"And all my siblings are dead." Quotes aside, it was so interesting seeing character development for an engine who hasn't seen the spotlight since the 90's. Seems to me people want Duke to come back yet they don't seem to make their wishes come true through much fan fiction. Anyway this story was really good, it feels like you did the most research into this and a really engaging story with lots of railway trivia to boot makes the best Thomas stories ever in my book. Duke getting reunited with his family really tugged at my heartstrings and the music was well timed to fit the atmosphere of the episode. With this soft story coming before a halloween special, I wonder what you have planned this Halloween, I bet it will be pretty dark considering your previous work.

I love the line Thomas said, "And all my siblings are dead...I think." Hilarious line of all!

I love how you characterized dukes past self as full of pride. He still has a lot of it, but it defined him over the years and gave him room to grow. Well done indeed!

1:09 Thomas "and all my siblings are dead ....... I think" xD

4:00 "His Grace?" "More like his ARSE! HAHAHAHA!" XD

"all my siblings are dead I think" Thomas 2016

An excellent plot, and very impressive overall. You know, I'd love to see something like this for Duncan.

Also I'd like to add: all the engines didn't have their cast iron saddle tanks until the 1880s. However, I obviously couldn't find any models so there are some historical issues XD.

9:38 I love dukes reaction when he sees the rest of his brothers

Come to think of it, I thought Duke was a bit spirited in his youth myself. And, well, I thought it was cool seeing him with his siblings on their line. But, when Sir Handel and Peter Sam went to cheer up their dear Granpuff, my heart melted, and it did so even more when the siblings arrived. Aww!

‘More Like his Arse!’ ‘Excuse me, Little Giant!’ My favorite moment.

"and all my siblings are dead...I think" for some reason that made my night right there

"And all my siblings are dead. I think? -Thomas. lolol great video T1E2H3 1:08 - 1:13

Duke: i haven't seen my brothers in way over a centries Thomas: and all my siblings are died, i think

R.I.P. Mountaneer R.I.P. Little Giant

Duke: I haven't seen my siblings in way over a century.Thomas: And all my siblings are dead... I think.Me: LOL that is hilarious!

I like how skarloay’s and rhenas’ brothers are their real life counter part

Steam engines have great memories they can remember stuff from LITERALLY HUNDREDS OF YEARS AGO!

T1E2H3, you’re one of the most creative Thomas KZfaqrs I’ve ever seen. 50K+ Subs are outstanding but I believe you deserve more

The S-Team duke loves it when a plan comes together

7:13 What A Minute, You're Not Bertram!

8:59 Epic gauge fail!😂

“This vid will always suit his grace!”

Thomas: And all my siblings are dead! .... I think. (A wild Timothy appears)

I remember watching your search for smudger and it's still in my top five favorite videos

I loved this episode; seeing Duke and Bertram reunited with their brothers really makes my heart smile. Excellent work!

This is a really good episode! Loved the sibling reunion! I'm super exited for your Halloween episodes!!

Duke: I haven’t seen my siblings in well over a century Thomas: And all my siblings are dead, I think This had me on the floor lmao

I was surprised that those engines are still around, I originally thought Prince was the sole survivor, also quite nice that Bertram is now a part of the family

Possibly my favourite episode form you! No ones ever mentioned about dukes history pre mid sodor or his family! Very well done the script was very well written!

I remember seeing one or two of Duke’s classmates at The Ffestiniog Railway in real life, when I visited in 2008. I loved the backstory and of how The Siblings made up in the end. It was nice of how Duke was like Skarloey, Sir Handel and Peter Sam when he was young. Interesting of how he used his sad backstory to mould himself into the character he became later in life. And don’t worry about The Ffestiniog looking not like it does in real life, it is understandable considering that everyone had a limitation on Trainz sets back then.

princess : he's Grace little giant : more like he's ass HAHAHAHAHA XD

Oh my gosh, I love Duke. He's so dynamic, and you presented him incredibly well! This is why he needs to return. One question though, why did you use the new model of Duke in some scenes, and the old one in others? Sometimes even changing just within shots?

6:42 - Wait a minute... Why is Percy pulling American tankers?

I love this episode and Welsh Pony's voice XD

That was a wonderfully thought out episode! I've never even thought about dukes brothers and sisters. And dukes new model and face masks look amazing! The music, the plot, and that little funny bit with Thomas made the episode amazing. And the touch back on the search for smudger at the end was amazing. I love how you included Bertram. Your best episode yet! Keep up the good work!

This is really great episode. Never expected Duke to have that many siblings, much less being that troublesome. Nice job of adding Talyllyn and Dolgoch for cameos. Small suggestion in the future: Think you can change pitches for separate characters, seeing as you're voicing all of them now?

He smashed into YOU Duke!

i love duke overall in TEOS. the sides of his character that we never saw, such as his temper, are incredible.

Good Job T1E2H3! Nice use of the new Duke Model. Also, Mountaineer reminds me of my home state West Virginia.

