Transgender: Where do you go to be Yourself?

  Рет қаралды 2,385

ClosetTransgender

ClosetTransgender

9 жыл бұрын

I encourage you to answer this question, because there is so much variation. Everyone finds a different place where they are comfortable, what place did you find? What do you need to feel connected to yourself? Where in the world are you? In some countries the expectations and cultures are so limiting, what do you do if you are transgender?

Пікірлер: 56
@mudkipjuice
@mudkipjuice 9 жыл бұрын
Writing, mostly. Not a physical place, but creating a world inside my head where I could be whomever I wanted was my therapy. I've been blessed/cursed to have vivid dreams since I was very little, so dreaming as well, was probably my biggest escape. I was always male in my dreams (probably shouldve been a clue that something was wrong lol) so I'm always more comfortable while in them. I lose all the anxiety and dysphoria and can just be free.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
I love those dreams where everything is just right! I share that too, dreaming as a man, and writing, that is a really good one. I did a lot of drawing too when I was younger mostly, I drew so many big muscled bearded fellas. Nothing but beards and muscles, it's funny now a days, having such a hard time growing a beard. My life long dream has become a tiny goatee! Oh well!
@Nunery29
@Nunery29 9 жыл бұрын
I have found that hiking all alone in the woods or where ever the trails are, that's when I am free. No boundaries, no one staring at me, no bathrooms to choose from. When the wind is blowing and all the little creatures are moving about out in the trees, I get lost in a world where my mind is the only part of me that exists. Therefore, I am not thinking about the body that I am in.....in those moments. My favorite times.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Yes. That was me also for many years. I hope you are finding peace and solace. I can see you in that place.
@wreckfemme8803
@wreckfemme8803 9 жыл бұрын
What you said about love is beautiful, everyone deserves that kind of love and acceptance from a partner. As always, I enjoyed your level of introspection. :)
@BrieBrowne
@BrieBrowne 9 жыл бұрын
Thumbs up n 5 stars 👍🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 I hid my feelings for 41 yrs, I'm TG , MTF, Thankyou for Sharing your Story Cheers 💖💜💚brie💙💛❤️
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Brie Browne Thank you for the hearts and colors! I am so happy for you Brie! Stay in touch!
@jtperez8177
@jtperez8177 9 жыл бұрын
Wow! This video really touched inside me. Thankfully I have a wife that accepts me fully. I'm also lucky to have family that treats me with respect and love. My community also accepts me with open arms. The most difficult areas for me is what's inside my head. Those "tapes" that play over and over that criticize me for being who I am.
@TheSLOfox
@TheSLOfox 9 жыл бұрын
I can definitely relate to going out into the woods/nature to be oneself. I've always done that, ever since I was 12 or something. I still do. Not that it's the only place I can be myself (thankfully), but being alone out in nature allows me to be centered, focused, quiet, not distracted, in the moment, active, in my body. And I love it even more now that I'm transitioning and have had top surgery! One realization I've recently had is that physically transitioning allows me to be more of the self that I always was, minus the distractions that a female body caused me. Anyway, now I feel I can be myself just about anywhere, except that being in a city makes me feel uncomfortable simply because I'm not a city person. :)
@kalenix2752
@kalenix2752 9 жыл бұрын
I like going places where no one knows who I am.
@bluebug111
@bluebug111 7 жыл бұрын
I know this is an older video but I just wanted to say that I really appreciated it and all the rest of the content you create. I really like that you talk about trans people as individuals and in a very nuanced way, emphasizing that all of our paths are very different. And this is such an important thing! finding comfort, really it is something everyone should look for.
@jessekatz4598
@jessekatz4598 9 жыл бұрын
I'm at my most comfortable and grounded when working with my hands- carving things and making art. Also, if I can suggest a topic- I'd be interesting to hear you speak on your art in relation to your transition, or your life in general.
@tobyr3
@tobyr3 9 жыл бұрын
Good points as always. I'm glad you pointed out how the struggles can go in different directions depending on how much 'deviation' acceptance one is likely to encounter from those around you. I'm glad you found solace in natural spaces. It appears it continues to work in your favor.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Indeed. I don't have that same need to escape and get away from people as I did PRE-T, that was always overwhelming. Now I just enjoy the solitude for what it is, and out here in my current situation I do feel a little isolated sometimes.
