To be fair, the red Dead 2's drunk effect not only makes the screen blur But also makes arthur and john's dialogues funnier

Another feature from this game that should be in the second game is people fearing you with a lower honor level, to the point where crimes outside of outright murder won't be reported by the townsfolk. In RDR2 the low honor benefits are very very minor, I think the only real one is gaining more money and jewellery from robberies and dead people.

John’s line, “poor horse. What’s wrong with me?” 😂😂😂

I totally agree about the Bounty Hunting. In RDR2, you have limited number of bounties. I wish we could keep doing them eternally. It's not for the money, it's for the fun.

The thing I miss the most is places having a limit on how many police officers can spawn.

The night watch activities are underrated. The most immersive thing about that game for me. You're just like, working for the sheriff and protecting the townfolk with the goodest boy

I do wish you could see your crimes listed like you could in RDR1. I'd like to get a number on the carnage I unleashed on the poor NPCs.

I understand why they took half of these out though. Like the properties doesnt make sense. Because Arthur lives in a camp with the gang. So he wouldnt be buying and living in properties. Only reason John does is because he is pretty much living off the land while on the hunt for the gang in the first game and hes on his own at that time. The pardon letter makes more sense in one.. because John works on behalf of the US government technically I guess.. so they didnt want him in prison or jail I'm sure if it happened while he was turning stones . Bounty hunting is unlimited in the first one because it basically boils down to simplicity. Every one is pretty much, Show up, shoot gang, capture leader. In the second game.. the bounties are a lot more unique and have story and substance. So thats why they couldnt do unlimited. Barrell roll is cool, but i can see why they opted for a more realistic approach with two. Skinning cats and dogs thing probably just came down to being and feeling more messed up in better graphics and a more realistic engine. But idk lol

Number 1 for me is the ability to fast travel to way points you set on your map. That feature saves so much time!

I still remember beating rdr2 for the first time, and being so exited to see the old map in its new glory. I was disappointed to see that everything I loved was gutted. Armadillo is a ghost town, though tumbleweed is renewed, I still prefer Armadillo. Thieves landing was gutted, MacFarlanes ranch was gutted. Most of the points of interest on the map were gutted. Just a big empty to journal around in.

The RDR1 Low honor benefits were so good, people would actually fear you. And a guy like arthur whos tough and scary would have been feared more if it was in RDR2

Should've allowed us to do a barrel roll as john in rdr2 epilogue

surprised i found so many things considering how good RDR 2 is

John committing unspeakable crimes: The pardon letter in his pocket

I think devs did intend for you to buy properties at some point, because theres a lot of abandoned shacks and buildings that arent dilapidated and look taken care of in random locations around the map, conveniently located not too far from a town. They probably scrapped the idea because they figured it didnt make sense for a criminal on the run from the law to buy a hous.

I’m dying laughing when he took his horse to the middle of the desert, killed it, skinned it while saying “you stink.”

Another couple things I wished were carried over are: 1. Do a bounty mission to pay off your bounty if you don't have enough money 2. Fast travel to your waypoint from your camp or stagecoach

I wish some of the outfits in the first game were in the second. I already heard people wanted the poncho but I personally always liked the deadly assassin outfit for the simple fact it's the only one with a badass eye patch. I'm also a fan of the elegant suit. I don't understand why they left some of those outfits out of the second game but oh well.

Adichu is easily one of the most creative rdr creater ive seen

Some of them only really make sense in RDR1 tbf, like the pardon letter. Given John's a bounty hunter sanctioned by the government it makes sense he has more leeway with the law, whereas Arthur is an outlaw on the run.

What I miss besides the main points people made including skinning animals, more bounty missions, bandana mechanics, fast travel/camp mechanics, fame mechanics and buying property, was the fact that you could enter high stakes poker matches with a buy-in/pot actually worth a damn to win. Also, the outfits and horse deeds in RDR1 were top tier

Another cool feature of RDR is dressing up and blending in with an enemy gang.

