1:04 D.O 1:16 Chanyeol 1:30 Baekhyun 1:42 Suho 1:54 Chen 3:04 Xiumin 3:16 Sehun 3:23 Suho and Kai 3:29 Kai 3:35 Lay 3:48 Baekhyun 4:47 D.O 5:00 Suho 5:29 Chen 5:42 Chanyeol 5:50 Xiumin 5:59 D.O 8:08 Chen 8:25 Baekhyun

A lot of people say the whale and the astronaut/space concept did not make sense in the Sing For You MV, but it actually has a lot of significance. The whale concept was derived from the a whale called Alice aka ‘The Loneliest Whale in the World’, who is an unidentified whale species, being the only whale emitting a call at 52-hertz (like a lonly sad song) The astronaut concept was derived from the story of the astronaut *Michael Collins* who spent 48 minutes in his spaceship and coming back saying that those 48 minutes were the longest and most loneliest of mankind. The combination of these two concepts placed within the MV discusses being away from home, being somewhere unfamiliar (since the whale and astronaut is in space) and being isolated. Isolation was one of the themes in the mv (when Kai was seen being alone when the other members were playing/when Chanyeol and Suho were fighting). The song and the MV seems to talk about how everyone, in their lifetime, would meet a low point where they feel most isolated and most out of their place, but that this song (and EXO) will be there to warm their hearts. In a way, this song could also be indirectly dedicated to the members who have left considering the lyrics of the song. Thx for the reaction

1:05 Do 1:18 Chanyeol 1.30 Baekhyun 1.43 Suho 1.54 Chen ( the way you cry ...) 3.09 Xiumin 3.17 Sehun 3.24 Kai ( with suho) 3.33 Kai 3.35 Lay 3.48 Baekhyun ( the way you cry..) 4.47 Do 5.01 Suho 5.30 Chen 5.43 Chanyeol 5.51 xiumin 6.00 Do ( the way you cry...) 8.09 Chen 8.28 Baekhyun exol correct if wrong :)

"Kai was dancing in the snow with a shirt on surprisingly" 😂

The whale concept was derived from the a whale called Alice aka ‘The Loneliest Whale in the World’, The astronaut concept was derived from the story of the astronaut who spent 48 minutes in his spaceship and coming back saying that those 48 minutes were the longest and most loneliest of mankind. ) and same time this mv show Exo story as a group ) that’s why it’s so sad

"Sing For You" is literally, as the title says, EXO singing to EXO-L and some say the MV and song are about how the members feel and how they are dealing with Kris, Luhan and Tao leaving the group. The members really felt like they let fans down during this time and that they broke their promise to always be one. (EXO's slogan is "We Are One." Which represents how even as sub-units they were one group and they are one with the fans, etc. So, when the Chinese members left, the rest of the members felt like as a group they broke that promise.) So this song was a promise and apology song. This was so far from simple times for the members of EXO. This was probably one of the hardest times for EXO and EXO-Ls. That's why you see Chanyeol and Suho get in a fight, because as the leader, Suho really blamed himself for not being able to keep the group together and Chanyeol is pretty much yelling at Suho to stop blaming himself and that there is no point because Kris, Luhan and Tao made their own choices and there is nothing he could have done about it even if he wanted to, etc. They are all angry and sad because they felt like they were all so blindsided by everything that happened because none of the members who left ever said anything to anyone before they decided to leave. A lot happened during this time, and there was so much uncertainty about what it meant for the group, etc. In the beginning you see them happy because this was after they have worked through their anger and are now learning to move on. The parts where you see them sad and angry are flashbacks to recent moments where they were still working through their feelings of anger and sadness. In the end of the MV you start to see them being happy and playing around as friends again because they were learning to get past it all and move on and they made the choice to let it go and to keep singing for us, EXO-Ls. :) The whale seems kind of weird until you discover the meaning behind it all, and then it shows how clever and meaningful they were with the concept. The whale is supposed to represent Alice a.k.a. "The Loneliest Whale in the World", who is an unidentified whale species, she is the only whale that has been found to emit a call at a really high frequency which means that when she speaks there might not be any other whales that can hear her or answer her back. Sehun is the one who is in the spacesuit and he is supposed to represent the lonely feeling you get floating all alone in space. The astronaut comes from the story/poem about an astronaut who spent 48 minutes in his spaceship as he came back to Earth and how he said that those 48 minutes were the longest and most lonely of mankind. The combination of these two concepts, along with the lyrics of the song, talk about being away from home, being somewhere unfamiliar (since the whale and astronaut are in space) and being isolated from everything and everyone. Isolation is one of the themes within the MV. The song and the MV seems to talk about how everyone, in their lifetime, will reach a low point where they feel most isolated and like they don't belong or don't fit in, etc. But as the song says, EXO promises that this song and the members will be there to warm listeners', and especially EXO-Ls, hearts. You should watch an English lyric video, so that you can see who sings each part of the song. :D All 9 members are singing on this song. If you knew the members voices you would be able to recognize each of their voices in the song just by hearing them. By watching more lyric videos, it may help you to start to place their faces with their voices. ;) Most of the time when you saw the member in the video they were the voice you could hear singing at that moment in the song.

