Great stuff

I f@#&n loved this reimagined scene! I WANT MORE! 'nuff said!

Disney THIS is how you respect what George Lucas did . This was epic and awesome !!! Loved how they included the prequel lines ..... Darth Vader : I Hate You !!!!! Obi Wan : You were my brother anakin , I loved you !

Cornberry Just two problems I have with it, maybe 2.5 problems. Sometimes the fight goes on just a little too long, and we really are only supposed to get a small glimpse of what saber fights look like, not to mention, the amount of rooms they head into really doesn’t fit in with the continuity of the film. But, hey...that’s really only have of a problem. My two real problems kinda come from the end of it and that one flashback dialogue. Whether you liked the prequels or not, I think that line of dialogue was a little too updated, and again, is a bit of a continuity issue. We didn’t watch Episode III yet, and it’s treating this movie like it was already released before this one. It may be just the fault of how they are named, but this is why one person on Metacritic thought Empire’s twist sucked because he thought it was not really a surprise, because Episode III, which **sputters** totally came before Star Wars, already showed the dad becoming Darth Vader. My other problem with this scene is, that they actually changed an event that was supposed to be important to how Jedi pass away. Unless Darth Vader just cut the robe and Obi-Wan actually disappeared before then in this video, then I’m pretty sure you just showed Vader cutting Obi-Wan in half to kill him.

Cornberry Can’t deny it’s still a cool fight.

@@thefirstbourne149 That's what this was aaaall about, the cool lightsaber battle that could have been...and hitting the fanboy g-spot

The FirstBourne dont see our point as ur supposed to watch the films 123 456 so it would make sense to hear the episode 3 dialogue

@@thefirstbourne149 your second 'real' point is false. the lightsaber did indeed cut the robe, from what i saw, kenobi turned into a ghost before the lightsaber hit him. i think you're misconstruing the robe getting cut and kenobi getting cut.

Huh? How can you compare 1977 to 2019 cinema tools and knowledge?

Adam Woodhouse I think he means how this one fight is better than all the recent lightsaber fight from the newer movies

Because idiotic OT fan boys who are the minority are loud and Disney thinks there opinions matter.

@@chancellorpalpatineakathes6130 um I know it's probably a stupid question but,what's OT

@@callmegrandpoggers OT = Original Trilogy

In this essay I will... But seriously, I agree and your opinion was well presented.

3. I love Vader

4. Since the death star was tilted on a 0.01 degrees, he had the high ground, making him win.

Vader is fighting here like he's pissed and wants revenge for Mustafar. This is a grudge match for him.

Damn right especially the fury oh my God the fury 🤘

I hope they reimagine his fights against Luke Skywalker, too. I want to see Vader break bad there, too.

Lance Curry especially in Jedi. That fight was weak compared to empire.

Really, both seemed a little weak to me. All the Original Trilogy duels were... OK. Not great, but not bad. I really prefer the Prequel Trilogy duels. But I won't deny I'd love both "Luke vs Vader" duels reimagined.

Lance Curry yeah true but you must think that when they came out, it was amazing. Over time we have seen so many improvements in choreography and CGI too coz people keep pushing boundaries

@@lancecurry7538 I mean, they WERE very weak, being that they came out in the 80's and the technology wasn't there to make super awesome fast paced duels that were made possible in the late 90's and 2000's. The fights are iconic, but not great by any means.

Well said, well said.

Its really sad too, Disney spends millions of dollars, on a 2 hour movie that has no soul, and garbage writing, these guys spend a year, with a shoestring budget, and make *ART* Its sad to see, that the fans have to make the good content now.

Oh opinion stated as fact that’s always fun

Amen

Heavens Dark Phoenix And if you analyze the fight, even at the very beginning, Vader is winning. Obi-Wan is just as skilled as he was back in Episode 3, but he’s older, and doesn’t have the strength, durability, or stamina he used to have. That said, he is still a force to be reckoned with. Darth Vader, on the other hand, is far slower than he used to be but he strikes with far more force than he used to. And, unlike Obi-Wan, is able to keep up the brutal aggression throughout the fight. And he is constantly making Obi-Wan give ground. It’s amazing that Obi-Wan, a Master of the Force, survived as long as he did against a man who is in agony every second of his life. This just shows how awesome both Vader and Obi-Wan are.

Rouge One was a great movie but I prefer Rogue One.

@@ogfunk187 wait, what?

Regat Kahsai Staats exactly 👀

@@cooljo5881 Read the comment again, you'll see it.

@@DerrickRG ROUGE ONE!! Rogue one

Dio Onore Rogue one vader scene was cool

A. C. True, but the sequels were shit

@@ac_master_9759 rogue one could have been brilliant expet for the lead character. What was his name? and what the heck was he mumbling?

@@sbaxter4207 Cassian Andor?

I think that was an overdue rematch, yes?

you were the chosen one

@@riches3581 don't make me kill you

You were the chose one Anakin.

@@isaacmaximoff5619 Anakin Skywalker was weak i destroyed him.

It's Padme's Destiny from Revenge of The Sith

@@overlookers thanks lol

Martyaxvar it is

~Sir Christopher Lee

Woooh! Someone spelt it right! You didn't say "Rouge One"!!!

Same bro

Same 👍

Same

that's a Garbage channel lol.

@@RafidW9 bad take

Agreed man!

Doesn't matter. Still not watching that Episode 9 cuckery. Screw Jar Jar Abrams and his precious MaRey Sue.

Jar Jar Abrams is personally responsible for tanking both Star Wars and Star Trek franchises.

Too right.. Fan film makers have raised the bar and expectation.

@@porgherder6109 Hating bad storytelling = "Toxic comments"? Talking about whiny bitches...

They would've had to pull the movie for a few decades because it would be causing too many heart attacks.

Haha... If you think the fan base is dedicated now... Haha... Had this been in 1977... Ohhh feverish obsession would ensue ... I imagine

An older fan said that this movie would've been rated as "Mature" for "intense violence". It would have been cool as well, but the movie itself was amazing just the way it was back then, with all the special effects and setting...

Really is, life is not a box of chocolates...but an awesome lightsaber battle between a master and his student. (Sighs)

I think the music was perfect with how they did this scene, it may not blend as well as a whole but it was damn good.

@@zzureee I'm with you. The emotion of the music was good. I'm really against the use of vocals in the music since that never happened until episode 1. We don't need episode 1 rubbing off on episode 4.

It’s far from perfect

Star Wars fans would be even more numerous than they are now...then again, more people would be angry with the sequels/prequels.

TRS right

The Falcon escaping was Vaders plan all along, to lead them to the rebel base. Thats why he did not force the doors open.