Additionally, i wish rdr2 had it where your honor wont go down if you wear a bandana i really missed that. Also, i miss the perks of outfits from the original maybe it could have been talismans ( an extra slot similar to rdr2 where you can equip one). My opinion will most likely get hate, but i prefer rdr1 in comparison to rdr2. Nontheless both are fantastic games.

honestly i prefer the shooting in red dead one, just something about the sounds and ragdolls feels more satisftying in red dead 1, it also goes really well with how low contrast the game is most of the time

John and Jack get drunk like Niko bellic in gta iv😂😂

RDR1 also had dynamic injuries. You could shoot someone's leg and they would limp, and if you shot both out they would kneel. I've even seen people crawling for their lives after being shot.

Liar's Dice was my favorite game and honestly one of my favorite things to do in the series hands down.

@Adichi you didn’t mention the best feature they took out. In RDR , you can shoot enemies at the knees which will make them kneel. You can run up to them and shoot them with a gun that plays an animation where John shoots them execution style. You can shoot them from behind too

Drunk walking in rdr1 and gta4 is my favorite thing to do. Especially the drunk cheat

something important you forgot is that if you buy the bandana in rdr1 they will never lower your honor if you have it on

"Red dead redemption 2's version of being drunk is making the screen blurry" Arthur:LENNY!!!

The fact that you can kill horses without the game moralising you for that, nd skin them. Or the fact that the horse trots next to you as you run in a direction instead of following you from a distance

7:46 even John sounds like he's questioning what you're doing to him

The only thing that is missing for me is ARM WRESTLING, was awesome in the original game. Imagine Arm Wrestle in camp against the gang members or in the open world.

"capture your own thief, woman" *BANG BANG BANG*

I like that the bounty hunting is limited in the second game because that makes every bounty hunting mission unique. In the second game they were actual missions that added more story content while in the first game they were just side tasks. In the first game they were all the same and the only bounty hunting task that was somewhat unique was for Mo van Barr.

Its a bit random, but one of the things i would change for rdr2 is the movement and search speed. I know the games are technically different styles. Rdr2 is more of a simulation while the first game is more of a spaghetti western. But johns movement speed is so much faster and you feel like a genuine clint eastwood type western heroe while running about shooting the villains men. Love both games, but rdr 2 just has too much lumbering around.

Arthur not doing a barrel roll makes sense since he’s more like a bigger, heavier, power house kind of character

Bro 7:47 john says "poor horse whats wrong with me" ngl i wish rdr2 had this feature

And some of these features greet themselves in red dead online. Such as the drunk walking, it isn't exactly like rdr1 but you do stumble a little and you can literally slap people while your drunk

One thing I don’t see talked about a lot is the horses in both games. While I can’t deny the variety and mechanics of horses is much more vast in RDR2, the horses in RDR just felt more real. The better horses had clear benefits in speed, agility, and stamina, and when you rode the horses there was just something that felt real.

One of the things i loved back in the first game was that after a rampage you can see how many crimes did you commit

8:09 “I guess it weren’t your day horse” is an INSANE statement from John 🤣🤣🤣 had me fucking dying

Imagine the rdr1 drunk walk in rdr2 with the screen blur

I think you can skin domestic animals in rdr1 cuz they just show john with a knife while in rdr2 they show animal and the skinning process so it would be cruel looking at a dog or horse or cat getting cut open

I liked how in the first game you could buy and equip a bandana to keep your honor from going down when you're offing people. I remember when I first played Red Dead Redemption that I grinded for cash by hunting, sold it all at a store, bought the bandana, and just began committing every robbing crime imaginable which allowed me to rake in a ton of money in the beginning and over the course of the story, as well as making my bounty go up at an incredible rate, but I made sure to also make sure my honor kept going up, up, up, instead of down, down, down. By the third to last mission of the story, I was at maximum High Honor and over sixty thousand dollars, and my bounty was at three hundred thousand dollars. And by the time I completely maxed out the entire game at one hundred percent total gameplay completion with everything collected and ninety-nine of everything collected in my satchel, I was able to accumulate six hundred thousand dollars, and my bounty capped out at the maximum of two million dollars and wouldn't go higher...trust me, I tried, but it wouldn't work.