*EXO - Diamond+Coming over+Run This+Drop that+POWER (The ElyXion) in Seoul.

This MV was for the 3 members who left exo.....Space represents Kris since he is very fascinated by space and galaxies , Basketball for Luhan since his favorite sports is basketball and fighting for Tao since he was called he kungfu panda of the group......also chanyeol and suho were fighting because chanyeol was trying to convince suho that the members leaving wasnt his fault because suho being the leader has a lot of responsibility....well exo mvs have multiple meaning every single time...so cant say if it is definately this or not

Suggestions for EXO day: •EXO→Dancing King MV •EXO→Lightsaber MV (Star Wars Collab. Project) •EXO-CBX→Hey Mama! MV •EXO-CBX→ The One MV (This is so funny) •EXO-CBX→Blooming Day MV •EXO-CBX→Horololo MV •EXO-CBX→For You MV (Moon Lovers OST) •EXO-SC→What a life MV •EXO-SC→1Billion Views MV •EXO-SC→Telephone MV •Chanyeol X Sehun→ We Young MV •BAEKHYUN→Un Village MV •BAEKHYUN→Candy MV •BAEKHYUN→Young MV •CHEN→Beautiful Goodbye MV •CHEN→Shall We MV •SUHO→Let's Love MV •SUHO→Dinner MV •D.O.→Tell Me What is Love MV •D.O.→That's okay MV •Chanyeol→Stay With Me (feat. Punch) MV •Chanyeol→Nothin MV •XIUMIN→You MV •XIUMIN→Shake kzfaq.info/get/bejne/o72Gq82k3qzQoaM.html •Sehun→On me MV •Sehun→Go •KAI→I see you •KAI→Confession •Lay→Lit MV •Lay→Honey •Lay→Sheep (Alan Walker Relift) •Lay→Lose control *Live Stages* •Unfair - kzfaq.info/get/bejne/rdJmfqSQ1L7GdIU.html •The Eve •Growl + Power | Winter Olympics 2018 •El Dorado •MAMA 2015 Lightsaber + Drop That •Promise (with English sub) •EXO'rDIUM in Seoul Acoustic Medley kzfaq.info/get/bejne/mqiohdR9tOCpeWw.html •EXO'rDIUM Wolf Remix *Funny Videos* •"exo isn't funny"? then explain this: → kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fMh1pcKTmJvXnn0.html •exo sharing One braincell because we are one → kzfaq.info/get/bejne/qJh7hdhesNLLqmg.html •how to be done with exo by do kyungsoo → kzfaq.info/get/bejne/jbKnqpmelZzGaX0.html •All exo members are done with Baekhyun → kzfaq.info/get/bejne/qdKDkq9839-YimQ.html •EXO moments I think about a lot → kzfaq.info/get/bejne/hqiJa8x61d6pZWg.html

It goes like this: vers - D.O, Chanyeol, Baekhyun, Suho Chorus - Chen, Xiumin, Sehun vers - Kai + Suho, Lay Chorus - Baekhyun, D.O, Suho vers- Chen, Chanyeol, Xiumin Chorus - D.O, Chen, Baekhyun

Chanyeol covered 'Creep' by Radiohead and 'All of me' by John Legend, and he plays guitar, and piano. He can also play drums..he's unreal. Oh and he's an actor, like many other EXO members.

wow you noticed Kyungsoo's voice .. the reason is because during my few months as fan I always find Kyungsoo and Baekhyun's voices almost the same ..

All 9 members sang in this song. And yes, you got it right! The first "The way you cryyyy, the way you smiiiiiiile" was sung by Chen, the middle part was Baek and the last one was D.O. 😂 Congrats!

