Top Gear BMW 535d (vs 545i)

  Рет қаралды 1,832,009

Bmw Fan Lithuania

Bmw Fan Lithuania

15 жыл бұрын

Top Gear

Пікірлер: 848
@xiDaban78
@xiDaban78 11 жыл бұрын
I own the 545i estate and its just an amazing car!The speed the engine the power the sound and its ability to pulverize other cars while looking like an old mans estate, its all fantastic.Never gonna sell it!
@rexroth1199
@rexroth1199 2 жыл бұрын
did u sell it ?
@WEEWEE_GUY
@WEEWEE_GUY Жыл бұрын
Are you still alive bruh? I have one now!! Follow me on insta !
@messiforeverinbarcelona9169
@messiforeverinbarcelona9169 10 жыл бұрын
well 240p, we meet us again
@Cellsolid
@Cellsolid 12 жыл бұрын
I've driven the latest 520d, and it's just amazing - effortless acceleration in any gear. I can't begin to imagine what the M550d would feel like...
@RushBuzzing
@RushBuzzing 11 жыл бұрын
That he was even able to keep sight of the 4.5 liter gas model, is astounding.
@knetterwauz010
@knetterwauz010 10 жыл бұрын
I had a 535d tuned and put some 520d badges on it. It could outrun a MB 500 cl and a Porsche Cayenne S
@aliouassini7738
@aliouassini7738 10 жыл бұрын
why would u wanna put a 520d badge on a 535d?
@HuhnK0t
@HuhnK0t 10 жыл бұрын
Ali Ouassini it's like putting an 1.4i Badge on a Supra.. It's for Special Effect purposes when someone behind you is getting itchy..
@knetterwauz010
@knetterwauz010 10 жыл бұрын
Ali Ouassini Why not? There's nothing more fun then underestimation, the underdog that wins. I had so much fun when the driver of that Mercedes CL 500 couldn't keep up with me and read the words 520d on the back. In his mind he got humilliated by a 4 cilinder diesel. The only difference is the single or double tailpipe on the muffler...
@knetterwauz010
@knetterwauz010 10 жыл бұрын
HuhnK0t Technically the Supra never had a 1.4 so never would one believe that but I got smoked one time by a guy who put a supra engine in a 80's RWD Toyota Corrola. I love sleeper cars.
@knetterwauz010
@knetterwauz010 10 жыл бұрын
Mohammed Janjua The car was stock, full M package in and outside. Only the ECU was tuned by an official BMW dealer with full factory warranty.
@viveklego
@viveklego 10 жыл бұрын
to be fair to the diesel, the track was incredibly wet, which results in torquier vehicles losing traction
@deoneanonly
@deoneanonly 10 жыл бұрын
2006 535d msport 2006, driving it five years now and still amazed by the power and beauty. true love!
@fallenange11
@fallenange11 14 жыл бұрын
I've had a 545i for abt 4years, and I still can't get enough of it. Effortless overtaking power , sheer luxury
@Mortalomena
@Mortalomena 9 жыл бұрын
No LSD god damn what are they thinking at BMW :D should be standard in any rwd
@hazzaknox1069
@hazzaknox1069 4 жыл бұрын
I believe it was an option
@reginaldbowls7180
@reginaldbowls7180 3 жыл бұрын
@@hazzaknox1069 nope
@ouroesa
@ouroesa 3 жыл бұрын
I have the 540i with M sports pack. Goddamn diff is useless, really could have used the LSD, esp at the price they sold for. You cant put down power when its anything but perfect good, dry tarmac AND you are going in a straight line. Power slides are also really difficult as you have to completely break traction of both rear wheels before it'll allow you to have fun - but just for a tiny bit of time.
@TerminatorTX11
@TerminatorTX11 10 жыл бұрын
Haha a heavy diesel saloon car is faster the a Nissan 350z, just showa how amazing german engineeing is
@FiredEmpire
@FiredEmpire 10 жыл бұрын
faster? the time was the same. idiots like you praising german engineering hurt the reputation of german engineering.
@TerminatorTX11
@TerminatorTX11 10 жыл бұрын
um yea that makes alot of sense, buthurt nisan fanboy
@FiredEmpire
@FiredEmpire 10 жыл бұрын
IIP Velocity butthurt nissan fanboy? I'm just a normal person who has no difficulties reading numbers, unlike you. good luck with your special school and the sudden shitting in your pants.
@TerminatorTX11
@TerminatorTX11 10 жыл бұрын
FiredEmpire Yea, great comeback took you long enough 4 months? lol!
@k3kboi665
@k3kboi665 3 жыл бұрын
Just at the cost of bmw heresy.
@eoghanhennessy15
@eoghanhennessy15 9 жыл бұрын
shouldn't they compare the noise to the 535i ?
@pbsmick
@pbsmick 10 жыл бұрын
Gotta love 240p videos :)
@StaK_1980
@StaK_1980 10 жыл бұрын
Fluffy kittens ... I've lost it there :)
@bilalahmed2123
@bilalahmed2123 9 жыл бұрын
Should have compared it against the 535i not the big v8 !
