Tory minister unhappy as Labour MP asks for legal advice on Israeli war crimes | Janta Ka Reporter
Рет қаралды 34,314
Ай бұрынLabour MP John McDonnell left Tory Minister Andrew Mitchell after he asked the Deputy Speaker to see if it was possible for the Speaker of the House of Commons to seek a legal advice on the UK government’s complicity in Israeli war crimes in Gaza.
McDonnell wanted the Speaker to seek the legal advice on behalf of all the MPs.
@guillaumefortina1209 Ай бұрын
The Deputy Speaker should also be investigated for complicity to genocide, by refusing to seek legal advice on behalf of the House of Commons.
@poplarboydavid Ай бұрын
Absolutely!!!
@jake751 Ай бұрын
Definitely
@lamueldagon7618 Ай бұрын
And being a member of the friends of Israel. The two alliegances are incompatible.
@fibanacci8 Ай бұрын
True..
@2gther4ever Ай бұрын
Nah, Hamas should be investigated especially the billionaires sitting in Doha.
@thembakhumalo-li7bl Ай бұрын
Did she deliberately misunderstand his question? She failed to answer a very simple question.
@bradcobb3418 Ай бұрын
she's thick as mince!
@poplarboydavid Ай бұрын
That speaker is a waste of space and obstructing a legitimate request from a member of the house - she is clearly avoiding to cooperate for fear it opens a can of worms causing the government difficulties!!! What a sham!!!
@emilymorton6510 Ай бұрын
Exactly
@jameslrbrand2002uk Ай бұрын
Pretty McDonnell is looking for excuses on behalf of his friends in Hamas just like he used to for his friends in the IRA.
@Roberta-gl2by Ай бұрын
Absolutely. It's quite apparent none of the current speakers are capable of doing their job. Sooooo inarticulate. Ironic really, a speaker that can barely speak. And whenever I have seen any of them say anything it is always hesitant and non-commital and totally unhelpful. Regardless of what anyone thinks of Bercow, at least he commanded some respect.
@paulbattenbough1002 Ай бұрын
well expressed indeed! the supporters of Israel are obviously in defiance of the ICJ ruling. l suspect some legal caveat has been found to squirm around for the time being.. more lies and side-stepping. Once this is over we'll see all the Friends of Israel in their true light as the true scale of the massacres are investigated. If we lived in a true democracy all diplomatic ties would be cut with those that commit genocide but these people are imperialist supremacists themselves. Parliament stinks, but good to see John McDonnell timidly have a go. the speaker seems incompetent.
@user-ln3lh2pz8h Ай бұрын
The Deputy Speaker is I think Labours Rosie .... She used to be a Minister in Blairs Govt.
@ChambersWineandTravel Ай бұрын
She’s clueless as to what the role of the parliament is in government.
@Nine-Signs Ай бұрын
Oh not at all my friend, she knows her job well as do all the officials and administrators, their job is to ensure nothing ever changes no matter the government at the time...
@tokenspirit6140 Ай бұрын
Much like the Prime Minister!
@JupiterThunder Ай бұрын
None.
@zainzoala1083 Ай бұрын
😂 why is she there
@fibanacci8 Ай бұрын
True..
@hypernorm4802 Ай бұрын
What an incoherent, incompetent, inarticulate “Speaker” 🫣
@emikili Ай бұрын
She literally referred to the ICJ as the ICG
@johnnyhall3942 Ай бұрын
She is poor.
@niallmccarthy1219 Ай бұрын
The ICG.....
@basfinnis Ай бұрын
Conservative Friend of Israel stands up and talks complete nonsense. Would be good to see most of the Houses of Parliament in court on charges of abetting genocide.
@esioanniannaho5939 Ай бұрын
Spot On totally Agree 💯 Shows up how limp and corrupted WM has become. SNP have also shown what a farce the place has become !
@Annabella24183 Ай бұрын
And the genocide on us
@L98fiero Ай бұрын
@@Annabella24183 If you are a Palestinian, absolutely, if you are a Z apologist, you should be ashamed.
@kwanchan6745 Ай бұрын
@@L98fieroshe is a typical zio...so self centred to be absolutely incoherent
@user-ln3lh2pz8h Ай бұрын
.... And so too are Labour friends of Israel complicit in the genocide. They are a disgrace to the Labour movement and internationalist.
