After this interview I started reading your book , Its such an Masterpiece .

Dear Dr Sb u have done great job.

@@arifnasr thank you.

You have done a good research..Will definitely read your book..thanks sir

@@arvinderkang6596 thank you.

Thank you very much Justice Prakash Paranjape.

@@Billumian47 Dear Sir , Only one book of yours about partition of Punjab is available in Hindi, I wish rest 2 books are also translated soon . Respect for you.

Ok parrot how many books read in ur life.

@@bbc6799 be respectful dude..😐😐

Which other Islamist radical are you a fan of? Osama ? Hafiz Sayed?

Agree, from India. Wonderfully informative.

I feel sorry for the moderate thinking people who are genetically Indian but they're stuck in this fiasco called Pakistan. What Muslims has achieved by getting Pakistan? Where it stands at international level? BUT India has relieve from united muslim fundamentalism fanaticism through division amongst them. India is globally today amongst top 5 gdp economy, 4th powerful military, and most stable leadership thus Pakistan has unmatched to the mighty Indians across the sectors. Now any misadventure done by Pakistan would leading them to join the clubs of destroyed Afghanistan- Syria- Iraq.

Must be embarrasing to be a Pakistani. Apart from being tragic.

Veřy good analysis

@@Gappasappa 00

Love with human partition destroy everything my 90 p family killed

@@imranyousaf5389 mera v hum rawalpindi rehtay thay

Pakistanis want a lot without working for anything. Not ready to take responsibility. Not ready to own anything. But want front role in everything. So funny.

And the truth is in between. Nehru will get appreciation & Redicule where deserved

Indeed Jawaharl Lal Nehru was a statement. India really needs go back to Nehruism.

Nehru created kashmir problem. By his manhandling

... Bharat needs --> Gandhi + Nehru + Patel + Shashtree + Modi + NeoModi ..... ?! @@induchopra3014

Unfortunately true and most unfortunate for us.

Absolutely right, we are the victims by our own hands

So true sir..,.it's horrifying ...but truth

@@pinturai9431 no dude...you don't know the horrors and this division lead us to never ending battle..we accomodated Hyderabad, accomodated southern states who were demanding freedom... accomodated north east are still fighting.insurgency and are negotiating with naga in Nagaland..

@@abhaypatel4292 stupid ,your answer is out of topic.only first and second line is true related to question but the rest is .

@Aminah Awan better than your Pokistan 😂😂

Why did Bengalis vote for Pakistan tho

@@binurajs yes, I know him. I have read his book. Don't know the in nterviewer though..

Both of them are good One for his knowledge the other for his ignorance Which is not his fault He has studied under the Pakistani education system

Jinnah did not sacrifice or go to jail for Pakistan..he was used by British to carry out their agenda. He was not a radical Muslim or a devout muslim..he was handpicked by British for his English and western dress..he was living in London..he was given a task,he acheived it. Thats why we dont see him stand for Sikhs. He had no mind of his own..he took orders from the British.

Bose was on the left

@@anshuraj4277 don't hurt him

Hi, look from what I understand is that Atlee a British Prime Minister will never accept that 'they lost'. I mean they always believed they were superior how could they say Gandhi/Nehru/Navy Revolts made them leave India. When the 2nd World War ended the masses were aware. They had just seen British fight Japan/Germany because they were being imperialistic (exactly what Britishers themselves were). The will of the people was strengthened by all of the above be it S.C Bose's Azad Hind Fauj + Navy Revolts + Red fort trials + Bengal Famine + Quit India Movement. Other factors such as the Balance of power changed in favour of USA and USSR. In fact Britain themselves had to take loans from USA to reconstruct their nation. And British soldiers were done with war. They were in no mood to stay away from their families and fight in India after seeing the destruction. Also, British rule was very much dependent on the civil servants in Indian who were themselves Indian. With the Navy Incident and Azad Hind Fauj they understood that they cannot trust the Indians anymore. It's all a combination is what I mean, but definitely not what Atlee said, you can't expect them to not save their faces you know.

Bose was hardcore communist whereas Nehru was centrist. get your facts right

جو اپنے آباؤ اجداد کی زمین، دریا اور مذہب سے جڑے ہوئے ہیں، وہ پانچ سال میں ایسا کر لیتے ہیں۔ m.kzfaq.info/get/bejne/edeid9iElrDRcmw.html

Biggest blunder and his history

Ppppppppppppp

@@imranyousaf5389 What's this habit of Punjabis and all ethnicities who were ruled by the British. It doesn't mean that you distort history just because your masters the British gave you English schools, printing press, cinemas, radio, factories, parliament, trained armies, railways, dams, bridges and much more. NO tribal of NWFP was interested in Kashmir, especially in 1948. NWFP voted for Congress and Bacha Khan had a strong following there. NWFP used Indian and Afghan currency until 1970's. It was Punjabi army-the stooges of the British in civilian clothes who attacked Kashmir. Nehru and Indian leaders had written off Kashmir and had informed the Maharaja that he can join Pakistan, The Proxy attack by Pakistan gave India good reason to stay there permanently. After the so called "tribal" attack , Sheikh Abdullah appealed to India for help as the "tribals" ( read army) were looting and raping ( as ordered by Jinnah) the Muslim women. They were not into liberating Kashmir. India insisted that it could not help as Kashmir had not acceded to India. The Sheikh then signed the papers of accession and India sent in its army. This is how British stooge Jinnah handed over Kashmir to India. The other stooge of British aka Punjabi army is 100% responsible for the destruction of Pakistan's economy and political institutions.

Can you tell me his book list?

Bhai per ye books mileyeingi kuhan ???