ARMY that ❤s and respects EXO!!! Chen my favorite Kpop vocalist and Kai my all-time favorite dancer!!!

when you heard KAI singing and went "who's that? WHO'S THAT?" wow king's vocals really are underrated. hopefully soon people will recognize his voice too.

I honestly enjoy your exo reactions more and more every week, they're like an absolute highlight of my week now...

That (3:22 - 3:33) is Kai

When he thought the vocals are just only coming from ChenBaekSoo when in fact all members have parts in it and that 'Who's that?!' On Kai's part, I feel very proud. I indeed stan a very talented group. Anyway, it's just a bummer that you haven't reacted to EXO's concert and live stages yet. EXO's lives are EXO's comfort zone. They are unworldly on stage.

(Timing from your video) 1st Verse -> 1:03 D.O / 1:16 Chanyeol / 1:29 Baekhyun / 1:42 Suho Chorus -> 1:54 Chen / 3:03 Xiumin / 3:16 Sehun 2nd Verse -> 3:22 Kai / 3:35 Lay Chorus -> 3:47 Baekhyun / 4:47 D.O / 5:00 Suho 3rd Verse -> 5:30 Chen / 5:42 Chanyeol / 5:50 Xiumin Chorus -> 5:59 D.O / 8:09 Chen / 8:25 Baekhyun

5:48 Chanyeol

(I cannot. This track made me feel like crying and something tugging at my heart. Beautiful and vulnerable) The lyrics of EXO’s winter ballad, “Sing For You,” describes someone who has regrets towards the person that they love and expresses the desire to sing a confession song for that person. But the music video, an entirely black and white production, initially shows EXO’s members enjoying their winter days and then hints to the darker feelings that people repress under their surface. The music video depicts literal loneliness, anger, and misunderstanding through the actions of EXO’s members, some fighting, some disappearing etc. And Sehun explores space as a lonely astronaut who meets a solitary, 52-hertz whale. This isn’t a case of possibly misunderstanding the music video plot; the 52-hertz whale is a symbol of loneliness and the wintery scenes likely hint to depression, particularly seasonal depression, a condition that affects millions of people. The video ends with EXO’s members coming together and Sehun befriending the whale, showing that loneliness can be beaten with the help of others. EXO have offered inspiration in the face of estrangement (EXO- Find others who understand you), and that’s all good and dandy but there is something deeper behind these two songs than just the normal K-pop/hip hop ballads. South Korea, the country that makes bubble-gum K-pop for all of us to enjoy, is one of the most depressed countries in the world. It has the highest suicide rate by country, with 24.7 people out of 100,000 committing suicide each year according to the Washington Post. According to the OECD Better Life Index, South Korea has the lowest ranking community support in the world, with only 72% of South Koreans feeling that they have people to turn to in times of need. Additionally, South Korea’s work-to-life ratio is lower than that of many other countries. By offering up inspirational tracks in the dark of the winter, EXO offer their own sort of 52-hertz whale to their fans. “Sing For You” feature aspects of loneliness, offering understanding to K-pop fans, both Korean and otherwise, who need support in the lonely world. Because it breaks the illusion of what it means to be an idol, and EXO is arguably one of the most popular male K-pop idol group in the world today, depression has been taboo to the group (despite former members leaving and others visibly struggling through performances). But throughout the music video for “Sing For You,” EXO depicts the sort of inner turmoil that isn’t about the love-related lyrics of the song, and instead depict the struggles that go along with the world that they (and the rest of us) live in. “Sing For You” is the opposite of an upbeat anthem; the music video shows suffering and loneliness in a way that just doesn’t let viewers ignore it. The 52-hertz whale may be alone, but he’s also a symbol of hope, of resilience, when feeling alone. By bringing out their inner whales and depicting loneliness that is on par with that of the 52-hertz whale, EXO not only helps their audiences understand that each individual isn’t the only one struggling in this world with loneliness, but also helps people relate more to the very human K-pop artists.

I love these reactions because i discover more songs that i didn't know. Thank u!

exo vocals os always crazy but after this mv i was crying for their acting my heart was so heavy

All the members of EXO are singing in this song from D.O. , CHANYEOL, CHEN, XIUMIN, SUHO, BAEKHYUN, KAI, SEHUN & LAY they all sing >< check the ENG lyrics of the song to know who sing each part

All members..you have to check out live ver. Of this..Sehun may surprise you his vocal.. pls..we still waiting your reactions for their Live performances

Ma dude spent the whole reaction guessing whose voice.....oh man :(

I love Baekhyun's voice. Please react to his solo Candy.