@krism6260 Ай бұрын
Excellent question!!
@holaclive Ай бұрын
Worried about the consequences of supplying arms to Israel if genocide claims are proven
@JupiterThunder Ай бұрын
The only genocide was on October 7, 2023 - carried out by a proscribed terrorist organisation - Hamas - which lists genocide of the Jews as its primary objective in its founding charter.
@paulbattenbough1002 Ай бұрын
oh to see them all prosecuted ....but by who? the entire political system, and judiciary are corrupt, just ask Julian Assange.
@IJ72 Ай бұрын
War criminals! Nothing else
@joebrandreth9959 Ай бұрын
Who
@SuperEarther Ай бұрын
@@joebrandreth9959 the entire uk, their air fields have been used to arm israel since october
@IJ72 Ай бұрын
@@joebrandreth9959 first 2 names
@kikigermaney6365 Ай бұрын
@@SuperEarther AND !!!
@IJ72 Ай бұрын
@@kikigermaney6365 nazi supporting Anglo-saxon
@CockWomble1000 Ай бұрын
Genocide complicit
@MrVariak Ай бұрын
It was NOT a question, but a request. Please publicly post the legal advice given. This is not democracy it is actually autocracy.
@Foxy_ladyYTSL Ай бұрын
They’re all “ Friends of ...” and bought by them.
@paulcritcley5839 Ай бұрын
60 labour and about 80 tories are with the zionist lobby call it what you want but they are breaking the international icj rulling and should be held accoutable
@p0ssiblypossiblynot557 Ай бұрын
YOU ARE ALL COMPLICIT AND YOU KNOW IT
@karenslater3026 Ай бұрын
He has a very good point He wants to know the responsibility of each member very sensible
@sheilamashali6426 Ай бұрын
Shame on the government but not surprised and I hope Sunak etc will have to appear before the International Criminal Court for complicity in Genocide.
@ObjectiveMedia Ай бұрын
You actually think that the PM is in charge of the UK lol British people are so politically illiterate 😂
@Heathen.Deity. Ай бұрын
“The government operates under a rule of law”… coming from a Tory, I find that to be as laughable as any statement ever made by them.
@zawarshah508 Ай бұрын
War crimes need to be brought into the open. Any minister helping to commit war crimes needs to go to prison. Corrupt government
@puravidadew7031 Ай бұрын
Of course the government is corrupt, it’s a conservative government. All conservatives, for the most part are corrupt..
@MrsZambezi 19 күн бұрын
Are there any ministers assisting Hamas?
@zawarshah508 19 күн бұрын
@MrsZambezi Hamas and the Israeli government are both the same. They both kill innocent people. But sadly the Israeli government is carrying out a genocide. And they killed 3 British people. The uk government has to protect it's citizens.
@ujean56 Ай бұрын
Speaker translation - You want ME to do work? Not a chance. I get paid to yack a lot and deflect responsibilities on behalf of my party. Nya nya!
@jake751 Ай бұрын
Well said John Mcdonald 👏
@pgl0897 Ай бұрын
Or as he’s usually known… John McDonnell
@jayb9779 Ай бұрын
John Macdonald was clear in his request. The Speaker and Deputy are just talking shite
@markhilbert6573 Ай бұрын
You dont need advice. You already know you are
@kirkhunter146 Ай бұрын
They do need advice because that's how the game works.
@andrewmaccallum2367 Ай бұрын
That speaker of the house is even worse than Hoyle, ffs!!?
@kirkhunter146 Ай бұрын
Nope, Hoyle is the Speaker, that's Madam Deputy Speaker.
@andrewmaccallum2367 Ай бұрын
@@kirkhunter146 Do shut up troll
@andrewmaccallum2367 Ай бұрын
@@kirkhunter146 pedantic fud
@andrewmaccallum2367 Ай бұрын
@@kirkhunter146 pedantic fud
@andrewmaccallum2367 Ай бұрын
@@kirkhunter146 fud
@jr-cx1ve Ай бұрын
the whole planet knows its genocide.
@willemdehaan4103 Ай бұрын
No, not all of us, only you, ignoramus!
@rickyg7662 Ай бұрын
Just the liars actually.
