taylor has said that the kitchen scene was mostly improv, there was a moment they both went off script and they just kept rolling !

Dylan & Sadie did an incredible job with this and I'm still affected by this short film many hours later. So real and heartbreaking. Btw the kitchen scene was mostly improv so that's really cool

"I get older but your lovers stay my age" should absolutely destroy Jake. Cause all his gf are around that age. lol. Taylor is a lyrical genius. Every lyric has intention behind it. She just added more context one of my favourite songs.

Not a Swifty, but she is a songwriting genius. Back in 2010-2011, he was very arrogant. He was embarrassed by her. He liked her but didn't consider her to be cool. He also didn't respect her musically. He did try to distance himself from her. He kept her a secret. Hence the line in the song. Whereas she wasn't ashamed. She kept him like an oath. Meaning he was important and she was loyal. He did her wrong. Side note: Rich peeps beware, the hired help have ears.

Okay, when she says "The only real thing you've ever known" they're showing a very familiar kiss, the spiderman kiss. Jake Gyllenhaal dated Kristen Dunst who we all know played Mary Jane. There's an interview of Jake saying that he'd only fell in love once, he was talking about Kristen. I think young Taylor was referring to herself when she said that, but now, old Taylor looks back at it and knows it wasn't her, so maybe it could be a nod to that, or maybe I'm just overthinking it. But also, in the spiderman movies Mary Jane is the one who iniciates the kiss with first Peter, and then another love interest as if trying to have the same magic, the same spark but after it happens, she realizes it's not the same.

The presence of mind to catch the details was beyond. And yes, there’s a connection to “The Moment I Knew” in which she describes how he didn’t show up to her 21st birthday party.

THE GASLIGHTING 🔥♥️🎯🥺 I feel like it’s Taylor’s advice and knowledge for the younger generations, and also personal therapy for Taylor. 😌

The insight from the two of you is insane. You're both very intelligent.

I just wanna say this is the only reaction I’ve watched so far that got the line “he’s gonna say its love, you never called it what it was” spot on. A lot of people are thinking that this line means that taylor’s ex never said he loved her- but he did, he did gaslight her into thinking that his actions and intentions were out of love, but in reality, it was manipulation. Just wanted to say that I loved this reaction video so much!

You were correct, The Moment I Knew is the name of the other song. It talks about Jake not showing up at her birthday party and her waiting for him to show up all night, so that's the connection.

from what i understood on twitter; yes this song is about her relationship with jake, when he was 30 and she was 19, hence the casting choice she made with dylan and sadie. a lot of people, me included, felt very weird watching the short film due to my view on sadie being a kid, and dylan being a grown man, but the fans believe that what taylor intended for it to be. to feel how messed up that relationship was, in reference to the line "I'll get older, but your lovers stay my age", indicating that young girls are his type. I don't know if I'm making any sense but yeah lol.

Anybody else noticing how they’re always alone?😩 Like he was ashamed to be seen with her in public

wow I watched a lot of reactors but you guys are the ones that understood the film's themes and connotations so well

I'M SO OBSESSED WITH THIS SHORT FILM, SHE'S INSANE. so talented, and Dylan and Sadie killed it. it was just perfect ❤

in the second fighting/breakup scene, you can see sadie screaming "fucking look at me!" while hes being cold and emotionless and god damn that just tore me apart. also i'm sure someone else has said it but he had her scarf on at the end, 13 years later which I think just enforces the idea that shes moved on and is doing great and he might still be caring or holding on to emotions about it if that makes any sense.

"You kept me like a secret and I kept you like an oath " I FELT THAT IN MY SOUL!

STILL FREAKING OUT. SADIE AND DYLAN ARE SIMPLY PERFECTION

'The moment I knew' is the song where the narrative is about that time Jake didn't show up for her birthday and the clip in this was a brief of what happened that night.

The fact that Dylan plays Jake perfectly. Plus Jake always has that moment where whatever character he plays has that moment where he blows up

"it's supposed to be fun, turning 21" is actually a reference to the moment i knew! it was about jake not showing up on her 21st birthday where the 'actress' also asked her what was wrong

I'm a swiftie so I've been watching reaction videos all day but this is the best reaction I've watched so far. Every comment you made was so spot on and I love that you were paying attention not only to the film but the lyrics. Really like the video

I am so ready for you guys to get into Taylor! Here is how I think you should do it 1. Fearless (Taylor’s Version) 2. Red (Taylor’s Version) 3. Lover 4. Folklore 5. Evermore and then as the other re recordings come out you can hear those albums for the first time with all the original and all the vault songs!

