Yeah, she literally controlled over the whole orphanage in a huge nation and take down those who betrayed the fatui. That kind of authority should be passed to someone with a high ranking.

I want arlecchino to be ranked higher than no. 10 too but after signora's death, some fatuis she raised, whatever said somethign like they could take that opportunity to raise Arlecchino up the rankings.

@@deathiswonderful250 They said they would increase her prestige which could mean many things besides I think Harbingers don't move up in ranks

What do you mean it doesn't suit her to be no.10, Childe is literally stronger than scara and signora specially with his abyss power but he's 11th, Even npc's says that they want to raise arlecchino's rank after signora's death. You also said it that she turn orphans to soldier she's a manipulative person its either because she's weak that's why she manipulates people and rather use her brain than her own strenght and Capitano being no.1 is the most bs thing to happen because the first 3 harbinger's are not a human, Pierro is confirmed as someone from Khaenriah 500 years ago meaning he has abyss powers like dainsleif, Dottore strength is not revealed but base on his experimentation he's already an strong immortal too either thats he himself or his prosthesis, and Columbina is a rumored character that from a seelie race, while capitano is just the humanity's strongest. Childe wants to fight capitano but even childe is scared of columbina.

@@Yunnnnnnn1229 Childe being stronger than Signora is debatable but he defo ain't stronger than Scara and like I said above they wanted to increase and quote "her prestige" not rank and I don't see why Capitano being number one is bs

Wait, the thing that still bother till this day are 11 Fatui's constellations. We can probably see that Pierro's constellation is the Sad Clown constellations that still among the 11. If Pierro is indeed not a Harbinger anymore, just a director then why he is still among 11? Also about missing or mysterious 10th. Should Childe or Scaramouce already talked about him/her in their voice lines? Unless, him/her was erasing themselves in the past like Scaramouce did though. The Winter Night Lazzo's trailer also stated this in the video description: "No one knows how long it has been since all the Fatui Harbingers last gathered.." Furthermore, In this trailer Pierro also using "we" like "the sages think themselves to be all knowing, but WE alone are wise to the virtue to those who acts in folly.." and "..in the name of her Majesty, The Tsaritsa, WE will seize authority from the gods.." This is probably just me but Pierro seems to keep including himself among Fatui Harbingers.

@@williamsl655 Like I said, perhaps the seat is empty at the moment. And they are still all Fatui, so of course Pierro would include himself.

@@SiliconOneFour Fair enough

@@SiliconOneFour Diluc hates the Knights and who is a knight? Kaeya Diluc hates the fatui and who else might be one? Kaeya Remember, kaeya is from khaenriah and he should also take revenge So it's very likely kaeya is the 10th harbinger I didn't watch the video, idk if you already talked about it

@@creation5389 spoliers: Kaeya is most likely coming in 3.5 with dainsleif. So we will prob find out.

Alice came to my mind as well, but I think if she were a Harbinger, Venti would know and would have told us, so I would think it would be another Descender.

@@SiliconOneFour venti has probably lied in the past so I wouldn’t exclude it but it’s not likely

Yeah totally, she’s the one who matches the most

@@forevernever3837 she would be too strong to be 10th though

@@SiliconOneFour Bro... Venti's not a trustworthy source AT ALL when it comes down to the truth of Teyvat.

What if it’s the same case with Scaramouche? After he got erased the 6th seat remains vacant for “years”, what if the reason no one mentions the 10th is because all memories and records were erased as well

Wait hang on I would love that actually!

@@SiliconOneFourit would be hillarious if they became harbingers together and then refused to fight us because we helped bring them together

I think this is quite likely honestly. Or at least that Crepus was a fatui member that betrayed the organization, even if he wasn’t a harbinger. Otherwise there would have been no way for him to get a delusion. They didn’t start mass-producing them until the delusion factory in Inazuma. And even then delusions are still VERY rare in the world. Plus it seems like Dottore made Ursa the drake attack dawn winery on purpose. And what other reason would he have to do that than to silence a defecting spy? Crepus clearly knew something.

good, I want more quests to engage with :)

Knowing how stories can hold truth, I do think the real Princess Fischl is a candidate for a descender. But I think we’ve seen that Flowers for Princess Fischl has an author, so it’s a bit unclear.