@skateonsnow21
@skateonsnow21 9 жыл бұрын
I'm like you in that aspect. I love running and I want to be an ultra runner someday. I also climb a lot and I want to get good at that as well. They both have become a part of me to go when nobody else understands.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
skateonsnow21 I wish we could train together!
@SomeStuff9
@SomeStuff9 9 жыл бұрын
this is a great question. I'm not sure there is anywhere for me to go to be seen, when I can't even deal with/see/accept myself fully. It's not as sad as it seems, but it makes me realize that there is no where to go to be recognized. I only connect with myself in a live music setting with my favorite band, where I disconnect from myself and connect with something all together different.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Music! That is a good place! A healing place! I love that one. Yeah, sometimes just lost in the music you are so present it is wonderful. Being in an audience sharing the beat and melody... yeah, that is a good place to feel alive. Good take on the question. I hope the self acceptance happens with time. Believe me, it's a nice feeling too!
@MrJimmyBeat
@MrJimmyBeat 9 жыл бұрын
Beard is comin in man! Yeah dude, I recognize everything you say. I like all places where nobody call me "trans" or discuss "gender".
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
I don't know if a little chin fuzz counts as a beard, but it is nice!
@apollicino1705
@apollicino1705 4 жыл бұрын
Reading from other trans folx experiences really helps. Even if it is a different trans experience there are always things that are relatable. Every trans author I've read has articulated something in words that I hadn't clarified for myself yet. (Julia Serano, Laura Jane Grace, SJ Miller, Jacob Tobia, Susan Stryker, Ann Travers, Alok Vaid-Menon).
@TheSLOfox
@TheSLOfox 9 жыл бұрын
Similar to what you say, I've also felt really truly myself when with a romantic partner who definitely saw me as I truly am, and treated me as such, and appreciated me. That was amazing and I am really heartbroken to not have that anymore. That was in fact an eye-opening experience for me; I felt like being with her got me more in touch with myself than I ever had been before.
@niko5ism
@niko5ism 9 жыл бұрын
I plan to go move out of state to california and start living as the man I am. I plan to Surround myself with the woman I love and people who respect and accept who I am.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
This is a plan that could serve you well. It's amazing to be in a state so diverse, depending on where you land you can experience that sense of anonymity which comes with a feeling of tolerance and safety. It's nice to start over sometimes, that's for sure! Good luck and thank you for weighing in on this one.
@metalgirlclaire
@metalgirlclaire 9 жыл бұрын
Before coming out, I could only be myself in my apartment. Between living in a more liberal city and learning to carry myself with confidence and not letting any haters get me down, I've become comfortable as being my true self anywhere. This was very important to me, because I choose not to modify my voice. I look like any other woman, but don't sound at all like one. By the way, your facial hair looks good. Once upon a time I would have been jealous, because mine never grew in that well.
@MPimT
@MPimT 9 жыл бұрын
I live in a city, but it has lots of green space and some wild parks so I go there if I can - go for long walks mainly, but I've just got back to running which allows me to connect with the bits of my body that don't feel wrong - the muscle and sinew, the lungs and beating heart. Of course I also have to deal with the bits I don't like, but at least they are strapped away during the run. I also come to KZfaq and now that I'm out to some friends I can spend time with them being myself.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
This is wonderful, someone once described it as: We are all made of the same ingredients-- the muscles, heart, skin, sinew, blood... yes. Connecting to the moving parts, and the health, it's important to just remember the human aspects of life. Also you bring up friends and the youtube community, I'm surprised not more people have mentioned it in comments! Thank you so much for sharing your park run here in response. I am thankful for your thoughts!
@krozem45
@krozem45 9 жыл бұрын
This is such a good video. I miss you. I think about these things a lot. If feeling safe in a heteronormative space is actually a cowardly response to my feelings about gender or not. I'm also afraid of being trapped in, in the reverse, if I get too comfortable in a bi-gender dynamic. The moment I started to really feel seen for the multiplicity of myself, was when I started teaching kindergarten. Five year olds have lots of room for difference and contradictions and magic. It's the place where I can be all the things.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Being yourself around children!!!! That is a great one Kate!!! They are so much more willing to explore, accept and just be. I love this image and I am fascinated with your identity, would you describe it as fluid? It would be funny if I went to one of your students and was like, "Could you describe your teachers identity?" Ha, the answer probably wouldn't have much to do with gender at all. In any case, I miss you too, and let's be in touch!