I don't consider myself a Swiftie BUT, with the pandemic (and thanks to Chats and Reacts, an aussie yt channel, that mostly talks about Taylor lyrics in a way that is so enjoyable) I started to appreciate Taylor's lyrics... they are soooo good!!!! Maybe sometimes I don't vibe with some of her melodies, but 99% percent of the time the lyrics are STUNNING! So I've been waiting for you to react to some of her lyrics like... months, maybe a year by now? Looooove folklore (favs: my tears ricochet, august, exile and peace), evermore (favs: champagne problems, ivy, evermore, no body no crime, and tolerate it), Reputation (iconic and underrated abum! fav: Don't Blame Me, I Did Something Bad, Getaway Car, Delicate, ... Ready for it?, King of My Heart and New Year's Day) and 1989 as an album is not my thing but I reaaaally love half of that album :B And I'm going to be honest, from Red I just loved All Too Well, but with the new version I kinda enjoyed several tracks, same with Fearless (Taylor's version). I'm not a "country girl" at all (I'm from South America) but there was some reaally nice songs in there like You're Not Sorry, White Horse, Fearless and Mr. Perfectly Fine. Looking forward to see you talking more about her lyrics!!! :)

you two are so incredible. im so so glad you caught the "you abuse me and then you embrace me" thing when they were fighting. its such a hard thing to see sometimes and its such an impossible and helpless feeling in that situation

wow your in depth analysis of this short film make me want to have you react to anything i am interested just to know your opinions about it!!! sooooo more Taylor Swift reactions please

"we are gonna jump into Taylor Swift's discography" -->> me subscribing immediately!!

Fun fact the kitchen scene was actually improv !! Taylor said that it was supposed to be shorter but Dylan and Sadie kept going and they were so magnetic that they couldn't turn the camera off😁😁

She needs to win an Emmy or an Oscar for this

Yes you were right about "The Moment I Knew"! It's another song on this album about when Jake said he would come to her 21st birthday party and then he didn't show up, and it was the moment she knew that their relationship was over

Omg when you mentioned that Jake and his friends are a lot older than Taylor, and that she cannot relate to them, I suddenly remembered a line from her song (Coney Island - a song based from her exes whom I think hurt her so bad) off of evermore album which says "if I can't relate to you anymore then who am I related to?"... It suddenly makes sense. Wth

You two are PRECIOUS! I loved seeing you young men recognize instantly these unhealthy behaviors right away. I've been married for 24 years to a man that treats me like the movie represents (except he didn't leave). I'm crying seeing your thoughtful reaction!

I love the whole thing it was super perfect! At the end he’s watching her, and he actually has the red scarf around his neck.

This was about Taylor and Jake Gyllenhal’s 3 month relationship. Sadie played Taylor (of course) and Dylan played Jake. There was an 10 year age difference between Taylor and Jake

yeah the party scene is in reference to her song "the moment i knew" which is about him (Jake) missing her 21st birthday & in the new ATW lyrics you can make the connection!!

taylor is literally my life. so beautiful and talented. such a masterpiece

First video I've seen of yours and I was really impressed with how thoughtful and nuanced your reaction was, unlike most younger reactors who just kind of react with emotion to videos. Great work and looking forward to seeing more of your content!

That kitchen seems so natural because it is, it was mostly improv. Incredible.

It is a ✨ MASTERPIECE ✨ I loved it so much 😭❤️

i like that this is the first time you listened to it because this is the version she intended to put out originally but her older record label made her chop it down

10 mins. Can you imagine a full length movie...Loved this video and your honest reaction. I had the same.

The way you guys see and analyze things is so mindblowing and amazing. It just shows a different breed of intelligence. Well done guys; great reaction. Loved this decoding.

You guys are so cute! Your interest is so genuine. “Abuse me then embrace me.” Keep up the good work!

I love your take and reaction on the song and the film. She's truly a lyrical genius.

I’ve been watching a bunch of these reactions and this has been the most insightful one I’ve seen, I really liked what you said about “I kept you like an oath” meaning holding on even when maybe you shouldn’t. Very interesting!

WHEN YOU GRABBED THE POPCORN I HOLLERED

i am beyond impressed with how insightful your guys’ commentary was! sadie and dylan were such a driving force in telling this story and you guys picked up on so many of the nuances. loved the reaction!

both sadie and dylan are unreal actors wow it felt so real

i don’t think y’all realized this but at the end when he is watching her, he has the red scarf on that she left

I'm still watching the video, but so far I'm loving it! I think both of you are so very insightful and attentive in your reactions, which really sets your channel apart. This is my first time watching your videos and I'm so into it

Omg loveee your reaction! You guys were spot on!

the analyses in this video were very insightful. it was nice watching you guys react to the short film :)

Very genuine reaction! Great job, loved it ♥️

Love this reaction!! Love that you guys point out the film themes and lyrics

IM SO HAPPY YOU GUYS MADE THIS VIDEO AHHHHH

I really love how you guys review the short film! Woaaaa

this is why i subscribed! i love love love the analyzing y’all do, from the lyrics to the actual film dialogue and the film itself. great video

By far my most favorite reaction to the song/short film. Loved all of the connections you made and the insights you both had. So good!!

