this is why these I-LAND 2 trainees did not make it (lacked skills?)…

  Рет қаралды 13,592

EK Cristobal

EK Cristobal

Күн бұрын

Welcome, I-Mates! In this video, we are going to analyze why these I-Land 2 trainees were eliminated in Part 1. The criteria are based on skills, talent, star quality, potential, and the picks of the producers and Mnet. A little disclaimer: this assessment is conducted as technically as possible and should be viewed as an opportunity for growth for the trainees. Enjoy!
Chapters
0:00 what to expect
0:18 24th
1:08 23rd
1:59 22nd
3:15 21st
4:10 20th
5:13 19th
7:17 18th
8:22 17th
10:18 16th
12:11 15th
13:59 14th
15:33 13th
17:49 outro
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
Contact
Gmail: ekcristobalyt@gmail.com
TikTok: @ekcristobal
Thank you for watching!

Пікірлер: 103
@ediiixy
@ediiixy 13 күн бұрын
Um Jiwon had a jaw injury, hence she never fully opened her mouth, she’s been getting treatment all while going to school and competing in iland2
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
My sincerest apologies, I should’ve researched more regarding her case. It must have been so hard on her part. Despite this, her natural vocal skills still shine. Thank you for sharing this detail.
@kimkardashi-un2.051
@kimkardashi-un2.051 13 күн бұрын
Yeah I was wondering why she didn't fully open her mouth to sing
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
@@kimkardashi-un2.051Unfortunately, i don’t remember it being shared in the show? Or did I just miss it? Or perhaps Jiwon and her fam didn’t agree on airing the reason behind? Regardless, I wish they aired it though, so it can reach more people and understand her situation.
@e4yila
@e4yila 12 күн бұрын
Yui never deserved to be eliminated
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
Can’t wait to see her slaying in another group someday!
@VTECpower2000
@VTECpower2000 12 күн бұрын
I feel like Yui's vocal has improved so much from Baggy Jeans to IWALY.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
there were improvements, yes
@anothabc
@anothabc 12 күн бұрын
Appreciate your honest and non-biased, structured review on Lingling.👍🙏🙏 Awaiting LL to debut elsewhere. Missing her already!😢😢
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
Thank you. Hoping only the best for her!
@prestonpa2437
@prestonpa2437 13 күн бұрын
My girl Yui always gave a great performance 💅🏾
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
yes and the stars will align for her in time…
@ritoja_banerjee
@ritoja_banerjee 13 күн бұрын
I wish I could see Yuiko more. Tbh Choi Soul is very cute, I love to see her performing. I am very sorry for YUI. She is in my top pick. I am very sad.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
I can see Yuiko’s potential as well as Soul - these 2 will be scary if properly honed cause they already have that natural strong appeal on stage.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
Yui will rise someday!
@elizabethlung3095
@elizabethlung3095 12 күн бұрын
I love Lingling and Yui
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
what if they debut together? hihi
@elizabethlung3095
@elizabethlung3095 11 күн бұрын
@@EKCristobal they would debut with a badass concept
@Spacerecord-yv5oz
@Spacerecord-yv5oz 13 күн бұрын
I come across some of the performances but I haven’t really been following the survival show. May the best and deserving girls debut.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
It’s totally worthy to watch! Even I am worried of the possible final number of members because the lineup, especially those in part 2 are strong strong.
@Spacerecord-yv5oz
@Spacerecord-yv5oz 13 күн бұрын
@@EKCristobal oh really? I will try and follow up on it💕
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
@@Spacerecord-yv5ozyes~ plus the debuting group’s music will be produced by Teddy. i am particularly excited what kind of music he has to offer this time…
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
Update: it has been officially announced that there will be 6 members for the debut group.