@lewis72
@lewis72 9 жыл бұрын
Bilal Ahmed Why, because the numbers are the same?
@lewis72
@lewis72 9 жыл бұрын
Bilal Ahmed ...they didn't make the 535i until 2007, these cars are 2004 registered.
@bilalahmed2123
@bilalahmed2123 9 жыл бұрын
Oh' but still comparing a inline 6 diesel to a v8 isn't right !
@lewis72
@lewis72 9 жыл бұрын
Bilal Ahmed Why isn't it? If they cost the same,why can't they be compared?
@b.sh.1941
@b.sh.1941 9 жыл бұрын
Bilal Ahmed Of course it can. I6 turbo diesel versus N/A V8. Diesel makes more torque, why shouldn't you compare then?
@hammer082
@hammer082 14 жыл бұрын
anyone else here not only seeing the car here, ... but the pictural masterpiece it is presented in??? 0:52 is just beautiful, with the song of hybrid in the background! The kittens :D and pictures like at 3:21 are just astonishing!!!
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 9 жыл бұрын
Back then, Clarkson was so terrified of diesel advancement, that he could only bring himself to pit a petrol engine of 50% larger capacity against the diesel, because he knew an equivalent capacity 3 litre naturally aspirated petrol would be blown away. That's all BMW were claiming. Like for like, against their own 3 litre petrol. That's what equivalent means, Jeremy.. 272 bhp cannot outperform 333 bhp in an identical car, no matter how much torque is produced. Torque is the strength of an engine, but power is the amount of work done per minute. The 4.5 petrol cannot equal the 3 litre diesel's torque anywhere in its rev range, but can more than compensate in power because of its much higher rev ceiling. This 'test' would be equally ridiculous if he had pitted a naturally aspirated 2 litre petrol 5 series against the 3 litre diesel. As for his damning by faint praise on the accelleration & top speed, - both would have been identical to a petrol engine of the same HP. The torque of the diesel is irrelevant so far as accelleration & top speed is concerned. Since the diesel only revs to some 2/3rds of the power revs of an equivalent petrol engine, it therefore requires 50% more torque @ 4000 than the petrol makes @ 6000 to make the same HP. All the torque really means, is that the diesel can pull much taller gearing & make the same HP as an equivalent 3 litre petrol, which will require an additional 2000 rpm throughout its entire rpm range to achieve the same. Clarkson, being an idiot, associates high revs with accelleration, when it is HP alone which gives accelleration & top speed. Torque only determines where in the rev range that power peak will occur. Which is why 1 litre motorcycle engines need 13,000 rpm to make 200 bhp, & a good 2 litre turbodiesel can make that figure at 4,000. Clarkson is dismissive of a diesel's 4000 rpm power ceiling, - but last time I looked, 0-60 in 6 seconds is still 6 seconds isn't it? Regardless of what the revs are doing.. Maybe he has just breathed in too many carbon monoxide fumes & lost too many brain cells...
@bicepius
@bicepius 9 жыл бұрын
I love the massive torque from these modern turbo diesels but you cant deny they are laughably unreliable.
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 9 жыл бұрын
Pickled Onion Which aspect? Perhaps you refer to modern emission systems to meet arbitrary targets? The diesel engine itself is inherently extremely robust & reliable, & with regular oil & filter changes can rack up gigantic mileages.
@bicepius
@bicepius 9 жыл бұрын
hiyadroogs Yes if they had lower pressure turbos and no silly emission controls they would not break down as much and would be more like the old merc e300d engines. But the trouble is car manufacturers now seem to be pushing for more power and more economy for a cheaper price so it looks better on paper.
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 9 жыл бұрын
Sergiu Orzac Hi Sergiu. 'Satan's fuel'?? I understand your other points, but must clarify mine. You are correct of course about diesel torque superiority only being available because of the turbocharger. The turbo is absolutely essential in diesel road vehicles if hp per litre parity with N/A petrols is required. Rudolf Diesel's goal was to achieve superior thermal efficiency to the SI (spark ignition) engine in theory & in practice. Equal power per litre was never an objective. - Nor because of pumping losses due to the extremely high compression, or the slow burning nature of the fuel (originally coal dust!) could it ever have been achieved. In other words, a well designed turbo diesel of identical capacity, can be made to achieve similar or even greater horsepower than a naturally aspirated petrol of modest rpm ceiling, - but simultaneously achieve considerably better mpg while doing so, due to the greater thermal efficiency. Which is the sole point of diesels in cars; Same performance, better economy. Obviously a turbo charged petrol has the potential to produce superior horsepower, because the petrol always has available at least 2000 extra rpm in which to achieve it. Also, the torque peak in petrols can be engineered to arrive wherever you want it, within reason, which favours power at high revs. Whereas the peak torque in diesels can sometimes be extended to 3000, but generally falls steeply after that. It is far easier technically & in terms of physics to gain more power through revs than through torque. Since even high speed diesels in cars are pretty much limited to little more than 4000, the ONLY way to achieve greater power in diesels is through the production of greater torque, - which of course requires turbochargers. The volumetric efficiency of the diesel is actually far better than the petrol in terms of cylinder filling, even when naturally aspirated. This is because there is much less impedence to induction air, as diesels are unthrottled. In diesels, only the amount of fuel injected per cycle changes, the induction volume of air, when N/A, remains pretty constant per cycle at all revs. At idle, a diesel may operate at air/fuel ratios of over a 100:1, & even at full power revs, will never approach the stoichiometric ratios of the petrol. Perhaps richening up to 25:1. Stoichiometric ratios in diesels would produce thick acrid black smoke & burn the pistons out in minutes. I think you were referring to the greater volume of air the petrol engine can process due to high revs. & of course the more air & fuel that can be processed per minute, the more potential power can be produced. Which, again, is why diesels NEED turbo's to achieve parity. I wasn't trying to make the case that diesels could achieve equal power outputs with identically multi-turboed petrols. That much higher rev ceiling & faster burning fuel of the petrol is pretty unassailable. But within its limited rev range, the diesel is, in theory & practice, usually stronger & more efficient at all engine speeds below 3500 than turbo petrols. This is because the brake mean effective pressures during combustion in turbo diesels - exceeds that even of turbocharged petrols - up to approx 3000 plus. Which is why turbo diesels produce greater peak torque per litre, entirely free of the dangers of detonation that inhibit high boost pressures in SI engines.
