and the ones I enjoy most are ones that feature Carnos -

I agree with you on Maia, -a fellow Maia (and sucho) main

Overall we have similar viewpoints. I'd put rex way lower in enjoyability and Utah way further up. Allo, I'd break the barrier of really good because pound for pound there is no better dino. Its got good bite force, excellent bleed, good speed (especially ambush), turn rate and hitbox are OP. Its just solid in every way.

Dino weaknesses. Cerato: bad bleed resistance Para: bad defenses Gali: takes too long to grow Giga: cant compete with rex Dilo:......... RACISM INTENSIFIES

Idk about trike being "done" if a Rex gets bone break on it, if it's a good trike or a bad Rex... I've witnessed a full adult trike take on two full adult rexes with bone break and win

A carno pack can kill suchos if they are good. I have been a carno in some of these fights. The mighty Speed Demon Empire.

I feel it is a great tier list, it explains everything fairly well, I even made my own video on my tier list. But for real, some of these dinos need major buffs

I'm relatively new to The Isle. You have reinforced me in my favorites so far. (Dilo and Galli)

You have pleased me with your placing of the galli, but it’s bigger than a Utah so of course it takes longer to grow, and it’s fun if you know how to use it, but overall great video

It will be fun to compare this list with a future one after the recode.

People always blame the dev team for making the game broken, but this guy has played the game for so long and finds more than half the dinos enjoyable. And only 4 dinos are “bad”. I would call that near perfect

Tbh giga for me is really enjoyable to play as, yeah the growth time sucks but it's just so fun to bite something and watch it bleed out while it's running away. And I really like the gigas model and sounds, it's just so pretty

I know this is an older vid but i love the para, it’s great to just clear your mind and play a fun easy dino.

"nothing a utah can do against dilo" except tail ride it to death easy af...

Ceratos in packs are extremely dangerous

so what's the tier list about combat, survival? is alt turn involved?

Trike is situational? Wtf he bodies every Dino in the game and is the only one who can 1v1 Rex.. Insane mass and health with stupid high bleed can effectively trade with 2 gigas at a time with bleed and higher standing bleed heal. And 2 bites from Giga is 28 bleed.. you not bleeding him out with that. Rex has to disengage if he doesn’t bb on first bite because he can’t take 2 stomps..Only downside is speed and he can’t kill anything unless whatever he’s fighting chooses to stay in the fight and die. But yea not that fun to play just from how slow he is lol

I love ur vids and how u guys are debating about the Dinos and also tell the isle to BUFF THE DAMN CARNO

I’m trying to get better at fighting. this vid helped me a lot in terms of what can beat what 👍

I personally find ALL dinosaurs enjoyable: Especially their juvenile and sub stages. A maia can fuck up an utah, it can kill it in 2 kills. Plus you're fast! My personal favorites are juv rex, maia, dilo (please i just run around and scream) and ai dinos lol

I feel better as a player ,with only around 80hrs, that loves playing the Dilo.😁 Thx for this review. Very helpful.

Imo sucho is also somewhat dependent on server rules, cuz, to me, the point of sucho is a high-mid tier carni that can escape accross water if the fight goes badly or if its outmatched, but if theres a rule against crossing a big lake to escape(not water camping, mind you, crossing to get away, not sitting in water)then it isnt as fun, and its also rlly slow on land(swim is faster than trot) so if you can really lean into the semiaquatic playstyle, yeah, sucho fun, but if not, its kinda just meh.

"You can run what you cant fight" as a dibble applied it with a giga, i had good distance between us too. Failed miserably.

Thank you for the enjoyable scale. Nice to know as a begginer

Sub Trike is amazing, it can face tank Acros and force Mid tiers to run if you hit them with a stomp. With the best non Juvie stam regen in the game you can outpace Gigas. Its also very good against Utahs and Dilos due to it's broken z walk. Basicly a Dibble with better stam and a monster stomp

Damn I was really surprised by Carno lmao I have nothing else to say

Good video my dude I agree with some but not all as you would expect like I don't find the Maia and Dibble as enjoyable to play while I agree with the statements about them they are solid herbies but for me just a bit lower and further back but not bad by any means, and the Sucho while amazing as an adult and I find super enjoyable it's juvie stage is atrocious and in my opinion probably the worst carnivore juvie stage like super slow and no stam at all ugh a nightmare. Personally despite you knowing my love for the allo I would put it back and lower as it in my opinion is true center with no bias its ok to play and all around decent stats but nothing phenomenal. I do agree the Carno needs an adjustment but personally I enjoy it more than the Allo especially in a pack. As for my most enjoyable creature (for me at least) hands down Utah like not my favorite but such a joy to play especially in a pack like without yeah not as great but pack life with it is by far the most joy I have had in the Isle. I put some thought into this so love it.

