I couldn’t agree more in every single category. I really think these two figures hit what they are striving to be. If you want ultra toon with great accessories, articulation and paint the Takara has you covered. If you want a more heroic/mature looking bot that still hits that toon feel then Phoenix is probably for you. I absolutely love Phoenix and will never switch him out. I really appreciate all the hard work you put into these verses and how fair you are. One of your verses videos was the reason I started watching your channel in the first place so thanks it’s helped me chose between a lot of figures.

MP57 wings also fold up way more clean in robot mode because the hinge is closer to base than wing tip, so the hinge totally vanishes into the backpack away from sight. FT10 also has so many more visible screws and pins. Got my MP57 for 240 dollars so MP57 easily wins for me.

I like them both so much, I like to imagine Phoenix is Skyfire's bigger brother and a new character all to his own

Man it's been a great few days with your skyfire reviews! Awesome job, thanks!

There's one category that should have gone to Phoenix: alt mode. The reason both got tied out was because of the playability of the Hasbro. But all those features also gave it the win at gimmicks. So they got rewarded twice for the same things.

This is the video I've been looking forward to! Thanks for the honest look

I will stick with Phoenix. I like it's overall look better in both modes.

Great video. Just the comparison that I needed.

Great fair comparison. I will have to wait until I have the Takara in hand to make a final decision as to which is staying with my season 1 display and which is going into my Skyfire/Jetfire/Macross shrine, but I think it is going to be very hard to displace FT-10X from the season 1 display.

Great review. I was never a big sky fire fan, but your comparison is spot on.

The members choice! Wow!.. As always great video.

This a good one I'm Getting my popcorn for this review!

Takara killed it. I just got mine yesterday. It's huge.😂

Great comparison! I like how the official has the option to be "like" the G1 toy as well. Jetfire/ Skyfire has always been in my top 5 favorite Transformers, and I really like the inclusion of the mini figures to mimic his mass shifting.

Great review as always

I remember when Phoenix first came out Maz at Transformers Square One took some pictures of it in alt mode next to some World's Smallest Transformers figures, I made the suggestion to use that front panel as a ramp with them which he did, it looked great with WST Prowl driving up it.

I'm keeping both too!

Thanks for the comparison! They both look great, but sticking with FT for now

My patience paid off. I just got him from the sale over the weekend at TFSOURCE. Like you, I've been waiting for a MP Sky fire since forever. So I really had to hold back until a sudden sale came up on him. Love the figure and the review!!! -Hastyle Prime

Great review and I'm getting Takara Tomy's version of Skyfire.

I really dislike the toon accuracy for the Takara but I love that alt mode. I’ll stick with my FT and just wait for the eventual KO of Takara.

Great VS. ✨️😀 Can't wait to get TT in hand

Great review, brother(per usual). It would be awesome if you added an extra point section for “toon accuracy” in alt mode as well. (before the “build” point section). Cheers!

I personally never like Phoenix so I’m not the best to ask but yeah for me Takara all the way

Phoenix actually does have a hip swivel if you unlatch the two parts above the Hip - if you take a look at EmGo's review of this one, he demonstrates how it works based on instruction he got from FansToys

Fair review. Im not sure if its entirely fair that Takara gets effectively 2pts for Gimmicks (you tied the jets because of the gimmicks). The Takara jet also does not look aerodynamic at all. Takara wins because of articulation, but the ratchets hinder it. Tho one could make the case that due to inflation, price is effectively tied. Both are great for different things -But I think its pretty telling that FT wins the Fan Vote absolutely.

Give me MP57 anyway. My nostalgia is for the cartoon, and like you said takara knocked it out of the park on that front. Fantastic comparison video too!!

Takara definitely looks very Sunbow accurate. I feel like Phoenix is kinda what he'd have looked like if Skyfire had been a character in Victory or Zone, with more heroic anime-like proportions. They're both good figures, but I'm definitely sticking with FT Phoenix.

I just got the MP 57 sky fire 🔥 He is Great .I never had the FT Sky Fire but I just like him all around more but both are great!!!

thanks for the review! now I know which one I should unbox and which one to keep MISB.. hehehe

This is a fair comparison. If I were to switch the points around to factors that matter the most to me, FT would win. But I can't deny that Takara met their target with a decent price on this one. Also, you forgot that the fingers for FT can be splayed. Wouldn't matter in terms of points, but it's still there anyway.

