chanting “white america” for 10 minutes isn’t a review melon

You would have given this a 10/10 if Eminem was white

"I'm only giving it a 4 because there wasn't enough N words" Dude wtf

Talking about how hot Eminem's daughters are is not an review

"at the end of the day hes white .. im white we look out for each other....strong 10" .. so thats how it is now melon ?

Dude, nobody wants to see your coin collection. I thought this was a review.

“How many hooks with Skylar Grey are you going to do that sound EXACTLY LIKE THIS?” *Sweats in Side B*

Music to be murdered by: 5/10 What happened on may 10th 1969? James earl ray pleaded guilty to assasinating MLK JR Where was MLK killed? Memphis Tennessee. What are the first three letters in Tennessee? Ten. Therefore, this album is a 10/10.

anthony you can't just rap the lyrics to lose yourself that's not a review

Giving this album a 10/10 because you listened to it while actually murdering someone seems like a weird choice Anthony

After all these years... WE FOUND WALDO

I was listening to this review until he called 'NO REGRETS' a boring song.

You realize Eminem’s not even black right. So when you call him the n word, it doesn’t even make sense.

Anthony, you can’t just say “im more of a skittle guy so 0/10” that’s not fair

"I'm unavoidable, I'm unavailable, I'm on a toilet bowl." Poetic.

Melon would have rated the album 10/10 if it was called "A Butterfly to be Pimped by"

Eminem has gone from 2 to 4 to 5. At this pace he only has about 4 or 5 years until he gets a 10.

“Could have been a lot worse” has to be one of the worst compliments you can ever receive

I have a feeling that the next eminem album is either gonna be a light 7, or a red flannel

Maybe may taste in bars is horrible, but " I get dough like Ed Sheeran, call me the ginger bread man" is straight fire for me 😂😂😂

saying "your beard is weird" for 13 mins is not a review melon

Melon, you aren’t the real slim shady, please sit down

I liked the review for the most part, but I thought the last 3 minutes where you were holding a tiki torch shouting “blood and soil” was a little unnecessary.

Don’t understand how nobody is talking about Black Thought’s verse on Yah Yah. He goes absolutely nuts

It was a decent review until you said the album was terrible because it features black people on it. You took it too far, Melon.

a 10/10 because eminem is “a well respected white man” isn’t fair melon.

“If he moaned like a female I would have given it a ten instead of a two” Bro wtf is wrong with u man

anthony, screaming 'MAKE SEGREGATION LEGAL AGAIN' isn't a review

Fantano looks like one of those pirates from terraria

I don’t see what your assertion that Iran “Did the right thing” by shooting down a civilian airliner because “people are not meant to fly in metal birds” has to do with Eminem’s album.

So... Light 6, huh? It's almost a MBDTF

I give this album 7/10 it grew on me in past 2 years its been out.

Anthony, filming yourself hiding behind a curtain saying “Where’s Waldo” just because you have a striped shirt doesn’t make this a review.

"Eminem has his moments but spends too much time featuring rappers who aren't white. 5/10 " Really fantano that's how we're judging this now?

Unpopular opinion “no regrets” is one of the best songs on the album

I’m confused as to how some of the bars are considered “bad” or “corny” when some go hard asf

This is the most positive 5/10 review I’ve ever seen

I originally had this at a 2/10 but my rating just changed to a 5/10. Weird.

7/10 melon. Say it

why are eminem fans watching a music review channel if they only want to hear a positive review

Might as well start the stats for 2020: 1/10: 0 2/10: 0 3/10: 0 4/10: 0 5/10: 1 6/10: 0 7/10: 0 8/10: 0 9/10: 0 10/10: 0 NOT GOOD: 0

Review was going great until you started taking your clothes off.