The buying properties thing was supposed to be an addition to rdr2, you can even find buildings you were supposed to be able to buy, but the devs figured that buying homes was unnecessary.

Also you forgot about firing from cover John will put his gun and revolver around a corner or something and shoot without looking but in rdr2 you will just fully turn the corner and hip fire

high stakes poker is another thing i miss a lot from red dead redemption. It really irritated me in the second game when you did the high stakes poker game on the boat in saint denis for that one mission and that was it. i was really hoping they would let you maybe go back to the boat later in the game for some high stakes poker as john, but no, you’re stuck at a max buy in of five dollars and that sucks. in RDR1 the lowest buy in is bigger than the max buy in RDR2. i was really hoping they would give us more than a 5 dollar buy in considering how much money you actually make during the story. at least in RDR1 you could make a profit from playing poker

I miss being able to rapidly throw knives or tomahawks into multiple targets with Deadeye.

I loved that it listed your crimes too

I'd imagine one of the reasons you can't purchase property in RDR2 would be that it can become a retcon, in that, if while playing as John in RDR2 you buy a property, there would need to be a reason you don't own it in RDR1, and it's possible that they didn't want to implement a feature in the earlier segments of the game as Arthur, that you couldn't use as John. Just a thought though.

dont ignore the fact that horses comes to you after whistle. not like rdr2 where you have to come to the horse. makes a quicker getaway

the 1 thing about rdr1 that i dont like is the weird prices, a lemat is $1250, but a property can be as low as $50. and then a bandolier is $125.

“What a beautiful horse. OK, now, lets kill it” Damn😂

Buying property in rdr2 would be cool but I understand why you can't considering the plot. I don't think Arthur would be buying houses whilst on the run. Would massively take away from the camp hideout element. However it would be nice in the epilogue.

I miss the fame part and the demon horse you get for low honor.

Adichu makes the best content ever

One more thing you miss is the weapon wheel i like the rdr weapon wheel because you can pick any weapon faster than in rdr2 where you have to your horse saddle to change weapon

I like the fact that in the first game (and many other games) you can fire some guns as quickly as you can pull the (controller) triggers.

I actually think the jump and slide is much more realistic/feasible/practical than the barrel role. John ain’t no ninja okay🤣 and most of these are just personal preference most likely based on which game you got used to playing first. Ultimately I think red dead 2 is way more realistic in every way. I mean the drunk walking is hilarious but seriously John?? What a lightweight… the poker cheat duel was freaking hilarious tho

I never played the first game, only read about it in its wiki. I can understand many things that were left out but the horse deed is useful to preserve a horse you like. Bounty hunting its understandable with its unique target but should have left low criminals as repeatable encounters. Why, with theneed to eat and such to perverse your stamina and such, you need steady supplies, so a way of a steady income is needed. With the bounties and nightwatch, you kinda had that in rdr1, something I think RDR2 would have needed

I love this content! Keep it up man

Man I just discovered your channel and I’m having a blast man keep up the good work

You can drunk walk in rdr2, you just have to get extremely drunk.

I don't understand the rdr2 bounty system since it only goes to 1,500 and if anybody watched tgtbatu, tuco has a 4000 dollar bounty when in rdr2 you can't commit so much more and worse crimes to realistically pass the other one Edit: tuco is from spaghetti westerns if you don’t know

Also the bandana is good because when you wear it doesn’t decrease your honour or fame

What I miss most about Rdr1 is that if you had a bounty you could kill all the cops and then be free in Rdr2? Infinite cops I swear to god it’s so annoyingly and unrealistic

4:51 "oh there a dog." "Aggressively draws gun"