@MrsZambezi 19 күн бұрын
@@rickyg7662 Liars think it's genocide when it isn't, and tout the guesswork of Hamas as evidence. Disgraceful. It's being on the side of criminals.
@SuperEarther Ай бұрын
how to prevent? they are already complicit in war crimes! are they that stupid?!
@bradcobb3418 Ай бұрын
@superearther No she's just simple and in over her head, he's a Tory stooge and clueless too, bring back Berkow and (bless her) Betty ❤
@SuperEarther Ай бұрын
@@bradcobb3418 correct, in this broken country it is not what you know it is who :(
@dangeross8050 Ай бұрын
such an obvious attempt by the speaker to deliberately misinterpret a very straight forward question. They're so corrupt
@johnbhoy2489 Ай бұрын
That deputy speaker is as useless as the speaker,both as useful as a chocolate fireguard
@RichardSpain-lz9cf Ай бұрын
WHO gives the legal advice to parliament,the Kray brothers ?
@Nine-Signs Ай бұрын
😂 😂
@spamme9021 Ай бұрын
To be fair, they used to look after their mum apparently so definitely have more moral fibre than any Tory
@DemonetisedZone Ай бұрын
They serve us We need to know if what our government is doing is legal so we need legal advice Our MPs are our representatives so it stands that THEY need legal advice as our representatives
@icenaz4471 Ай бұрын
Deputy speaker with respect is absolutely useless
@veronicachikosi3224 Ай бұрын
She is conflating issues, and not answering the question. ICG ? What is that . I guess she meant ICC. The question certainly made her very nervous 😅
@Jean-rg4sp Ай бұрын
*The woman knows as much as Mrs. Johnson on the N277 bus to Islington.*
@noelfleming3567 Ай бұрын
Did d speaker have a few gins fo breakfast sounds dodgy
@SuperEarther Ай бұрын
she said ic gee looooooool
@cgmahony Ай бұрын
What a great question. Respect John McDonnell from Ireland. 🙏🙏☘️🇵🇸
@cgmahony Ай бұрын
PS means that the emoj of Palestine flag has been removed. Why???
@Aronshmuli665 Ай бұрын
Great coverage, these war crimes have to stop and Israeli occupying force must be held accountable.
@colsmith7257 Ай бұрын
Damage control , humanity has reached a new low
@chrism415 Ай бұрын
Some appear to be possessed by demons. Have we become the nation of the forked tongue?
@terryroxburgh3276 Ай бұрын
We are one side of the fork. The US is the other.
@Nine-Signs Ай бұрын
Chair: "I would like to help you but if we publish highly unusual legal advice in this obviously every day event of arming and funding a genocide, then neither the government nor parliament overall would be able to continue to sufficiently muddy the waters regarding our complicity in that perfectly normal every day genocide"
@omerosdaskalos7708 Ай бұрын
Independent legal advice must be obtained urgently.
@sueyourself5413 Ай бұрын
The Speaker has been asked to give legal advice to all MPs. These people are 🐍s
@memeisticdan4135 Ай бұрын
The speakers ear piece must have been going into overdrive telling her not to do her job
@tonylowe6770 Ай бұрын
Fully agree with him. Anyone not a Conservative MP has no access to any of the governments legal advice over these arms sales, but face complicity with every vote.
@paulahayden6091 Ай бұрын
What this shows is that we are by ourselves on this. And now have no other option but to seek assistance in having ALL of our countries leaders held accountable for multiple breaches of not just international law but common law against the people and anyone who supports the current system needs to take off their rose coloured glasses and see it all for what it really is illegal!!!!!!
@paulfildes5489 Ай бұрын
Deputy Speaker Rosie Winterton, who is in the chair in Hoyle's absence, is also a member of Labour Friends of Israel.
@user-michael444 Ай бұрын
is it lawful, never mind legal.
@user-ln3lh2pz8h Ай бұрын
Members will not be complicit if they have declared their opposition to the Govt policy. It is only the Govt and it's ministers that could be complicit in the allegedge ocide. ODonnel knows that is the position Mitchell is a disgrace as are the Cabinet and ministers collectively.
@desmondquailey6476 Ай бұрын
Is she on the sauce😂😂😂
@samahdi6972 Ай бұрын
Their day Will come when held to account for war crimes.
