No video

The most Scandalous garment in history? A History of the Farthingale and Guardainfante

  Рет қаралды 47,694

History Lessons with Dr Sarah Bendall

History Lessons with Dr Sarah Bendall

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 99
@LittleMissAwesome121
@LittleMissAwesome121 4 ай бұрын
14:54 funny (not funny haha, funny sad) how there is absolutely no winning here. *Wears normal, form fitting skirt* “oh mon dieu, those slatterns want us to look at them! temptresses” *Hides our ‘desirable flanks’ under many skirts and a four foot wide cage to keep you creeps away* “there they go again, trying to trick us and pull us towards them” 🤦‍♀️ misogyny is a mental illness, truly loved the video Dr Bendall Very informative 😊
@sarahabendall
@sarahabendall 4 ай бұрын
Most of women’s history definitely boils down to: damned if you do, damned if you don’t! Glad you enjoyed the video 😊
@jahirareyes1102
@jahirareyes1102 4 ай бұрын
Keep your opinion to yourself with your terminology.
@jeraldbaxter3532
@jeraldbaxter3532 4 ай бұрын
Curious. The first critical\ judgemental comment is a quote of a female member of the court.
@denisemcdougal6445
@denisemcdougal6445 4 ай бұрын
Apparently women are dammed if they do and dammed if they don’t
@cathleenc6943
@cathleenc6943 4 ай бұрын
@@jeraldbaxter3532 do you think women don't routinely get taught, perpetuate, and pass on misogyny?
@cap4life1
@cap4life1 4 ай бұрын
This explains so much why Queen Elizabeth the 1st adopted the farthingale. She was trying to say “I’m unmarried, but I have enough power, authority and favor to bear a child whenever I want with whoever I want. So you will respect me.”
@SpiritGirlSF
@SpiritGirlSF 4 ай бұрын
How many children did she actually have?
@-Reagan
@-Reagan 4 ай бұрын
@@SpiritGirlSFShe wasn’t supposed to have any children… officially. She never married. Her father, King Henry VIII had her mother, Anne Boleyn executed on false charges. Elizabeth was thought safer - due to people who wanted her crown and the power a husband had over his wife, back then. There are rumors of her having a child with a secret lover who was a favorite of hers. It’s interesting that the favorite, Robert Dudley was married to Amy Robsart Dudley at the time, but she died in a very suspicious way. She was home alone, without any of her usual servants when she suffered a fall down stairs. She died but the way she fell and her injuries didn’t match up. It’s still unclear if she was murdered, by her husband or someone hired by him and maybe even Queen Elizabeth was involved. As a widow, Robert Dudley would have been free to marry Elizabeth. However, the scandal caused by Amy’s fall to death was so serious that there was no way for Elizabeth to be able to marry such a man as Robert Dudley. It would have turned people against her and endangered her life and her crown. There is a certain portrait of her that is thought to actually depict her pregnant, with symbolism and allegory. All paintings of the era used secret messages that people would understand, each flower stood for something different from love to grief or innocence and there were symbols in everything in the painting. Nothing in a painting like that is ever accidental or meaningless. Everything in it is there for a purpose, including the way the subject is posed and portrayed and what they are wearing. The painting is one of the only pieces of evidence of a pregnancy happening, but it’s debatable bc it can be interpreted in different ways. It can be said that she is the mother of the country and the “baby” is her country and her subjects. Many scholars suspect she did have a baby out of wedlock and it was adopted and raised by a noble family but, the official history says she never had any children. Her 45 year reign is considered one of the very best in English history and is known as “The Golden Age”.
@roodbennett
@roodbennett 4 ай бұрын
​@@SpiritGirlSF she didn't have any. She was the queen, her ladies in waiting were around her at all times. The Catholics would have jumped on her "immorality" in a nanosecond, and move to have her taken off the thrown.
@roodbennett
@roodbennett 4 ай бұрын
@cap4life1 your comment is off the wall and not at all based in historical fact. Elizabeth I did not wear farthingale to cover up pregnancy, but because she could. She was rich and she was queen. Her power was unmatched in early modern times.
@cathleenc6943
@cathleenc6943 4 ай бұрын
@roodbennett I think you misunderstood what they said. They didn't say she wore it to cover up a pregnancy, but as a show of her ability to do so if, when, and with whom she had chosen to. Her grandiose style was both very powerful and exaggerated, showcasing her feminity, height, wealth, and presence.
@BrownRiceBunny1
@BrownRiceBunny1 4 ай бұрын
So the rumor was started by a man who was upset that he couldn’t get physically close to women and then it was perpetuated by other men.
