Same😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

😢😢

nah I can't even put my mind to believe any of it like WHAT HAPPENED 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 He was always very innocent it's heartbreaking

I'm heartbroken for both of them. Sua the most. I know the feeling of someone not calling you back anymore. It's like whenever you can call them they'll answer. But at the same time it's hard to try call cause it hurts so much.

The same happened to me😢

Totally agree..

Today this hurts more

moonbin be like: 💀 😂😂

@@user-rem7c7c8qw I'm sorry but it's not funny especially for the fans

@@user-rem7c7c8qw Dude

Honestly, now that he’s gone seems like there were other reasons he couldn’t be open with her

​@@pix1943 yes ,I feel the same, something was really bothering him😢

@@pix1943 Perhaps if he had called her he'd still be with us… but I can imagine any number of reasons he wouldn't reach out to her, all of which are _because_ he cared about her (and maybe also knew she was promoting) 😢

@@Soufriere84 He does care for her, but I’m pretty sure they were never that close, as in they didn’t spend much time together when they were children, Sua was a trainee at YG and Astro was busy debuting. It’s hard opening up to someone you’re trying to build a relationship with.

So true. He seems like a more practical person & talking to her would’ve led him to confess his struggles to her. I really wish he opened up to her more. She may see him as her strong successful older brother but he should know it’s okay to show he has weaknesses too 🥺🥺

Binnie the tsundere type to his ASTRO members too

Same my bro did cares a lot bout me but not when i mentions his money hahaja

Then I’m lucky I just go to oldest brother and tell him why i want his card and he will say okay maybe because i just ask for food or books for uni

@@shyhana3055 same i could literally used up his bank money and never get mad

My younger brother uses my Card all the time. He is very reasonable with his spendings though as i dont earn heaps these days

@@user-ri6jq4so3i like I don't earn as much as I used too

Yeah or using that sibling relationship lovey dovey for fame.

I agree

I agree too

Did he committed suic!de?why there are so many k-pop idols taking this path. it's unbelievable that he is no more.

@@sushreesangitanayakraul it’s still not confirmed but that’s what the police are speculating, I honestly want to believe that he didn’t bcs he died on his mom’s birthday, why would he choose to end his life on that specific day??? and I never felt that anything bad was going on with him. He was literally just active on tiktok a few days ago, but at the end of the day we really can’t tell what everyone is going through no matter how much smiles and laughter they show us. He was 25 he was wayyy too young and even now I still cant accept the fact that he’ll never come back.

Binnie also offered to other Billie members to take care of their health and to get something to eat using the credit card he left with Sua.

@@tsinibin Woa, she’s just kind and generous as her brother. What a great big sister of Billie!

What a sweetheart, truly just a stellar and beautiful human being none better, he is definitely missed and truly loved.❤🥲

That's true. That's the last stage of a suicidal person. Cutting away from people most valuable to him/her.

I think the same too maybe he didn't want to answer her calls because he thought she would feel something was wrong...

I wish he had reached out to someone instead and expressed that he was in pain, asked for a break say I don't like this or I'm hurting. To be honest I haven't even processed this situation properly as yet so I don't want to write what I'm feeling until I've figured it out. I feel sad but also confused as well. I don't go deep in the kpop industry as there are aspects of it I can't support and don't like I don't know fully how it operates but I've seen that their industry isn't easy for a lot of them as some have expressed it. Since recently persons have become more candid about it and the difficulties they face and are more open to being more of their natural selves so I'm just left wondering what he was going through that he couldn't share with someone around him. I don't know if he had a religion but I wish he knew how much God loved him and could have brought him through anything he was going through. I can't imagine what his loved ones are going through just thinking about it hurts. Everyone no matter what you're going through please know that God can fix it just call on him and tell him everything and he'll fix it for you. Nothing is impossible for God just trust him.

​@@tomomiweir6386 как же вы правы! Уверенна, Бог способен помочь каждому, но и конечно определенное лечение тоже нужно, если есть депрессия

I dont have a phone but i always receive text messages from my friends and i read them but keep forgetting to reply back…i even left them off for a week because i forgot (i didnt mean to ignore them) 😭

He forgets ....but it is also because he feels awkward with her as they didn't talk much with each other

Me too 😭

Same here.....i've been binge watching over and over again his videos and the more i like him. I just knew him after he passed away and what a pity that he isn't with us in this world anymore. RIP Moonbin....you will be remembered forever....

Yeah i thought same too. Like giving all those money to his family for their happiness but when they wanna contact he avoids it as if he doesn't wanna let them know. I'm curious about from when he is feeling like that and to what extent. I really wanna listen his thoughts but sadly cannot 😢

@@sahananu7117 even if he did not suicide i l sure stress/ pressure/overthinking effects the heart and it leads to heart attacks

it’s kinda hard to say if someone is struggling mentally. from the previous signs, it’s more likely for him to pass due to exhaustion/illness that we don’t know or maybe it’s just sudden death? but still, we never know the real reason :( i hope we get the closure

@@blossomrose5134 nuh it's a bit easier when you pay attention to the details my mom passed away by sadden heart attack but i could tell she was depressed and mentally struggling after many miscarriages i was young but i noticed it all i did not understand now i do so i can tell i lil moonbin's death was cuz of mental health and physical health illness these two combined lead to heart attacks and strokes, when someone is physically ill his mental health effects directly (it's nerve and brain related), also when you got sick mentally your body reacts to it by anxiety/hair falling/ pale skin/dark circles/eating disorder...

@@Rinadharb98 that’s fair. it could be combined with both. it’s hard to say the cause of his death. no matter how difficult it is, i wish he wouldn’t die due to mental health but again, we never know anything about someone’s struggle. i really hope he is happy there

That’s exactly what I’m thinking as well and it makes sense 💯💔💐 rip moonbin 😞😞

he not suicide ok the police not any found any injure on his body is could be his physical health he nose also keep bleeding at many time

and now people are overanalyzing his behavior/words because of what happened 😮‍💨

Please don't over interpret when you know nothing of him personally and only because of his sudden loss.

@@catlechat7785 that wasn’t the intention.

Lol

True...He was suffering

you don’t know anything. his behaviour don’t indicate anything. might be his personality or out of habit lol stop speculating

@@blossomrose5134 if ur a astro fan from long time like me i know better than u

@@blondies8061 lol just because you’re a heavy stan, that doesn’t mean you know everything about him, or whoever idols you’re stanning. we are just fans, not family. in fact, even his close ones are shock at the news. know your boundary and stop speculating.

Or maybe she might feel betrayed, cause now she knows why he wasn't picking up her calls.

I hope it’s not suicide( I don’t think he would do it on his mom’s birthday (

He is sick stroke/blood pressure. 99% we believe not suicide

Bin oaid for earpieces, an expensive camera, and bought a phone for Sua, too. He even told other Billie members to have meals using the card he left with Sua. Buuuut... he doesn't give Sua a copy of the Refuge album and she had to buy it herself. Haha!