@Gambeli02
@Gambeli02 9 жыл бұрын
Yep, solo hiking or backpacking. Me, a fishing pole, and drowning worms in an alpine stream. I could easily be a hermit in a decent size cabin (WITH Internet) and come into town just long enough to resupply. Living in a large city brings a measure of anonymity. When I was going around to different entities doing my name change gig, I'd say 90% of the people I dealt with didn't even blink. So it went smoother than I can imagine it would in a small town where personal changes turn every busybody on their collective ears. I have to think of a childhood friend of my father's who claims, "I have nothing against gay people -- as long as they don't come to my church." Of course "gay people" are the total collective of LGBTQI. He's in a tiny town, yet, across the road, another childhood friend is fully accepting.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Very good contrast! I remember being thankful that at the time of name change I was in a city too, and the anonymity was really nice. Where I live now the people at the post office make small talk about the things that came in the mail for me... YIKES! I would never want to transition in a place like this. So I wonder how it must feel being trans growing up in a small town. It seems like you would always be planning to leave so you could do your thing.
@OddballLife
@OddballLife 9 жыл бұрын
Honestly, I hide in my room. But mostly, I sleep it all away. Not healthy at all, but I'm taking measures to change these patterns in the future.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
That's a lonely place. I've been there before. When you sleep away the time it is a form of running away when you can't run, it can be an attempt to fast forward time. It sort of works, but you end up returning to the bed that you were hiding in having to put on the mask and return to the world that can't see you yet. I think a room with a closed door is the safe place for many people who can't share what's happening inside them. It feels lonely, but with others are doing it too, across the country and the world-- it's almost like people are doing it together without knowing... hang in there buddy.
@bfranklin69
@bfranklin69 9 жыл бұрын
My bedroom (lol). I live with my grandma who's very old fashion and "watchful." I spend most of my time is my room, pretending the outside world doesn't exist and generally avoiding her. School lunch time is also a place to be myself. I hang out with 10 other dudes in the school's band hall and it's probably the best part of my day. Lastly is the sewer system behind the apartment. Sounds disgusting but it's just a huge open pipe that I use to ride my bike through. Really fun.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
This is an awesome answer as I imagine each place in my mind!!! Thank you for sharing so many good ones. Places I wouldn't have thought of if not for you comment! THANK YOU!!!
@akarikiddo1607
@akarikiddo1607 9 жыл бұрын
I'm somewhat hesitant to put rural living in opposite position to urban living in terms of openness/stealth. From my experience smaller places aren't always traditional and close minded and the queer communities in the cities aren't always open and including or spaces to feel comfortable enough in to explore and be yourself. The power relation in rural/urban is "sticky" and the urban world is often quick in using its interpretative prerogative in defining rural areas and how life is there. I'm just mentioning this to give an idea of from what point I'm talking about this, not as a contradicting comment on your post :) Oh…and I'm writing from a swedish context. I guess if I narrow it down it would be three things that I would count as equally important for being able to connect with myself. Solitude, both out in the nature as well as in my home. I need the distance to sort feelings, reactions and thoughts out. I also need other people both close relationships as well as acquaintances for sharing thoughts, mirroring each other, giving each other comfort and also challenging each other. The third thing would be writing. I'm most honest with my self when I write and writing is also a tool for me to find out more about my self, my inner/outer world and how that correlate to the world around me and how I can combine, change and work things together. Living in cities has of course given me a broader spectrum of contexts to explore myself in but these contexts hasn't necessarily made it easier for me to be myself…whoever that is, I'm figuring things out :) Thanks again for a great vlogg!
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Thank you!!! I am so glad to read what you have to add to the conversation. This is what I love about this topic-- and vlogging in general, there are so many experiences and stories to share. I really appreciate what you have to say here-- and that is an important point, some small communities can be the kind that are dedicated to staying open minded... Also I love the space that can be created through writing, I relate to that one for sure!
@bluebongos7
@bluebongos7 9 жыл бұрын
my place is some what similar, behind my house is a patch of wooded area. If you walk back far enough there is an abandoned train cart, I know, it sounds like a horror movie, but its actually quite relaxing. On a totally unrelated subject, are you doing no shave November, because i think you would look good in a beard? :)
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
I would look GREAT in a beard. I have tried, right now my attempt at no shave November would get me fired! I have one of those scraggly beards that people don't enjoy looking at... but one day it will be thick!!!