@plia1984
@plia1984 4 ай бұрын
The first time I heard the name "guarda-infante", meaning keep infants, it came to my mind the idea of keeping the infants (children) inside the skirt. And then I imagine little children playng hide and seek in the courts hiding inside guarda-infantes, paniers , peticoats and cronolines. Yes, I'm very aware this would be highly scndalous and must never have happened, but noting can make me not imagine it
@cathleenc6943
@cathleenc6943 4 ай бұрын
You mean like the Mother Ginger scene in The Nutcracker?
@amazinggrace5692
@amazinggrace5692 4 ай бұрын
@@cathleenc6943 or also in “A Christmas Carol”
@maryguillemette9441
@maryguillemette9441 4 ай бұрын
Actually in my family, the tale is some men hide in the skirts to get out of being dragged off to fight in the civil war.
@dianank
@dianank 4 ай бұрын
The ultimate goal of all the criticism being of course control of women's bodies. Same old story.
@j.b.6709
@j.b.6709 4 ай бұрын
So aggravating. At that time, fashion was one of the few ways women had of expressing themselves and exerting some control over who had access to their persons and their immediate surroundings, and still men criticized them soundly for having the audacity to "take up space", basically trying to shame them into abandoning clothing that they perceived as a hindrance in some way. They wanted women in a neat little box, something they could take out and allow to exist when it was convenient and put back and forget when it wasn't, and they took great offense the second women did something to please themselves that impinged on that access or took them out of that box a little bit. The sense of entitlement to women and their bodies is appalling but not surprising and sadly has not changed much. By the way, I found your channel through your wonderful collab with Bernadette Banner, and I'm so glad I did! I'm very much looking forward to more from you : ) Thanks for all the time and effort you put into your work!!
@SpiritGirlSF
@SpiritGirlSF 4 ай бұрын
Especially with men today who still want to exert their entitlement over women's bodies by trying to surgically alter themselves to look like us.
@verenamaharajah6082
@verenamaharajah6082 4 ай бұрын
The farthingale and later crinoline caused the skirts to swing from side to side like a bell when you walked which always attracts attention.
@valeriepark9444
@valeriepark9444 3 ай бұрын
It also keeps your legs cool, particularly in hot regions!
@morticiaaddams7866
@morticiaaddams7866 3 ай бұрын
Don't forget the bustle! Same idea.
@cathleenc6943
@cathleenc6943 4 ай бұрын
Seems like backbiting and maligning comments of a new foreign queen by the ladies of the French court that the king chose not to marry are to be expected, lol.
@sarahabendall
@sarahabendall 4 ай бұрын
Yes there’s definitely some elements of pettiness there! Although generally it was accepted that a king would marry a foreign princess at this time to cement alliances.
@cathleenc6943
@cathleenc6943 4 ай бұрын
@sarahabendall well of course, but that doesn't mean that the local ladies (and their parents maybe) didn't get butthurt enough to have a scathing tongue when she showed up. Or the general "we're better than you" attitude that many groups can have with foreigners might have caused wagging tongues as well. And also there is the general jealousy and backbiting that arises as a natural result of the young women of that era being used as bargaining chips. Everything I've read about the royal courts of those eras makes it seem like they were filled mostly with social climbers with little to no consciences.
@bcgrote
@bcgrote 4 ай бұрын
It should have been called a "Hapsburg Hoop" 😂
@nekonyx
@nekonyx 4 ай бұрын
Also reminds me of quinceñera dresses
@jonnawyatt
@jonnawyatt 4 ай бұрын
The title could also be "mysoginy in history"
@sarahabendall
@sarahabendall 4 ай бұрын
100%
@LisaEtter
@LisaEtter 2 ай бұрын
​@sarahabendall you should NEVER apply today's standards and beliefs on people hundreds of years older than the current society. Historians and archeologists agree to slap a current IDEALOGY on to past groups DISTORTS REAL HISTORY.
@annemiekbarnouw6132
@annemiekbarnouw6132 4 ай бұрын
I just read this part of your book yesterday in the train :-). Thank you so much for this very informative and well written book! It was a pleasure to read (had another few hours of train today).
@sarahabendall
@sarahabendall 4 ай бұрын
Oh that’s wonderful! I’m so glad you enjoyed it! 😊
@annalieff-saxby568
@annalieff-saxby568 3 ай бұрын
If anyone's interested, there's a bloodcurdling story called "Mother of Monsters" by, I think, de Maupassant, which deals with garments designed to conceal pregnancy.
