I really like the idea of Jo as a finalist now. Reminds me a lot of how Heather learned from her mistakes and was able to come back in full force after previous blunders

The Anne Maria and Brick ideas are actually really good, too. I love this idea

I feel like Courtney Vs Lindsay should be the finale. They are the true ‘all-stars’ who’ve never won yet. Both had actual storylines in TDI. Then in TDA Lindsay was the (decoy)-protagonist & Courtney was the antagonist for the second half. Not to mention their established rivalry. Lindsay didn’t make it far in TDWT unlike Courtney, but I did notice that they both supported Alejandro in the finale, meaning they might have more in common than they think. Then they have some type of (friendship?) going on in TDAS, but then that goes nowhere and they both are in the bottom two votes.

I don’t understand why brick wasn’t in all stars, he not only is an all star/ fan fav but he would also be the PERFECTTTT example of a “hero”

I actually really like this rewrite. Things are done with a purpose and people have character arcs and storylines and aren’t just there.

Leshawna had an advert running saying she’d return so I would put her in 😭

All six people competing in the finale are second gen…

Heather, 12th place?! In an all star season? That’s a crime, especially considering she is the face of TD 😭😭

It's overall a great rewrite. I like the idea of finalist Jo and the decision to eliminate Mike earlier. I personally disagree with some things though. Heather and Alejandro went out too early, although I understand why it would be the case given their placements in World Tour. Second off, I don't agree that Duncan's character was handled well. Much on the contrary, he was very poorly written in this season. I don't mind him still going 8th, but at least on a higher note, like making his ending something more respectful than to be humiliated the entire season for being "good" to others. Lastly, while I do agree Sierra shouldn't be in this season, I don't think Beth did a lot of relevance in the rewrite in order to need to be the one to replace her. Leshawna could have sufficed her role as well.

Thank you for bringing us top tier TD content 💪

Idk if adding Beth and leaving Owen as the only finalist not on the cast feels wrong considering how iconic Owen is

Beth being here was the best possible pick. Thank you. For that

I LOVE THISSS AND THE FACT JO IS A FINALIST PUMPS ME UP, BEST ALL STARS REWRITE EVER!!!

I think the cast we got for all stars could work, here’s my idea for a boot order: 14th - Lightning 13th - Sam 12th - Heather 11th - Gwen (Quits after making amends with Courtney and ditching Duncan for good) 10th - Cameron 9th - Scott 8th. - Sierra Merge 7th - Mike 6th - Alejandro 5th - Lindsey 4th - Duncan Finale 3rd - Jo 2nd - Zoey 1st - Courtney - No Mal - No good guy Duncan but instead he gets back with Courtney maybe only as friends who he helps make it to the finale, which is a good sendoff for him in the final 4. - Jo and Alejandro make an alliance, being the main two villains of the season but Jo double crosses him at the final 6. - 3 person finale,

I love that you got most of the winners out early. there is an extreme lack of tension in this season as so many of the charecters have already won so you know they are not going to win again. Personal i think a cast with more cherecrers like sam who haven’t won would have been way better. having Joe as the final antagonist would have been amazing. she is such an underrated charecter. I feel like your verson also leaves space for mabey more stuff with the revenge cast before pakitew comes out. Just over all so much more interesting and clearer. agin loved sams arc i would have loved to see that.

something ive always found interesting about sam as a character is how in roti's first episode he says he doesn't wanna get eliminated first but would be fine with going like sixth or seventh instead. i always thought it could be cool if he instead guns for trying to get as far as possible after making it a little far, so its cool to see someone else think the same

I don’t see a universe where Cortney will ever willingly sacrifice herself for someone and miss the chance at the money.

Normally I would have told you everything just to prevent Courtney from reaching the final but the truth is that the idea of her being eliminated to save her friendship with Gwen seemed splendid to me.

Cody was actually supposed to be in All-Stars but they scrapped him😭😭

My version Cast G1- Owen, Gwen, Cody, Heather, Alejandro, Tyler and Beth (Beth cuz of S2 and Tyler cuz he’s my favourite) G2- Zoey, Mike, Scott, Cameron, Brick, Jo, Lightning The good- Tyler, Zoey, Cameron, Mike, Brick, Beth and Cody (yes Owen and Gwen are in villains team, what you gonna do) Villains- Jo, Lightning, Scott, Alejandro, Heather, Gwen and Owen (I didn’t plan for this btw) Elimination order 14. Beth 13. Owen 12. Lightning 11. Tyler 10. Heather Chris does a twist were two campers from each team get swapped without inspecting it, Cody and Gwen get Alejandro swap 9. Alejandro Merge 8. Jo 7. Cameron 6. Cody 5. Scott 4. Gwen 3. Brick 2. Zoey 1. Mike

This is a whole lot better then what we got

I really like what he did with courtney and gwen! I was hoping for there storyline to end better then it did in canon.

