+Black00xXx00Rose 1 year late, but absolutely agree. This whole competition-like view ruins it completely for me. Wherever you go, you see people talking about how they played it after X year or how hard it is. And then there are those websites rating pieces from "easy" to "expert", like it's some sort of video game similar to guitar hero... The technical aspect is an important part, but that on its own won't get you far. Not to mention, who knows how well these people played the pieces when they were young? Saying that you played it at age X doesn't have to mean anything, and I'm hoping that the actual prodigies don't go around bragging online about it.

Anthony Williams Shut the fuck up

No one cares about how good you are you are posting anything on your KZfaq channel

wow...

+Ling Gu I agree with with you, but I also want to point out that you can't help but be rude when you are completely shocked. Anthony Williams is the rude one by posting this reply to a comment that tells people not to say that they 'played this when they were young'. Also, Anthony Williams goes further and says that he did it at 6 better than the amazing lady in the video (huh? not even if you are prodigy - Haydn's compositions need a kind of maturity to execute and a 6 yr old is far away from that). He also claims he improved on the original piece. This is where I get baffled. A 6 yr old 'improving' on a piece full of sublimities composed by the classical master. I can imagine how he improved it, most probably by smoothing out Haydn, and completely substituting the musically difficult passages (hint: there are quite a few). A 6 yr old's perspective is so limited - he wouldn't appreciate complex flavours, impressionist paintings, and philosophical literature. He wouldn't appreciate Haydn.

Mary Beth Dietrick good luck！

How did it go?

@@Anonymous-wj6bu Very well. Unfortunately my dear teacher was too ill to attend and died shortly after.

@@marybethdietrick79 Oh no! So sorry for your loss of your teacher. 🙏

@@texaswildcat6425 Thank you. It's been 2 years now. I played this piece in recital a month before she died, but she wasn't able to attend.

I agree with you, except this is not a song. It is a piano sonata.

The only person who ever played this sonata that young or younger was Ilana Vered from modern day Israel, who actually was able to play it at age 3.

"fetus" 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@Silver Chak Agree 😊

As an RN I find that really disturbing a fetus can play this......and yet...that was so fricking funny 😂😅🤣

I actually composed this sonata as a fetus but I guess she can play it decently enough - prodigal fetus

@@jaybosher6144 nel we

I still find it more enjoy able then Mozart. I know he was a prodigy and all but his music makes me fall asleep

@@romanmihalic4544the elegance of the music by Mozart is what makes him so special to me

Are you sure that you have no words?! 'Horowitz, go home?!' Those are some words! I appreciate the audacity of such a statement but I do not take issue with the sentiment and am not shouting you down for it.

Simpin ain't easy

Simp

The word simp did not exist 6 yrs ago

There is such a thing as focusing on her looks too much

Why is it always about looks with female musicians?

@@stepatatime5388 Sure, but in every art there's something that only the years of experience make you understand what I mean. An 11year-old child may probably play this sonata fantastically but, in some years in the future you'll understand what I mean, its a question of how old you are to understand the point, and cannot be explained until you get older. In ten years or so you'll get my comment. It's not a question of talented people, its a question of experience, and only the years can give It to you.

I sometimes agree with it, but you may be prejudiced towards the young pianists. There are thousands of kids who can express the true music of Haydn and other composers very well. And there is really something that kids can express rather than as an adult, like the brightness of Haydn.

@@isabellllee Are you really sure a 12 year old pianist can "express" all the complexity of a Beethoven's sonata? Or express all the nuances implicit in a Chopin's piece? I think they dont. It's similar to Literature. No kid can express in a novel or, better, a poem all the experiences, sensations, deceptions ,etc that only the years can bring to you. Poetry is similar to music, an art of emotions and experiences, and a child hasnt lived enough years to have enough experiences of Life. He/she is not mature enough. That's all. It has nothing to do with talent. Picasso was an excellent painter as a child but he created Cubism when he was an adult. That's the point. Children may be talented and fantastic players but they are children after all. We should ask Baremboin's opinion about this topic, since he was a child prodigy. He's got the answer to this discussion. We need him to read our comments, (would be wonderful) and answer

Step at a Time I’m 11 and I play the Turkish march by Mozart, it’s such a great piece, gives my heart a nice warm feeling and makes me smile 😊 then I close my eyes and lose myself in the music and play it the way through😊🤓

Though I may be 12 I feel like I can play with heart the best. People always say my best quality or talent in piano is my stage presence and feeling towards the piece that I’m playing. They also say that I make very good faces and my mom always says that I should play like somebody in the audience may be deaf and I agree. She said that I should play with emotions like someone deaf is watching so they can understand the emotions. ❤️

Exactly! That's what I'm doing right now.

me too i dont like presto for 1st mov. vivace is better to feel nuances.

Same 😉

me too😄

@Randy Kern I agree and how did your jury go?

@@yejohn8162 it went well! I graduated with my degree. One thing I learned is that a piece is never done. When you first learn them, like I was doing for this piece 4 years ago, it was my first attempt. Solidifying and memorizing notes, phrases, rhythm, etc. Those first two months of finishing and memorizing the music is only the beginning-you have to drop stuff for a while, come back with a fresh mind, and suddenly the piece comes alive again in new way. What I’ve found works best for me, is always going back to a piece after letting it sit for a while. That’s 100% more effective than sitting at the piano until your brain dead and can’t feel your fingers anymore; wondering why you can’t get it right.

说得好

😐😕😕😒😒😒😒😒😒😒😒

Idk what this mean but i give like

在舞台上弹好每个曲子都不容易。

Just keep going !🥰💗

@@Penguren I’m actually moving on to some new prices that I enjoy a lot, like notturno (Edvard Greig) and nocturne op 9 no 2 by Chopin

@@tas5622 that’s cool !💗 화이팅!

You don’t really need to say that, plus I think everyone knows by just watching the video 😊

@@yejohn8162 i think was just if anyone liked that movement in particular and wanted to skip to it

Definitely 🙏🏻

Same, my interpretation of this piece when I was younger was agitated and contrasted, like how one might play Beethoven as you mentioned. I really appreciate Tiffany Poon's interpretation, the emotion and phrasing is beautiful. I am now in my thirties and revisiting this piece.

Dude,things like that are important

I absolutely hate your account name. But I have no idea what that chair is.

@@zenchenpiano Im pretty sure its a hydraulic press concert chair; I have one at home that I just got.

I have no idea what you’re talking about!? And I do see a chair but what about it?? 🤔

@@tas5622 Hmm, sounds expensive I guess

Woodrow Woodbridge i know this comment was four years ago but just in case you didn't already do that - go watch her vlogs :)))

Junyi Desu I like to play Hanon all the time as a fun exercise that also really helps to warm up. If you practice stretching techniques and songs that are made to stretch your hand and fingers then you could probably improve a lot :D

There is always the option to roll the octaves or play the bottom or top note. Don't stretch to hard tho

IT IS A PIECE NOT A SONG GET IT RIGHT OR YOU’RE NOT A REAL PIANIST

No one cares just enjoy the music

Hand and arm movements are incredibly beautiful, the tone is excellent and basically everything about this performance is superb!

I also like how this performance is slightly slower than other performances out there...even though it's slower, to me it feels like it's just the right speed (others, though also great, feel a bit rushed...)

I'm working on this sonata right now. I'm always using this to know if i'm playing the right notes in the right rythem

Ahh... Hi Wimpy Kid I didn’t know you knew how to play piano 🎹… by the way are you the real Wimpy Kid????¿

다들 외국인이셔서영어썼어여