When I first heard this album, I initially thought it was decent, but I found it to be lacking substance in a few areas. Then, it grew on me overtime and I listened to it a few more times and now I like it a lot more. I initially thought it was too much of a retread of Kamikaze, but when I took that notion out, it became a better album with time for me. Not every track is a winner, I did find tracks like Those Kinda Nights and Never Love Again to be kind of...blah, and I like the hook to Leaving Heaven, but most of the song was pretty underwhelming. However, I liked most of the stuff on there, even if the horror theme was inconsistent. I can understand why that may be a problem for some people, but I see this more as an Eminem album than a Slim Shady one, and I liked the various topics that were used in the songs. Some of my favorite tracks include Stepdad, Godzilla, Little Engine, Marsh, and Lock It Up, which has one of the greatest features Em has ever had in his songs in Anderson .Paak, whom I have recently become a fan of in recent memory. It is dumb in some places, but I find most of this album to be pretty strong overall, and even when it gets dumb, it never gets Encore levels of dumb for me (although songs like Rain Main and Ass Like That are a guilty pleasure for me). I give this one an 8/10.

Melon screaming the n word at Em doesn't make sense at all, he isn't black, and it's definitely not a review. I give this review a 4/10

I don’t know Melon. Granting Eminem the N-Word Pass feels like too big of a reward for this ngl.

saying "thats an awfully hot coffee pot" and pouring boiling hot coffee on your naked body until your skin started to melt for 13 minutes isn't a review, anthony.

The Slim Shady LP: 8/10 The Marshal Mathers LP: 10/10 The Eminem Show: 10/10 Encore: 3/10 Relapse: 7/10 Recovery: 6/10 The Marshal Mathers LP 2: 8/10 Revival: 2/10 Kamikaze: 7/10 Music To Be Murdered By: 8/10

great review Anthony but did you really have to give your opinion and then assign a numerical score to the album based on that opinion? seems a little too far tbh

you can’t give him a 0/10 just because he’s white, melon.

It's not a needledrop Eminem review without at least a minute of Anthony looking deadpan at the camera reading sick lines from the songs as if they're bad lines.

That's a 8/10 you're all sleeping!

Melon, calling Eminem a fake white man while screaming “White Power” for the entire video while waving a Confederate flag is not a review 😔

Damn can't believe this was the first ever 12/10 album just because Eminem revealed he's biracial like his father Logic

Do the b side

Man the lyrics on Marsh you caled bad are actually... man you didn't get them. 1. I get dough like Ed Sheeran so call me the ginger bread man: this is a reference to Gingerbread man Records. 2. I look up to myself like a fucking headstand: Not only the headstand but a Head-Stan that looks up to him as an idol

I agreed with all your points up until you gave him a zero “because he was black”

This is the most positive 5/10 review I’ve ever seen lol

6.5/10 for me. I was amazed that u didnt like "no regrets" easily my fav track from the album. Kinda shows just how subjective music it is.

if it was called “music to be TPABed by” you would’ve given it a 10 melon

I really enjoyed this review, that was until those last couple minutes. Was it necessary to say the Armenian genocide was justified? I feel like thats a little much.

To me the album is great, but I'll rate it 0/10 cuz he hasn't released "My Salsa"

Look, we found Waldo!! Ha

Anthony, discussing Eminem's BBC is NOT an album review.

That's an awfully hot coffee pot.

Anthony, just because Eminem is taking a “new direction” doesn’t mean you had to spend the rest of the review talking about your One Direction fan fic

this comment section is golden i love it

honestly i loved this album and i’m not a big em fan and stepdad was a great track em channeled his anger in a great way

Calling yourself the ‘real slim shady’ and saying that Eminem stole your ‘damn identity’ for 13 mins is not a review melon

Thank god. I was almost forced to form my own opinion on this album.

I know it’s not your thing but I fucking love those shitty corny lines like the eyeball line and the Nintendo cartridge one. They just crack me tf up.

This album is his literally his best since a longgg time. I enjoyed every track. He’s 25 yrs into his career and I’m way more than impressed. Production was almost flawless. It’s my 5th favorite Em album. Yes, however good recovery is I don’t go back and play that as much as I bump this one. Replay value is just huge.