TBF all you need to fix TDAS really is more thought behind the eliminations besides "We didn't know how to get rid of them so we just made some bullshit up."

i still with all stars should have been paired with all loosers as part b of the season. we really needed some development on characters like eva, katie sadie, staci, b, dawn and zeeke/dakota back to humans to name a few.

I really like this rewrite, and Jo making finale is always great in my opinion Personally I would change a few things though. Brick replaces Sam in the season Zoey goes out in 6th Brick and Jo finale personally But thats just me lol, great vid 🤙🤙🤙

Whats with lighting getting booting so early every time lol can someone explain 😅

I really like the idea of this season, but I feel like it would work much better as a Second Season for the Revenge cast since it feels like it has a greater emphasis on the Revenge cast over the original one.

I also wanna redraw TDAS. Here are a few of my ideas: 1. After Lindsay takes the flush of shame, she ends up in the NY sewer, but instead facing a giant albino alligator, she actually falls into a truck, used by Simon Gruber and his army to carry the gold bars from the Federal Reserve Bank. Some of Simon's soldiers noticed Lindsay in the back of a truck and begin chasing her with some guns. 2. After Jo takes the flush of shame, she ends up in Egypt, but instead of scarabs, she faces the cursed vengeful mummy Imhotep and the cursed chest in front of him. At first, Jo is angry at Imhotep for watching her with an evil smile, but she changed her mind after noticing the cursed chest. She opened it, which caused a white smoke to come out. After the white smoke is finally cleared, Imhotep grabbed her and consumed her body. Then the camera switches down to Jo's consumed skeletal body, and Imhotep can be heard laughing evilly and closing the cursed chest to await for his next victim. 3. After Sierra takes the flush of shame, she, instead of the military base, ends up into a hospital, where the doctors recognized her as ,,The mad Cody patient", so they tied up Sierra to a hospital bed with some chains, while she's still ,,Cody mad". Then the doctors dragged her to the ,,Mental section", where all the mentally ill patients are placed. 4. After Cameron takes the flush of shame, it's revealed that he ends up into his own house, where his mother picked him up and begin helping him to be cured from his injures. 5. After Gwen takes the flush of shame, instead of the Niagara Falls, she ends up into Cameron's house, and Cameron is so happy to see his new friend again. 6. After Alejandro takes the flush of shame, instead of that cold place, where Heather ended up, he ends up in Rio De Janeiro. 7. After Courtney takes the flush of shame, instead of the beach with sharks, she also ends up in Rio De Janeiro. Alejandro noticed her and invited her to come. She showed him her sundae, which disgusted him. Now Alejandro has a new girl, Courtney. 8. After Scott takes the flush of shame, instead of the Niagara Falls, he ends up into an aquarium into the sharks's cage, which caused a few sharks to chase him around. This attracted the attention of the visitors, so they picked up their phones to make pictures of Scott chased by the sharks. 9. During the 1st part of the final challenge, Mal picked up Courtney, then Alejandro as his helpers, who are now a couple after spending a few days in Rio. 10. Inside some of the balloons will be Lindsay's shot dead body (which means that Simon Gruber's soldiers shot her while running in the NY sewers from them.), Jo's consumed skeletal body (which is because of the cursed chest that makes Imhotep going after everyone who opens it.), the new not Cody crazy Sierra (which means the doctors cured her from her ,,Cody madness".) These are some of my ideas for TDAS redrawing.

Okay then, I say this All Stars Rewritten Idea is your best idea, refreshing to not have Courtney as a finalist (as lots of TDAS rewrites really wants her to win it's getting more stale), plus having Beth in all stars would make since, but I would say have Brick in Sam's place and I would like this as the default All Stars. :)

Why are there so many Beth haters in the comments? Something no-ones seemed to mention with all the "you shouldve picked Leshawna" comments is that Leshawna is in no way heroic, shes more in the middle, the grey area. I know Courtneys there as well, but the team names dont even matter after like 3 episodes when Duncan gets put onto the other team. And another thing, who is Leshawna supposed to interact with if she was here? Beth can be friendly with everyone, can bounce off of Courtney for the time shes on the team, and can work well with Duncan once hes there. Also while this isnt too good of an argument, Beth in Island is one of many BS eliminations so she shouldve made it much farther then she did, Island has that problem with so many characters