@@wolfkitty42 It's still a bit odd how these so called fantasy stories supposedly made by citizens hold truth of the past in them. You have to keep in mind that Nahida only did what she did because she was aware of the possibility that scaramouche will succeed in his plan. The average citizens of teyvat do not, and their memories about such things should be absolutely zero. Mr.Nine, the author of "Flowers for Princess Fischl", is also the author of another book called "The Shattered Halberd", which tells about the **archon war** and **the primordial one** . Keep in mind we don't know of any NPC who could be Mr.Nine. He's veryyyy sus so I think it might be the Oz of the real Fischl. EDIT: or he's the regrator, who wants to both make money and plant a seed into the people teyvat's heads. [I'm only saying this because there's multiple things pointing to Mr Nine being from Liyue]

@@Astrophel24 Ooh that’s a good point! I was not aware of other books by the author.

I was thinking that the Flowers for Princess Fischl might be a fairy tale backup of the Abyss Twin's personal journey, with Oz being the stand in for Dainsleif.

​@@Astrophel24 There's Chang the 9th, but his entire schtick is that he isn't a successful author yet, IIRC.

But then, one would expect Dainsleif to have combat abilities that surpass a few more of the Fatui Harbingers and should be placed higher on the list

@@StephanMok His power could be weakened by the curse? This isn’t a well thought out theory, I just thought of it while watching the video. But Dain has to be pretty strong since he was a Knight Captain in Khaenriah

@@StephanMok Adding on to say I’ve seen a few videos of people pointing out that the Abyss Herald in Enkanomiya hinted that we shouldn’t trust everyone we meet and to be wary of people, and they believe that this is foreshadowing of a Paimon betrayal, but I think it’s more likely about Dainsleif given the timing and the connection between him and the abyss

Dain doesn't like gods, it is illogical that he could be a Fatui in the position of fight the abyss in the name of the cryo arcon

@@DusDusDus Most of the fatui aren’t really loyal to the Tsaritsa and are just in it for personal gain. I know you know Dottore would betray her in a heartbeat in the name of science

We've seen what happens when a Fatui Harbinger is deleted, namely people comment on that seat having been empty for Xth number of years that that particular Fatui had been active. OTOH, the fact that Scaramouche's seat remained empty rather than having been filled by someone else in the new timeline might be an indication that whoever is responsible for filling that seat (Dottore, in Scaramouche 's case) is a Descender and immune to having their memory tampered by those kind of Irminsul temporal shenanigans. Actually, I'm going to get that Dottore is a Descender because that's the only way that he wouldn't lose all the centuries of study he put into Scaramouche's Archon/Khaenri'ahn-wrought puppet body, which would probably make him a somewhat weaker that, which seems a bit early in the story to happen at this point.

Finding a better editing style was one of my goals for when I started making videos again, so I'm glad you enjoy it!

Yeah, but here is one problem... Harbingers rank in power, and i can't believe that Kaeya would be stronger than Childe, no way.

@@Disorder2312 The man is always performing. It’s written in his talent set: Never Ending Performance. It’s also a pretty common trope for the ice prince with Steppford smile to be an absolute secret power house when they finally drop the act. And Kaeya dresses very much like a proper Fatuus with his theatric, over the top garb. He has the Rennaisance-esque tights, the extravagant layers of impractical decoration (vest, belts, jewelry, that BOA), the way his clothes block themselves into elongated diamond/star shapes (even if it is everywhere in the game and atteibuted to Khaenri’ah) is similar to the flashier Commedia characters (like the Harlequin’s diamond pattern motif), and his overall design is like a more youthful and light version of the Jester. It would not surprise me if he was supposed to be the Jester’s heir even if they aren’t related by blood and that’s why the crying mask (the face behind Kaeya’s smiling mask) is still on the Harbinger roster. Because the Jester has an understudy. (All a spur of the moment musing. I’m growing more fond of Fatui Kaeya by the hour!)

@@mythogenesis4788 Idk, just Childe's Foul Legacy transformation still remains pretty strong. What Kaeya can possibly do to rival that? You never even explain the point i have said. I can't imagine how would he be more powerful, i did not argue that he's not suitable for the 10th harbinger by other means.