@Spacerecord-yv5oz
@Spacerecord-yv5oz 13 күн бұрын
@@EKCristobal yes I love Teddy too I was particularly waiting for his girl group from the blackLabel. I am sure the iland 2 girl group would be good if he is the producer. So looking forward to both, I will follow up on iland 2
@just_josh_scoups_of_icecream
@just_josh_scoups_of_icecream 5 күн бұрын
For me the most surprising was yui's elimination. Back then I was a little reluctant about gyuri getting selected instead of her, but she proved me very wrong in the recent performances.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 4 күн бұрын
i believe gyuri has always had that *it* factor, it’s just that she was very overlooked in part 1. finally she’s able to unleash it in part 2..
@just_josh_scoups_of_icecream
@just_josh_scoups_of_icecream 4 күн бұрын
@@EKCristobal yeah right she reminds me of how sunoo was in S1 both had amazing intro performances but just kept getting stuck in ground. She does have an amazing debut potential. Can't wait to see more from her.
@Joemamam-rv4cx
@Joemamam-rv4cx 2 күн бұрын
I feel like gyuri was very unlucky throughout the show but then lucky at the last minute 😭it was so unexpected shes very talented despite her young age I'm happy she was picked but I'm still sad yui didn't make it she deserved better
@Jas-tb5bt
@Jas-tb5bt 3 күн бұрын
Ill never forgive mnet for what they did to Yui. Girl is a GEM. The ACE of the show
@soshinae
@soshinae 5 күн бұрын
I never followed iland. But, once Ling Ling was eliminated, words spread that she is actually talented enough. So, I watch her fancam. It is not as bad as people write in her performance, saying she only survived because of her nationality. I know how difficult it is for east Asian to win a popularity contest in Korea. Not saying Ling Ling is totally number one material, but, she is not that bad.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 5 күн бұрын
Yup, Lingling needs improvement, but she’s not that bad…
@lullets5083
@lullets5083 12 күн бұрын
Would love for more videos on I-Land 2 and especially the current 12 contestants skills & performances in Part 2!
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
Would you guys love a performance review too? But the top 12 are already in line for review. I’m just looking forward how this would unfold.
@sunghaneul
@sunghaneul Күн бұрын
I'm so upset that Yui is eliminated. I've neither been watching nor following the iland 2 but I listened to final love song which i rly liked and iwaly was amazing too. I watched the performances of the two teams for iwaly and yui presence and star quality as well as vocals rly stood out to me. I could've pointed 4 other contestants who were better singers, performers or had better presence and star quality but idk why she rly stood out to me for some reason? I hope she debuts elsewhere, i'll definitely support her!
@ireneraqueticaa4450
@ireneraqueticaa4450 7 күн бұрын
Ngl I was shocked when Yui was eliminated, she was like my second place's pick.
@mimimamam0m0
@mimimamam0m0 8 күн бұрын
Yui was robbed😭
@user-pb2sd6mv2p
@user-pb2sd6mv2p 5 күн бұрын
You where totaly right with Soul! There are this few people who have it in them and this is special. Thats why she was my main pick. I hope she debuts sometimes in a good group, i think she would suit every concept. She could even be the leader. I will wait for her and the other trainees debut. They are all so talented. Thank you for this great video
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 4 күн бұрын
ahh yes a leadership role also for soul - I can see the vision! thank you too
@lenardferdaussiuntal8102
@lenardferdaussiuntal8102 10 күн бұрын
Yui and Lingling was robbed
@user-zj7dq6tf3f
@user-zj7dq6tf3f 10 күн бұрын
Can you do a ranking of gen1es? They formed in a survival show Chuang asia 2024
@user-xn7cj3fi1d
@user-xn7cj3fi1d 11 күн бұрын
nana was such a big loss, she could shine a lot in IWALY and she even could be saved bcs she was very popular in japan
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 11 күн бұрын
too bad she wasn’t highlighted in the show
@XavierIbnuu
@XavierIbnuu 11 күн бұрын
Do you have plans to analyze top 12 that entered part 2?
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 10 күн бұрын
yes, i do but planning to do it when we could see how things would further unfold in part 2.