@sorinturle4599
@sorinturle4599 9 жыл бұрын
hiyadroogs By definition, diesel engine required turbocharger to work optimal (non-Turbo diesel is pointles). Turbocharger brought not only performance to diesel engine, but also made it much more economical. Now, there is a perception, in principle may be correct, as would be pointless to directly compare a turbo-diesel with a non-turbo Petrol of same capacity (much less torque at much higher rpm). Usually this equivalent would be the TD engines capacity * Turbo pressure = the equivalent of N/A Petrol. Meaning something like, a 2 Liter TD * 1.2 bar (turbochargers pressure) = 2,4 Liter Petrol (non Turbo) is the engine to compare with. If the TD is twin-turbo, then the petrol equivalent should be higher. Perhaps a 4.5 liter petrol is a little too big for this comparison, but a 4.0 Liter (maybe even a 4.2) may be fair. For example, if the Audi 3.0 TDI is twin-turbo, then the 4.2 fsi may be the correct comparison. Anyway the 535d (the 3 Liter twin-turbo from BMW) was remarkable and no doubt would easily wipe a 3.6 Liter non-turbo petrol engine out and probably would still beat a 4.0 liter one. I think we should notice, the 535d may have been a Little in disadvantage in this situation (exactly because of the huge torque at low rpm) because of the wet track. It would have been interesting a test/race on dry. Also both are BMW, so premium cars, very suitable for family to. They are not meant for race (although they are very capable cars) but for long ways, journeys, many many miles per year. Now there is the question, which of them brings more advantages (reliability in time, economicity, comfort etc). Because those who want a car almost(or completely) sport oriented, perhaps would go for an evo (maybe the MR400 one), completely sacrificing the comfort and any economical principle. Now there is one more principle, saying a turbo-diesel (again, diesel works by default with turbo for optimal results) should be compare with N/A Petrol and the twin-turbo diesel with turbo-Petrol. The question would remain, what should we the twin-turbo petrol compare with?
@kibcubed
@kibcubed 14 жыл бұрын
Tuners can get the 535d to about 350hp, which for a 3.0L diesel is a gargantuan amount of power, but say that in stock condition the engine is relatively under-stressed. I wonder if, like the Porsche Cayman to the 911, the 535d was tuned below 300hp so as to not make the bigger petrol engines seem redundant.
@iantownsend5480
@iantownsend5480 10 жыл бұрын
My mate has bought a E60 535d 286 bhp, he's completely in love with it, it's bloody fast, but I've just bought a 320d F30 & I tell you what it's not that far behind even tho it's got 100 bhp less
@alanrad5
@alanrad5 10 жыл бұрын
2014 BMW F10 535d - 260k/h - only 4000 revs. What a great car. Add the M Sport package - looks fab.
@karlwest536
@karlwest536 10 жыл бұрын
my 535d has 258k/h at 3600 revs it´s a E60
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 11 жыл бұрын
A strong 2 litre turbodiesel can attain 115 bhp at as little as 2000 rpm, before adding another 50 bhp or more by the time 4000 arrives. A naturally aspirated 2 litre petrol will require 4000 + before 115 bhp arrives, & at 2000, will be doing very well to produce 55 bhp. This is why turbodiesels feel so much quicker until the equivalent capacity petrol is north of 5500. Only the very high revving high tune petrols can add 20 or 30 bhp at the very top end of their rev range by comparison.
@lewis72
@lewis72 12 жыл бұрын
Yes, it's called the flame front speed, which means the diesels won't rev beyond 5000rpm because the fuel doesn't burn quick enough to go any faster. The black smoke is from overfuelling on acceleration, IIRC.
@Upperclassgentlemen3
@Upperclassgentlemen3 14 жыл бұрын
i just upgraded my Bimmer from a 2009 328xi to a 2010 535i with sport package. I tell ya, this car is great. I cannot begin to tell you how much I love this car.