I will confess to my girl with this song i like the lyrics

Kai for some reason is the I have Trust issues with Exo . Lol. Love your intro. Thanks for making my week and days better. I’ve been down today cause I just found out that my dog passed away from cancer . He was 11 years old. Once I got your notification u made me stop crying and made me happy once again. Thx again. #grownsquad

I just love your reactions

We all know what this song really means but we'll never open our scars again...

Can't wait for your EXO Live Stages reaction. You will love them more! They are amazing!

I LOVE THIS MV !!! and the song it always warm my heart🤍🐋🌌

He is in love with Kyungsoo, Jongdae and Baekhyun! Love it!

I'm so proud of you , you recognize Chen, Baekhyun and D.O voice

PLEASE watch Chanyeol's "All of me" cover (playing piano as he sings) and "Stay with me" (Goblin OST) KCON Australia performance. 《 it's a duet with Seola. The original is with Punch. You will hear Chanyeols deep soulful voice and my god the feels. I cry everytime for stay with me 😭 if you have already watched the Goblin drama it will hit you with the feels even more. I was at the Aus KCON in person and i swear the chills the whole crowd got were unreal, i wasnt the only one crying either! It's simply beautiful, and as you have a V bias i imagine you will appreciate his voice.

1:00 sehun DO sang first, Then chanyeol, Then baekhyun,Then suho, chen during first chorus,then xiumin and sehun at the end Then Kai, then lay and then baekhyun at second chorus then DO. Then suho at the end. Then suho then chanyeol, xiumin then DO at last chorus then suho then baekhyun at the end

CANT WAIT FOR MORE EXO REACTIONS 🔥🔥🔥

It’s nice to be watch on live so that u know whose singing on its line

Im so happy seeing you a little bit hard to find who is singing. And your thought chen baek and d.o are singing. But in fact all of members are singing. Exo vocal is not joke bro! You know that😂😂 our main rapper chanyeol is lit in this mv. His vocal🔥

When youre friends have a gap each other ,have a deep impact to others i think thasts the message. i like sehun and chanyeol's voice

The lyrics are so beautiful :')

wow you are amazing. you noticed their voices.

Remember Suho and Chanyeol performed the fighting scene on stage lol

If you don't know who is singing please reaction to exo "sing for you" lyrics😍

The first time you asked "who's that?" it was Kai with Suho providing the background vocals, and the second time it was Chanyeol. I saw some comments listing out all the parts, but those were the ones you specifically asked out about 😊

They're all singing in this song...❤

wow i came early hehe..

Exo Day Bro, Also should be NiziU day too, both are fire

I've already listned to this but it's stil heatttt

All sing this song

Ooohh... you really should hear them sing this live. There are a few songs like this in EXO's catalog, where their vocals shine. They are all fire.

I love this song

Now I'm emotional

1:26 Our main rapper Park Chanyeol🥺

Es una canción cantada por todos los chicos de exo la forma en que armonizan wooo de verías verla cuando la cantan en vivo es excelente

I like your reaction! PLEASE DO MORE REACT TO EXO!

they all are sing for this song

6:32 you're right

Singing order in this song : DO, Chanyeol, Baekhyun, Suho, Chen, Xiumin, Sehun, Kai, Lay then back to Baekhyun and etc. “Who is that?” That's Kai. And then another “who is that?” 5.49 That's Chanyeol See, every member in EXO can sing beautifuly, I cry Here Sing For You live in Japan kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fNCjnt2Q0dCwm4k.html Next : For Life MV

can't wait for you to react the live stage performances and the concert

WE ARE ONE EXO SARANGHAJA

These Exo songs hits different

finally it's exo time! on this 6 Dec Xiumin will be back from military and next year D.O will comeback too 😍 tq for your reaction!

