You're right, of course, but they'd most likely have different points of view.

That being said it's a little oversaturated on how close they were as songwriters when they wrote more apart than together.

Paul taught John chords and how to tune his guitar! His Mom taught him banjo chords, Paul taught John how to write songs! Paul brought George into the band! Paul kept John going because John was lazy! If not for Paul, John would have quit in 66 John was jealous of Paul and competed with him. Thank You Paul!! Yoko cheated on John at the time of his death! No true love story there.

@@antimurphy8212 Everything about them is oversaturated. I wish one person out there would give an honest appraisal of their relationship.

I COMPLETELY AND TOTALLY AGREED WITH YOU WHATEVER IS BETWEEN ME AND MY LIFELONG FRIEND IS MOST DEFINITELY NOBODY’S FUCKING BUSINESS NO ONE HAS PRIVY OF SOMEONE ELSES RELATIONSHIP WITH THEIR LIFELONG FRIEND AND THEY SOULD’NT HAVE PERIOD

Correct.

Also, McCartney said in an interview that some of the lines in Yesterday, namely "Why she had to go, I don't know, she wouldn't say", could be in reference to his mother.

Yesterday was a reference to Paul's mother

Yeah and ppl thought "Mother Mary" was a reference to the biblical Mother Mary (I did as well).... It was his actual mother whose name was Mary.

@DnB and Psy Production He was aware.... Take a sad song and make better

I was thinking the same thing

I agree

Don't forget Paul

@@motnosniv I don't believe you that theory sht and a fruad just like you

@@Miist3rDuce1 they were making a joke....

Really??

@@terrihamet5617 Yes ….. Really!

@Ross Smith Okay 👍

@@adorabledeplorable5105 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

@@robertvannoy4412 o..............Kay .

It does. I made a similar comment without having seen yours.

Came here to say the same thing.

I think you are correct - I also think the song "Your Mother Should Know" off Magical Mystery Tour. and I think that on Sgt. Pepper - "She's Leaving Home" (is either his mom's youth regarding falling in love with Paul's dad - or - it is about one of her sisters.") I've never seen an interview where Paul proclaimed such - but once when asked - he sort of shrugged his shoulders and blew the interviewer off - in one of his rare aloof moments - and needed to keep moving through the airport. And in Paul's solo career - I think there may be other impressions of his mom - but can't say that with certainty. But he was very shaken by her death - to boot at the time his mother was the breadwinner - and he was only 14 years old (so his trama must have had a double edge to it) - and it would not be long after her passing that Paul at 15 or 16 wrote: "When I'm Sixty-four." That also made Sgt. Pepper - Now the song does not reference his mom - but you can tell that her passing had him thinking of the time - and life - and being fed - and all the mothering tones within the lyrics.

@@2DanTube 👍☺

There may not be any people in 100 years!

Yeah, I caught that too. He took enough credit for the Beatles in his book "The Man Who Gave the Beatles Away." (I actually thought it was The Man Who Sold the Beatles.)

@Ross Smith Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein were fine composers and wrote many great Broadway plays and musicals. They entertained millions of people but no way shape or form did they have the impact of the Beatles. The music of Lennon and McCartney influenced western culture. They changed the way we look and the way we think. The decade we know as the 60s effectively began on February 9, 1964 when the Beatles appeared on the Ed Sullivan show. The 50s had affectively ended with the assassination of John F. Kennedy on November 22, 1963. The Beatles rekindled rock ‘n’ roll which had.died when Elvis Presley went into the army in 1958. Lennon and McCartney songs were covered by more artists then any other duo in history. The proof is in the history books my friend. Now you can offer me some proof that Rodgers and Hammerstein were the greatest song writing duo of the 20th century.

@Ross Smith next joke Ross

Period?????? Why are you telling people you have lady problems?????

Truth Indeed AMEN

and Jagger-Richards

Amen

That is true because the one you love the most can hurt you the most

What about the people/fans that don't know?🤔

Fxckk that rehash that sxit lol

@@Zeldarw104 don't know what??

Maybe you are older, but many younger people do not know this stuff. Let the truth prevail. Forget about Beatles propaganda

@@blairbrownie1223 Younger people don't need to know. The music stands for itself...gossip about the Beatles is useless.

Wings are great

@@Bella-nt7ec agreed...When discussing Macca, it doesn't end with the Beatles. He went on to record some truly great music

Has he died!!! I’m such a big of the Beatles best song is hey Jude !? I can’t believe John is gone

@@simonwilson812 dunno if you got the memo, but he's been kinda dead since 1980.

@@simonwilson812 Do you natively speak English?

@@christrontherobot4100 Yes

@@slikethesnake 1980 🤔 you suuuuuuuure !¿ I’m pretty sure he only died recently

Neither will I. I'd just gotten back into the Beatles about two years before. The summer of 1980 was something else. I'd found a couple of old Capitol albums, was watching reruns of the Beatles cartoon series and hearing songs I hadn't heard before (we didn't have ALL the albums when we were growing up, but I soon remedied that). I'd also bought "Rarities", and was lucky enough to watch "Magical Mystery Tour" on a local station for the first time ever. Then I started reading about him going into the recording studio, then I heard "(Just Like) Starting Over" for the first time in November, then a month later......

Pretty accurate

Only two did. I’ll leave it up to you to figure out which two.🙄

@@gretchennelson7056 Paul and Ringo? .

@@afreakaboucher1316 😂😂

I agree, the Beatles made some of the best music in history. And in my opinion is it still the best.