@@Disorder2312 I mean, that “hidden power house” WAS the explanation. Add in that strength doesn’t necissarily mean might (i.e. Pantalone bejng considered weak, but is higher ranking because of his commercial strength or Pulcinella’s political strength). When I analyze story, I look at it from the perspective of a story-teller and designer. I look at tropes (MHY loves to twist them!) I look at allegory (gotta find those windblooms!) and I look at design intent (in a game full of incredibly unique designs, what motifs do we see shared between characters, and why is that?) What is the message the developers are trying to tell us? What are the connections hidden in plain sight? MHY is VERY good at telling multiple stories simultaneously and tying them together near seamlessly. Did you really think that Childe had such an ace up his sleeve when he first appeared at your rescue- until you fought him for the first time and he had not one, not two, but THREE boss phases with each serving as an escalation of power and transformation of character? He was a capable, but fairly non-threatening big brother type when we first met him. And Kaeya is confirmed Khaenri’ahn nobility. He HAS to have some inherent or learned magical abilities. If Childe got Foul Legacy from three months in the abyss as a kid, what did Kaeya, someone likely BORN in the abyss pick up from it? We’ve seen lectors and heralds transform from human to monster. We’ve seen the shadowy husks. We’ve seen abyss tainted gods and monsters. All of Kaeya’s Talents and skills are screaming at us “This man is not showing you his true strength. He’s just playing the long game.” He never takes a threat too seriously. Abyss mage at the start of the game? How amusing! Dvalin is going nuts and hilichurls are ransacking the city? Hmm. Seems like a good time to go have a “chat” with a contact. Signora, the 8th, behaved in much the same manner. Then let’s look at the sources they’re based on: Childe/Tartaglia- Childe is a term for a young lord, often spoiled and meek. Tartaglia is the stutterer, often in a position he’s clumsy and under educated in. (Sounds a lot like our “toy salesman”!) In this identity as a Fatuus, he’s spoiled, clumsy, meek, and (barely) putting on appearances as a respectable career man. Then there’s Ajax (the great). A fierce, unrelenting, and bloodthirsty warrior who fights entire armies in the Trojan war unscathed. So proud that he would sooner kill himself than face defeat in battle- Yep that sounds like our headstrong Russian ginger. And then there’s Kaeya. Alberich: OBERON: King of the dwarves (or dark elves/fairies depending in the story referred to). The villain in Wagner’s poetic opera, who renounced love of the Rhine Maidens for untold power in the form of a GOLD ring. Who had the power to become invisible (great skill for an infiltrator). Who, when punished by the gods and stripped of his belongings, curses the GOLD ring to drive anyone but himself mad (inspired LOTR, btw, Alberich is literally Sauron). Whose half mortal son’s (who may actually be Kaeya’s inspiration?) birth marked the beginning of the apocalypse and the end of the gods. Who could not be slain in combat because of his unrivaled magical prowess save for by a fearless and inhumanly powerful warrior: Seigfried. Seigfried. The name of another MHY character who is a member of the strongest family in the series. A descendent of likely the single strongest human being in the entire franchise engineered for killing god-like beings. That’s what MHY is saying it takes to stop an Alberich. A team of gods, or a warrior meant for godslaying.

@@mythogenesis4788 Omg... I did not ask for so much text. Even though i myself often write that much, but usually on a much more interesting topics. Whatever, let's just assume you have some evidence that you believe in.

As a fan of the character of Dain, I think I will left Genshin if he is one of the Fatui harbingers

dain gets his info from irminsul

I think Dain, as the highest ranking guard for the Khaenri’ahn Royal family, would be too strong for this position. But if it was someone of a similar position would be fascinating.

@@mythogenesis4788 The notion that there is a khaenrian survivors colony somewhere lives rent free in my head. I would like to see other survivors pop up. Especially with the idea that some of them followed Pierro because he was able to help them or pseudo help them. In turn, they served as the beginnings of the Fatui. Dain himself is intriguing, because there's a lot we just don't know about him. He states he was traveling partners with our sibling, yet there's no record of him with our sibling so far. We know the journey started in Sumeru. The Aranara never mention Dain. The answer to that is it's likely he found the sibling later on, but it makes you wonder. NGL, since hoyo dropped the Pierro lore and introduced what seemed to be a cloaking device in 3.3, for a hot second I thought Pierro and Dain might be the same person. The Halfdan stuff sort of kills that though. I will say it's interesting we've never seen Dain raise a sword. He's only ever used his powers, much in a way that a catalyst user or a mage would. Dain's trying to stop the loom of fate operation, but why? Did he set this task for himself as penance due to his past sins or did someone convince him he needed to stop it? One thing he specifically mentions is if he and the traveler succeed, that “Fate will be ours to re-weave.” Why would the Captain of the Royal Guard want to re-weave fate? Is he trying to undo his past failings or is he planning to hand the responsibility off to someone else once it’s done? Let’s not forget that part of the Fatui’s overall goal is to create a new world that is free of Celestia’s rule. Rewriting fate to make it so Celestia never even gains control is a possibility. I know he gets his information from Irminsul, but information on the eye of the first field tiller seems like an oddly specific thing to search for given Irminsul is a record of the world. How would he know to look for it at all? How does he know they’re planning to build a god? This wouldn’t be a spur of the moment plan. It’s something they’ve been working on for quite awhile. Did Dain discover it while spying on the Abyss or did someone tell him? Then there’s the eye itself. We still don't know where the eye is hidden. Dain specifically mentions the Abyss Order can grab it from anywhere, so it's likely in a place where it's protected/guarded. Dain doesn't tie to any nation, so taking it to Pierro for safe keeping makes sense, unless there's some super secret place the Abyss Order can't reach. The Fatui are also seemingly unconcerned with the Abyss and their actions. You would think Pierro might be a little worried about someone else trying to go for Celestia as well, but he's not. In fact, it feels like that situation is very much under control. Could he have someone in place handling all of that? Due to his connection with Irminsul, Dain would be an attractive get for Pierro in the early days of the Fatui. Since Pierro is into the whole manipulation thing, he could easily sway and use Dain for his benefit. The trick is, what happens after. Since Scara doesn't mention them, the proposed missing harbinger was either already out of the picture by the time Scara was recruited or Scara doesn't know about them. For me personally, I feel like at some point soon we're due for a major betrayal. It's been a minute since that's happened. The traveler is far too trusting and eventually that has to come back to bite us. Time will tell though. Also, sorry this got so long. :)

"You thought it was Aloy, but it was me, DIOna!"

I feel like Capitano HAS to be #1. Childe fanboys over Capitano like no one else. He gets excited at even being noticed by him. There are others that Childe wants to fight (like Varka) but Capitano is at the top of the list and probably for good reason.

If that's the truth, I can't wait for our own Harbinger intro

@@sagehoff969 That would be so amazing!

Traveller would be beyond 10th seat by then. He’s gonna be 3rd.

​@@1mol831 the Traveler will already be somewhere at top 3, cause we already control all 7 elements

He deserves to be a 5*

@@xivering fr thay gonna rerealese him as 5 star or give him a 5star skin

Yelan stole Pantalone's gift for Tsaritsa and took apart the fatui plot in Liyue. Childe never gave the casino to her but only took down the previous owner. She only told the man in her story quest that the fatui could find her so she could make him give up info.

I would enjoy this

Comico comes from the root of the word Comedy. Not cosmos. I do think it would be cool if a guy named comico was secretly super strong, but the seat of 10th harbinger still fits just fine. He’d still be super strong. Childe for example is stronger than most of the people we’ve met in our travels and he’s only the 11th. I do think we’ve met a few normal people who could beat childe (namely: Diluc, Eula, Beidou, Yelan, Hu Tao, Shenhe, Alhaitham, and Cyno) (also possibly Ayato and Jean but they might not quite be up to it) (and obviously an adeptus like Xiao and any of the archons could kick his ass). Childe is very strong but even in his foul legacy transformation he’s not that much stronger than in his other forms, and he can only stay in that form for limited amounts of time.

This would actually be hilarious if true. But I think the reason it plays in relation to fischl is due to the theatre and opera themes of the harbingers, fischl also encapsulating that energy. I do kinda like your idea though, and to kinda add onto it the idea of fischl's power being "ten" is mentioned in the princess fischl story which could connect her to the tenth placement. Amy (our fischl's real name) is also the name of a demon in the Ars Goetia which means she might have more importance than we expect.