@ellennjenniferdiary7177
@ellennjenniferdiary7177 11 күн бұрын
To be honest i would love to replace yui with yuju😢
@ImagineNotBeingInTheBerryCult
@ImagineNotBeingInTheBerryCult 2 күн бұрын
Not really yuju and yui are both all rounder
@ellennjenniferdiary7177
@ellennjenniferdiary7177 Күн бұрын
@@ImagineNotBeingInTheBerryCult i know but i think yui is better
@soshinae
@soshinae 5 күн бұрын
And I see how many idols now has that YG style/ Blackpink style of singing...
@BUY_YOUTUB_VIEWS_493
@BUY_YOUTUB_VIEWS_493 13 күн бұрын
Can't get enough.
@its_Gad.5
@its_Gad.5 9 күн бұрын
Ling ling being dark horse ended because of not being popular despite of being noticed with mentors about being doing good as day goes by 😢
@abcd-pj1bp
@abcd-pj1bp 13 күн бұрын
Please do baby monster dance analysis after debut
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
planning on waiting for their full album to have more recent materials but let’s see what we can do~
@baizhuisadeks
@baizhuisadeks 6 күн бұрын
i think this is the only analysis video of iland2 contestants that i mostly, if not fully, agree because all of it fit the same views as mine
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 5 күн бұрын
thank you!
@baizhuisadeks
@baizhuisadeks 4 күн бұрын
@@EKCristobal thank you for the non biased and well suited constructive criticisms as well 🥰
@shelfwarrior42
@shelfwarrior42 8 күн бұрын
Yall don’t know how bad I miss Umji😭 I swear she’s in the top 3 best vocalists in the show. She’s so stable even with her sore jaw it’s crazy how her vocals are so clear. And the fact that she’s also such an incredible dancer at the same time is what makes her an all rounder. She has so much potential and i’m so disappointed that more people didn’t pay attention to her. I know it’s not really right for her to debut now bc of her young age but I wanted her to at least get more time to show what she can do so she can solidify her debut in the future.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 8 күн бұрын
Skill-wise, Um Jiwon already is doing great. Plus, she also has the visual so I’m excited for her future.
@Querrant
@Querrant 6 күн бұрын
​@@EKCristobalEven though I knew Umji was going to be eliminated, I was devastated when she was eliminated because she's super talented 😭
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 5 күн бұрын
⁠​⁠@@QuerrantI understand, feelings are valid. this show was only umji’s starting ground and we know she’ll become stronger in her time
@SoraiaLMotta
@SoraiaLMotta 12 күн бұрын
I dont get why this type of programs give the girls dont get at 2 to 4 dance and specialy singing teachers. The amoung of progress they the would be able to show specially in singing would be compeling. Like your ranking cleary demonstrates the lack of singing fundamentals that the equivalent in dancing selection criteria is a bit higher. -- From the 12 who do you think has the most potential for being a finalist "rapper"? Yuju has a bit of this title. But unfortunally I dont think that she will make it. This new phase makes me think that the final group concept will be between ive and aespa.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
Hi, Firstly, I apologize if I misunderstood your first statement, but I assume you are talking about why the program doesn’t provide girls with 2 to 4 dedicated dance and especially singing teachers. On this point, I agree. Programs like Produce 101 and the Planet series had more focused coaches before and even after interim checks. However, since this is a different program, similar to the first season, relying on the producers' feedback and having the participants figure things out themselves might be part of their training method.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
Secondly, while I agree with your point about the lack of fundamentals in singing and the criteria for dance selection being a bit higher, I want to clarify that this ranking is based on their final ranks in the show itself, considering the producers' and i-mates' votes, rather than me ranking them based on their skills.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
Thirdly, regarding the rapper, I also thought they could be maximizing Yuju for the rap because I believe she has the best flow overall. But I'm not a rapper, so this is only based in my opinion. However, as you said, it’s hard to predict what might happen next.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
Lastly, initially, after hearing that Teddy would produce the group and that many producers come from The Black Label, I thought we had a clear idea of the concept the final group might take. But based on their recent Black Made test, I agree with you that the final concept might end up being something between IVE and aespa, or a combination of both. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
@SoraiaLMotta
@SoraiaLMotta 12 күн бұрын
@@EKCristobal you got it right, sorry for the confusing writing. Their feedback sometimes look to be lacking, specially in timing, I know that they talk more then what is showed, but isnt much construtivist like a teacher or coach would do or similar to a professional setting ( from my small personal experience). Oh I liked the last 101, but the large amoung of candidates makes harder to get to know better potential finalist. I use to skip around lot too due repetitive narrative / editing.
