Theory: When Geniuses Write Confusing Notation

  Рет қаралды 44

Gary D Lloyd

Gary D Lloyd

28 күн бұрын

When Geniuses Write Confusing Notation
If I write something and then see how it could be rewritten a different way to be clearer, it only takes me a few seconds to make changes.
But what I am doing now has only been possible since around 1990.
Let's go back about three centuries and look at what composition was like for Johann Sebastian Bach. At that time, if you wrote something, you didn't change it because it took forever. Unless what you wrote was an absolute train wreck that absolutely had to be rewritten, you left it as it was, because changing it was so ridiculously hard.

Пікірлер: 5
@garydlloyd7718
@garydlloyd7718 26 күн бұрын
CORRECTION: I said C sharp "minor" but meant "C sharp major" at 0:47....
@bearfoxwolf
@bearfoxwolf 26 күн бұрын
Some interesting thoughts about writing music then and now, and the implications.
@garydlloyd7718
@garydlloyd7718 26 күн бұрын
I think a larger point is that when we are doing something for the first time and we feel it is original or at least highly effective, as creative people we feel motivated and perhaps excited. But once we have finished something, we won't feel that initial excitement again if we have to do any kind of redo. That is true for me when composing, and it is also true for me when making these instructional videos. Once I have composed something and I know that it works, that composition will never be as exciting for me again. In rare instances I become remotivated if some time goes on and I have new ideas. What is absolutely frustrating and irritating is when something works very well when I play it but I see something that is not efficient or clear when I look at the score. The only reason that I am able to revisit old compositions and renotate them is that the process is very fast and is mostly a matter of reshaping things mentally. Just imagined how old composers felt if they recognized that something they did before could be written better, but they didn't have new ideas about the music, only about the notation. In that case just the thought of doing the whole thing over again would have been totally unpleasant.
@aldeayeah
@aldeayeah 26 күн бұрын
I'm imagining the main culprits for this kind of stuff happening are repurposing works in different keys, and working under deadlines. Although I'm not sure the latter would apply for the Well-Tempered Clavier, since AFAIK Bach wrote it for his students and revised it often. Maybe he didn't expect people to play it from sight?
@garydlloyd7718
@garydlloyd7718 26 күн бұрын
In the case of the C Sharp major prelude by Bach, there are a whole bunch of ways why composers at that time did not write in the key of D flat major. I believe I once did a search for Domenico Scarlatti and could not find one instance where he used this key for one of his sonatas, and this is a man who is famous for doing unbelievably original things. Using the tuning systems of the time, some keys sounded remarkably weird, and this is why Bach's tuning system is called "well-tempered" and not equal temperament. Whatever he used was closer to the way instruments are tuned today, but there were still noticeable differences from key to key. There have been other people who have researched this extensively, but you might get close by hearing a harpsichord player do this prelude. The difference in tuning is rather subtle to the ears of most people.
Theory: "Martian" Chords
4:37
Gary D Lloyd
Рет қаралды 32
Gary D Lloyd: Augmented Etude
4:30
Gary D Lloyd
Рет қаралды 32
버블티로 체감되는 요즘 물가
00:16
진영민yeongmin
Рет қаралды 92 МЛН
Каха ограбил банк
01:00
К-Media
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
The child was abused by the clown#Short #Officer Rabbit #angel
00:55
兔子警官
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
Programming with Math | The Lambda Calculus
21:48
Eyesomorphic
Рет қаралды 118 М.
Slav Defense For Newbies: A Beginner’s Guide to Solid and Principled Opening Play
30:47
Wheel operated only by a chain and gravitational force (Fischertechnik)
1:19
Jacques Van den broeck
Рет қаралды 11 М.
Perfect Shapes in Higher Dimensions - Numberphile
26:19
Numberphile
Рет қаралды 5 МЛН
Grandma: from NieR:Gestalt
2:43
Gary D Lloyd
Рет қаралды 50
I Upgraded A Mystery Budget Mic to Hang with $400 Mics (SM7B and the Ethos)!
14:58
Music Software & Bad Interface Design: Avid’s Sibelius
21:35
Tantacrul
Рет қаралды 1,5 МЛН
Circle of 5ths: Easiest Way to Memorize and Understand It
16:05
Gracie Terzian
Рет қаралды 1,5 МЛН
Numberphile's Square-Sum Problem was solved! #SoME2
26:37
HexagonVideos
Рет қаралды 384 М.
버블티로 체감되는 요즘 물가
00:16
진영민yeongmin
Рет қаралды 92 МЛН