8ve never heard anyone say they don't need healthy soil, just use electro culture. It all starts with healthy soil. Electro culture is a supplement

This video makes a well reasoned case against aggressive secession planting. It does not present any other negative effect of electro culture techniques. There is no reason to believe that electro culture can not be added to standard organic soil care.

I know a man who has been using this system for many MANY years and his gardens are super-producing. His corn is 10 feet tall! His tomatoes are doing fabulous, and so is everything else. Electroculture does not kill the soil, it improves it.

I placed some copper pipe w antenna next to my dying orange tree and it does repel termites which they were killing the tree.. At least bad ants and termites are gone, let's see if the tree will recover..if it does, I'll believe that it works ! I need at least one year to see.

Why Not a combination of both? Taking care of the soil and electroculture

The best way to feed your soil is with the exudates of the plants themselves. I use lots of compost, vermicompost, mulch etc. But cover crops and cover plants are awesome some are better than others

I am not interested in secession planting so it sounds like electro is good for a huge crop and then keep maintaining a good healthy soil. Thanks so much. Others have proven and shown the difference in crop yield. Thanks for the information, nice to hear both sides.

I have a feeling that like many things within the realm classified as “conspiracy” their are elements of truth and elements that are completely over exaggerated. I’m going to give it a go on my blueberry plants and compare results.

My husband bought home 8 kilos of copper wire for me to experimenrt with. I have wrapped a few stakes to ground with peas and beans but have prepped my soil as well. If for nothing else they look pretty 😍

I've run a 6' -1/4" copper tod back & forth thru a raised bed, then did 1 foot circles with it while spinning it counterclockwise & singing up the scale 3 times, then reversing, singing down the scale & spin clockwise, going all over the 4' square bed. Learned it from Viktor Schauberger. The soil was soft for 8 months or more. I could just run my fingers thru it easily. Prior to that I had to use tools. Iron. Steel hardens the soil. This winter I am copper electroplating my garden tools like they did 100-150 years ago.

I just recently stumbled across "electroculture" and when I search for it everybody is talking stupid nonsense. You are the first normal person I found.😁

Did your negative expectation effect the results of your experiment? Using electroculture, no good gardener is going to stop using compost. Let's do everything we can to produce food, right?

Electroculture is the an ancient practice of increasing yields utilizing certain materials to harvest the earth's atmospheric energy. This was presented in 1749 by Abbe Nollett, in the 1920s by Justin Christofleau, and 1940s by Viktor Schauberger. This energy is always present and all around us also known as Chi, Prana, Life force, and Aether. Be Blessed!

the technique electro culture was first presented in 1749 by Abbe Nollett, then in the 1920s by Justin Christofleau, and in the 1940s by Viktor Schauberger.

I'm in my 8th decade of life and gardening. I came across this subject only recently and have done much research on it. To date you are the only one who call it like she sees it. It is largely another bright idea to gain money at the gullible expense. As P. T. Barnum, who came from my area used to say: there is a sucker born every minute.;-)

If it seems too good to be true, it probably is. Korean natural farming and working with the soil life for maximum diversity has given me explosive results.

I have found electroculture gardening awesome and I also feed my garden a lot with compost, worm wee, seaweed, grass clippings etc. I haven't heard that with electroculture you need no fertilizer that doesn't really make sense. I have found its been great for keeping away bugs and massive veggies. Thanks for the video :)

Question... Do you think this will work for potted plants? Because you still have to take care of the soil yourself (in terms of putting nutrients back into it by hand since its in a pot in an apartment building and not directly to the ground )

I completely agree with you, and thank you very much for the wonderful and simple explanation

Thank you for this video! I feel like it is “real” in a way where people will take care of their plants and soil more but if they are not taking care of their soil they will eventually run into problems no matter what.

I would like to ask you when I harvest I have to add soils and fertilizer to the post or not.