Anyone else notice that the trike picture keeps moving just a tiny bit? Like, it hops a couple pixels in random directions. All video long.

A few months late to the party, but here's my input: *Carnotaurus:* I don't think you've given them enough credit. A single carno can take on 3-5 utahs (depending on skill), and I've even killed two dilos that saw me coming because Z-walking gives you the turn and momentum you need to fight them. There's no need to run through a utah or dilo, if you're face-to-face, you slow down a few feet before them and react to the turn they make with your more controlled Z-walk. I'd say that carnos need to be in the middle of Enjoyable/Unenjoyable, but lower in the Good/Bad scale (inbetween dryo and rex). They are the carnivore equivalent to maias, but might feel less impactful due to stronger competition and a more unique playstyle compared to other carnivores. *Dilophosaurus:* In my opinion, they are the closest thing to the perfect dinosaur we have right now. *Pros:* good trot, good turn radius, fast sprint and ambush, excellent stamina recovery (dilos don't need to sit to recover stamina travelling, it's more efficient to recover via trotting), fantastic healing, refills on water quickly and maintains a full stomach for a long time, the best night vision, access to near perfect camoflage (meaning they can be almost invisible day or night), and amazing bleed damage. *Cons (the only one I can think of):* More reliant on ambush than most carnivores. If a dilo is spotted before it can engage, almost every dinosaur can deter or outright win the fight. As a side note: the dilo vs utah match-up is 50/50 and generally comes down to who got the first bite. Tidbits: -Ceratos are probably my favourite dinosaurs in terms of animations. Their stances and posture - they look great, despite being a bit underwhelming. -You hit the nail on the head with suchos. -Diablos are pure evil, and perhaps even underrated by most. -Gallis I'd say are a bit more enjoyable than where you've placed them. Running circles around carnivores and skillfully evading bites is quite thrilling.

Cerato is literally an allo that is smaller, has less dmg, HP, bleed, and is slower

Well carno can kill things.... and good when you know how to turn. For me personally i dont like carno that much but with my friends we almost killed an rex and carno is the only dino that counters maia. Btw maia is just op :) but i think the rest is ranked in good. For me is just everything except utha more fun. Even giga because i love it when it is more of a challange to kill rexes (or other dinos). Sad is that giga needs 10 minutes more than rex :x

Whe you get youst to the triceratops

Carno ranking hits close to home turn gives it personality

Also, what about progression dinos?

imo theres a difference between really good because its easy and really good but hard and dinos that are really good but hard to use are very fun to me, my favorite carni is carno, my favorite herbi is para, and my goto apex is giga. carno's main strength being that it has the high sustainable speed; in a pack carno is a god of war para looks cool, sound neet, and can run down allos... nigiga gangiga

As a para lover and cera lover I can say that they really need a buff.

What kind of tier list is this called again?

Utah, Dilo, and Maia are some of my faves to play. xD

I feel like docktahs are just waiting for a fight and thats why they wait at docks

Yeah Para should be like a deer, can scare away one or two wolfes (ceratos) but must run away if a pack or a bear (Apex) comes

why no spinos or ankys and stuff

If you know how to play Utah, you can kill many things alone such as a rex , allo , dilo , maia and it's really fun

👏👏good choices

what about spino brooo is he NOT in Survival

Didn't scanova do a tier list video before you uploaded this one?

00:05 bro why did it zoom into the dryo when he said hi

Giga ain't much slower than T-Rex is, but it's a good bit more agile, his Alt-turn is so good that even Dilos have a hard time outmanouvering it and most importantely it has much much *MUCH* better stamina. Complaining about Giga's mobility is a bit odd I think. It's basically like a T-Rex with less power (still enough to 1 or 2 shot the majority of the cast), but with better mobility, stamina (causing that it's actually excellent in longer ranged pursuits) and bleed. He has the best bleed damage in the game, which is also an important factor.