The idea that she's more powerful than we expect or has a variant that could be a 5 star I think is actually somewhat likely and I think the tenth harbinger being fischl would be a neat way of accomplishing that. I suppose we'll see soon enough though.

For Capitano, being the strongest human and maybe even the strongest being made me think he is likely number one. For Arlecchino, while yes her subordinates wanted to raise her prestige, that means they basically just wanted to improve her image, as prestige is more based on respect and admiration.

@@SiliconOneFour I think the bigger rank should have more respect and admiration too. I think it would make a lot more sense if her subordinate said it's just an order for Arlecchino herself or complained about having to clear the aftermath of Signora's death or not saying anything about raising her prestige Right now, I'm more believe that the No.1, 4 and 10 seat are either Pierro No.1, Capitano No.4 and Arlecchino No.10. or Capitano No.1, Mystery character No.4 and Arlecchino No.10.

@@cardnacn6704 The ranks are based on power and strength, not respect. Scara was Number 6, but not many of the Fatui soldiers liked him. Then Childe is Number 11, and he seems like he'd be more liked.

@@SiliconOneFour Maybe, but that line and the voiceline order really mess my head. Just why did her subordinate want to up her prestige, if she really is No.4? Is there any purpose for her to do that if her number is so high?

@@cardnacn6704 Perhaps the soldier wanted to up her prestige for their own gain. Additionally, they may have wanted to up her prestige in Inazuma specifically after Signora died to show the Fatui can still have power there.

We actually don't have any confirmation that Pierro is the First Harbinger. Tartaglia's voiceline tells us that he once was, but is now the Leader of the Harbingers, being the Director instead. Him being the Director has confirmation in the description for A Winter Night's Lazzo, while him still being the First has no confirmation.

@@SiliconOneFour Most of your reply just proves my point lmao Argument 1: "Tartaglia's voiceline tells us that he once was, but is now the Leader of the Harbingers, being the Director instead." said voiceline says: "**He was the first ever Fatui Harbinger, and today he is our leader.** He only appears on important occasions. As for his accomplishments... To be honest, I don't really care. I owe my loyalty and devotion to the Tsaritsa, no one else." That doesn't imply that he stopped being the first harbinger and ascended to a higher role, nor do I see how that can be confused that's the case. He said he was in past tense the first Fatui in past tense because those events are in the past, hence "past tense". It doesn't mean he stopped being the first Fatui, that doesn't make sense. Argument 2: "Him being the Director has confirmation in the description for A Winter Night's Lazzo, while him still being the First has no confirmation." Again, that has very little to stand off of considering all we know. I don't want to argue whether or not he's been confirmed to be the first Harbinger, because I'll be blunt, **he hasn't.** But you're assuming the top ranked spot and the term "Director" have zero correspondence because it's not said flat out "Yes he's #1." which makes no sense considering every single sign we know of that points to him being the first. His name meaning "sad clown" with a clown mask on the Constellation board? Him having a codename to begin with which is blatantly said to only be bestowed onto Harbingers? The "commedia dell'arte" which the Harbingers are **directly taken from** only having 11 characters? It makes no sense.

I think it s a spoiler so i wont say it anymore. Just wait and see

I talked about this idea in the video, and while I think the Traveler wouldn't want to join, the idea that it's saved for them is very interesting.

the fatui is not a solid faction as it seems, with each one having their own interests. im pretty sure there is a divide in loyalty here, tsaritsa faction and pierro faction having the traveler tips the scales, and i believe a Civil War in Winter Snezhnaya will happen once the traveler comes in as another piece of their chessboard

If i was to choose as traveler I’d pick fatui side for the final battle as celestia (the 2nd throne and not phanes) is clearly a tyrant.

It is possible that he is both, but to me it seems far more likely that he is just the Director. The description for a Winter Night's Lazzo only says Director, not Director and Harbinger, plus Tartaglia's voiceline on him gives the idea that Pierro was once a Harbinger, but now is the Director. I've also seen the idea that he acts as sort of "Number 0" of the Harbingers if you will.