@sarahabendall
@sarahabendall 3 ай бұрын
Ooh I’ll have to check this out!
@leightonolsson4846
@leightonolsson4846 4 ай бұрын
Whether it's enormous skirts in voluminous luxury fabrics, flimsy empire line dresses in fine muslins, big wigs or excessive long nails, mini skirts or athle-leisure wear, stilettos, pale skin and now tanned skin, etc the subliminal message is always the same: I have wealth and do not need to work. It's always about impracticability - although this has changed over time, once it meant what was practicality for the field and kitchen, then factories, then offices. I agree with your analysis - I think also in the pre Beau Brummell Age men aldo preferred their clothes to be the focus, especially 'the sun king'!. Also the large overskirts allowed women to hide their 'pocket' and keep items on them discretely. Also the farthingale did evolve into formal court dress in France in the later century, albeit in a modified form the side pannier hoops. It's a different profile but it was equally broad and absurd in the space it occupied.
@saundrayork767
@saundrayork767 3 ай бұрын
I imagine that, in hot weather, wearing a farthingale would hold the skirts away from the body and thereby be more comfortable than having all that fabric clinging around one's legs -- which is why hoop skirts were popular in Southern states in pre-Civil War USA
@aussie_vonnie
@aussie_vonnie 4 ай бұрын
Just discovered your channel through Bernadette Banner, looking forward to learning with you.
@danawinsor1380
@danawinsor1380 4 ай бұрын
The farthingale that consisted of a disk tied around the waist made the dress look like there was a table underneath. I believe this fashion was popular primarily, if not solely, in England during Queen Elizabeth's reign. However, in all the movies and TV series depicting Queen Elizabeth, I have never once seen her dressed this way, even though it was obviously the height of fashion during this era.
@myladyswardrobe
@myladyswardrobe 2 ай бұрын
There are different types of farthingale. The early one was a cone shape - "Spanish" farthingale (late 15th century in Spain, and from 1540s in England and a little earlier in France). 1580s onwards, the "French" farthingale which does have a sort of "coffee table" look. This continued into the early 17th century and was seen in France and England. And then we have this style which is almost pannier style which is seen in Spain in the mid 17th century. Odd that France get upset at with this fashion as they were the ones who had the early "wheel" or "coffee table" style of farthingale! And of course, France then have the huge panniers in the 18th century. And we have Crinoline in the 19th century.
@angelsinger4574
@angelsinger4574 4 ай бұрын
This is the first video of yours I have seen, and color me impressed! The amount and detail of your research is impressive. Subscribed!
@sarahabendall
@sarahabendall 4 ай бұрын
Thanks so much! Happy to have you here 😊
@user-tn8cp3hd6i
@user-tn8cp3hd6i 4 ай бұрын
Excellent video! I love how you explained cultural history and implications in a digestible way. A suggestion: have you considered highlighting passages you quote so viewers can follow along?
@MegCazalet
@MegCazalet 4 ай бұрын
Would you consider Saque gowns of the 18th Century to be as scandalous? They had similar reputation as meant to hide pregnancy, while also appearing fairly tantalizingly casual. They were very similar to farthingales, too, and I guess are related. The Robe á La Francaise, or Saque, or Sack-Back, was both very fashionable but extremely controversial.
@historyismyplayground1827
@historyismyplayground1827 4 ай бұрын
Besides being misogynistic, the criticisms about wearing a Farthingales are just plain ridiculous. Farthingales may push your skirts out a lot, but they are not going to hide a swelling stomach. It would be much easier to hide a pregnancy in the clothing worn in the middle ages, or in the regency. I wear corsets and Farthingales frequently, there’s no place to hide a baby in those outfits except under the skirts, as one of the other comments mentioned, but that only works after the child is born, walking.
@susanpolastaples9688
@susanpolastaples9688 4 ай бұрын
Did anyone mention this to Elizabeth I who was painted wearing one of these 'card table farthingales? Think not.
@rawilliams5881
@rawilliams5881 4 ай бұрын
Not if they wanted to live and keep all their limbs.
@Benito-lr8mz
@Benito-lr8mz 4 ай бұрын
Can be seen perfectly for exemple in the superb painting of Velazquez " Las Meninas" in the Prado Museum.
@1964_AMU
@1964_AMU 4 ай бұрын
Maria Theresa could have had Turner Syndrom. She had a small adult size, a big neck and head. She had a few children with Louis the XIV, but more misscarriages, she menstruated after the age of 18.