There are 2 theories about what the astronaut and the whale in space mean. Not sure which is accurate. One is about Alice, the loneliest whale in the world. Or the 52 Hertz whale. It's an unidentified whale species that communicates at 52 hertz, well above the communication frequency of any other whale species, so it can literally not communicate with other whales. Some people have theories about the astronaut as well, being related to an astronaut that was in space for 48 minutes and how it was the loneliest 48 minutes of his life. I don't know. The other theory is that the whale and astronaut scene symbolize the poem/children's story The Astronaut's Whale, about an astronaut named Augie, and Vincent the Whale, who were friends. Augie took Vincent to space and they had a lot of fun exploring, but Vincent eventually missed his family and his home, and he realized he didn't belong in space, they went back to their original lives. I honestly think the latter is the more accurate theory, but they both could be possible. Regardless, the theme is about being homesick, feeling lonely, and not belonging. Which could be meant to represent the members that left EXO.

I love Chanyeol's singing voice. He's so versatile. 🥰

at first D.O. then Chanyeol. after that, it's Baekhyun and Suho. the first reff, after Chen is Xiumin then Sehun. when you say "whO is That?" it's Kai then Lay. Yes, you right at early 2nd reff it's Baekhyun. then D.O. and Suho. after that, it's Chen and Chanyeol with his deep voice. Then Xiumin. And you right it's D.O. then Chen. at the end it's Baekhyun. They have a different voice colors from each other, and all of their voices are beautifull.

❤❤❤

All 9 members have lines in this song. Maybe check out the live version so you know who's singing every time :)

All the 9 members are in this song even the rappers and the dancers

My favourite sad song by exo lol

why don't you pay attention to the MV too? GOD!

I'm not crying at all

React to exo'rdium in japan white noise + thunder + playboy + artificial love 🙊💔💔

All EXO members can sing. . even the rappers line can sing.. I like EXO . I can recognize their voice even without looking whoever sings..

this is a song that every EXO-Ls can understand :((

Haha I’m laughing while you’re guessing who’s who. You’re really fun to watch, and I can see you really want to learn even small details of the group. You should start to watch their live stages to know them more. Some of the live stages they have are good to upload here in youtube.

🔥

This is really meaningful mv ) and sad mv

😂❤

I always cry when I listen to this song. because the scene Suho and Chanyeol fight.

Dude, i think you need to react to exo's amazing vocal

EXO Tempo🔥🙏

See this song live in jaban , you'll understand

Bro you can refer the colour coded videos for verification n stuff and also u could read the lyrics. Lyrics are thr best part of EXO

Maybe you should also check out the color coded lyrics. Just to see the translation and it's better see their faces as they sing their parts. But good reaction was always ❤️❤️❤️

Please watch this group too (SuperM is a supergroup formed in 2019 by SM Entertainment and Capitol Music Group. The group consists of seven members from four SM Entertainment boy groups: Taemin from Shinee, Baekhyun and Kai from Exo, Taeyong and Mark from NCT 127 and Ten and Lucas from WayV On October 4, 2019, the group debuted with their self-titled EP, which entered the Billboard 200 at number one, making SuperM the first Asian artist in history to top the US album chart with a debut release. Their debut single, "Jopping", is among Billboard’s Critics' picks of "25 Best K-pop Songs" of the year.)

You got the order right in the chorus! First was Chen, second was Baekhyun, third was DO. Very generally, Chen uses more vibrato than the other two, and DO the least. If there are high notes it’s usually Chen, unless Baekhyun‘s going off. Don’t worry, you’re doing really well, you’ll get this! To me the themes are loneliness and companionship, anger and love, sadness and joy. I don’t think the song is about the EXO members, these are things we all feel at different times in our lives. I’m just glad Sehun and the space whale found each other.

If you're confused who sang each lines, try watching I Sing For You color coded lyrics. Way better.

KAI SOLO IS TOMORROW IM EXCITED!!! IF YOU GONNA REACT TO IT MAKE SURE TO REACT TO “FILM:KAI” (which was the teaser of all the songs in the album). THAT WAS MASTERPIECE

Kai Solo Album on November 30💎💫💝

7:53 that was d.o

Great reaction you had some right.. you should watch a live or a lyric video you will be surprised everyone sings.

You must see the vocal line of this song at you tube......please see

Poem: THE ASTRONAUT’S WHALE

im pretty sure someone already told u who is it one by one but i just wanna say that they are all singing here :)

reaction to exo best live vocals 2020

Next must be *EXO "Dancing king"* pllllz, Sorry for my English but number of views didn't mean that the mv it's a minor song, there is EXO's mvs with less than 20 or 30 millions views but are better than others with more than 400 millions views !!!

All membres of exo are vocalists also the rappers

Please reaction to exo "for life" MV, exo for life live performence and D.O for life cover in english