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 11 жыл бұрын
You missed my point, Mike. Petrols don't NEED turbo's for high performance. Obviously they improve performance dramatically, but a naturally aspirated petrol engine in high revving motorbikes can be made to make 200 bhp per litre even in road going form. A naturally aspirated diesel makes about 37 bhp per litre. Turbodiesels can have double the torque peak of a NA petrol, which gives superior accelleration in 3rd 4th 5th & top, but does NOT improve all out accelleration which is HP dependent.
@aracaen
@aracaen 14 жыл бұрын
the twin turbo trick is staging, i love the sarcasm clarkson uses there
@eskon12345
@eskon12345 12 жыл бұрын
If you haven't never tuned Diesel(Old) then you dont know how much fun they really are :) Im currently Driving 1989 Bmw 324Td with 238hp and 521Nm and well...Its fun car to drive :D good car to tease newer Diesel's
@Foxbat1155
@Foxbat1155 5 жыл бұрын
Aphex twin in a public tv show. This is top gear's greatest clip ever...
@silverblackss
@silverblackss 14 жыл бұрын
@Moxtrox There is- the 530i with 2 small turbos and delivers 302bhp (306PS) and 400Nm (about 390 torques).
@Area51UFOGynaecology
@Area51UFOGynaecology 14 жыл бұрын
535d, 535i 335, 335d, 135 are all 3,0, 545, 745, 645 are all 4,4, 750 is now a days a 4,4 twin turbo, all 1 series except 130/135 are 2,0. Mercedes 500 models are 5,5, just as their 600 models, the only difference is the number of cylinders v8/v12. The 350 s, sl, ml, and r are all a 3,7. And then there are the 180, 200, 230 whitch are all a superchargerd 1,8 if im not mistaken :P The conclusion is that the number has more to do with output than engine size :P
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 11 жыл бұрын
To illustrate the point about the relationship between torque & HP, we have the example of the 1 litre motorcycle engine producing 200 bhp @ 13,000 which requires 81 lbs/ft. Or at 75 lbs/ft per litre for a naturally aspirated petrol car engine, would require a 7 litre capacity to produce 200 bhp @ 2000. Or at 175 lbs/ft per litre, a 3 litre twin turbo diesel engine would produce 200 bhp @ 2000. In both the 7 litre petrol & 3 litre diesel, 200 bhp @ 2000 would require 524 lbs/ft.
@JeffreyOsb
@JeffreyOsb 15 жыл бұрын
The small/big turbo (twin turbo) solution has been around for a long time. Even the mid 90's Supra MK IV had the same type of twin turbo setup.
@stroggwars
@stroggwars 14 жыл бұрын
very nice drift race with very nice sound track
@KurNorock
@KurNorock 14 жыл бұрын
In the chevrolet Silverado HD pickup trucks the diesel option is 6.6 liters making 365hp and 660lbs/ft of torque. The equivelent sized gas option is 6.0L making 360hp but only 380lbs/ft of torque. The horse power is very close but the torque is no comparison. Also the gas engine will net you an average of about 10-12mpg while the diesel will average 18-24. So it is perfectly fair to compare small diesels to larger gasoline engines.
@TristanDesnos
@TristanDesnos 12 жыл бұрын
I've just bought a 335d m sport, which has this engine in. It's an absolute monster, though my missus can drive it tamely to work everyday and get around 50mpg! Even when i was booting it aroud yesterday i was getting 35mpg on average - incredible.
@545iAR
@545iAR 14 жыл бұрын
@strathpol There is no 535i in the range at the time. The whole point is to show a car that comes close to the 545i in terms of bhp but has a considerable amount more torque. Oil burner has around 270 bhp, V8 has 333 bhp, Oil burner has about 410 lbsft of torque, V8 has around 330 lbsft torque.
@Aristocrafied
@Aristocrafied 14 жыл бұрын
@raduandreyi probably in displacement but it hasnt got two turbos so the power equivilant is indeed the 545i probably in cost aswell cuz diesels cost more at least here in holland
@kibcubed
@kibcubed 14 жыл бұрын
@ShahnamPersia I think its "stroboscopic effect". Your brain can process see so many frames a second, even if your eyes are catching all the light from what you're seeing. In the right lighting, angle or speed, the wheel would thus appear still because you're only getting image of the wheel in one position. This is how tire companies find cracks on wheels. If the wheel speeds up or slows down, you'd see images in different positions, giving the illusion of backward rotation.
@TheShmakser
@TheShmakser 12 жыл бұрын
@lilincetooo It is actually: The 535d's 3.0l straight 6 has two turbochargers whereas the 545i's 4.5l V8 has none. So it's pretty equal I think.
@wino0000006
@wino0000006 11 жыл бұрын
Torque is nothing more than force multiplied by lenght of an arm. Usualy in engines the lenght of piston connected to crankshaft is similar, so it is force produced from blast in the cylinder that makes matter. All I'm saying is that petrol engines pushes the crankshaft twice the time of diesel engine which is essential to understand the difference between petrol engine and diesel engine.