@andystocks3252 Ай бұрын
Why Madam Deputy Speaker cannot just say ‘Yes, I will seek advice’…the question related to advice on the complicity of MPs not the legal advice the government takes on its action. Is the thing so difficult to understand or are the officials of the House too thick to understand the question! It feels that the latter might be the case!!
@davepb5798 Ай бұрын
Another disgusting show of ineptitude by the deputy speaker, scared to even challenge the government.
@davidcourt238 Ай бұрын
Um is not a word. Er is not a word.
@MrVidification Ай бұрын
American Heritage Dictionary, Biber et al Longman Gammer of Spoken and Written English, and the University of Nottingham's Carter and McCarthy book of English all list Um and Er
@mysticjoy2924 Ай бұрын
WAR CRIMINALS IS THE TERM FOR THEM ALL UFFFF 🤦
@mattgloyn3928 Ай бұрын
Ah um ah um um .
@eamonnwest244 Ай бұрын
Uh oh😂😂😂 complicit in war crimes😂😂
@Foxy_ladyYTSL Ай бұрын
100%
@philiptyson4000 Ай бұрын
A low point for parliament and valid point from john
@keithbarlow6596 Ай бұрын
How can inadequate people end up being Speaker or Deputy Speaker of the House. She doesn’t understand the question. She waffles an incomprehensible answer. And why does she keep waiving her arm around. Pathetic.
@Heshem_Joel Ай бұрын
Yesss.
@bmanagement4657 Ай бұрын
As an American, I can say we and the UK are on the wrong side of history. We are asking for divine retribution.
@user-fc1ik8ms2m Ай бұрын
She needs to go. This is shameful.
@pgl0897 Ай бұрын
Well done John. Solidarity.
@terrycastleman4037 Ай бұрын
STOP PAYING COUNCIL TAX AND BE ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE LAW
@ianwright389 Ай бұрын
Its like somebody let their nan in, she does not even seem to speak coherently, strawmans points raised, does not seem to understand the basic legal framework in place, she even got the name of the international court of justice wrong she called it the ICG, was she drinking beforehand, who gave this lady her job, I cant imagine she was very good in the interview going off this performance. Definitely a case of who you know rather than competance, knowledge or hard work!
@terryroxburgh3276 Ай бұрын
Eight times I have tried to post a comment here in various forms about the item shown. KZfaq is obviously against free speech even when the comments are truthful, none swearing and to the point. Censorship is rife here. EDIT: I notice this comment went up with no trouble as it is irrelevant.
@joelnogueira7692 Ай бұрын
Quite a few of mine have also vanished into thin air. All regarding the same matter.
@MomoBar91 Ай бұрын
And they are asking this now? They should have ask that at the very least after the ICJ ruling. And two weeks after the ruling the UN issued a warning that every country still sending weapons could be held accountable for supporting war crimes.
@ericp1139 Ай бұрын
Why did she seem so nervous? Everything is legal, right?
@niemrobiniemrobi8397 Ай бұрын
Ffs, why is the deputy speaker shilling for the government????.... Big up John Mcdonald for a simple but excellent question 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
@orvisboy8188 29 күн бұрын
What a pathetic Deputy Speaker.John McDonnell's request seems perfectly reasonable in the context of public debate about the legality or otherwise of Israeli tactics in Gaza. The Foreign Secretary should be answering pertinent questions in the Commons,not having a very soft life in the Lords.Utterly pathetic situation !!
@frankerbeznik5193 Ай бұрын
Imagine a world without Great Britian and its Balfour Declaration, Lord Rothchild, Chaim Wiseman, Theodor Hertzl, and Harry Truman. How many more people would be alive today except for them?
@edanguish5564 Ай бұрын
Question not answered.
@italgong Ай бұрын
She is totally out of her depth.
@abnewall Ай бұрын
‘Checks and Balances’, Madam Speaker; The Labour Minister is asking for guidance on the particular rules of law related to the specific situation; that being, the ICJ’s ruling that Israel may be heading towards a genocide of the Gaza population.
@nonenone-vt8cg Ай бұрын
An example of how convoluted bollocks can become in the games of parliamentary hide and seek.
@richardchurchward4413 Ай бұрын
Worryingly the Speaker appeared to he incapable of understanding the question, and in doing so acted as sentinel for the government.