It's crazy that you haven't spotted Taylor yet, because she was like THE artist of the last 10 to 15 years.

this reaction is amazing! i love how you guys captured most thing people usually don't, so good.

I loved your reaction and breakdown if the lyrics, music and music video. Your insights made me rethink my view of certain scenes. Thank you for sharing !

pure masterpiece🥺💔

Omg I loved you guys so much, so aware and so into the video, every comment on point. Subscribing rn!

the observations and deductions you guys made were SO SPOT ON !!!!! love this reaction sm

yessss I need those reactions!!!!!!! her albums are soo goood

You guys are so thoughtful, this video is amazing.

I love how invested you were in this, how rapt you were when watching, and your reactions were so honest and insightful. I'm new to watching you, but you have a new fan! Taylor Swift is a genius, and I love seeing her be appreciated. Great job, you two.

Great reaction. Thank you. I enjoyed your analysis and comments. Taylor 's writing skills, singing skills and filmmaking skills are on full display in this video. I loved it.

Your comments were so on point. Loved this reaction! I hope you do more Taylor stuff.

You two are phenomenal!

really loved your reactions!! you were very insightful and smart

You guys have great rhythm, bobbing your heads together in time

Love this!!!! The moment I knew is about how Jake very famously stood her up for her 21st Bday party. So, yes she included that part in this song and film.

Great video guys! I love both your faces when Taylor appeared at the end! Beautiful big smiles! Thanks to both of you for sharing your reaction to this fantastic film! Peace~

I loved your thoughtful narrative on this. Good men.

This is my favorite reaction so far ♥️

I loved watching it reaction Ty for sharing it

Damn I love your guys’ reactions. You really picked up on everything.

you guys did so well in this video!! amazing observations!!

as a taylor fan since middle school i can say i absolutely loveee ur reactions to her. It’s so genuine and authentic🥺. Thank youu there’s so many that just try to hop on what’s hot or not actually respect and appreciate her craft. Absolutely loved ur reaction! WILL DEFF CONTINUE WATCHING🤩♥️

It's supposed to be fun, turning 21.. it's about her 21st bday .. jake was supposed to come but he never showed up .. and yes it's from the moment I knew.

the birthday scene is so much more emotional when you listen to the moment i knew before!! i totally recommend listening to it and watching the film over. also the moment i knew and all too well are both about jake gyllenhaal

I watched about 150 videos like this, of people watching and analyzing the heartwrenching song and the great performances that are in this film, and your video is the most unique one I've seen. I loved every second of it, I loved the way you interpret and analyzed what you heard and saw. You are bright and emotional and I appload you for such a great piece of content. Thank you very much.

Man, you guys are good. Truly enjoyed your perspectives.

This is such a good review. It’s so intelligent, yet it also delves into the emotions. I’m so happy I stumbled by this one when I went down this ATW reaction video rabbit hole. I didn’t even notice it was an almost-30 minute video! Thank you so much for such an insightful review. 💙

Great video! I’m a twin as well. ☺️ But that kitchen scene was one take! And they kept rolling. This short film was so good, I’m still not over it. ❤️

you nailed the interpretation! loved your reaction!

Omg,I love you guys!My fav channel rn

This reaction is IT. Love the insight guys, wow.

I very much enjoyed your take on the song and breaking down the scenes and lyrics. You picked up a lot on your first watch 😊

Great reaction!!! Can’t wait for you to react to her discography!!!!❤️❤️

in-depth talk, love it

this was such a beautiful and heartbreaking video and i loved it so much!! sadie ad dylan were incredible. i love them both so much and need to see them in a movie together now

Omg i love their reaction. That's sooooo on point!

okay but this is my FAV reaction/review video from All Too Well: The Short Film, i loved this!!!

you guys are the best reaction video of all too well i have ever watched! the in depth analysis and the side comments, not to mention that you are also pausing at the exact right moments. now im not satisfied, you should react to other lyrical masterpieces of taylor now ❤

Impressed by you two! Thoughtful & sincere. Also appreciate your respectful comments as you spoke in the moments after Ronan.

i loved your reaction, thank u so much for that

Loved your reaction. It was o honest and true. THANK YOU.

You guys really did well with the reaction video 🧣🤌✨♥️😩🧣

yeah you guys were right she also talked about the 21st birthday thing in her song "the moment i knew"