Sam getting to 6th place... 😂😂😂

I love what he did with courtney.she needs a better character arc.

choosing Beth over Leshawna and saying she deserved the All Stars spot more than her is WILD 💀

So far my favorite rewrite, having jo as a finalist AND gwourtney. Plus having mal seem like an actual villain too. I'm not the biggest fan of Beth but I would've preferred having her instead of Sierra as she does have more of a hero vibe to her plus the plot points she has had in the past.

ngl I love this Courtney gets farther and Gwen and Courtney’s friendship never ends

I really enjoy this rewrite, as much as I enjoyed Neodica's, but I'd change the cast to 16 as I feel Sierra should be in all stars, she got 4th in her first season so yeah, all star. I would add Beth, for the reasons you described, and Brick on the villains, Because Similar to Gwen, Having one of the most Heroic Characters on the Villains would lead to great interactions (he'd switch to the Hero's though!) also, while I love the plot you gave Sam and that fact you made him go far, this in my mind would also make it easier to have Brick replace him.

If the elimination order was flipped (possibly with a bit of adjusting and some extra characters) I feel like having lightning, Lindsay, and Jo go toe to toe in a final 3 would be a very interesting concept and a big nod to survivor having a final 3 in later seasons. I know there is 2 second gen players against 1 first gen player but each will still get helpers. This would likely include at least 1 second gen player and 2 1st gen players to balance it out a bit.

I have 1 more idea for redrawing Total Drama All Stars. Here's what this idea will feature: 1. The teams will be 8 vs 8. This means 8 1st generation and 8 2nd generation cast members. 2. Sam will be replaced with Brick and Anne Maria. 3. Courtney will be replaced with Trent and Noah. 4. Sierra will be on the villains team for all the creepy stuff she did to Cody and for blowing up the plane. 5. The teams will be: A. Villainous Vultures: Lightning, Jo, Anne Maria, Scott, Duncan, Heather, and Sierra (Alejandro joins after he's released from the robot). B. Heroic Hamsters: Brick, Mike, Zoey, Cameron, Gwen, Trent, Lindsay, and Noah. 6. At the pancake-obstacle course, the villains will lose and Anne Maria is out. This means that the heroes will have the map, while the villains have the bacon hats and the sausage tails for the blue harvest moon challenge. 7. After the heroes lose the blue harvest moon challenge, instead of switching, Tyler will join them (not knowing that his girlfriend was on the team and is already eliminated). 8. During the boat race challenge, Trent, Gwen, Cameron, Zoey, and Mal will use the purple speedboat (together), Duncan and Scott will use the boat of losers (since Mal didn't took it or destroyed the other boats). 9. After the feral Ezekiel challenge, Trent will be crashed by the boulders, so he will be eliminated. Cameron will give Trent his bubble to protect him until he recovers. Gwen quits the game cause she's tired of Chris and because she wants to bring Trent to a hospital. This makes it double elimination. 10. This is a list of everything destroyed by Mal: A. Brick's night vision goggles; B. Trent's guitar; C. Noah's favorite book; D. Cameron's glasses; E. Tyler's favorite picture of Lindsay. 11. Cameron will be 1 of the 2 eliminated competitors at the pirate loot challenge (the semi finals of the season) (I still had no idea who will be the other eliminated). 12. Chris will give 1 minute instead of 30 seconds to Zoey and Mal for the 1st part of the finale. Zoey will take down Cameron, Gwen, and Trent, while Mal will take down Heather, Alejandro, and Anne Maria. 13. Whoever wins the season (either Zoey or Mike(after he and the other personalities defeated Mal) Zoey wanted she, Mike, Cameron, Gwen, Trent to have the best night ever, to which they all agree. 14. Instead of floating on the roof of the loser cabin, I've made a few ideas for an exclusive clip: A. In my 1st idea Trent (holding his guitar), Gwen, Cameron, Zoey, and Mike are sitting on a cliff in the woods. They're also watching the stars and smiling at each other. Then they hugged each other (Trent his guitar behind for it). B. In my 2nd idea the friendly five are in the woods and they're watching the stars (again), but this time they laying on the grass in a circle. This is my other idea for redraw of Total Drama All Stars.

I love Zoey, she's my favorite character

Hey QG, maybe what they should have done is bring the pahkitew island cast first, then do total drama all stars.