This dude looks like old logic got addicted to opium and went to audition for a where's waldo book

Great review, could’ve toned it down with the whole ‘Rosa Parks belonged at the back of the bus’ thing but aside from that, well put.

i know that this album is not perfect but i personally love it just because of the way songs sound like alfreds theme, guns blazing, tone deaf, in too deep...

Yo the most shocking part about your review to me is that you don't like the I Will chorus, I think that's one of Em's best modern choruses like ever lol

You know I respect everyone’s opinion, but to call “Stepdad” the greatest song ever recorded may be a stretch Melon

This review 2/10 The album 7/10 This comment section 10/10

Hello person in the newest comments section after Eminem released side b

Goddamn this was the first video that i watched from this guy and reading the comments before watching it made me really scared of what he might've said

Dang Anthony, I respect your decision to give this album a 10, but did you have to say "it's the greatest thing to happen in earth since the Holocaust?"

I'm not sure if the 5 minute rant about how you are the 'real boy in the striped pyjamas' was very tasteful melon

Man, I really think a lot of Em's "corny" lines would be completely acceptable if any other rapper said them. The ones Fantano rolled his eyes at in this review would be iconic if MF Doom said them instead. I really don't think his new stuff is all that bad (generally), it's just that The Marshall Mathers LP and The Eminem Show were so good they set an impossibly high standard for him.

I liked the album a lot, it had only two duds for me, In Too Deep, Those Kinda Nights. Stepdad is a guilty pleasure, the song isn't good, but I just enjoy it. It's fun. Although the hits on this album are really strong, Darkness, Leaving Heaven, Never Love Again, You Gon Learn, No Regrets, I Will are all great. It's imo his best since MMLP2

It’s A 5 Because He Doesn’t Say “We Tha Best Music” At The Start Of Every Song.

If you play this video at "2" playback speed, Melon makes another Eminem album

is he going to review side b or what?

Holyshit I found Waldo

I don't understand what you mean when you say "the Holocaust never happened, but it should have"?

anthony, saying “i must say, Em can write!” over and over again is not a review.

i have eaten so much chalk that it caused a huge blockage in my intestines and now i am paralyzed from the waist down

The “I get dough like Ed Sheeran so call me the ginger bread man” it’s pretty dope in my opinion

I liked Revival tbh. Kamikaze was fine, but I think this album is one of his best. Plus, the Side B is FIRE😩

I was really moved when Anthony tearfully cried along to the lyric "I-I hate my-my stepdad" for the whole last half of the video

he didn’t mention the line where he says he’s getting head like a pillow pet. and that’s what i’m upset about (edit) yes eminem actually said this on unaccommodated

How can you say No Regrets is tedious? It is an amazing song if you actually listen to it enough times

Did he really said the hook on "I Will' is weak? What???

anthony, you can’t give the album a 10/10 just because “he my white brudda”

Revival: 2/10 Kamikaze: 4/10 MTBMB: 5/10 Is Eminem growing on you, Melon?

If you take the best songs of Side A and Side B you got a 10/10 which is the plus side of making your own playlists on Spotify etc and Em has finally caught up with that - he just put it all out rather than holding songs back. If he had trimmed it we would have something like this; 1. Premonition 2. Unaccommodating 3. You Gon Learn 4. Alfred (Interlude) 5. Alfred's Theme 6. Book of Rhymes 7. Tone Deaf 8. Leaving Heaven 9. Darkness 10. Higher 11. Gnat 12. Key (Skit) 13. Marsh 14. Killer 15. Godzilla 16. Zeus 17. Alfred (Outro) 18. Discombobulated That's my playlist for these 2 albums and it's a 9 or 10 - his best work since Relapse

After listening to this album all year as the super Stan I am I would give this album a 7/10, I do agree with alot said about this album but I thought the high spots were really high, the lows weren't great at all but I think a solid return to some sort of form for slim