@bluebongos7
@bluebongos7 9 жыл бұрын
can't wait to see it when you grow it:)
@ovh992
@ovh992 2 жыл бұрын
I hate it when transgender people want to erase their past. Your past made u who u r today. U r actually very lucky. U had a family who loved u. U had girlfriends. U had rich life experiences. U have to accept it for what it was. It was definitely not a disease like u stated. U had a difficult youth but u were actually very lucky and blessed. Consider how far u have come because of your strength and consider how many people didn't make it as far as u did.
@calexzander
@calexzander 9 жыл бұрын
Nice video man
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Where do you go to most be yourself?
@Meowchang22
@Meowchang22 9 жыл бұрын
I go out in nature usually to parks, I actually came out to myself when I was outside around plants but mostly my mind, at least for me I always go into my head and stay there for long periods of time and be myself inside so that it can seep out into the outside of me hah if that makes sense.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
That's a good one, you should write a poem about that, going into your mind and then seeping out. That's cool too, that you have that memory of coming out around some plants outside. Some people believe that plants have spirits and energy, maybe they were encouraging you!
@niko5ism
@niko5ism 9 жыл бұрын
I've known I was trans since I was 17. Up until recently I've always isolated myself in my room away from my family. I've been trying to come out so I can begin to live a more connected life as you say but no one is acknowledging my gender identity so I have nowhere to turn except my room. No one will listen or try to understand. I have no resources. I feel stuck. Stuck living a lie for now.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
It can be an up hill battle getting people to understand, or even just listen, but because you know what you are talking about, and you know who you are, the fact is that with time family has to accept what you are saying. Truth doesn't just go away. I am glad you end your comment with "for now." I am curious what you plan to do, where you plan to go to be yourself. Your thoughts?
@jamesmills8709
@jamesmills8709 9 жыл бұрын
I think reading books is a nice solace. Especially if you have a nook :)
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Ah yes, the little book nook, I'm right there with you!
@alexhaney100
@alexhaney100 9 жыл бұрын
I don't think its always as black and white as you're making it seem here, urban vs. rural, out vs. stealth etc. There are trans ppl living in cities who are some level of stealth, and who live here for different reasons other than their trans status. As for me, I couldn't stand being secluded out in nature prior to transition. It's interesting that my experience seems the exact opposite of yours- being out there was hard because, for me, being out in the mountains or whatever forces me to confront myself and my body in the most intimate and intense way- and I just felt too incongruent to feel comfortable with that before. For me being in the city was a way for me to feel invisible. Currently the city drives me insane a lot of the time, and if I wasn't queer (not talking trans here) I might consider living more rural. That has to do with my sexuality and how that is read, not my being trans. Anyway thats just a tiny part of why I still live here. I feel most myself when I'm away from the city, and not necessarily around trans or queer people- but I still live in the city. And it all has to do with what kinds of communities you surround yourself with- it sounds like you are talking more about people who immerse themselves in the trans community completely. Believe me, there are plenty of people in the city who still see gender as very binary and aren't educated on trans stuff at all. You sort of create your own experience of what living in the city is like, in my experience.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
I was really hoping for discussion on this one, so this is great, but people have really been focusing on examples I've used it seems like. My examples were of me recalling a moment that led to a reflection on why I am where I am and how it feels. But what I'm getting at is not: what are you city or country? How do you connect to yourself, is it virtual, is it physical? Is it cultural or community driven? People are giving a variety of interesting answers I didn't consider like: when I listen to music. Heck yes!!! There is a huge diversity of answers and interpretation to the question as well, and this variance based on what part of the process you are in. For example some people can only be themselves alone in their room-- you could do that in the country or the city or in a space station... This isn't a necessarily a physical answer. I was also hoping for an international response about how people in religious countries or communities connect to their identity-- where do you go? What space? What person? What outlet? How long, I wonder, can each outlet fit? It's like as we discover ourselves we grow into these larger exoskeletons-- ok, that image and amplify was making sense to me but I'll hold there... Based on your answer, I see my video fell short of asking the real question I was going for. It was an meeting up with an old friend that made me have this conceptual thought & I was trying to contrast that what my friend had found worked for him, but he had trouble finding it in some of the rural areas he's worked. But the same oppressive culture can exists in any urban area, just as small artsy mountain towns could be totally queer friendly-- I was thinking about culture more than actual population size... And was endlessly fascinated as well as embarassed of my attraction to blending in with what is an oppressive culture, fascinated because maybe before I couldn't & now I can... And then I was like: I know there are some Muslim trans folk, for example, who would love to embrace their traditions, who may relate to the conservative doctrines, yet are stuck in their role-- so what do you do? And if you fell into the queer end of the spectrum in such a culture-- where is the light at the end of that tunnel? Where do you possibly go? See how exciting and rich this topic is? My examples fall short of anything but... I'm just a small bean -- weirded out about who I am, why & how
@alexhaney100
@alexhaney100 9 жыл бұрын
ClosetTransgender ah gotcha. yeah it makes more sense now. I'll be reading through the answers as well, and hopefully you get a great diversity of responses.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
Thanks-- I was so excited to answer your comment I've been using my phone & I know that some of my words & thoughts got altered to sound funny-- but anyway-- thanks for understanding, I also hope for more feedback & thoughts on this one... Maybe I'll ave to rephrase or try again though...