@allangibson8494
@allangibson8494 4 ай бұрын
Turner syndrome sufferers are usually sterile because they cannot produce viable ova.
@sirenernestine
@sirenernestine 4 ай бұрын
SO INTERESTING!!!!
@Elvertaw
@Elvertaw 3 ай бұрын
Really good!! This is something I was unaware of 👏🏼👏🏼
@scottyG153
@scottyG153 4 ай бұрын
Hey awesome content. I came across your channel through your collaboration with Bernadette banner. Glad to see more on period clothing on KZfaq.
@debbralehrman5957
@debbralehrman5957 3 ай бұрын
Thank you I did not realize the farthingale had such a reputation. I new that Katherine of Aragon introduced this item to England.
@sarahabendall
@sarahabendall 3 ай бұрын
While Katherine wore it when she first arrived but she quickly changed into English fashions. It’s not until the 1540s that we start to see it regularly in English wardrobes 😊
@camille_la_chenille
@camille_la_chenille 4 ай бұрын
This video made me order the movie at my local library. I had toread the novel in high school and found it more boring than anything else but this movie really makes me want to re-discover this classic!
@kaleahcollins4567
@kaleahcollins4567 3 ай бұрын
Yet this would come back in style 200 years later slighty different
@liolef7403
@liolef7403 3 ай бұрын
Fascinating👏🙏🎉
@eric2500
@eric2500 4 ай бұрын
They all look like the waistlines go way down and are expected to be drawn tight to get that shape would be pretty bad at hiding any pregnancy but the earliest ones.
@patmaurer8541
@patmaurer8541 4 ай бұрын
I like a long, flared skirt or coat as much as anyone, but the idea of carrying around a frame (to the sides, or to the rear), is ridiculous. Because I'm not a display rack; my clothes exist to serve me. 😊
@SG-1-GRC
@SG-1-GRC 3 ай бұрын
We can't win. Misogyny, the art of making sure men are always right and women always wrong, whatever you do. The soft fall of the Regency dresses criticised as too clingy, cages that draw skirts away from the body criticised as deceitful and immoral.
@johnnzboy
@johnnzboy 4 ай бұрын
Super interesting
@alva--._..l-._.-l.._.--
@alva--._..l-._.-l.._.-- 4 ай бұрын
Joana was from Portugal and her name was not pronounced as "yuana". You read Joana using the "J" sound. The phonetic symbol is /ʒ/.
@janlafournaise6505
@janlafournaise6505 2 ай бұрын
Oh for god’s sakes. I guess you schooled her, Karen.
@alva--._..l-._.-l.._.--
@alva--._..l-._.-l.._.-- 2 ай бұрын
​@@janlafournaise6505 if you think that someone who is providing other people knowledge is being a Karen, then u r a d*mb*ss!
@NoelleTakestheSky
@NoelleTakestheSky 4 ай бұрын
The thought that anyone other than a woman should own her body infuriates me. I'm also in the US, where single-digit-aged children are able to be forced to have babies now. Anyway, I love finding new small channels that are worth subscribing to. :) #681
@kevinjewell233
@kevinjewell233 4 ай бұрын
Scandalous??? That was the mini skirt in the 60's....although many things were cultural revolutions i their own right, the Mini skirt really was the last castle wall after breaching the chastity walls and moats of societal norms....
@PicoAndSepulveda
@PicoAndSepulveda 3 ай бұрын
Fascinating and infuriating!
@recoveringsoul755
@recoveringsoul755 3 ай бұрын
Difficult to hide a pregnancy unless the skirt halloons out directly under the breasts. If the stomach is still flat...and only the hips and butt and thighs were hidden, how does that hide pregnancy?
@kikidevine694
@kikidevine694 4 ай бұрын
Put wheels on the guarda infanta and you have a baby walker.
@janlafournaise6505
@janlafournaise6505 2 ай бұрын
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. Good one.
@SewardWriter
@SewardWriter 4 ай бұрын
A worrying number of comments about farthingales sound exactly like modern misogynistic comments on women's clothing.
@jahirareyes1102
@jahirareyes1102 4 ай бұрын
Yeah,cause you and the other people in the comment section love to blame men its annoying frankly,just stop stick to the subject.Iam a 16yr old girl and iam fed up with it ,i love historical fashion.But,i hate modern anachronisms.
@nanasaldarriaga7452
@nanasaldarriaga7452 3 ай бұрын
​@@jahirareyes1102calm down, pick me
@janlafournaise6505
@janlafournaise6505 2 ай бұрын
@@jahirareyes1102 Oh, honey you have so much to learn.