Yay love for Beth :)

Katie, Sadie, and Eva needed to be in another season

I would love to see leshawna in as tbf

My way of the original one 14th- Lightning | kept bragging how strong and good he was making the team annoyed 13th- sam | he was the weakest link of the team with lindsay but at the end he quits cuz he missed dakota 12th- jo | the team got sick of the fight between her and heather but with alejandro help heather was able to got less votes 11th- sierra | she kept crying about missing cody 10th- lindsay | she lost the challenge cuz of her dumbness 9th- scott | he was annoying 8th- mike | alejandro knew he was mal so he rigged the votes 7th- heather | alejandro got the statue 6th- cameron | injured 5th- gwen | she was done with duncan and courtney so she quits 4th- courtney | alejandro made her flipping making her angry 3rd- duncan | didn't bring anything back 2nd- alejandro | mal slowed him down during the challenge 1st- zoey | she was faster then alejandro and gwen and Cameron did very well helping

what if there was an alternate ending were court didn’t quit but anyway this was an amazing video

I would swap 7th-5th but this is pretty good

DJ should have returned, he was never actually voted off and everyone like him, he could’ve won a season

a good order, only thing i dont like is heather going out TOO ealry

i cried laughing when he picked beth like 😭😭

im not saying this isnt a great cast but i think sierra and owen should be in this season because in the only season sierra was in because she was a part of generation 1.5 she placed 4th and only got out because of technical difficulties and owen because he won a season and has been in many other reality television shows meaning he would also be good at this season

They could have a bigger cast.

I rly liked this video! However, i think Leshawna is MUCH more of an all star than Beth ngl

People are just mad that Mal bested Alejandro easily and they can’t cope

Amazing!!!!!!!!!! though i never understood why Courtney was put on the hamsters when she has literally never done anything heroic and if anything is the biggest villain to chris as she coused more proplems for him then any of the other villains. they dont even try to explain it because it makes 0 sense in universe.

Sam’s arc is cool, but I think Brick being there could be interesting as well, especially considering if Brick replaced Sam, Jo and Brick would both make the final 6, that’s a lot of screentime for their rivalry

Why was Duncan's sendoff unchanged?

My cast would be the same as the original size 14 and just replace Mike, Sam and Sierra with Cody, Owen and Bridgette (She's an All-Star for me because she made the merge once in island and was in the Aftermath and got a bunch of screentime with that) (I replaced Mike so Zoey can be her own character without talking about Mike 24/7.) (I put Cody in since he technically is a finalist, he just never got an ending where he won, and I put Owen in because he's just Owen.) The teams would be the same, but all my replacement characters would be on heroes. Elimination Order: 14th Lindsay 13th Jo 12th Lightning 11th Owen 10th Heather 9th Bridgette Merge 8th Duncan 7th Cameron 6th Alejandro 5th Cody 4th Gwen 3rd Scott 2nd Courtney (Who want Courtney to win: (Jo, Heather, Bridgette, Alejandro and Scott) 1st Zoey (Who want Zoey to win: (Lindsay, Lightning, Owen, Duncan, Cameron, Cody and Gwen) (I really like the elimination order in the original so mostly the whole order is the same because Bridgette is Sierra's replacement, so she gets 9th place, Owen is Sam's replacement, so he gets 11th. One of the changes I would make is Courtney switches out with Mike's replacement Cody in the finale, so Cody gets 5th and Courtney is in the finale.) (My only other change is switching out Lighting and Jo's placement since I feel like Lightning deserved at least one more episode and Jo got annoying bickering with Heather all the time.) (Also, I would keep Duncan and Gwen together since I would keep world tour the same, but I think the end of the season Courtney should make up with Gwen and just be on good terms with Duncan.) (But I feel like they still will cheer for Zoey though.) Honorable Mentions for Total Drama All-Star contestants: Beth, Dawn, Brick, Anna Maria, Tyler, Trent, Justin, Harold, Mike (to bring him back) and Leshawna.

Owen to me is the face of Total Drama so I think he deserves a spot.

I dont think scott is that person that wouldnt forgive, after courtneys elimination he said that she wasnt that bad, so ill do a courtney resemption arc? What would i do is to make that gwen gives courtney a chance, so sam still goes 6th zoe goes 5th, she really didnt had that many allies and courtney didnt wanted to vote scott(joe got inmunity instead of zoe) Since scott was still kinda annoyed that courtney made the chart, courtney helps him to win, in a close result scott wins the challenge and gwen still gets last bc of joe, joe tries to manipulate scott but fails and gets 3rd, then courtney voting herself is revealed and gwen and courtney are still friends And then the final occures, courtney finally apologizes for drawing scott like that and well the 2 endings arent that different, but atleast this closes courtneys whole arc

what tierlist did you use

Does anyone think of gen 1 vs gen 2..

make a non stars season

i came into this hoping that courtney would win but tbh this is better. gay people ❤️