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 11 жыл бұрын
Cont.. Regardless of how much torque an engine develops, all out accelleration rate is determined by the peak horsepower figure, (weight being equal of course) - since HP is the rate of energy developed. The torque figure, simply determines how early or late in the rev range the peak HP will arrive. In diesel cars, to have 75% of the power arrive by 2000 rpm makes progress effortless. in racing, you want torque peak to arrive very high up the revs, as it increases HP massively.
@InitialDAmine
@InitialDAmine 14 жыл бұрын
@kibcubed Pushed yes it is for a stock car, you have to remember that a stock have to respect a realiability aspect in which tuners doesn't count as much of a factor as the car maker. The diesel engine doesn't have a image performance problem at least in France and germany and you have to understand that diesel engine are way more advanced than petrol ones, but there are stuff that no matter what you do you can't change about diesel
@pascalmpower7944
@pascalmpower7944 9 жыл бұрын
and now they uses variable turbo which is lot more brilliant than a different size tri-turbo
@bodybuildingABC
@bodybuildingABC 5 жыл бұрын
a 1.9tdi b5 passat got a variable turbo if im not mistaken and its older than the e60!!:D i love old passats they are brilliant cars lol:D
@InitialDAmine
@InitialDAmine 14 жыл бұрын
@kibcubed no not really, the single turbine 3L engine developes 240hp adding a small turbo for low revs, the power increase is 270sh seems to me more than correct especially knowing that the 3L single is kinda pushed
@BlueHopi144
@BlueHopi144 11 жыл бұрын
It's on the album " Insides " ...best album ever for that great live band. U can buy it with closed eyes because it's one of the best techno/art album of all times . I have it since 2006 and i will never sell it . Cheers
@NachoAItz
@NachoAItz 13 жыл бұрын
@xRAMxDOD it's straight 6, a inline 6 was used and still is used in Le Mans racing cars producing up to 800bhp
@DICsquared
@DICsquared 10 жыл бұрын
I got a 335d, perfect car!
@chadwick828
@chadwick828 11 жыл бұрын
I'm pretty sure half the people commenting have never even driven the 535D. It's the lumps of torque that make it fun to drive compared to any petrol variant.
@JeroMusicLT
@JeroMusicLT 9 жыл бұрын
The best and the most realiable diesel engine ever made.
@KurNorock
@KurNorock 14 жыл бұрын
No it doesn't. It may prouce slightly more particulates, but those do not stay in the atmosphere and cause no harm when they fall to the ground. Gasoline (petrol) exhaust actually has more of the stuff that is harmful, Benzene, nitrogen dioxide, etc...
@-GA-MancsFinest
@-GA-MancsFinest 11 жыл бұрын
e60 545 is 328hp ,e60 535d is 270hp ,the diesel has over 500nm torque but torque alone isnt enough ,the new m550d is the same engine as 530d just it has 3 turbos in stead of 2 like this one,i own the 530d its not bad,heavy robust and quiet fast
@Gazpacho8
@Gazpacho8 11 жыл бұрын
I like how they made it seem like a huge deal and a great leap forward in tech only available in a fancy bimmer but we have had the same thing for quite some time in well... The international school buses have the same set up. lol Source: I'm a mechanic at an IH dealer.
@wino0000006
@wino0000006 11 жыл бұрын
Im talking about engine power and torque before it reaches gearbox - which of course can reduce speed and increase torque or quite opposite.
@ccx806
@ccx806 12 жыл бұрын
"It doesn't matter whether you win by an inch or a mile. Winning is winning"
@111danish111
@111danish111 10 жыл бұрын
i bet it would be faster than the 535i gasoline .
@tomo9992
@tomo9992 10 жыл бұрын
the 535i isnt turbo though
@juandef4115
@juandef4115 10 жыл бұрын
x Jaffa Cake you have to have turbo with modern diesels though
@andylie7699
@andylie7699 10 жыл бұрын
The 535i e60 has twin turbo..
@greg197107
@greg197107 10 жыл бұрын
for sure comparing v8 to v6 is not really good comparison, I am sure gasoline v6 would be a bit faster as well but not as much as v8
@mariusobreja4530
@mariusobreja4530 10 жыл бұрын
Grzes Greg What V6 ? BMW doesn't produce V6 engines, just L6.
@FeintMotion
@FeintMotion 12 жыл бұрын
Having racing slicks helps a fair bit, too. A good driver is only going to lose 3% or less to a great driver and a great driver even less to the Schumachers and the like in equal equipment.
@Super69Hotstuff
@Super69Hotstuff 12 жыл бұрын
@ihmesekoilua It's actually alot more than half as loud, as for every 3 db louder, it is twice as loud, therefore the petrol is 2.33 times louder than the diesel.
@NOSIRROMxMIJ
@NOSIRROMxMIJ 11 жыл бұрын
Orbital? The song is called We Have Arrived off of the Aphex Classics album.
@Amazetbm
@Amazetbm 14 жыл бұрын
@jxvwp Diesel cars and fuel are sold at a higher price as gasoline. But the diesel does make up in lower cost per mile.
@wes276
@wes276 11 жыл бұрын
the diesel was definitely at a disadvantage in the rain lol with clarkson driving it and the stig driving the petrol version. all that torque is not exactly fun to toss through corners...lol i think if the stig was driving the diesel and it wasn't raining it would be a different result. and clarkson wasn't that far behind either
@shaggz20022002
@shaggz20022002 11 жыл бұрын
very true, the RX rotors had the RPM range to make use of them
@elementaladmin123
@elementaladmin123 15 жыл бұрын
the only reason that the 535d was slower than the 545i is because the track was wet and since it had more torque you slip more if you give it to much power but your slower if you dot give enough power. not to mention it has the turbo kicks as well and i know jeremy said there was no turbo lag there is the kick you get when they kick in
@tiagogoncalves7248
@tiagogoncalves7248 13 жыл бұрын
@superdooperroofer dont need to look. if you listen well, in the noise test 4:07 he says that the v8 (545) does 70 db, and the 535d 66, and when they go for the race, when he is going out of the 535 5:01 he refer the v8 4.4l, so no doubt about that.
@jonathanedwards8913
@jonathanedwards8913 11 жыл бұрын
Twise the torque after going through a reduction gearbox, yes but thats not whats being specified, they are specifying the ENGINE torque. But the torque drop-off of a diesel at 6000rpm is not half therefor if you where to apply the same logic and put the diesel through a reducing gearbox at 6000 rpm it would still be more.
@kibcubed
@kibcubed 14 жыл бұрын
@kibcubed Sorry, corrections: "your brain can process seeing only so many..." and "this is how tire companies find cracks or defects in tires".
@Romerco77
@Romerco77 10 жыл бұрын
Not bad, a 4.4 being driven by The Stig, vs a 3.0 being driven by Clarkson. Overall 535d is better.
@InBoostWeTrust7MGTE
@InBoostWeTrust7MGTE 10 жыл бұрын
that just shows how actually clarcson is a good driver.
@vizzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
@vizzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz 10 жыл бұрын
InBoostWeTrust7MGTE why??
@InBoostWeTrust7MGTE
@InBoostWeTrust7MGTE 10 жыл бұрын
VTECB18 thre is no question WHY.. he IS
@vizzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
@vizzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz 10 жыл бұрын
InBoostWeTrust7MGTE maybe if they dropped a 7mgte in there jeremy clarkson might have won.
@InBoostWeTrust7MGTE
@InBoostWeTrust7MGTE 10 жыл бұрын
VTECB18 haha maybe but i think clarkson in built B18B lightweight civic would just ate stig for a dinner :D
@fargoth7
@fargoth7 14 жыл бұрын
BMWs are wonderful to drive and beautiful to look at
@aliouassini7738
@aliouassini7738 10 жыл бұрын
335d bmw should be faster cuz it's lighter and got same power if not more.
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 11 жыл бұрын
Petrols don't require turbo's for performance. Diesels do. At the time of this test, the 545i developed 325 bhp to the 535d 268 bhp. 57 bhp in the same model car is a very significant difference. The 3L petrol of the time produced the same 268 bhp of the TT diesel, & the 535i TT petrol produced 302 bhp. So a comparison with either of the 3 litre petrols would at least have been evenly balanced. But then, no one expects objectivity from the Top Gear team!
@aaaaaaaaaaaa38
@aaaaaaaaaaaa38 12 жыл бұрын
You can't push a diesel over a given point, because the fuel doesn't burn properly, and you get some problems with the oil. That's why so much diesel cars makes black smoke when the drivers accelerating... So much expensive manutention costs.
@Amazetbm
@Amazetbm 14 жыл бұрын
Which means your cost per mile is even lower. Unfortunately for us in the U.S. the diesel is higher price at the pump giving people the wrong impression that it "costs more"...even though the cost per mile is still lower. Also the way our EPA measures emissions and our overly strict "emissions standards" keeps fuel efficient high torque diesel passenger cars in the niche market status. It's a damn shame that we fawn over hybrids when cars like the VW Polo get over 70mpg on a bad day.
@StratfordWingRider
@StratfordWingRider 13 жыл бұрын
The new diesels are just amazing. Who would have knew diesel would be so good? I'd have a common rail diesel today. Brilliant
@sreddy117
@sreddy117 13 жыл бұрын
@jasshands, the r8 was petrol but audi started development on the diesel r10 with a completely new sheet. IMHO, there are a lot of physical and mechanical similarities between the r8 and r10 tdi and audis dominance at le mans is far deeper than using a diesel powered car. you are correct about the fuel tank handicap but honestly that won't hold em back. I'm looking foreward to their new closed top prototype r18, closed top lmps look sexier to me
@TransporterEurope
@TransporterEurope 15 жыл бұрын
BMW makes very good cars.Ever. Thank you GOD for this amazing cars!
@tubejorrit
@tubejorrit 11 жыл бұрын
Yep in Europe the new Focus can be bought with a 1.0 turbo charged 3 cilinder engine. Makes 125hp
@Anzhausen
@Anzhausen 13 жыл бұрын
Until 19th of Dec, I owned a 2004 545i but it unfortunately had the cooling leak, N62 engines are known for. So I sold it and know a have a 2007 535d. The 545i is faster but can not leave the diesel significantly behind on a motorway. The 535d comsumes only 60% of the fuel the V8 takes. I like the diesel more, for me it has more advantages than the V8.Thats the test result - only looking on performance: take the V8,want the overall more advantageous car - take the 535d and accept no substitute.