During resting you should feed the microbiology. 1 Tablespoon yeast, , 2Tablespoons sugar, half cup rice and 1 cup water. Prepare yeast in normal way. Feed 1 teaspoon sugar every 2 days, 7 days in strain water add cup of milk. 10 days water down by half and feed to plants. Replacing the micros

Madame, while I may not completely agree with you yet… My first year trying electro culture. I am incredibly impressed that almost on an eight minute video. You did not need to look at any notes in the previous 15 minute video that I just watched of you. You didn’t look at any notes… That being said that is a rarity in today’s society where people have enough cognitive ability to talk about some thing that they know for 15 minutes straight. I recognize this, as I have spent much time outside in the field in the garden as well, and I recognize that you don’t get that ability without spending much time in the garden or the field… Clearly you have! Good job!

Hi, how's your garden going? Are you still into electroculture?

No matter what kind of farming you do you need to introduce your chickens to your garden patch put up some chicken wire around it and then open up the chicken wire and put your chickens in there so they stay in one area and they’ll go around pick up the bugs and they’ll poop and pee and have a great dayput some water out there for them to have but other than that they’ll pretty much take their dirt baths and find every little bug you have out there and they’ll also scratch the soil. This add air to it.

Here’s the link to the results of my original trial of electroculture which I REALLY wanted to work. Other videos of earlier progress are on my channel kzfaq.info/get/bejne/npZ_e6qHq7Wdcn0.html

One word. Donkey doodoo, real good fertilizer.

Electro magnetic culture is the best thing around ! She did her experiment which we should all do but from what I gather form her she didn’t read many books or watched the videos out there on it ! PRk au have forgotten the important message that they all mention on their research !’ Test your soil make your soil know hour difference kind of soil that your plants need to grow in! Yes make certain that your soil is good to go. But it doesn’t really matter to start with as long that there’s a little nutrients on your soil your food is going to pack !because the antennas are going to do their work! Then if you need to add composts aged manure .. you do ! What she isn’t telling you is that with an antenna you don’t need to fertilize your soil as often the antennas help to prolong your soil fertility!! It also help reduced watering ! So less fertilizing and less watering ! They also help reduced pest and brings predator insects that will eat the bad insects those antennas help balance it all and the higher the antenna the more coverage it will have . You ll have more life . More predator birds to eat the insects You’ll have less slugs and snails. Less infections. It will attract the right fungi that your garden and soil needs. What she isn’t telling you is that the antennas help to bring balance between the soil earth and air atmosphere! It balances out the positive and negative Ions and helps with the energetic transfer and helps ease the flow of the micro voltage from the earth atmosphere ! All book says the you must test your soil once or twice a year. They also mention to add compost and other natural nutrients during the growing seasons they also mention to add mulch or wood chips to help keep the moisture on the soil . She also didn’t mention that for the antennas to work the soil has to have some humidity for the transfers of energetic micro nutrients to work ! All of you must at least read 2 to ; books on the antennas of you want to grasp the effectiveness of the antennas and how they actually save you from spending to much money and time on the garden or on your field ! Yes field because it is used on commercial size grops ! Have you seen the sizes of vegetables that you ll end up getting ? Have your veggies tested for its nutritional values between non electro Magnetic culture and electro magnetic culture ! Many crop growers across Europe the USA and Canada are all belong each other out on testing . There’s mNy videos on your tube that have been made on the research especially by the Belges the French and Germans and came out with amazing results Maybe she didn’t red many books on it or didn’t watch many research videos . Actually the English ( Brits Scot’s Irish have done many videos about it and they also came up with amazing results and they all do mention for the big crops you need or amend your fields between every 4 to 6 years ! So just imagine your small garden ! Anyways experiment for yourselves do your own personal research fro maths old books and on your own garden . Pay attention to all details on rhe books and right then down on your own garden diary! I’d Suggest to start reading of the history of it where it all began Z

My beans are rocking, I have so many and they just keep providing!. It’s crazy , my in-law has pulled all his beans , I have picked 9 bags of beans , picked again for another there 6 bags, this was a week ago , I have to pick tomorrow. My tomatoes are a week and a few days in the ground and they have doubled in size . Works for me. I mean you can break up the soil and get some good soil and top up as you go!. 😊

I wonder if electroculture just helps the CDC (cation exchange capacity) which helps with water and nutrient uptake in relation to plant growth.