@deleyderismynamer
@deleyderismynamer 13 күн бұрын
Hey there's 12 people left and I'ld like to say the people who have the biggest dance of not debuting from my analysis (don't scroll down if u dont want spoilers). I would like to say I am also immensely disappointed in Yui not debuting. 1. juwon 2. saebi 3. sujung 4. jungeun 5. gyuri 6. mai Those who will 100% debut (or almost 100%) are jeemin, jiyoon and maybe fuko? The ones I'm ??? about are sarang, koko and yuju.
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 13 күн бұрын
4/6 who have the most secured debut spots atm in no particular order: 1. Saebi 2. Jiyoon 3. Jeemin 4 Fuko others who are most liked by mnet: Sarang, Mai, Koko
@bn0639
@bn0639 13 күн бұрын
To be honest Jeemin is not bad but she is overreated... everyone is choosing popularity and look over talent. I don't get it how she has higher ranks than Jiyoon, Jungeon or Fuko 😢
@aurumdias750
@aurumdias750 13 күн бұрын
maybe because she is as good as Jiyoon, Jungeun and Fuko at what she does and in her talents. Like bro, wdym overrated? She was a legit finalist for R U NEXT and was a top trainee at Belift too. The others are good too - don't put down one trainee to promote your favs
@bn0639
@bn0639 13 күн бұрын
@@aurumdias750 Actually they are not my main favs but i'm not saying she is bad but i mean she gets promoted because of R U Next and other trainees in ILAND 2 are as good as her or even better and gets ranked low because people promote her more. And that's good but at the same time not fair for the others. But that's my opinion
@naornever
@naornever 13 күн бұрын
​@@bn0639 Did you watch R U Next? If so maybe you feel that way bc you're used to seeing her skills, or maybe bc she doesn't seem to have improved much since R U Next. But it doesn't change the fact that Jeemin is one of the top trainees on the show who deserves to debut
@bn0639
@bn0639 13 күн бұрын
@@naornever i watched it 🥲 i'm really happy that she is here but still... she is good and improved but some contestants are better than her and get lower ranks and i just don't get it why...
@jjangjinni
@jjangjinni 13 күн бұрын
there is a reason why jeemin made it and not other visual contestants like yeeun, she has star quality. Jeemin’s personality is likeable and she does have good stage presence, which is even more strengthened if it is a more dark/mature concept. Her presence on stage is proved in La vie en rose performance and even in performances like Dream of You and PRIDE on RUNEXT. Jeemin also has good idol dancing skills and she certainly knows how to use her face as seen in Final Love Song. I do agree her vocals are comparatively lacking but thats something she can work on with training easily. However, star quality cannot be trained and you are either born with it or you need to discover it yourself.
@MoseMose-bi3xd
@MoseMose-bi3xd 2 күн бұрын
링링 유이😢
@Majern05
@Majern05 8 күн бұрын
yuiko > nana
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 6 күн бұрын
yup if we talked about being well-rounded
@marinettedupaincheng8751
@marinettedupaincheng8751 12 күн бұрын
YUI was definitely better than Fuko in 3 aspects (Dance, Rap, and stage presence). She has more skills that are clearly better than Fuko but she still got eliminated. Fuko is good in vocal but that does not mean she's better with only one strong aspect. I mean she's not even the best Vocalist in the show.🤦🏻‍♀️
@EKCristobal
@EKCristobal 12 күн бұрын
I respect your opinion, but I disagree on some points. While it's true that Yui excels in aspects like dance and rap compared to Fuko, stage presence can vary depending on the concept and is largely subjective. However, the focus here is not solely on who has the most skills, but rather on who best embodies the central theme of the IWALY performance they both competed in. In terms of vocals, Fuko demonstrated strength in this area. Moreover, I must agree with the producers' decision, as I believe Fuko possessed a stronger star quality and better fit the concept for IWALY. The performance was more about overall performance skills (skills + star quality with stage presence as one of its strongest aspect), rather than technical dance skills alone, which may have given Fuko another advantage. This isn't to say Yui doesn’t have star quality; sometimes, it's about how well a contestant's strengths align with the performance's requirements. To consider another perspective, if the IWALY performance had a darker vibe, Yui might have had a stronger impact because that concept would align better with her strengths, thereby making her stage presence more noticeable. Lastly, your statement "She has more skills that are clearly better than Fuko but she still got eliminated" may wrongly imply blame on Fuko. However, Fuko has no control over Yui's voting outcome, so it wasn't her responsibility. The elimination is in the past now, and we can view it as a redirection for Yui. Undoubtedly, she has gained valuable lessons from her experience on the show.