@TheCompyshop
@TheCompyshop 11 жыл бұрын
Diesels need turbos though. The way gas and diesel engines work is way different. Without enough air the diesel doesn't burn properly.
@aljo0069
@aljo0069 14 жыл бұрын
the 35i engine hadn't been made by the time of this show. but i agree with you, they should have compared it to a v6 petrol
@dahorn100011
@dahorn100011 11 жыл бұрын
VW polo blue motion 1.4L 3 cyclinder , a hyundai diesel 1.5L 3 cylinder. Most small cars like the ford focus have 3 cylinders
@djrno2
@djrno2 12 жыл бұрын
@lilincetooo yeah but v6 has twin turbos while v8 is n/a + diesel has 80 more torque ...
@Ouwtlawzzz
@Ouwtlawzzz 15 жыл бұрын
they are cute but the small and the big turbo is a cuite good solution
@femopa88
@femopa88 12 жыл бұрын
the stig was drifting while clarkson wasn´t. very good car the diesel one
@peugeotCitroen2CV
@peugeotCitroen2CV 13 жыл бұрын
The comparison is against a turbo charged diesel and a naturally aspirated allbeit large petrol, if the petrol is given a turbo then it will have more power and more torque than the diesel. However the petrol motor is too sore on juice so only really good if you enjoy filling up, and the diesel is probably a more relaxed thing to drive on long distances. But even so bmw diesels just blow their turbos and give bother so a mercedes e320 cdi is the better choice for a big motorway cruiser.
@beermonster65
@beermonster65 14 жыл бұрын
There is no 535i in the UK only 530i or 545i. So for this test the 545i was the nearest equivalent, the test is just to show how far diesels have come.
@paddyc20
@paddyc20 9 жыл бұрын
jeremy. your knowledge in cars seems to be pretty poor in some areas. how is a 545i the equillivent engine to a 535d. 535d = 3.0 545i = 4.4 v8 or was it ye didnt want to put a 530i against the diesel because the diesel is far quicker?
@callumcurtis15
@callumcurtis15 9 жыл бұрын
paddyc20 and if you spend £100 on a remap it will be faster than the 4.4 v8.
@paddyc20
@paddyc20 9 жыл бұрын
Callum Curtis i know mate. what a wopper. me dad had a remapped 535d was boss. just stipid they way he slates diesels an trys to show tgere not as fast when he comparws it against somethin veey different. 530i is good comparison.an it would smoke them.
@prshntydv14
@prshntydv14 8 жыл бұрын
paddyc20 these 3 litre 6 cylinder germans are really fast and economical. My cousin has a E350 CDI and after a remap it is pushing close to 700nm torque's! And the E350 Diesel is more refined than the petrol car.
@paddyc20
@paddyc20 8 жыл бұрын
+Prashant Yadav diesel are excellent mate
@AlexanderPews
@AlexanderPews 6 жыл бұрын
Why do people always have to find something to bitch about xD
@InitialDAmine
@InitialDAmine 14 жыл бұрын
@kibcubed like engine response due to fuel composition, despite the use of the advanced technologies like commonrail, injector pomps valetronics.. a diesel won't be able to burn as fast petrol.....
@DoranAngelo
@DoranAngelo 15 жыл бұрын
I've own many of the cars you are talking about. I have an 06 330i right now and love it. People only put down BMW because of the price. If you can afford it, or if all cars cost the sane then it would be no competition. Hav
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 11 жыл бұрын
In your scenario of a diesel achieving max torque @ 3000, while the petrol achieves max torque @ 6000, - if the diesel is making an identical torque figure @ 3000 that the petrol gets at 6000, then the petrol would be making twice the BHP. However, if the diesel achieves TWICE the torque @ 3000 of the petrol at 6000, then both engines are making IDENTICAL bhp.
@JDKindustries
@JDKindustries 11 жыл бұрын
It seems like every car in europe is fully spec'ed with options such as sat-nav and appearance package. Here in Canada, 1 out of 10 e60 has sat-nav.
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 11 жыл бұрын
To be honest, Mike, I've quite forgotten why we're arguing here. The characteristics of torque, & how it relates to power production when allied to revs, was my original point in reply to another commentor. I'm not advocating for petrols, just explaining that their characteristics & virtues are different. My last 6 cars have been diesels, so my personal choice is clear. I once achieved 105 mpg in a Citroen AX diesel over 250 miles down to Cornwall @ 50 mph, & no petrol's gonna match that! : )
@KabatDaniel
@KabatDaniel 12 жыл бұрын
Actually it did for the E60.. 535i, 3 liter straight 6 with 2 turbos and 306hp.. But if not with the 535 then it should at least have been the 530i with 272bhp.. About the same power output as the 535d.. The 545 has 333bhp and 450nm..
@diego750il
@diego750il 14 жыл бұрын
I have a 550i Premium and it is very very good when you drive it.
@RikiJasmin
@RikiJasmin 12 жыл бұрын
the problem is when this review was done there was no 535i. It came out late 2007 and only in the USA. Instead they could have matched with the 540i. It would be more fair.