Overall I liked this, it was a fun watch! But I’m sorry they did not do the Courtney, Gwen, and Duncan thing right, that was the worst part of the season 😭 Though Jo as a finalist was a really good idea

Leshawna cuold've been better if in

Why would you keep Sam as an all star instead of replacing him with Brick then you removed Sierra 😭

Would’ve had Sam booted after Lightning

🎉🎉🎉

Leshawna would have been a better candidate for all stars

in my opinion for the cast, cody replaces beth and dawn replaces sam. dawn got robbed in tdri

No one mention The BOY PURGE în The merge

Sarella, Campster, Cody, Sierra, Lindsay, Tyler, Gwen Trent mike zoey and dawn

in my opinion I think everything was great but I do think that Beth and Sam could be swapped in elimination.

L merge Sam is not making that data And Alejandro is not getting out that early

No way Heather is 12th…

My order with your flop cast: 14. Beth 13. Lightning 12. Sam 11. Jo 10. Lindsay 9. Heather 8. Duncan 7. Cameron 6. Alejandro 5. Zoey 4. Gwen 3. Mike 2. Scott 1. Courtney

While i like the idea of beth returning if she did Lindsay getting out first is a waste and her getting sabotaged the same way as cam is just uninteresting while it's a bit better than the original i would've rathered a lindsay vs jo finale and courtney shouldn't be redeemed because after everything she's done i'm not forgiving her

Villainess vultures will be AnneMaria Courtney donkeys Alejandro, Heather Jo lightning Scott and Lashanna

I think you should've gone for Leshawna instead of Beth, it doesn't seem like Beth added much of anything to your season whereas Leshawna's presence could drastically change the season which I think is needed

Jo should win

I’d rather be 18 contestants instead of 14

In my opinion they should have had Bridget instead of Lindsay in this season.

My way Sam is now brick Sierra is now Lewshana 14th Lighting He is A Previous winner from last season and he isnt really a vilian 13th Alejandro He is a big threat and he got out half of the ppl in tour 12th Cameroon Hes really weak Courtney and gwen switch (Gwen hero) 11th Zoey she is dumb 10th Scott i think he will sabgote the team 9th Mike merge 8th Duncan 7th Jo 6th Bricjk 5th Gwen 4th Lindsay 3rd court

Courtney should have won. She got robbed by bad storytelling, because she suddenly now has a bad stomach. I really liked how Lindsay became a good leader in action (a bit too far but good). I wish they explored more of that rather than making her dumb in world tour and all stars...

picking betyh over leshawna made me click off the video. but i tried again and it was pretty good

Episodes:18

Why Sam I would pick Brick and Anne Maria

real

Brick should have been there instead of sam

I don’t really like the order i think Cameron should be first boot and Heather should make it further

I dont think lindsay would be first because of beth she wouldnt vkte her bestie

Generation two will be Mike Zoe dawn anneMaria Jo Lightning and Scott

Should of picked leshawna !!!!!!

I like all of it but I think beth shouldnt be back and leshawna should

Hello?? Sam is literally useless???

personally who i'd do: 7 from gen 1: heather, courtney, gwen, alejandro, harold, duncan, leshawna 7 from gen 2: scott, jo, zoey, mike, lightning, brick, and i guess anne maria? team villain: heather, duncan, lightning, jo, anne maria, scott, alejandro team hero: zoey, mike, brick, harold, leshawna, courtney, gwen 14th: anne maria (basically she is just voted out cuz everyone found her annoying) 13th: lightning (same as anne maria) 12th: leshawna (mal victim) (gwen and duncan switch teams) 11th: heather (seen as a threat) 10th: alejandro (seen as a threat) 9th: brick (mal victim) MERGE 8th: duncan (same as show) 7th: scott (mal victim combined with the fact that he is the only known villain left) 6th: courtney (same as show, just 1 ep earlier) 5th: gwen (same as show, just 1 ep earlier) (instant elimination) 4th: harold (mal victim, but he reveals mal at elimination) (jo wins immunity, jo zoey and mike/mal all vote harold, harold votes mike/mal) 3rd: jo (mal/mike gets immunity) finalists: zoey and mike (same as show) when i say mal victim im imagining as if mal was actually like competitevly strategic (like alejandro), instead of just comically evil, which is how he is the cause of some people getting out in this scenario

Generation one Cody Sierra Lindsay Tyler Gwen Trent Heather Courtney Duncan Alejandro and Leshana

The 1,000 liked

Getting rid of Sierrah instead of Sam is crazy

honestly seeing two revenge of the island finalists is lowkey horrible