I’m gonna be honest, after nearly a decade of Live-Action remakes, there’s just nothing left to say anymore.

It's crazy to think that this kicked off Disney's live action remake trend, and that despite massive flaws, it's still one of the better ones. Points for at least making it different, I guess.

the worst part about this is that it's (probably) one of the better disney live action remake out of all of them. this says a lot about society and yet we live in it. -Peter Griffin

I personally enjoy the live action Alice In Wonderland. I even dressed as the Red Queen once for Halloween.

Ok but why does the Mad Hatter look like a fusion between Willie Wonka and Pennywise 😂

Oh yes, the one that starts the Disney remakes (not counting the 101 dalmatians one, since this was not for cash grab yet.)

Sad thing is their first remakes were decent because like Illumination, in their first rodeo they didn't realize they didn't have to try yet. Maleficent and Cinderella (remake) are both pretty decent especially the first Maleficent. And so was this one

There’s a 1988 stop motion movie directed by Jan Švankmajer that’s an adaptation of Alice in Wonderland. But if you watch it or look it up, you’re gonna need a lot of therapy after that and it makes McGee’s Alice look like Dora the Explorer compared to it.

At least Mia Wasikowska went on to be in Crimson Peak, one of Guillermo del Toro’s most underrated films in my opinion.

Alice's pet in the silent shorts was not Felix the Cat. His name was Julius.

If Wonderland had to be real, I wish they could've handled it in a similar fashion to the Ni No Kuni games (if you've played/heard of them). It'd be more interesting if they played with Wonderland being a bizarre reflection of the real world.

Not gonna lie, even though I know they're not that good, I have a giant soft spot for the two live-action AIW movies. I saw the first one in theaters with my family, it was one of the first 3D movies I saw, and I watched it all the time when having sleepovers with my cousin. The second one is the same, as I also watched it with my family. I can't bring myself to dislike these movies, they have a special place in my heart. Plus, they do the one thing modern live-action remakes don't: it actually tries to be different and stand out in its own way as opposed to recreating iconic scenes from the original and screaming "REMEMBER THIS?!?!?!"

Both this movie and the sequel feel more like deep cut remakes of the Adventures in Wonderland show from the 1990s. The series basically follows the same formula of Alice dealing with a problem in the real world before going into Wonderland where she partakes in strange adventures with its inhabitants that revolve around the situation that she is dealing with at home and then uses what she learns there to solve her issues in real life.

Ahh yes, the legend of the futterwacken lives on...

Remember seeing the ads in early 2010 and thought it looked meh, thank god I instantly skipped it. The end result is a train wreck, yet became a billion dollar hit. The sequel on the other hand, bombed horribly and not even muppets most wanted director James Bobin was able to save it!!!

My favorite Alice In Wonderland adaptation is the 1933 live-action one with Charlotte Henry. It was the reason why Walt Disney didn't make the Live-action Animated one he was planning for his first film. I do have nostalgic fondness for this one, but I know it's got flaws, and it started a big Disney Live-action dump. Loved the review 👏

But the Question is what is worse? Live Action Disney Adaptions or Public Domain Parodies like Blood and Honey & Mickeys Mouse Trap?

Raisorblade in Wonderland!

I'd remembered Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland and it's Okay it's Nowhere near as Great as Nightmare Before Christmas and or Corpse Bride

I'll see this movie. I was restarted and I I did man's to watch it when I was AA kid. I think around like 12 years old and I generally forgot about it. And frankly, no one has even talked about it since, like at all

This movie seems to have the effect that Schaffrillas calls “Phantom Menacing”, where a movie comes out that is objectively bad, but at the time, everybody was trying to convince themselves that it was a good movie, and tries to block out any problems that are in the movie. However, over time, they start to realize the movie’s true colors and shortcomings, and they now call it a bad movie, which was what it always was the moment it came out.

0:09 the stock is the lowest it’s been in DECADES and the 100 year anniversary was a joke, he would totally hate it.

I may have only seen this movie once years ago, and even I was not a fan of the whole prophecy idea. It doesn't fit with the bizarre chaos of Wonderland and it just sounds so dull.

The only thing good about this movie in my opinion is Johnny Depp’s performance as the Mad Hatter. He captured what the spirit of the Mad Hatter was in the movie mixed in with how they portrayed him in the books. Brilliant. Other than that is movie is fine. Only fine.