@MadIIMike
@MadIIMike 11 жыл бұрын
Well, turbos boost the performance of a Petrol engine by quite some margin, maybe the best examples were the Ford Sierra with Turbo as they dominated the DTM in the 80s. They got weight penalty and still won so they got even more weight into the car to the point where the front suspension collapsed. Then they got banned. You only take the bhp, but a Diesel has far more torque. iirc, the Diesels in Le Mans have 3,7L while Petrols drive 5,5L and get left behind in the dust.
@Max1mum4444
@Max1mum4444 12 жыл бұрын
It's only 3.0L,but it has 2 turbos. That's the different between 530d and 535d :) and 545i is 4.4L. 545i has 333 hp and 535d has only 272 hp and between 2007-2010 it has 286 hp. But maximum torque of 535d is 560/2 000(Nm/RPM and 545i) and maximum torque of 545i is 449 Nm at 3600 rpm. I think diesel is better, but they should compare 535d and 535i with turbo. Maybe 535i with turbo would win, but it would be more fair.
@angelo4478
@angelo4478 9 жыл бұрын
Unfair test 535d has 272bhp. 545i has 333 bhp. If he used a bmw 535i (245bhp) he would have no chance.
@yigitmusaklc4649
@yigitmusaklc4649 9 жыл бұрын
e60 535i has 306hp, 530i 272hp, 535d 286hp
@fearless9292
@fearless9292 9 жыл бұрын
Yiğit Kılıç exactly, 535i Turbo Petrol, 530i without turbo 258hp or 272 facelift
@IztormI
@IztormI 9 жыл бұрын
Horsepower is how fast you can drive into a wall. Torque is how far you can drag the wall with you after impact.
@nyyra
@nyyra 10 жыл бұрын
3:07 priceless , gotta love jeremy (:
@hiyadroogs
@hiyadroogs 11 жыл бұрын
Cont. In the case of the very impressive 3.7 litre Le Mans diesels, (formerly 5.5 litres) the characteristics would be very different to a road car. These engines spend their life between 3500 & 5000 rpm, & so the turbo is sized to provide maximum boost & torque at those revs. The engine would have a big turbo lag at 2000, because the turbo is too large for low speed boost. 532 bhp is a fantastic output from a 3.7 diesel, but a 3 litre naturally aspirated F1 engine develops 750 bhp.
@kagolko
@kagolko 14 жыл бұрын
@faavil very very true. BMW's sometimes get broken, but su do Audis and Mercedeses. BMW's are just every boy dream. Unreal performance, styling, handling - everything.
@PedroMendes25CC
@PedroMendes25CC 12 жыл бұрын
I think the word "EPIC" would do......shame we cant have in the UK! Get a new Alphina D5 pretty much the same, but for the UK! And also the 530d is one of the best cars ive ever been in, best ever.
@fDerz7
@fDerz7 9 жыл бұрын
at that time when 535 was a 3,5l and the 545 was a 4,5l....
@danielcasu134
@danielcasu134 9 жыл бұрын
535d is 3.0l twin turbo. No 3.5l.
@NoWay23548
@NoWay23548 12 жыл бұрын
In the land of eternal rain it must be hard to do a car show that displays cars going around a track while timed..
Nissan GTR Car Review - Top Gear - BBC
9:30
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 13 МЛН
BMW M3 vs Mercedes C63 AMG vs Audi RS4 - Top Gear - BBC
9:37
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 12 МЛН
路飞太过分了,自己游泳。#海贼王#路飞
00:28
路飞与唐舞桐
Рет қаралды 43 МЛН
managed to catch #tiktok
00:16
Анастасия Тарасова
Рет қаралды 19 МЛН
This BMW 535d messes with supercars
3:16
Lars Mars Cars
Рет қаралды 2,1 МЛН
Porsche GT3 vs Ferrari 360 | Top Gear
9:53
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 4,9 МЛН
Audi R8 vs Porsche 911 Carrera - Top Gear - BBC
9:25
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
BMW 760Li vs Mercedes S63 AMG - Top Gear - BBC
7:12
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
Porsche Carrera GT Car Review - Top Gear - BBC
7:58
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
Hammond, May, Clarkson Making Fun of Countries Compilation #1
10:55
Mustang150
Рет қаралды 4,4 МЛН
The One Gallon Fuel Crisis Race - Top Gear - BBC
6:19
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
The Ugly BMW M5  | Top Gear - Part 1
4:46
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
Corvette ZR1 vs Audi R8 | Top Gear | BBC
8:00
Top Gear
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
Toyota Camry 80! Толық жетек! // QAZ Kolesa.kz
12:44
QAZ Kolesa KZ
Рет қаралды 110 М.
Он Супер Фанат Хот Вилс 😳😍
0:23
ДоброShorts
Рет қаралды 432 М.
Cute Mx5😍🤩 #JDM #mx5 #modifiedcarculture #car #modified #shorts
0:10
Kuangye Feichi Pub
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
Механик «от бога»  создал автопропольщик
0:47
🌲ВЕНЁВ Питомник Растений
Рет қаралды 1 МЛН