Since both are different in height for bot mode. I was interested in seeing which scales better and also wondered if scale is a factor in your versus. IMO the ft-10X would of at least tied with TT. I’m keeping my ft but also have a desire to grab the TT. Thanks for another great video review comparison!

Keep knocking them out for us Sony 😊

Robot mode goes to Takara..., alt mode goes to FansToys! Bot mode is what I care about most, so I'm glad I waited for the Takara version.

Wanted an official Skyfire..love my MP-57 ..bot mode is definitely the strongest out of the two..That being said FT alt mode is cleaner..

Thank you for the VS Sony. Looking at both sides by side, my heart registered FTs as what was in the Cartoon eventhough I know TT is more accurate. I agree with your assessment that TT takes this VS, but I also believe we are looking at apples to oranges here. TT is a VW Golf R as FT is an older 911, for 70% of the Community TT will take it, for the other 30% (including you and I) it will always be FTs...Conclusion, TT wins the Mind, FT wins the Heart...as Bobby always says, "If you like it, You win."

It really did help i will get the takara but i still love fantoys more..i m only getting takara because of cartoon accurate..

Completely objective and accurate. That said, I still prefer Phoenix.

Thanks for doing this vs. they both really hit the goal for what they are trying to do. I prefer fts heroic look and will stick with phoenix. Great options for everyone’s preference. Are you planning to look at the siege oversized ko?

Gotta keep little Jazz in perpetual Crane kick pose.😂👍

One thing that stands out hugely that wasn't even touched on in the monologue, but is evident in the shot being used in the last 2 minutes - FT has _so_ many more screw holes. Looks like he's been hit with buckshot! 3 on the kneecap, 3 on the thigh, 3 on the lower leg... _5_ on the forearm and even more on the upper arm, shoulder, etc.? MP-57 robot mode is _impressively_ clean by comparison with just 5 _in total_ visible across all those areas. Wow.

If you averaged the characteristics of both figures, I think that would be the ideal figure.

I had MP Skyfire on pre-order and it would have been my first non-Diaclone repaint MP since Ironhide, but I had to cancel due to my current finances unfortunately. I really want the mini-figures at some point. That said if I had to only have one it would be Phoenix, which is fortunate since that is my current situation.

I like the look of the Takara one better.

I like minifigs to stand next to the bots if they're the right scale, so you get a good idea of just how big they're supposed to be. Prime in particular is an easy one to measure actual scale in vehicle mode, because the cab section of an FL-84 truck is allegedly exactly 8 feet wide, so the Spike that comes with MP Hound is pretty dang close to being the right size (about 3 quarters as long as the cab's width) to place next to him in either mode. The minifigs from other toys go well with other figures, too, you just have to find the right scaling.

I don't agree with giving alt mode a tie. You already gave Takara the point for gimmicks, which I think are the same as play features. The FTs kills it in the alt mode. The gappy-ness of the Takara takes it out of the running in my opinion. Otherwise I agree with the assessment. Overall, I still prefer Phoenix, but will also be keeping both. Thanks Sony.

I'm bothered by all the screw holes on the Fans Toys figure. I don't have either toy, but I would buy the Takara for the gimmicks and accessories alone.

Both

Maybe I’m the only one but I wish they would include far less accessories and offer a cheaper figure. Sure they’re nice, but I don’t need all that stuff and won’t change the display weekly to show them all off. Give me the figure and a gun and that’s all. That said, your comparison reviews are fantastic and logical where as some others that do these seem to have a lot of attitude, aggression, and more subjective than objective. So keep it up.

Either figure works in any collection. Simular to the new magic Square prime vs the mp 54. Either figure works. Of course, toon accuracy is the deal breaker

For some reason the goofy face of the Takara Skyfire reminds me of Buzz Lightyear. I'd have liked an extra face that really has a menacing expression, but sadly the al is even more dopey

Honestly both great figures. FT Phoenix definitely fits well in the older MP aesthetic like MP-08, MP-10, and MP-13. Takara fits better with the newer aesthetic like MP-44, Robot Paradise Acoustic Wave, MP-45. I’m personally a toon guy so it’s Takara for me. My favorite part was how they engineered the wings. Most Skyfire/Jetfire toys have the wing tips folded back along the rest of the wing and I prefer Tamara’s take here.