The actor who played Alfred in the live action movies in the 90's had his final role in this film as the dodo.

The killer bean meme had cought me off Guard it's funny 😂😂😂😂😂

To be fair, this was amazing because it was a sequel. Most of the other films were terrible because they remade (relatively) recent films with too much changed or little to change, or were reimaginings that, while fine as standalones, took the bite out of the original characters.

7:33 to 7:41 - OMG, I totally forgot it had merch!!! 🤯🤯🤯

I didn’t hate the remakes as much as I should, but this is one of the few that I refuse to defend.

I never wanted to strangle 8 year me so bad in my life. I may have fond memories of playing pretend with my sisters where one of us was Alice or the queens, but I don’t think the decay of modern entertainment was worth it tbh. Also I had a crush on the Mad Hatter back then and now I regret it.

Never was really a fan of this movie the first time I saw it. I thought that it was just an okay movie. But you're right that this movie at least tried to do something different unlike Disney's later live-action movies, which are mostly mainly copy and paste of their original work just with unnecessary changes.

I really hated the Mulan remake. What's the point of this story if she's a strong and capable fighter from the start?!? All the songs are gone, and they cut out the funniest character, Mushu. I avoided the Lion King one entirely. That one should not even exist. The stage musical is so much more creative and stands on its own compared to the animated movie. I was fortunate enough to be able to see that as a kid.

9:30 Actually back then, people still had lost interest in Disney. I mean sure, we had Princess and the Frog which came out the year before, but that didn’t do so well. I’d say it wasn’t until Tangled when Disney regained everyone’s hope.

I thought the live-action Wonderland was pretty good upon release. But rewatching it recently, the amazement isn't there anymore...

That cat in 1920s is Julius not Felix I know it looks like Felix but it's not

Here's a better idea on a live action remake, Big Hero 6 and make it Marvel!

Can you do a video about "Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron"? 🙂❤️

this is for me the best one i mean crispin glover atee in this movie the visuals were amazing so its a 8 ,9/10

What could definitely work better if Disney remade their bad films from the past like for example, Home on The Range or Chicken Little.

Godzilla X Kong Gives Giant Monster More Expression then LA Lion King!?

20:13 Omg, Sinbad Legend of the Seven Seas, my childhood!!😮🥳 *ahem* Anyways, a nice analysis. I didn't ever really feel one way or another about Tim Burton's AIW. I saw it first time with a bunch of friends, it was a fun night, and that's about it.

18:37-18:41 Paul Attrakis: *SILENCE!!!!*

Oh i cant way for the uncontrollable rage from this man once he gets to the "maleficent" movie (if he even does it at all)

So this is what you meant when you said Walt made a remake. Yeah, I don’t think I’d count that in the same regard as the remakes we’re getting now. I don’t even know if those old Alice films were made when Disney (company) was a thing. All you have in the terms of a remake is that they’re based on the same thing. So I wouldn’t say Walt made a remake and would agree with current Disney’s plans, based on that at least. But this stuff about the strike does seem more believable in terms of evidence (more so than a certain other thing Walt is accused of) and even though I still do believe that Disney was better paying than other animation studios at the time, clearly that just means others had to be worse. Either that or we’re just so used to hating on corporate leaders that we ignore all other details. (Hopefully joking here)

looking back on the Tim Burton live action Alice in Wonderland it's just Okay for what it was the Sequel on the other hand NOT so much

so your going to review all disney remakes after this right?

I recently had the realization that this movie is arguably the most important film that Bob Iger has ever greenlit. Like this is the movie that changed everything for Disney, the one that led them onto their gradual downward spiral to the sorry state they’re in now. So thanks Bob Iger, you destroyed the Disney empire without anyone noticing

Missed opportunity to make a "Mila Wazowski" joke

And the fact they're doing live action with httyd especially makes me worried. One cuz dreamwok is gonna run with that trend now and two cuz it's going to miss why the franchise was unique in the first place

Yeah, there is a possibility that Walt Disney probably would have liked this new direction. So all of these oversensitive lunatics can stop accusing Disney of “s#%tting on Walt Disney’s grave” every time Disney World makes any changes.