جو اپنے آباؤ اجداد کی زمین، دریا اور مذہب سے جڑے ہوئے ہیں، وہ پانچ سال میں ایسا کر لیتے ہیں۔ m.kzfaq.info/get/bejne/edeid9iElrDRcmw.html

Sikhs history is full of Muslims killing murdering Sikhs. Read their history. Read your own history. Why sikh population in Pakistan is so less???? Where are Sikhs of Pakistan????

Massacre in reply to Massacre isn't justified. If 5 thousand were killed in one area by one majority, 7 thousand got killed in reply by other majority in another area. Now what was the mistake of those 13 thousands, they were not the culprits why did they pay for the crime of other people of their believes. What happened in Rawalpindi cannt justified what happened afterwards

Thanks for sharing this. We must face our history. Presently in the present times where new divisive forces are again rising.

@@Diwana71 Thanks! Author Nasim Yousaf (Allama Mashriqi's grandson) views about Jinnah, Gandhi & the partition of India facebook.com/AuthorNasimYousaf/photos/?tab=album&ref= kzfaq.info/sun/PLbiCHHl6HdCYoVAG9SR6ZZ9-H5iR9kLhY archive.org/details/@nasimyousaf Must Read: "India & Pakistan Owe their Freedom to Allama Mashriqi" archive.org/details/india-pakistan-owe-their-freedom-to-allama-mashriqi

@Labhesh Haria آ

@Labhesh Haria Thanks for your nice comment. You should read Mr. Nasim Yousaf's (Allama Mashriqi's grandson and researcher) books on Jinnah and Gandhi. Being a grandson of Allama sahib, he is the only researcher/author who knows the inside stories about Jinnah, Gandhi, and the partition of India. Sadly, We have never heard Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed (@Ishtiaq) Ahmed talking about Allama Mashriqi and the Khaksar Tehrik. Mr. Yousaf's books are eye openers and areavailable on Amazon. Many of them can be downloaded. Links to Books/articles: www.amazon.com/Nasim-Yousaf/e/B001JRVVWY archive.org/details/@nasimyousaf

If I keep blaming my grandfathers dad for what is happening now then its my mistake not his or his times. So yes britishers caused issues but for todays situation respective countries are responsible. Also remember Jinha was pakistnai and was supported by people here. So blame doesnt help.

😂😂 , oh man I was all serious listening this podcast , you made my day

😂😂

the more mysterious part is it's still functioning. 😂

Nope, it was based on vote of 1946 elections.

@@vinamrasinghai2339 Pakistan map was drawn before 1942 dear. Just check it.

@nwfp nwfp Hinduism is not like Roman or Greek paganism. It is in fact very diverse with some sects opposing idol worship & some avowing agnosticism

@@smithlouisnk9913 A follower of Arabian death cult won't understand the philosophy of Sanatana Dharma. You stick with fantasies of An illetrate Arabian warlord

Caste is an English word. Please find the Indian word that we used for caste and come and reply here. When you find that word, research what it means, where it comes from, writings about those words.

From where Hindi version or english one

@@navneetsingh8169 english version.... I think no hindi version is available... I bought online from Amazon

Can u plz post the link here

@@navneetsingh8169 www.amazon.in/dp/8129129612?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share

@@navneetsingh8169 it's printed price is Rs. 495 but Amazon charged 712 ruppe.so try any other way to purchase...

He knows Swedish. He is a citizen of Sweden.

Then who stops u people to have a conversation over caste based discrimination in India ??

@@PradeepSaddha0 it is happening since I was born. In school books it was written caste based discrimination is social evil. There are intellectuals, movies, books which are applauded and there is a ongoing conversation as long as I remember. In urban areas caste based discrimination is declined. In villages my generation is also quite aware and keep harmony with people from different caste and religion. You have to see it in broader perspective. There are still people who does this but they are not entertained in mainstream.

@@Vk-sk7nm no I don agree that it has been declined or moving towards dat side, it has become micro in urban areas, I live in delhi i was born in delhi n brought up in delhi, i know caste system is an integral part of Hindu religion, if you see Hindu without aste system Hindu religion starts collapsing.. so no need to say it is declined it is moving towards a more complex form which will definitely create a type of situation of civil war, on the top of the hierarchy will suffer the most.

That’ll take……. 500 years

@@dharmicindia6325 it starts happening, in lower strata, low caste groups start organizing in India as well as in Europe and US...

I felt second hand validation! Smiled like a goof 😅

Thank you very much Sat Biswas ji.

But at least they would be able to put a sentence together🤷🏻‍♂️

Sikh should convert Muslim girls in Punjab India

@@raushan7856 They spared Malerkotla.

@@Kinginthenorth64 like your cricketers?

جو اپنے آباؤ اجداد کی زمین، دریا اور مذہب سے جڑے ہوئے ہیں، وہ پانچ سال میں ایسا کر لیتے ہیں۔ m.kzfaq.info/get/bejne/edeid9iElrDRcmw.html

Another interesting anecdote I have is that we have some land near the India border (given to my grandfather by the army). One day some Sikhs were allowed to come onto the land and they dug around a tree and there were some valuables they dug out and took back with them to India. In a way, I’m happy that they had a chance to be reunited with their valuables but I would’ve been much much much more happier if they were allowed to come back and take ownership of their ancestral land.

You wont like this but muslims as a whole are more easy to manipulate into fighting and violence and something tells me most of them even enjoy the bloodshed.

There were no telephones but there were oral narratives and rumors. Rumors are more dangerous when there are less source of communication. And then there were immigrants coming from India. I have heard that when they reached Pakistan with the horrible stories and dedbodies, they challenged the "ghairat" of Pakistani Muslims and some places gifted them bangles. This provoked the violent behaviour. Then there were criminals on both sides who took advantage of the situation. Violence at that times were on both side of border, anytime trying to be victim is dishonest

You are a good person ❤