I love ur vids and like all this trike isint fun but it ain’t weak it can face tank a Rex giga and spino

8:50 you know that utah can solo every dino (spino and stego are very hard but still possible), dilo is easy vs utah, maia is decent, allo is also easy. if you want to check this you can join dm server just type "rx" in server browser

I agree Trike dies easily to Giga, but a Rex bone break isn't the end for a Trike, at least in a 1v1. You can't stomp, but you can still out turn a rex since a broken leg is basically z walking. That allows you to trade several attacks for 1 rex bite. One could argue that a good rex player wouldn't allow this to happen, but I 99% of rex players aren't good.

i didnt know i would ever go to this vid just to know what isle dino is the funnest

I loved it when Diablo went all the way up there.

Wdym carnos can't fight I solo a shant earlier and killed it

pls giv Para some better stam regen I love Para but having to sit down for 3 minutes every time I run for 400 yards is so unenjoyable that I regularly hope that a rex will come from the trees and end my existence.

do a tier list of all the dinosaurs (acros, spinos and theris)

Sandbox S tier would be herra, they're just so fast that nothing can catch them or outrun them except for an ambushing carno that sneaks up on it (and even then herra can easily outmaneuver the carno). Herra can also hide easily and can rely on hunting ai to stay alive. The dryo is literally herbi herra in every possible way.

That was a perfect writing on cerato

I completely agree when it comes to maia i will play it and the maia will last a week

sucho is my fav dino but i understand you putting it in the middle

para is like an elk if ur smaller than it'll kill u but if ur its size or bigger it'll get recked by u

Wouldnt the fact that you cant do anything with carno make it not good?

Dryo mains rise up

All legacy servers i can find now are no alt turn, this make Cera really amazing dino to play.

So Giga is not OP?

Why is galli growth time two hours? Thats bs right there

coming from a long time sucho main its fair to put it dead center. it can kill anything weaker than an apex but is hard countered by smart apexes. only other issues for it is that nasty growth time slow time and lack of gameplay.

Sub rex. Allo suddenly has to worry about rex like giga does

the only thing i hate about the isle in general is some players who invite people in their nests literally some minutes before leaving the game.....WHY THEY SAY THAT THEY HAVE EGGS IN GLOBAL WHEN THEY ARE ABOUT TO LEAVE? JUST LEAVE

Carno grows so fast at growing

"I think I'm not sure"

Man I don’t understand this tier list. How do you define really good? Shouldn’t apex’s be the highest on that scale? Giga needs to be all the way in the top right corner imo haha and y’all did trike dirty. He’s so fun to play in a herd and I love 1v1ing other apex’s as trike, such a Tanky boi.

Can't believe I just watched two grown men seriously debate the skill of playing dinosaurs that just run through eachother and bite lmao no collision btw

Cerato is perfect right in the middle

7:13 I'll put it a little forward proceeds to move him a bit back

Tenonto is best animal.

I went to the future in 2036 still no recode but we have isla nublar still

I like playing as para for something different

Poor Para xD I like him, becose on alt turn servers he is good (but too lame)

Damn, you did para and pachy dirty (not that they didn’t deserve it cuz they do)

I beat 4 adult suchos with a carno just the other day. If you get em out in the open you can just harass anything in the game until it dies.

What about spino?

Giga realllyyyy doesn't have to worry about rex. Giga's trot easily outpaces rex and it can sprint for faster and longer, too. All you gotta do as a fully grown giga when you spot a rex is trot away from it. You don't have to keep too much of a distance, either, as long as you have a clear view of the rex. Just be wary of the rex's ambush and you're fine.

The para should not do so much with the head but ... in fact it shouldn't have a head but attack any ways cause its crest was used to make sounds and make the Bellos sound louder so in order for it to do that the crest has to be very hollow so a single headbutt can either badly damage the crest or even worse it can break the crest in half so in tern the para should only do good in fights with small dinos like raptors or dilos and do fairly bad against carnos but they should be faster more agile and have more stam they also should have a roll in the recode so if raptors jumped so they crush them and they should have a stomp and they should be 5 kilometers slower than a caro .... thank you

I killed 2 Dilos at once with the ceratosaurus i mean I died like 2 seconds later but I pretty much took them both out by myself in a no alt turn server