To be honest I thought this movie was pretty cool to see excepelly Tim burton style and the cool 3D expression but to be honest this is why people should see Tron legacy instead because we could’ve stop these remakes form beginning

This was the best part of the video 22:38

It’s not that remakes are an inherently bad thing. Peter Jackson’s King Kong is A great film. With some of the best world building I’ve ever seen. But King Kong at least tried something new.

I Guess Not All Disney Remakes Are Bad After All!

While I am in no way going to defend Walt Disney for his business practices and stance on Unions and how he treated his workers, I will at least say that what puts him above Iger and other modern CEO's (if only slightly) is his actual ambition and risk taking nature. You'll never see Iger use the profits of these billion dollar successes to fund an arthouse film like "Fantasia," or try developing an entire city that was intended to become an advancement on civilization. I do think Walt would be smart enough to take advantage of these products, using them as a foundation for financial stability while using their excessive profits to fund more creative and ambitious films he was passionate about and his more "out there" ideas. Love him or hate him, he got things done, and didn't just sit around on his money pile.

i know that the plot is bu*lshit but i still like this movie

After hearing the story from reviews and clips (mainly NC’s review on it) I think the story is sound and some of the character designs are pretty good for being live action, it’s just that everything else is pretty bad. But at least it’s better than the remakes we have now

I like you Tim Burton but… I don’t know about this. If you ask me, I’d just keep playing Alice: Madness Returns. That game is so damn good for an Alice in wonderland adaptation. Also the marketing was mostly talking about Johnny Depp’s character because it’s Johnny Depp stardom money obviously.

What’s the footage with the frog at 12:39?

for me its just a movie i can turn off my brain

Your about one early Disney remakes at least try to be different which is more than what I could say about a lot of the latest Disney remakes doesn’t make this movie suck less hey a for effort I guess personally I prefer cinderella 2015 and jungle book 2016 which I can’t wait for you to get to those

I feel like Walt would on board with using AI if it meant he didn’t need to spend as much money paying writers. Although, I feel he would be strongly against the woke themes mostly out of his more dated social views.

If only we could go back in time and prevent this movie from turning a profit.

I actually kinda liked this movie.

I'm gonna be honest, I've never cared about these live-action remakes like yes I agree with everyone else that the jungle book remake is the best of the remakes. But outside of that I've never cared about these remakes. The only purpose of these remakes is just for us to go back in time and see those classics. But yeah nice to see where these remakes began

I'd so much rather re-watch Charlie and the Chocolate Factory over this Boring remake to Alice in Wonderland and shockingly to some people I'd never liked the animated Alice in Wonderland

11:48 Mike Wazowski?

30:07 NOO-

I have a difficult history with this movie I liked it as a kid but has I got older and watched the nostalgia critic review yeah its bad

I've never liked the old animated version 1951. But i LOVE Alice in Wonderland 2010. Cinderella (2015) was beautiful. The Maleficent movies and Cruella (2021) was good too. But the other live action remakes SUCKED! Beauty and The Beast (2017), Lion King (2019), Aladdin (2019), Mulan (2020), all these were TERRIBLE! They had no hearts or souls. The magic wasn't there. And Snow White (2025) will ABSOLUTELY BE THE WORST MOVIE EVER! But anyway, i like this one. ❤

And we thought Tim Burton's Willy Wonka remake was bad!

What amazes me is the lack of imagination behind the very premise of the story. It is literally all about slaying a dragon. Why would you waste Wonderland on slaying a dragon? Considering all the madcap stuff you can do with Wonderland, you pick the most clichéd fantasy story. The fact there is no character arc for Alice nor does Alice really do much more than the most bare bones interaction with her environment just makes it all the worse. Really, it was successful because of the name, and many of the remakes were success because of their names. However, I do think we've reached the point of diminishing returns. The Little Mermaid might've made money, but not nearly as much as the others. We will see what happens with Snow White.

Jack saint made a great video about this movie,explains why this movie sucks at writing.

22:10 people made p*** of these two

AWESOME REACTION OF MY FAVORITE JOHNNY DEPP MOVIE!!!!!!!!!😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

REVIEW Velma 2023

The sequel of that remake is better

You put Iger in the same category as Walt Disney? Well, you people are destroying Disney so hopefully soon it'll be gone and you'll be happy.