Just got rdr1 and I love how where you shoot different parts it does different things like if you shoot them in the leg then they roll around on the floor

I do agree about bounty hunting, its one of my favorite things to do in the game, and i wish they made it a job or atleast put more of them in the game

I wish Red Dead Redemption 2 had Fame Like in RDR1

How can you forget bank robberies 💀

1 cool detail not a lot of people knew about rdr2, when you make it to the epilogue, you can glitch into Mexico, Rockstar added detail into Mexico and you can explore a bit before either dying from falling out the map or get bored and leave since there is rarely any npcs there

I think no properties because in red dead 1 John was no longer a proper outlaw canonically so it would be weird stor-wise for arthur to own properties. And also plenty of these, depending on whether or not you use pc, can be simulated with mods but obviously some people can't/dont want to.

As someone who has played rdr 1 since I was 9 I'm 22 now for reference, rdr 1 online is superior to rdr2 in every way besides graphics.

7:51 the way he said "You stink"

Another thing in red Dead Redemption 1 that's not in 2 is that you can set up camp and fast travel to anywhere you want to go if you set a waypoint marker.

I wish you could shoot while your aim jumping as arthur this would be so good with deadeye and it would look so good in the kill cam

I am currently on my 30+ play through of this game (too many I forget) and I've never played it first person mode. I am on the mission right now bank robbery where lenny dies and done it first person and I am thinking to do the whole game again first person mode I can just imagine it to be a whole different game. I love this game so much there is still things I am still finding like on this play through I have just found the old tomb and the viking hat you can get from there is just boss when you want to do robberies and where the bandada too. Just love this game so much.

I love liars dice 🎲 lol although it took a while to understand 🧐 I loved horseshoes aswel lol Edit: How is the horseshoes game not on the list? 😂

Tbf about the pardon letters It fits the “my family was kidnapped by the government and they’re forcing me to work for them” aesthetic

In red dead redemption, one you can go to Mexico, and in red dead redemption two you can go to Mexico

Something I miss is the weapon wheel. In RDR2 I hated that we had to go to our horse each time to change a weapon, even today it gets irritating.

This makes me wanna play red dead 1. I actually never played it 😅

In rdr2 if you drink enough you’ll get a slight drunk walk

i love your videos bro!❤ keep up the great work🔥

I know people get frustrated that you can’t do these things but in RDR2 you can do so much more.

Pin if you are the best KZfaqr!

I’ve found out on rdr1 is you can use throwing knives at a person at both knees caps, and the person will stand up on his knees and you can walk up behind him and slit his throat

“So poker is a game present in both games” **shows blackjack table** 😂

Another great thing about red dead redemption is being able to rob banks when ever u want in rdr2 u can’t rob a bank it’s all locked behind a story mission

to be fair on the buying of houses in rdr2, It would probably undermine some of the meaning behind the gang's camp, since now arthur is out there living on a random house he bought, while the rest of the gang lives on a random camp in the middle of nowhere. Also, its probably a lot more difficult to buy property as a career criminal compared to marston in the first game, since he's at that point working for the government, and doesn't need to hide his name or anything.

Another in rd1 you can do is what we called “emergency stopping” and you can shoot your horse will riding it 😂

My favorite red dead redemption content creator you really deserve more subs

Max bounty in RDR2 should be 5000. It's more coherent with the story, as Agent Milton says that's the price for Arthur's head. Also, it also helps players to create a hard mode more realistically where they can put Arthur wanted at 5000 bounty in all states to match up with his bounty in Blackwater.

the properties thing makes sense imo, since the gang is on the run they wouldn't want a bunch of places to be in their name so they don't get tracked down

You're so right about liar's dies. It actually is one of my favourite games IRL and I used to play it a lot with my younger sister

The only thing I wish you put and that not there is the fact that in rdr 1 you can blind shot from cover with any gun, like without getting out of cover

the first in rdr 2 is more realistic since its faster if you roll you are slow in games its just sped up