Man i really miss Duke. COME ON ANDREW BRENNER GIVE US DUKE BACK! ANd yet his chance of his return is very low since he was never seen for years now

I love this channel. This content is keeping the Thomas stories going. It's incredible

i think the story would have worked much better if duke hadn't mentioned not hearing princes dialouge

All my siblings are dead I think Eh well Thomas you still got one, a ghost engine number 0.

:D Percy is pulling German tankers at 6:42! But good video.

Great episode I must say , including other railways witch the Thomas one were based on , amazing and great that you thought of the 150th birthday of the Talyllyn railway too

10:07 Ivo Hugh, Fred and Luke, I certainly was not expecting that

when Thomas said he thought all of his brother were dead, I think, was that a reference to the new e2 there planning on building?

Great episode! I loved Sudrian Afro's Post Train theme at the ten minute mark. It really fits the tone of the reunion.

"exuse me, little giant!" says old red head

Duke’s backstory is kinda similar to my days at middle school. I meant well, but I was a difficult learner.

2:30 “That is one of the hardest things to imagine ever. Duke being hyper?!” ~Peter Sam 2016

I usually don't care that much for touchy feely stories but I highly enjoyed this one. 10 out of 10.

henry i just loved the line " MORE LIKE HIS ASS"

"And all my siblings are _DEAD_ i think.... - Thomas

2:49 '' i was just a little stuborn and wouldn't listen '' * *proceeds to crash through a building* *

At 0:34, I think you meant to say Sesquicentennial, and if you don't know what that means, that is a 150th anniversary. Also all of Thomas' siblings have been scrapped from February 1961 to April 1963. There has been a rumor that another LB&SCR E2 will be built, with a larger coal bunker. (These last two sentences are according to Wikipedia.

Duke is one of my favorite characters. I always wanted him back in Thomas series, since he was only appearance in season 4, in season 5 only picture of Duke

In addition to the 6 year old comment, it is beautiful to not only see Duke start out as immature but prideful as Matt said back then, but also make amends with the biggest mistake he made. It really hit close to home, making this episode one of my favourites for sure.

Very nice. Your voice acting has improved great.

I love your Duke voice and keep up the exceptional work :)

I loved seeing my brothers and sister again! Only if Little Giant was there with them…

4:06 Excuse me, Little Giant.

great job, love your series, and this has to be one of the best episodes

This was just like The Great Gathering.

the thing Thomas said at the first part of the video...nice way of putting it Thomas

i miss duke so much.he was my favorite form this railway.i really hope he comes back to the tv series one day

Duke: I haven't seen my siblings in well over a century. Thomas : And all my siblings are DEAD! I think?

I was almost close to tears when I watched this. Great job!

6:26 The Sodor Garratt!

4:02 "moar like his ARSE !! , HEHEH"

Well, Thomas is right, unless... the rumblings I've heard about a fund coming around to have a new E2 built in the future since Thomas is an E2. Somewhere on DA I heard it. And unless you want to have Timothy be cannon (with tons of editing to his story) he could be Thomas' ghost brother.

Haven't even seen the episode but the title already makes it good already

1:10 in this scene thomas say “and all my siblings are ded..... i think” well the e2 class engines have been scrapped for a while but thomas said i think because hes not sure if timothy the number 0 engine counts as his alive brother or a ghost.

This is so nostalgic, and the story is great!

3:29 DUKE! WHAT ON EARTH ARE YOU DOING YOU CLUMSY BOOB?!

Question in 10:10 Who is that Gray narrow gauge diesel engine with the number 9?

I loved this episode, it was funny when Duke was talking to his two brothers and then when the others appeared he said " oh, you have got to be joking! "

that was a heartwarming episode there. good job

6:51 Wow, Sir Topham Hat Shrunk Henry's Tunnel

how did duke know that little gaint is dead

Prince: looking for someone. Duke: yes bertram I... wait a minute.. you’re not Bertram.. oh my goodness.. it can’t be. Prince: Hello Duke Duke: Prince... good gracious I don’t believe it

Smashed right in to the coaches. Though welsh pony hit duke instead

Duke's siblings being able to forgive him for his arrogant behaviour may help me with some painful memories that have recently returned to the forefront of my mind.

3:21 duke: and he smashed right into the coaches Me: actually he crashed into dukes tender (were are you GWR studios)

1:09 "Well all of my siblings are dead, I think?"

Even though I am not in this fandom anymore I still think this is pretty good.

“And all my siblings are dead... I think.”

Real locomotives,with real fates.WOW.

1:09 Thomas "and all my siblings are dead ....... I think" LOL All you're siblings are dead Thomas, but Timothy is not just dead he's a dead demon who comes back and haunts you.

11:17 - the ending theme comes in a little early for a split second

2:10 Gordon's Face

I find it odd that duke is the youngest to his siblings but to the mid sodor engines like Peter Sam and sir Handel he’s like a grandpa because of them calling him grandPUFF

"And all my siblings are dead!" "I think"

3:35 isn't that the ghost engine from ShunterProductions's Duncan Gets Spooked adaptation?

that "I think" brings so much lore its unreal

1:09 Thomas: and all my siblings are dead… I think Me: heh

"And all my siblings are dead!" XD

*"And all my siblings are dead... I think"* - Thom

I loved it that you putted in dens CGI face in it