Thank you for your presentation.

What if you didn’t change anything about your soil emendment and just added the copper antenna? In between harvesting, amend and let soil rest before planting again? How would that effect the soil negatively?

Im in SD. USA I only get on crop maybe 2 small leafy greens, I also use rabbit manure and amend the soil as i go for about 6 months or so the soil is resting and covered with grass and leaf mulch. Just curious on your thoughts about this

Where is the link where you tested? Please 🙂

it naturally occurs even without and antenna so it does work and every farmer knows it takes good grow dirt to grow

Isn't farm fencing with metal t-posts essentially electroculture? If that's the case it's in use on almost every small farm already

Just wanting a superior crop this season and less pests. In winter, I compost fall leaves till mid spring (trash can composting). I incorporate those into the soil for the next years' planting. I also use biochar. When planting, I add in some azomite. Occasionally I will add some Epsom salt. All this is mostly for tomatoes and wife's flowers. Biochar gives the microbes a home. They LOVE sulfur free molasses and multiple like crazy. You still need organic matter for them to do their job.

Thank you for sharing this information with us

I would obviously never abandon my soil. I haven’t seen anyone say they abandoned their soil either. My question would be if it prevents pests the what about the beneficial pests and worms. I want to know if they are affected. Anyone?

I'm not seeing people report, with certainty, that electroculture works in containers, however, a high central antenna connected with a large underground spiral of copper wire made plants grow extra tall along the underground wire on one report I saw by Cahlen Lee.

Thanks so much Beck. I'm so going to thin back next year. The garden suffered massively this year due to not thinning out excess seeds. Actually I'll admit this is the second year I let all the volunteers go. We all know the fool saying so I've definitely learnt my lesson. Thanks for your great informative videos.

The best thing for your plants is composted plant matter from your last grow season

I think when electroculture was originally used the earth had a different more electrical atmosphere. That being said there is still merit to the practise today particularly with antennas of a good height 20ft+. Also i have found magnetoculture to still be very effective today

Reasonable argument

I'm going to do both.. Manifest and Believe✨ Green Garden Magic 💚🌿💚🌿💚

What if I’m growing in pots?

I planted my rods in December over winter. Now my garden is 3-4 times bigger, thicker, stronger and more productive than EVER before! It’s incredible!

Impressive. Are you still into electroculture?

Thank you.

If it doesn't work where is the link that you promised? You give lots of theory but don't show the evidence. How is that different than those in favor of elctroculture?

Why don't you just try it side by side? This will be a lot more valid if you do. I agree I don't think you should not add anything to the soil, but at the same time a well tended beds some with and some without coils will be a better test.

you perked by attention when you mentioned in nature. When walking in the woods I do not see copper wire sticking in the ground.

Finally someone who take symbiosis into account

Watering with Kompost tea & electroculture will be good for soil 👍

Best Electroculture video out there. Thank you so much for doing a proper video addressing this nonsense going around.

There is a lot of logic to this ,can I just ask if you have tried this method to study the effects?or just using your experience to come up with a well delivered theory , with many scientific analysis,theories are just that, I would probably use both methods of electroculture and no dig ,

The soil part makes absolute common sense

Electroculture does not replace nutrients or water, you still need to create good soil, what the copper wire does do is bring good energy to your soil making it more efficient

This is another way to ask for handouts from a fertilizer company Did you get any?

Copper is very expensive...but available.....go ahead and make investers rich

Electro culture says that? I haven't read anywhere that you shouldn't have good soil ? So strange how it's being put down when it really is something to do in addition I would think! Hmmm

Products of mother nature work in synergism. They need each other to boost and accomplish the goal. Like taking vitamins should be taken with a matching mineral or another type of vitamins or may do more harm than good or be less effective as they should be. Same with the balance use of the NPK that might deplete one or cancel the other from improper use. A healthy compost pile balance of brown and green ingredients is just another example of mother nature's sacred way. They all work together for the living things to survive. All for our own interest vs the man-made synthetic products that are beneficial to the bid corp pockets while destroying this one and only beautiful planet given to us for free.