@@pplmstr6965 . 👍

Ofc

@@TRUMP-2024-STF Oh sure. Just like Justin Timberlake and the Backstreet Boys

@@TRUMP-2024-STF lol. 😁

Truth Indeed

@@justiceforjamespaulmccartney The thing with that "Theory" is that they've somehow managed to replace "The real Paul" with an even more talented guy.....

Yeah. The Beatles had to take care of the business side of things themselves after that. Definitely didn't help matters.

@@justiceforjamespaulmccartney I hope you’re joking

@@justiceforjamespaulmccartney You don’t know for sure. You would *like* to. But you don’t. You are so put into this idea, this fantasy, that you have blinded yourself from reality to a sickening degree.

I doubt he would be too impressed with commercial modern music. Few people are.

No, she showed him banjo chords which hé used on his guitar.

It's saying nothing..

What?? Why?

zzzzzz

@@bob44044 the truth scares you.

Long live Billy

@@OldSchoolVibes1978 May he live a long and agonizing life of lies and deception...

​@@mdorn6592The original Beatles were Colin Unwin, Jahn (Viv) Stanshall Halliday Ackrill, Terry Johnston and Mark (last name unknown). After their gig in Candlestick Park in 1966 they all disappeared in a van, never to be seen again After that The Beatles continued with taller look-a-like's. We don't know the real names of Fohn, Feorge and Fingo but we now Faul's is William Shepherd. The original Beatles are still alive and atill friends.

The scenes in which John's playing with the Quarrymen and they meet for the first time are from the movie "Nowhere Boy", which came out in 2009 I think

There was at least two movies made about the Beatles, possibly more...

@@filofilo1178 Thanks! I'll look for it!

@@GailGurman you should definetly watch it. Nowhere Boy is great imo

Paul died in late 1966 and was replaced by Billy, who has been impersonating him for decades. The apathy of most people when told this truth is astonishing. Its like pauls personhood has been erased. Killed, replaced and erased. Someone else took his name. For money, a successful career and fame. And most people still oblivious.

No it’s because Brian Epstein died which left a leadership vacuum. John was too strung out on LSD so Paul stepped in to keep it going. John resented this as he was always the leader. Paul’s stickler ways and cheesy songs annoyed John and George as well

@@aunch3 No it's because Paul died which left new Paul in total control.

Paul took over Epstein's role not leadership of the band.

Yes, Paul died on September 11 1966 in car crash and was replaced by William (Billy) Shepherd a right-handed session musician.

Because, see, I can tell them apart by their voices...

Yes, I was wondering about that!

The last thing "Sir Paul" (William) is speaking are the facts.

@@olskzeri8007, another Paul hater ! Don’t you know that Lennon daid a lot of lies? No you don’t know then google as he himself said that he changes depending of the time, his humor blah blah. He even lied how he met yoko , lied about the time she stalked him around 2 yrs. And lots lots of times moron

I had never heard that, that’s interesting that it was Epstein that made it Lennon-McCartney and not vise a versa. I thought it was from alphabetical order but your reason makes more sense.

@@MrSpooner1985 you will find that there first album Please please me all the songs are written by McCartney and Lennon

Wrong. They went with Lennon/McCartney because L comes before M in alphabetical order.

@@jeffmurray1681 I am afraid you are wrong, it was McCartney and Lennon, if you look at Love me Do you will see it is written by McCartney and Lennon, if you look at their first album with their first songs they wrote you will see they are credited with McCartney and Lennon, believe me I know

This is not true. John and Paul decided to share authorship years before Brain came on the along. One idea was the person who came up with the idea for the song, their name would come first, but later decided that Lennon and McCartney would be what they'd use all the time. Why ? Alphabetical, it's that simple.

It was because of shock. Very easy to undrstand.

@@bob44044 it was not of shock. William was just very arrogant of Lennons death.

@@olskzeri8007 No, your wrong. When caught in a moment like that people don't know what to say. He was still in shock.

@Ross Smith Yoko Uno did an outsider art performance where she stood in an art gallery and started screaming like that you moron. Do you live under a rock? Type in keywords Yoko Uno Screaming on KZfaq for the video.

@@efilwv1635 Yoko Oh No !

There's loads of stuff on the internet detailing exactly who wrote which song. Although I agree most of the delicious melodies were Paul's, most of the interesting and dreamlike songs were John's. I truly believe it was a partnership of equals

No, Mary was not the mother of "Sir Paul" (William)

The truth!

What? In the early days, they where very similar to any other british pop bamd at the time. What separated Beatles from the likes of Herman's Hermits, Gerry & the Pacemakers, The Kinks, Manfred Mann, The Hollies, etc. back then? It was when they quit touring and started experimenting their true creativity and genius started to show and shine.

I sort of agree with you! My favorite LPs are Rubber Soul & Revolver then Beatles For Sale & A Hard Day’s Night. I enjoy the other records too but I think those are the best.

@@kimmern999 You have no soul.

????

@@marcosvideos6787 If you don't believe me check it out

The one and only Billy six toes

No. "Sir Paul" (William) have just made that up.

@héctor escobar medina Escobar No.

@héctor escobar medina Escobar incorrect. His mother played ukulele not banjo. It's why John played Ukulele chords, not banjo chords. they say it inn many interviews and its also why George played ukulele years later too.

"There's no future for guitars bands"

Where the hell do you get your information? John and Yoko were still doing heroin when they lived at the Dakota. And Yoko was always the one to fall off the wagon first!