The saggy wings on the Takara really bother me. There had to have been a more robust way to do the joint or foldability. The Fanstoys' wings are nice and straight.

How can you not like two big bots? Cool review 🙃

Only thing I can't agree with is the price win for FT , it should go to takara because of all that you get for that $270 the overall package, but great comparison

I'm very shocked that the Takara version won, but then I'm not a huge fan of the overly cartoonish look. I'm very happy with my Phoenix, so I win.

It has been almost 40 years of transformers but for some reason the guys couldnt figure out how to give mp skyfire a waist swivel. I'm still trying to wrap my mind around the fact that the legends versions of skyfire would absolutely wipe the floor with any of the mp versions.

Landing gear seems to have always been a problem for Takara, MP24 Starsaber's V-Star front landing gears can and will collapse under the weight almost immediately out the box. And the gaptastic jet mode combined with that should easily enable the FT to take the jet mode. (Takara's jet mode features really should've been wrapped in under the gimmicks) Outside of the gimmicks, I'm still struggling to see what MP57 Skyfire does that Siege Jetfire and FT10 Phoenix didn't already do and/or do better. Especially when there's an oversized KO of Siege Jetfire on the way that's less than half the price of both MP57 Skyfire and FT10 Phoenix...

I was thinking getting the Takara for plane mode as FT looks better as a bot. But the Takara doesn’t look to good as a plane also. Especially from the front the part that should look the best. What FT won at cost. Lol

Which of the two is easier to transform?

FT10X would have been a better comparison as it's newer & that tie for alt mode? C'mon... you gave TT gimmick points twice.

The biggest flaw of Phoenix in my opinion, has always been the non matching red metallic paint on the legs on the original version. Like, why? Why didn't they just use a red that looks like the rest? It's clearly a conscious design decision they made and I've never been able to figure out the point of it.

I still like the fanstoys but this is takaras best in a while

I think you can throw out the cost because if FT reissue this year it will probably be $275 since they have been increasing their prices on reissues

Depois de muito ter pesquisado, decidi ir no Jetfire. O da Takara Tommy me decepcionou um pouco. Esperava uma figura que superasse o FT-10.

Oh really? The fans toys skyfire also has no waist rotation? I thought it has one, since it's appearance has the waist cut off between.

the chest area on the MP is such a turn off for me. i love the more heroic lean look of the FT

I have Phoenix, and for me, its best mode is the Alt Mode. that massive jet just looks beautiful. I'm getting MP-57 for the robot mode. I just love the way the chest curves upward. It gives it more dimension and personality. The one knock I have it no hip swivel and those thighs are just straight sticks with no sculpt to them. Similar to the seekers.

How can they make that little Jazz but not have an MP of him?

Visible screwholes on Phoenix shoulders is off putting.

I'm going with MP-57 Skyfire but if it were just a bit taller with better faceplates, it'd be pretty much ideal in my eyes. I'm also pleasantly surprised by the price even though it would've cost more if it had been fully-painted.

yeah cartoon accuracy is a weird category when both arent gonig for the cartoon look. it actually penalizes (in this case fanstoys) non-toon aesthetic. good comp though

lmao members choice 100% FT? I see the fan base isn't bias even a little huh? Especially considering most people don't have the Takara in hand yet.

Takara has more gaps

Phoenix is too boxy and bulky looking, and all those screw holes are off putting. MP-57 looks very clean and much more G1 accurate. Like Skyfire before hitting the PED's.

Phoenix still better. You can just see it. Can’t believe Takara won because of the gimmicks.

Not great review! No Gerwalk mode comparison?

Hyper toon doesn't translate to figures well at all. Takara's looks awful imo

Takara has a lot more articulation... and looks terrible doing it.

sorry but the masterpiece looks horrible. the original g1 art was silly and goofy. A G1 transformers MP figure should look cartoon accurate but not at the expense of the aesthetic and look of the figure. for example optimus primal is a really dumb goofy-looking figure, but the masterpiece optimus primal looks amazing, and not so cartoon accurate that it jeopardized the look of the figure this one easily goes to fans' toys for me. another Takara L

Oh boy. You're gonna trigger a lot of Fan Toys fan boys. LOL.

Takara is no match for FT …. Looks & quality …its just like compairing mp44 & te01 😂