You could grow Crops like cannabis or Hemp that Naturally rejuvenate soils and Grows very Nicely with electro culture

I use in a hydrophonic garden. Only the 3.5m antenna, grounding system and properly routed wires with magnets. You don't need any nutrients just like plants don't really need light to grow properly 😉 it's all about the right proportions ☀️🌕

Where is the proof or link that it doesn't work?

I try and test this electro culture for 3 months now in the garden and several pot plants. For me it does not work at all and no difference to other plants without the copper coil around the stick. Some sick plants even die and magic copper stick did not help at all. I hope to see the magic later. I already spend time and money to create the so called magic sticks so I will keep on test and experiment

What is not discussed here is the use of intelligent soil management (compost, natural soil enhancers, worms, worm castings, etc.) ADDED TO electroculture. Electroculture can be done any number of ways, then, not just as some are suggesting--i.e., without any other soil treatment or enhancement. Disappointing that you would leave this out!

Perhaps you could have expanded your tests by coiling the copper wire clockwise and then anti-clockwise. You did not specify whether the rotation was from a bottom-up, or top-down perspective. I've seen a gardener in 🇳🇿 do an experiment with both directions, as well as various other contraptions and she got an improved result on one of them but not so much on the other. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/ermdlJifvrXWoI0.htmlsi=WpJvEOmUzr6jzmhB

In conclusion electro culture doesn’t work

As they say, feed the soil not the plant

You do not need to “rest” soil. That’s as much of a myth as the “no fertilizer” one! You CAN grow continuously if your climate allows it AND you are replacing the nutrients used with organic matter. It’s the combination of having organic matter AND a living root system that creates the perfect environment for well balanced microorganisms in your soil. This is why using cover crops is so important.

If you look to grow a garden without actually fitness nutrition and is expected to come out the sky Danielle, this video is for you but if you actually understand how stuff grows, I have the power of the side and what about thumbs up my video not this one

Electroculture needs a ground pole of 1.8 meters or 6ft and also needs different types of metals such as galvanized wire that travels under the soil and also different type of antena theres a few more things it's not just a copper wire antenna as they explain. When it comes to the soil the problem is the probiotics or the light beings that use the electro culture to breakdown the nutrients need to be grounded because if you are just giving them the ionosphere energery just the antenna and not the ground then eventually they will die and they are the ones in control of the moisture of the soil the use and bond of nutrients that will then be delivered to the roots of the plants. To get an amazing soil obviously need all minerals nutrients and probiotics mix good bacteria mix with right bugs and then the use of compost tea and shade. Stop using iron and steel shovels e.t.c because they absorb the soils nutrients and moisture there's a lot of factors activated char and probiotics blend with minerals is my secret there's truth to all types of gardening need to research more then just adding copper wire to ground

If anyone thinks they just need to add antennae and do nothing else their dreaming. That is all this video is saying, no argument with that. Adding antennae on top of being the best gardener is not detrimental to your gardening. As even this channels has no longitudinal data (Years of testing) from the experiments they have done. Gardening is a balancing act and those that are more successful have the time, expertise and or the money to dedicate to nurturing a garden and growing the best produce they can. Again a no brainer.

The dirt looks a lot better than the hay pile

respectfully, it would have helped your video/ opinion if you would have taken pics or made a video doing electro gardening. How else am i suppose to see and believe???

I bet you’re fun at parties

Thanks for making this. Seems the kooks are all about this right now

Ohh sweetie you do you. No need to exert Your findings as truth.

Very simple solution. at the end of the summer beginning of the Fall you will remove your copper antennas and let the soil rest until spring

You still need the nutrients with electro culture, you're watching the wrong videos anyone with a growing background knows you need nutrients with or without electro culture

Speech coach was a California valley girl 😂🎉

Good arguments. But, so a wise combination is the key.