If in the description of the Winter Night's Lazzo it says next to every harbinger that they are harbinger, why wouldn't it say that Pierro is the harbinger as well? Only because he also have the title of the director? That doesn't make any sense. On top of that, it's kinda hard for me to believe that Capitano is the 4th, with how stupidly strong he is being presented. (that was said he can kill a ruin guard with one of the Klee's pencils, kinda god-like in my opinion, so he can't be lower than 3)

Honestly that would be a pretty interesting twist, and would also explain why the Tenth isn't mentioned.

He is confirmed as the Director in the description for A Winter Night’s Lazzo

@@SiliconOneFour yeah i saw it, what I mean is, being director don't mean is not the n°1. But I guess we have to wait and see

I feel like if Kaeya IS a sleeper agent and the 10th harbinger, he’s probably a double agent that actually sides with Mondstadt. Because all the people he actually cares about are in mondstadt. All the people that raises him and care about him. Meanwhile the fatui use their harbingers as tools and that’s it.

I am aware of this. This is why I said at the end that the Tenth seat may be empty at this point in time. The mask hasn't been confirmed as Pierro's constellation either, though it is likely.

@@SiliconOneFour Piero is the Jester. The crying mask is the Jester lol wdym

@@schopenhauer5427 It’s likely yes, but we don’t have confirmation. I agree that it probably is him, I’m just saying it hasn’t been confirmed.

As per what leaks say, Capitano is first. You can think of Pierro as being zero, leaks only states that he's the director.

@@rafaelbittencourtmiranda4338 if you check the description of the fatui trailer ( a winter night's lazzo). It is confirmed/stated there that Pierro is the director of the fatui and the rest are labelled as fatui harbinger. Leak allert: But yes, the leaks further expanded that Pierro is not counted on the 11 fatui harbingers and that capitano is indeed number 1 and the 10th seat is vacant

Like I said, the 10th Seat could just be empty, but Pierro has been confirmed as the Director, but not as the First.

I think you confuse his delusion with his foul legacy - which is abyssal magic and thus hard for him to maintain without damaging his body ~ Unless he also has problems with his delusions and I just didn´t know haha

Bruh imagen getting ranked 11 from 10 people 💀

Pulcinella was the one to recruit Childe though, not Pierro. Childe also didn't get his delusion until he became a Harbinger, and it's not even the delusion that he has problems with, it's his Foul Legacy transformation, which is an abyssal technique

It's canon that pulcinella is the one who suggested to make Childe a harbinger,not Pierro

@@Ben-vg6ox yah he sugsested but pierro and tsaritsa have the final say

Pierro is the Director of the Harbingers, so their boss. He doesn’t hold a place among the Eleven, but I still mentioned him because he is their boss.

And as for Paimon, I said I had my doubts, and I don’t really believe she is one.

It's not actually, it's rather vague with Pierro's spot. While he is "The First Fatuus," this is just referencing how he created the Fatui alongside the Tsaritsa. Additionally, the description for A Winter Night's Lazzo tells that he is in fact the Director.

Thank you so much! And those are all good ideas! Skirk seems very interesting actually, I would love to see that. And I would love to take a look into those video ideas, so thank you!

It might be possible that Pierrot, being the Director, doesn't have a number or is 0. That would leave a spot for a missing one. The symbol for the Harbingers does include 12 symbols after all. Maybe Pierrot is symbolised by the Fatui symbol and not any of the other 11?

We look at the description of the artifacts of the Pale Flame set: Mocking Mask «My name is Pierro, The Jester.» Stainless Bloom- «The first Fatuus gave power to a young woman in whom the flame of life had all but died,» Wise Doctor's Pinion -«Following a trail of rumors of heresy, the first of the Fatui tracked him down...» Here are the words of Tartaglia from his voice remarks -About The Jester-«He was the first ever Fatui Harbinger, and today he is our leader.» It can be assumed that he is still number one. But we will find out the truth in the game in the future!

Pierro was the First Harbinger, but he no longer is a Harbinger. He is instead the Director of the Fatui. This is confirmed in the description for A Winter Night's Lazzo. Being the First Fatuus doesn't mean he is still the First Harbinger either. And as for Tartaglia's voiceline, the use of "was" shows he no longer is a Harbinger, but is ranked above them.

@@SiliconOneFour Argument,Thank you!