@glenngilbert7389 29 күн бұрын
The Deputy Speaker is painful to listen to - clearly attempting to use her position to avoid the spirit of the question
@timothypye901 Ай бұрын
She don't know what she's doing!
@brianeke2586 Ай бұрын
Tell McDonald to sit down! He’s up to no good as always.
@johannafreeburn3061 Ай бұрын
i think the time has come for a housekeeping/book keeping audit on this house. ANY time i hear someone speak sense in there, they do so to a very scant audience. when there is a lot of 'nonsense' being debated, the benches are bulging. is it not time we had a 'clock in, clock out' system and their paychecks could be corrected accordingly.
@lissamae8719 Ай бұрын
Nice to see the House if Commons practically empty as usual they really are working hard for that 5% pay rise they have themselves.
@elainewilkes1937 Ай бұрын
The 1948 Geneva Code explicitly states that...anyone paying tax to a Government that is complicit in Genocide, ie supplying Weapons to the perpetrators, is required by Law to cease such payments or they to will be complicit and could be prosecuted.
@keglat1 Ай бұрын
Deputy Speaker can't even string a coherent sentence together. Em, uh, a, . No surprise she was not capable of comprehending the point of order.
@MJWPub Ай бұрын
Ask how it is Rishi Sunak can own Infosys who are supporting Israel's Unit 8200 who are identifying Hamas targets for IDF?
@nigelandrews5617 Ай бұрын
She seems clueless as to what her role is and answers with eh, em and long pauses between words, giving a totally disjointed and incoherent reply. Beyond a joke!
@gingerladyaubern Ай бұрын
Madam Deputy Speaker cannot make a decision....really says it all - Sat on the fence!
@ianmacdonald1956 Ай бұрын
Should he not be asking Tony Blair 🤔
@davidd6130 Ай бұрын
They need to be charged .
@GreenGrass90-oh8gd Ай бұрын
Thay are embarrassing to call the things there our leaders
@mdj9765 Ай бұрын
The Speaker should simply have taken the issue on board and said she would come back on the matter to the member.
@jesuschrist2284 Ай бұрын
Only following orders
@margaritayuste4377 Ай бұрын
👍
@michaelstevens3479 Ай бұрын
They are bloody slow I said this weeks ago.
@davidcollin3808 Ай бұрын
How about debating the demise of the UK
@ronwhitehouse23 Ай бұрын
WHAT A FARCE.
@christianmccann9400 Ай бұрын
BDS apartheid Israel .. Free Palestine!
@murraymicha Ай бұрын
Why has my comment of yesterday on this topic 'disappeared"/
@markfrankham1 Ай бұрын
Doesn't he go on 🙄
@tauqeerkhan2053 Ай бұрын
❤
@jamesdevlin6373 Ай бұрын
She's a joke 😢
@Heshem_Joel Ай бұрын
Jacob left the scene, should be around to witness this.
@user-kg9rb5dc7w Ай бұрын
Ha ha , at last UK shows it's backbone in Parliament !
@djmikesea Ай бұрын
minister completely brushes question aside, mentions other people give us legal advise, yet fails to mention any of those supposedly in charge of giving that advise... very simple request to make sure they are not complicit in genocide, yet they cant come up with any thing in writing. because they know they are complicit in genocide and are still sending weapons to murder more innocent Palestinians
@hectorhaus1823 Ай бұрын
Took them about 5 minutes to claim the houthi's were breaking international law, but so far, five months on, still not quite sure.
@b.nichols3255 Ай бұрын
Typical politicians, lots of words to say nothing. The question was never answered properly.
Janta Ka Reporter
Рет қаралды 313
Reporter clashes with US official on fear to criticise Netanyahu for interference |Janta Ka Reporter
Janta Ka Reporter
Рет қаралды 87 М.
TENGRI TV
Рет қаралды 2,9 МЛН
David Lammy asks question on Gaza, but minister’s reply leaves him in discomfort | Janta Ka Reporter
Janta Ka Reporter
Рет қаралды 29 М.
The Telegraph
Рет қаралды 539 М.
PoliticsJOE
Рет қаралды 341 М.
The New Culture Forum
Рет қаралды 18 М.
Rishi Sunak doesn’t like MP’s question on immigration policy, cites intimidation | Janta Ka Reporter
Janta Ka Reporter
Рет қаралды 34 М.