@marinettedupaincheng8751
@marinettedupaincheng8751 12 күн бұрын
@@EKCristobalTo be honest, it's is basically Visual and popularity are more importantant than stronger skills
@lullets5083
@lullets5083 12 күн бұрын
@@marinettedupaincheng8751 You basically ignored everything they said, Fuko outdoubtly performed IWALY better than Yui because the song suits her better.
@guinnmyahslaysstaymad
@guinnmyahslaysstaymad 11 күн бұрын
Rap isn’t even a necessary skill an idol must have,only if the group opts to have a rapper or rap verses in their songs.Fuko has clearly shown a more developed and overall skillet as an idol and she also has leading qualities,which would greatly benefit the group.The girls know,that they can count on her and that asset alone makes her a more valuable member than yui.This isn’t about visuals or popularity as you guys like to throw these words around loosely.Not only that but she seems to be one of the most consistent contestants, who knows her skills and is able to transfer her knowledge to others.I really have to completely disagree with that statement.
@by_tzuyu
@by_tzuyu 12 күн бұрын
Gyuri just got saved because korea favoritism
@joansapy6648
@joansapy6648 Күн бұрын
Gyuri is pretty talented as an all rounder though, she especially has nice vocals
RUNEXT: Why Talented Trainees Didn’t Debut with ILLIT…
22:07
EK Cristobal
Рет қаралды 11 М.
Can You Draw A PERFECTLY Dotted Line?
00:55
Stokes Twins
Рет қаралды 34 МЛН
She ruined my dominos! 😭 Cool train tool helps me #gadget
00:40
Go Gizmo!
Рет қаралды 57 МЛН
UFC Vegas 93 : Алмабаев VS Джонсон
02:01
Setanta Sports UFC
Рет қаралды 223 М.
3 wheeler new bike fitting
00:19
Ruhul Shorts
Рет қаралды 49 МЛН
American was Shocked by The Things That Only European Knows!!
22:00
World Friends
Рет қаралды 1,3 МЛН
I-land 2 Jiyoon Editing Clips
8:49
Nior ᐢ..ᐢ
Рет қаралды 7 М.
The PROBLEM with Le Sserafim and kpop vocals: a video essay
11:59
the FUNNIEST moments of kpop idols
11:44
bpeditor
Рет қаралды 108 М.
Pass or fail?🤔 @Colapsbbx #pedro #beatbox #beatboxchallenge
0:45
BEATPELLA HOUSE
Рет қаралды 57 МЛН
THEY WANTED TO TAKE ALL HIS GOODIES 🍫🥤🍟😂
0:17
OKUNJATA
Рет қаралды 2,8 МЛН
ХЕЧ БУЛМАСА МЕХНАТГА БИТТА ЛАЙК БОСИНГ
0:12
Муниса Азизжонова
Рет қаралды 6 МЛН
КАК ОН РАССТРОИЛСЯ СНАЧАЛА 😂😂😂 #пранк #юмор
0:36
СЕМЬЯ СТАРОВОЙТОВЫХ 💖 Starovoitov.family
Рет қаралды 3,4 МЛН
Why didn’t Nika like my long and beautiful nails? #cat #cats
0:25
Princess Nika cat
Рет қаралды 126 МЛН