Dude, that was never confirmed 🤦‍♂ He was never called a harbinger. That being said, he was only called as the director of the Fatui. Of course, he is the strongest of them all, but that doesn't mean he is a harbinger.

Zanni is gud

No he,s not he,s the head of the fatui but not nr.1

The Jester is the Director yes, but is no longer a Harbinger.

@Grunty Gaming He hasn’t been confirmed as the first, but has been confirmed as the Director and the former First Harbinger

@Grunty Gaming Tartaglia’s voiceline about him says he WAS the First Harbinger, and is NOW their leader, which suggests he isn’t ranked in the Harbingers.

Perilous Path

@@SiliconOneFour thank you very much!

I googled and it says arlecchino

@@cinnamon4954 fake

He’s actually been confirmed as the Director and no longer a Harbinger.

Or the game showing capitona or arlechino ranking 4 & 10. Then all this theory from leaker will be dead.

@@harfi212 i always though this was the case since didnt we get confirmation that capitano is the strongest human, implaying he isnt the strongest amongst the fatui since the top 3 arent human, aka dottore, columbina and pierro.

@@catsouplover7745 yep, its from varka letter that mika read. Those leak ranking are making a lot of people in shamble and taking it like somekind of truth. Why the f 10th seat is even empty ? Far stretch bs theory. I guess some people dont accept arlechino is low ranking and capitano is not higher coz dottore is no 2. I really cant wait for the game officially tell their rank and be done with this.

@@SiliconOneFour I m just going to leave this here: wiki footnote on the Harbinger page Given that all other seats are known, Capitano and Arlecchino are likely the currently unidentified Fourth and Tenth seats, respectively, based on Tartaglia's remark that he is too low-ranked for Capitano to notice him and Efim's desire to take advantage of Signora's death to raise Arlecchino's prestige. If The Jester's directorial role is a different role than the First seat (which has been neither confirmed nor denied), then it's possible that one of them may occupy the first seat too. However, no official confirmation on their ranks has been given. references: - Archon Quest, Interlude Chapter, Act III - Inversion of Genesis, Part 1: The Night-Bird Falls at the Curtain's Call - KZfaq: Teyvat Chapter Interlude Teaser: A Winter Night's Lazzo - Tartaglia's Character Story: Delusion He was confirmed to be director, but never confirmed to not be a harbinger. Your theory is built on the assumption that the two roles do not overlap, which I think it is fine because it's a theory.

Pierro is not actually a Harbinger anymore. While he was the First Harbinger, at some point he instead became the Director. The order I presented in the video has support too, as I mentioned with Tartaglia and Wanderer's voicelines.

They just haven’t been confirmed in game yet, and no Dottore is the Second, so neither of them would be 2.

@@SiliconOneFour in the trailer, 9 are present, one is dead and the other is forgotten. That makes 11. Isn't that the number of total Harbingers? Capitano doesn’t have much of a role in the story yet. However, as per leaks, he will play a major role in Natlan. Grand Master Varka confirms this much in his letter to the Knights of Favonius during the Ballad and Brews Event from Genshin Impact 3.1.

@@ark2985 Yes there are Eleven Harbingers, but Pierro is the Director of the Fatui, so technically not a Harbinger.

@@SiliconOneFour sounds one and the same. Many google searches about 1st Fatui Harbinger return the results Pierro.

Pierro's title as Director was confirmed in the description of A Winter Night's Lazzo. You can go to the teaser and scroll down to look at its description. There, Pierro is written as being the Director while the others are written as being Harbingers.

@@danamaierean but why are we assuming that the director is different from #1?

@@forscythejones8525 mostly because he is called the "First Fatuus" and "the first ever member of the Fatui" as in him and the Tsaritsa are the founders. For example afaik in the original CN text it's clearly stated that Pierro is "the first ever" of the Fatui members which ranks him above even the Harbingers, while Childe confirms in his voice lines that today he is their leader. Some translation nuances get lost from CN to EN, just like with Nahida stating in EN that the top 3 Harbingers' powers are comparable to that of gods: in the original CN text she uses the same character used for the Archons specifically, not usual gods like the term used in EN. That's why I usually read explanations from the CN native speakers, so I won't lose details like these.