The number one nutrient you can put in your soil is worm castings you’re doing it you just saying it wrong

everything you said about electroculture is wrong! including the claims about not needing to add compost or fertiliser to the soil. Maybe your test weren't done right? Theres plenty of gardeners using this method and getting amazing results, including myself.

If u dont do it right it will draw the wrong energy.

I don't know if or how electroculture works but you contradict yourself trying to make the point that it is harmful. You say organic process involves plant taking up nutrients and other organisms urinating and defecating near plant is nature's process and when plant dies all of it's nutrients go back to soil. However all the same processes can or would occur with a conductive wire running near the plants. Your argument to me is null and void. Having said that I am still looking into how this electoculture may possibly work. I do know that ALL life is affected by electromagentic fields all the way down to the cellular and DNA level, that is well documented in peer review science. How it may work on plants and food production I do not know but I am certainly not going to give up just because you say so without any clear scientific evidence to back it up.

The facts speak for themselves and i tried it and it works and is soo easy. ..just go to the next video if you see this. The method speaks for it self and is super cheap to do. And if you have a understanding of energy frequency and vibration and go deeper into the topic it all makes sense. Just continue you're research cuz this ladys is definitely poor just like her crops. Not to be offensive dough just do some more research and give it another chance and become a A student. Electroculture + good monoatomic nutrients = magic

Do you have a microscope? The only way to know if you have good compost or good soil is by looking at what biology is in the soil for the crop you are trying to grow. You have to calculate the bacteria and fungal ratio, as well as inspect the nematode if its is bacterial feeding, fungal, feeding, omnivore or predatorial. This is the best way to determine if your soil is fertile. Problem with manure today is the animals get injected with antibiotics which ends up in the manure which kills the soil microbes as well.

So you are saying it works you just need a good replenishment program.

Even this video isn't true. Yes it's all about soil health but the modern practice of playing in compost is ridiculous. Dig a hole, add seed, water when needed. In the fall allow your weeds and clipping. Plus plant to die and return to the ground.. this keeps your soil healthy. If you're following Biblical garden, rest your land on the 7th year.

Tell that to the Chinese they are growing with no light with elec. Electrolyzers are devices that use electricity to convert raw materials like carbon dioxide into useful molecules and products. Acetate is a common ingredient found in household items, such as vinegar, cosmetics and hair care products. But here, acetate was used to cultivate yeast, mushroom-producing fungus and photosynthetic green algae in the dark, without photosynthesis.

I thought the point of electro culture is to enhance what is already there, not replace it. Maybe you’ve been seeing some hyped up vids/tik toks or something. 🤷🏼‍♀️

She mis-characterizes Electroculture. I know no one who uses Electroculture who doesn’t also practice good farming techniques. Nothing of what she says about Electroculture is what those who I know employing Electroculture do or consider. She doesn’t really appear to know what it is. The empirical evidence of Electroculture working is overwhelmingly in its favor.

SNAKE OIL

Did you experiment with everything you are saying? Or are you just theorizing about what might happen?

In my opinion electroculture should be used together WITH Terra Preta dar earth. I didnt done any experiments so its still just a hypotesis of mine but i think it would be worth a try.

This woman is apparently completely undaunted by her lack of knowledge and understanding. First, “electroculture” doesn’t claim there’s no need for nutrients. Wherever in the Lord’s name did you get that from? Second, an electroculture antenna does not “draw electricity” into the soil; it raises the electrical ground around the antenna several feet into the air, which lessens the electrostatic load of the earth’s atmosphere onto the surrounding plants, which makes it less effort for them to grow. Due to this saved energy, the plants can grow faster and with deeper roots, allowing them to absorb more nutrients. Third, how are you not returning the nutrients to the soil? You only need to spread the plant material around your plants, be it mulch or compost. It sounds more like you are just a bad gardener. Don’t blame electroculture for that. A little tip: don’t start an argument about something you don’t understand. You’ll just look foolish.

Looks like you bought a dozen worms for the video.

This video sets up a straw man argument that I have never heard a single person that is advocating for electro culture proclaim. It feels like an excuse to be a pretend expert Karen