@alexhaney100
@alexhaney100 9 жыл бұрын
ClosetTransgender I've been thinking more about it. And this is my own answer to that. I've realized over the years that I can't go to any one place to find myself- neither physical, virtual, etc. Rather I have to connect with different parts of myself in different places and in different ways. I think that this might apply to people who might be into religion or conservative values yet have this 'opposing' queerness or transness. I can't relate to that dichotomy, but I do have another huge one in my life- being a young parent and always having these opposing parts of myself to nurture. There has been my younger self which has never completely fit in with people my age because I became a parent at 19, and then there is the more mature parental side of myself that never completely fit in with other parents because I'm young. This has a lot of parallels to those situations I feel. I used to believe I had to pick a side and sacrifice parts of myself, otherwise I'd never fit in anywhere. Now I realize that people are complex and that we don't need to 'fit in', we just need to feel we belong. And I belong in several different spaces in different ways. Different parts of me get seen and not seen, nurtured or neglected, and its all sort of a balancing act.
@ClosetTransgender
@ClosetTransgender 9 жыл бұрын
alexhaney100 What a great thought to share! YES!!!!! See, the topic itself is pretty philosophical I think... I mean, it caused me this huge reflection on my own patterns and which aspects come out where... but we do have so many sides, and I am glad you brought it beyond trans... As human we deal with all these self inflicted and society inflicted standards, it's a balancing act, where sometimes the ultimate is not just to completely free yourself, sometimes it's just nice to blend... but it comes down to a process I think, of discovering new parts of your identity and integrating them in, self-examination and self acceptance... Great comments Alex, I like this exchange very much.
@BrieBrowne
@BrieBrowne 9 жыл бұрын
Will do subscribed, stop by n check my channel when you get a chance 😜
The Healing & Helplessness After Top Surgery
14:01
ClosetTransgender
Рет қаралды 10 М.
FTM: Starting Transition after 50, Works Fine!
14:53
ClosetTransgender
Рет қаралды 29 М.
Khóa ly biệt
01:00
Đào Nguyễn Ánh - Hữu Hưng
Рет қаралды 19 МЛН
Smart Sigma Kid #funny #sigma #comedy
00:19
CRAZY GREAPA
Рет қаралды 21 МЛН
I wish I could change THIS fast! 🤣
00:33
America's Got Talent
Рет қаралды 58 МЛН
The Queer Code: Secret Languages of LGBTQ+ Art
10:23
nationalgalleries
Рет қаралды 1,6 МЛН
How Transgender Shame & Rejection Plays Into Relationships
10:14
ClosetTransgender
Рет қаралды 4,9 М.
The Big Surgery Question
9:36
Scribbs
Рет қаралды 4,1 М.
Detransitioning: Why Did I Even Transition? (FTM Transgender)
15:58
Then and Now - Trans Men Share Their Stories
12:53
Val's LGBTI Ageing & Aged Care
Рет қаралды 27 М.
When Transmen Fall in Love with Each Other...
12:00
ClosetTransgender
Рет қаралды 10 М.
Art, Fashion, & The French Revolution
15:09
lemoncholy
Рет қаралды 3,7 МЛН
Trans: It's Never Too Late to Transition (INSPIRATIONAL!)
10:17
ClosetTransgender
Рет қаралды 20 М.
Can you spot a psychopath by looking at their eyes?
10:16
Dr. Todd Grande
Рет қаралды 289 М.
Khóa ly biệt
01:00
Đào Nguyễn Ánh - Hữu Hưng
Рет қаралды 19 МЛН