@jahirareyes1102
@jahirareyes1102 2 ай бұрын
@@janlafournaise6505 Don't talk down like that to me,i think while of course,like every person i know not everything especially since iam still new but, i know quite alot for my age infact that is indeed at least what many people have come to tell me,adults and my own friends my age,,unless they are lying of course. Also,for your information I'm just getting my experience now. Doesn't mean I can't have my own opinions too.
@janlafournaise6505
@janlafournaise6505 2 ай бұрын
@@jahirareyes1102 You don’t have the lived experience to being “talking down” to others who others who have. You might know quite a lot for your age but you are right, you are quite new and opinions are all that you have at this stage.
@pipitameruje
@pipitameruje 4 ай бұрын
Found you through Bernardette's video. Great video essay, you got yourself a new subscriber. Ps: did you record this with a fan or another machine working in the same room? There's a high pitched sound in the background that becomes bothersome a little while into the video.
@melenatorr
@melenatorr 3 ай бұрын
That painting is not Joana of Portugal, but Juana of Castile, who was born in 1479. We do not have a portrait of Joana, as far as we know, but please do not use the wrong painting - Juana is a notable person in her own right, and so is Joana. They deserve to be distinguished from one another. Also, of course, Juana is not, in this portrait wearing Spanish fashion, but Flemish, as suited her position as Archduchess at this time. Juana did, though, wear Spanish fashion during a feast in Blois as she and Philip journeyed back to Spain with Philip the Handsome, in 1501. She caused a positive sensation and impressed the French court with her dancing.
@sarahabendall
@sarahabendall 3 ай бұрын
Thanks for your comment! You are to totally correct - my apologies. I got my Juana/Joana queens of Castile mixed up. I can’t edit the video, but I’ll pop a correction in the information box!
@DariaAmato-wz2xg
@DariaAmato-wz2xg 4 ай бұрын
So what did a pregnant married woman wear
@codename495
@codename495 3 ай бұрын
Lose robes and they stayed in confinement until they delivered.
@myladyswardrobe
@myladyswardrobe 2 ай бұрын
@@codename495 Nope. They wore the fashionable gowns with farthingales. There are a few paintings where its VERY obvious that the lady is pregnant (she is really showing it off) but the stomacher isn't flat and down as the growing belly is pushing it up...not the farthingale. The book The Tudor Child by Ninya Mikhaila shows in photos how full fashionable 1590s wheel farthingale can be worn whilst 6 months pregnant and when not pregnant.
@NenneSez
@NenneSez 4 ай бұрын
Came over from Bernadette, glad to find you
@therani9600
@therani9600 4 ай бұрын
So, i figure nothing changes in humanity lol
Stop Idolizing Coco Chanel : a shocking history of theft
33:01
Nicole Rudolph
Рет қаралды 431 М.
The Ugliest Dress In Fashion History (That Bridgerton Got Wrong)
22:40
Karolina Żebrowska
Рет қаралды 415 М.
拉了好大一坨#斗罗大陆#唐三小舞#小丑
00:11
超凡蜘蛛
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН
PEDRO PEDRO INSIDEOUT
00:10
MOOMOO STUDIO [무무 스튜디오]
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
Glow Stick Secret Pt.4 😱 #shorts
00:35
Mr DegrEE
Рет қаралды 9 МЛН
How much clothing did they *actually* have back then?
32:47
Nicole Rudolph
Рет қаралды 173 М.
18th century embroidery is NO JOKE. (Trust me, we tried it.)
33:00
Bernadette Banner
Рет қаралды 649 М.
The Actual History of Pink for Girls and Blue for Boys
29:17
Nicole Rudolph
Рет қаралды 269 М.
The Scandalous History of the Tuxedo
21:57
Nicole Rudolph
Рет қаралды 82 М.
Sewing a Tudor farthingale is hard. Let's make a modern one instead!
22:55
Another Dream Gone West
Рет қаралды 16 М.
The Myth of Tuberculosis Fashion : Victorian History Debunked
31:27
Nicole Rudolph
Рет қаралды 162 М.
The Quiet History of Adjustable Clothing [from a non-historian]
24:55
The Stitchery
Рет қаралды 266 М.
Getting dressed for Elizabethan court, circa 1590s
27:29
priorattire
Рет қаралды 335 М.
Dressing a Tudor Queen: Historically Accurate 1530s Clothing
6:17
Samantha Bullat
Рет қаралды 328 М.
拉了好大一坨#斗罗大陆#唐三小舞#小丑
00:11
超凡蜘蛛
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН