It started before. With the British mandate in 1917 and before.

​@@ghofranesalhi7386very true

@@ghofranesalhi7386 for the Palestinians it started in 1917, when the British colonized Palestine... but zionists Israelis invaded Palestine in 1948

Yes, but actually months before the Arab neighbor states declared war on May 15. A little bit in December 1947, and kicking into high gear by March 1948.

@@ghofranesalhi7386 Ideologically, the Zionists were talking about the need to get rid of the non-Jewish "Arabs" from the time of the Balfour Declaration, and the local non-Jews knew this for 30 years before the Zionists actually acted out. When Zionists tell stories of "Arabs" attacking Jews before 1947, they leave out the part that says that the "Arabs" already knew that their removal was planned decades before it actually happened.

Peace be upon you too!

Iran is safe place for Jews

👍👍👍

Hello, brother in peace! 👋

Is it possible for you to immigrate to another country like US so you are not part of a settler colonial state?

You should really respect all Jews because they're humans and you should respect all humans. You don't have to agree with them though.. And of course I am not saying you should respect people like Bibi, that guy is a psycho... But really, Jews are great people with a beautiful religion and long history that doesn't just encompass their religion but that of the middle east as a region through millenia. Worthy of respect for sure 😊

​@@samf.s.7731 Wtf are you blithering on about? Nobody said othererwise.

You understand that if Jews followed this man’s lies, Jews would be extinct today right?

​@@samf.s.7731Modern Day Christianity Exposed by their own bible ❤ Isaiah 43 15= I am the LORD, your Holy One, Israel’s Creator and King. But you guys still call. Jesus god. Right? Well my brothers and sisters bible has answer to that too Mark 10:18= And Jesus said to him, Why do you call Me [essentially and perfectly morally] good? There is no one [essentially and perfectly morally] good-except God alone. Jesus says only god is good right? Buy you guys still call jesus god right? Here we go again❤ John 20 17= Jesus said, “Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father. Go instead to my brothers and tell them, 'I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God. ' ” O you people if you are true person then you don't have to do anything but just read last line what does that say ? Jesus says to my god and your god so who's that god jesus is talking about?? Well bible has answer to that .❤ John 17:3= And this is eternal life, that they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent. I know its hard to accept truth but at the end of the day your own bible says this look so what to do ?? James 2 19= You believe that there is one God. Good! Even the demons believe that-and shudder . Still not enough for you guys to accept the fact that father is the only one true God and Jesus is his prophet?? If that's the case then no problem your bible has answer to that too ❤❤ Matthew 21 11= The crowds answered, “This is Jesus, the prophet from Nazareth in Galilee.” 😕 Still don't have guts to accept the truth??? Now I know that you guys will start saying no but jesus died for our sins Well Timothy 1 17= All honor and glory to God forever and ever! He is the eternal King, the unseen one who never dies; he alone is God. Still not willing to believe that god is one and moses , Abraham, David, Solomon, Jesus and Muhammad ( Peace Be upon them all) are his prophets❤ Then see this Qur'an 4:171= O People of the Book! Do not go to extremes regarding your faith; say nothing about Allah except the truth. The Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, was no more than a messenger of Allah and the fulfilment of His Word through Mary and a spirit ˹created by a command˺ from Him. So believe in Allah and His messengers and do not say, “Trinity.” Stop!-for your own good. Allah is only One God. Glory be to Him! He is far above having a son! To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. And Allah is sufficient as a Trustee of Affairs. Still not satisfied?? 😢 Christianity Bible Mark 12 29= God is one Judaism Deuteronomy 6 4= Lord is one Hinduism Chandogya Upanishad 6 2 1= He is one. Without second Islam Qur'an 2:163= Your God is ˹only˺ One God. There is no god ˹worthy of worship˺ except Him-the Most Compassionate, Most Merciful. So my brother and sister what is stopping you to believe in that one true god ? Is it because of the sin of adam and eve ? Well don't worry about that god doesn't need blood Sacrifice to forgive our sins as his mercy, majesty ane compassion is greater than our deeds( Both Good and bad) And after all this if you still believe in trinity then this is my last message to you hope it helps otherwise you know yourself what would happen to someone who goes against the commandments of almighty god right? # Displeasure oF God# Qur'an 5:73= Those who say, “Allah is one in a Trinity,” have certainly fallen into disbelief. There is only One God. If they do not stop saying this, those who disbelieve among them will be afflicted with a painful punishment. ❤⚔️

​@@SolarEclipse1996you must respect boundaries

Hi Yarden. Nice to see like-minded Israelis here. I'm also from Israel. Lots of love and light!

​@@RawChangeIsrael Peace and love my friend 🙏

Doğru tarafta olmanız, işgalcilerin yanında olmamanız, size cennetin kapılarını açacaktır

Im watching the atrocities commited by idf every day on instagram by gazan journalists i cant hold tears , and what makes it even worse is the huge israeli public support (western support as well) anyways good to see some people who dont let nationalism kills their humanity

christians and jewish peoples are one!

AshkeNAZIS

Незнаю ,но я не верю им некому ,все они одинаковые. Смотреть на то ,что сейчас происходит и жить там это просто жееесть.

Dear Rabbi Elhanan Beck ...it's not like "we " did not try to separate Judaism and Zionism [nazi] Hope you understand [ not looking for forgiveness ] , what must and will be done

May allah protect iśrael from hàmàś

@@codingstories nah. try again, nazionist.

just my opinion... in simple logic if everyone comes from Adam and Eve, there should not be any quarrel amongst eachother... the only enemy to humanity is satan, he will always try to influence anger and hatred... just my 2 cents...

Agreed!

Beautifully said ❤ this earth is all one land, and all one people. There is no place for those who pay for and sanction the deaths of children.

Do you justify the killing of people, their abduction, and torture, including of children and infants, and acts against women in the fight for freedom?

@@user-yg7fv3jo8vwhy do you people keep projecting the IDF's crimes onto Hamas?

Alhamdulillah Is it easy for Israelis to leave their country? Because I've suggested that to many Israelis on KZfaq but they haven't answered

Also congratulations sir. You are one of the very few Israelis I respect

Israel = stolen lands.

The world needs more people like you who stand up for what's right ❤

Because your in constant fear, there is so much injustice even towards Jews and our government really does not want peace. They think if they continue to be hostile and strong on others that we as Jews will be safe, that's what they told us all along. Its sad that I've left but I had to. We were never truly happy

he's not, though. if he was wise, he'd know 1929 came before 1948

The palestinians were massacring the Jewish community in 1929 -- that's 19 years before there was a modern state of Israel, so if he was so wise, he wouldn't say the only issue is the "occupation," and that the Muslims are so good to the Jews otherwise, etc.@156ml

Agreed

So this guy and his organization actually represent about 5% of the global Jewish diaspora who overwhelming support The Jewish State Of Israel & A Two State Solution to the ongoing war between Israel & Hamas terrorists. Also ask any Arab Israelis serving in the IDF what they think of what happened on Oct 7, and defending Israel from Hamas terrorists. I guarantee they'll be opposed to pretty much everything this 'Rabbi' has said.

​@@DavidDemursTrue! But Hamas apologists invent their own historical facts regarding Israel & Palestine. If it doesn't fit their narrative, then they don't want to know

So no "khaybar, khaybar ya yahood!" for him?

He said that the Zionists are anti God. So I 100% believe he is right from a true Jewish perspective. Their defeat is inevitable. God has predestined it.

Yes may you be defeated.

​@@DavidDemurs No, not every muslim is a terrorist. I´m a muslim and I don´t wan´t to kill jews. Just like 99.99...% of muslims on earth.

@patriceagulu8315 Why do you think he lives in a country where there are no jews?

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Yes definitely, just listening to him makes me feel peaceful.

Yes he does exude peace. Believes in God whereas most Zionist are godless thus the arrogance. Only Allah can be arrogant. His slaves cannot.

His look shows a kind of madness, yes, the guy doesn't even have teeth... he is in a state of denial of reality, a coward who prefers to join his enemies... and by the way, he is not safe at all living in England...

He certainly wouldn't win an award for film star looks, but this is definitely one of the most beautiful human beings I've heard speaking. Than you Rabbi Beck.

They exude pure stupidity.

"Let's set the record straight: Judaism is not just a religion, it is a rich and diverse cultural identity with deep historical roots. The founder of the modern Zionist movement, the modern day Moses, was none other than the atheist Theodor Herzl. So to all those who try to deny the ethnic aspect of Judaism, take note: the very founder of modern Israel was an atheist Jew. Let's celebrate the complexity and diversity of our heritage, just like the modern Moses, Theodor Herzl, did. 🇮🇱❤️"

@@JewishAtheist So you owe God nothing? Ok.

see, christians are not standing by anymore. we will defend the jewish community!

he doesn't speak for all rabbis he is radicalized by people who belived that jews can't live in Israel yet

hes not a Rabbi lol. Just wears a disguise and has an agenda to make money from this by organizations

@@HillelSabban or perhaps. he's not a fan of genocide. numbers 31:17-18

i mean 70 % of israelis become atheist its says everything

if zionism is a mistrust in god you would win a single war but oops u didnt

How do you explain the atrocities against Jews when Israel did not exist?

Nope. The Land will always belong to the Jews forever

​@@davew1421Israel didn't create evil, it existed way before. That doesn't mean Israel is not evil though.

But the Nakba didn't happen in Lebanon

@@harimauindia5775 true, but the NAKBA caused many palastinians to flee to Jordan, Lebanon and Gaza.

@@ianturpin9180 Where palestinians, there is crime, murder, pare and war, you right...

@@ianturpin9180 and tried to take over

See So it wasn't your place of birth. That's why the other Jews were allowed to Leave Gaza land.

You don't have. Jews got the right to live there or wherever they want, which it's not the same as creating a national state. Someday we all will be living in a internationalist system. I wait hopefully for better days.

Why not? I believe this Rabbi was originally living in Palestine but then emigrated to UK

May God give you a way to leave. Until then, as long as you're stuck in Israel, speak out as much as you can

Please look after yourself and stay strong. Praying for the safety of all the innocent people caught amidst the violence 😢

Its funny they mention electricity and water when its Israel themselves who supply it and are not obligated. They dont get a penny from the PA for these services. If not for them it would have been shut off permanently

Oh Benito, you're such a specialist on Jews...

@@charlesayache6801thats right papi

@@madcatter1 none of your businnes bummer

They got 23 countries already!

At its peak, the Jewish community of Bosnia and Herzegovina numbered between 14,000 and 22,000 members in 1941. Of those, 12,000 to 14,000 lived in Sarajevo, comprising 20% of the city's population.

@@DavidDemurs They lived very good together. Some Muslims saved them while the Nazis came in WW2. Some Jews saved the muslims in the yugoslav wars. Sadly they emigrated to Israel, and a lot lost their life in WW2.

Interesting. How can I find more info on the Jews who saved the Muslims during the Yugoslav wars? Do you have any further info? @@brate2725

Dont forget Jewish Autonomous Oblast (JAO) MADE BY STALIN. SINCE 1928. and i've seen Israeli smirking going into their synagoge, only to be chased out and reported to the police . didn't these israeli knows it was an insult to call JAO "israel of russia" and Russian-soviet jews is the opponent of zionism from day 1?

Omg I've just learned about Yugoslavia and the war in Bosnia that happened with Bosniak, Croat and Serb. I read a story (which is quite accurate from what I learned) about the war from a Chinese author (pretty funny right 🤣). I learned about the conflicts in Ukraine and Gaza and it led me to Yugoslavia, then I turned back here. And I'm extremely surprised that I heard about Sarajevo. I never think Jewish and Sarajevo stand together (like I lost in another universe :)))). The story I said above talk about Sarajevo A LOT, it expressed wishes about a tolerant, diversity Saravejo that can accept all ethnics and religions (like it was in 1984). And I'm very sympathized with all you guys stepped out from wars because I'm a Vietnamese. We all know the cost of war and just want a peaceful world right 😊? Sent loves from Vietnam💕, and a special love to Sarajevo, hope I can visit the city one day ❤

he doesn't, though. he said it started in 1948, but 1929 came before 1948

@@DavidDemurs Give him some wiggle room - he is probably speaking to an uneducated audience.

​@DavidDemurs Body you needs to get lost from the comments section!

Nope not wise at all

It's hard to imagine now, as hearts and minds of too many Jewish people have been captured by Zionism, that most Jews and virtually all religious Jews were against the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine in the early 20th century, many of them clearly stating that it was both immoral and dangerous to all involved. It was the dream of a very vocal and aggressive secular minority.

christians will stand by all jewish people because we are one!

@@leonardnordenstrom1463 A lot of Jewish people are standing with us Muslims. Will they stand with those Jews? Or do Christians play selective and only stand with the Jews who hate Muslims? Keep in mind Muslims have stood with Jews for thousands of years. Muslims have treated Jews better in Islamic countries than the so-called "Christians" in Europe and Asia.

"Let's set the record straight: Judaism is not just a religion, it is a rich and diverse cultural identity with deep historical roots. The founder of the modern Zionist movement, the modern day Moses, was none other than the atheist Theodor Herzl. So to all those who try to deny the ethnic aspect of Judaism, take note: the very founder of modern Israel was an atheist Jew. Let's celebrate the complexity and diversity of our heritage, just like the modern Moses, Theodor Herzl, did. 🇮🇱❤️"

I am a Muslim and want peace for every human being whether they are jew or Muslim or christen everyone has equal rights

Vynikajúce zhodnotenie..😊👍🙏❤️🇸🇰

Pepole like his is danger for jews. Dont want to Israel -dont go, but why cooperate with a enemy?

not a rabbi, paid to speak

​@@madcatter1Well the video states he's a rabbi. So unless you can prove otherwise, I will believe that he is.

@@margaritakleinman5701well if the video says then i guess thats proof that cannot be disputed. SMH, what kind of proof do you want? I know because I am Jewish and I know the qualifications and individuals. Im not here to prove anything, I only stated a fact

​@@madcatter1Ok fine, so then again I ask you, how is it that you know with complete certainty that he is not a rabbi?

​@madcatter1 Shut up punk!

The real Jews hear him, the problem is that it is the zionists that not only do not hear him, but get angry at his words and actions... Religion is but their assassin's mask.

We hear. Hi is traitor and sectant. One of their sect of naturei carta lose his rabbi licence in Israel, afther he walked on Iran demonstration in shabbat.

No completely false in every way

😊👍🙏❤️🇸🇰

True! ❤

I believe ❤

So no "khaybar, khaybar ya yahood!" for him?

@@DavidDemurs trying to be funny ?

@@DavidDemurs you repeat the same thing over and over, because of low iq. three scientific studies have proven there's serious issues with the guns trucks religion crowd

Jesus was jewish.

@@leonardnordenstrom1463 He was Palestinian!!! 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️❤️❤️

love is what a rabbi does.

You are occupying a land that is not yours.

@@rasjidahmova Well said.

How does that make any sense?? Ireland was (and partly remains) occupied by the British???? ​@@rasjidahmova

@@user-un4mi6eh2eA person of middle eastern decent should not be living in Ireland. They should go back to where they came from...if they believe all Jews should leave Israel and have no right to be there. Especially the middle Eastern Muslims living in United States...they really need to leave. They are occupying native land

​@@rasjidahmova You talking about the English in NI?

We all know. Nothing to share like this.

Add malaysia, turkiye, south africa, maldives, mauritania, yemen, tunisia, bolivia, belgium, spain, and ireland, too. Even france, japan, and south korea want ceasefire. Basically everyone supports Palestine, except the evil united states

in fact 153 countries (all the world except USA and theyr proxys

Ironic when china oppresses the Uyghurs

Dont forget South Africa, who are now launching a case at the UN court accusing Israel of genocide.

😢 I just hope it doesn't scare your neighbor into fleeing to Israel, because this is one of the reasons why Jews from my country fled to Israel, it's because it became clear that their safety was no longer a guarantee. This tactic was used to drive up immigration to Israel, Jews left their original homelands and went there in hopes of feeling safe. I am not going to go on on how it's been 75 years and that's still not a guarantee 😥 because this whole thing has been a mess.. a western governmental project that used Jews because they were persecuted (still are, in some places).

Does it prohibit receiving it from the gentiles? if Ottoman empire collapsed and victors decide to give the land to the jews is it prohibited to accept it?

@stephenglasse2743 This passage I quoted is speaking from the destruction of the second temple and onwards, so roughly from 70AD an onwards. If this period in history is post second temple era than seemingly it would be forbidden in any capacity for jews as a nation to establish a country until the arrvial of the moshiach (Messiah).

@@matisyahup613 I've not read much of the talmud but my understanding is that much of it goes, 'Rabbi such-and -such said...' and 'Rabbi so-and-so said...' 'however our sages conclude...' I take it that the prohibition on creating a state would be the latter ie a final conclusion then? If so how do other pious rabbis get around that. Apparently Schlomo Goren chief rabbi of israel although he denied he'd ever called for the destruction of the al-aqsa nevertheless said 'certainly we should have done it and it was a tragedy we didn't'.

@stephenglasse2743 Correct, the talmud is the arguments and logic behind the laws of the Torah. Not every statement is the law. There is another text called the shulchan aruch which is the clear cut laws an observant person must follow. What I quoted in kesubos could be open for debate, however, there is a clear cut halacha (law) that one may not enter the temple mount before the messiah comes. This is not open for debate. Basically even most of the ultra - orthodox who settled in Israel hold by anti-government policies and they openly reject the secular culture of most israelis. This topic is very complex and most will never see eye to eye on it.

@@matisyahup613 I won't keep up the replies lol. Rabbi Shapiro is very passionate, informed and interesting. Do you think his 'admission' , if one can call it that, around the 49 minutes mark that Ultra-orthodox presence in the government could bring the government down is in fact a flaw in his argument? If the Ultra-orthodox have such power not only in Israel but in the government can it really be said Zionism is completely antithetical , hostile, poisonous to Judaism? He also seems to think one can replace the modern state of Israel with any other and Peled seems to think that one needs a secular Palestine from 'the river to the sea' with equal rights for arabs and jews. But surely neither hamas, islamic jihad or, indeed the c45% of Gazans who voted for hamas or the c65% of palestinians who regard oct 7 as 'legitimate resistance' would tolerate a state with arab-Jew equality. Wasn't the only reason Arabs and jews got on pre-1918 because the arabs/muslims had 'superiority' in the Ottoman empire and the Jews were willing to, as Benny Morris puts it be "submissive ..and deferential"?

Because they are called Neturey karta, who oppose the state of israel. They believe when Massiah comes, israel would be a real state for jews. They do not speak hebrew either, because they believe it is the holy language of torah. They speak yiidish. As for me, I am born a jew and I stand with Palestine❤

​@@jettyharrison4377they don't out of a feeling of respect. Other religions don't feel that way because they teach a more intimate connection with God/Allah. Different ways of revering the Creator.

Learning about true judaism from neturei karta is like learning Islam from lSlS. This heretic doesn't even represent 1% of the jewish world

@@user-kf8fl5rm3s what does the Torah say about establishing a Jewish state?

@@jettyharrison4377 I don't know about any restrictions on speaking the Hebrew language, I'm familiar with the commandment against "uttering God's name in vain" which is why they don't directly say "God". The idea is that pronouncing God's name "profanes" it, or undermines His divine attributes, because there's nothing like God, and words don't do Him justice. If they're forbidden from speaking Hebrew (idk anything about that), probably for the same reason, but it might have more to do with the fact that the original Biblical Hebrew, as spoken by Moses, is a dead language.

Nice whataboutism. He obviously acknowledges them, look at his shirt. However he also reveals something that is not very well known and it just reveals Israel's colors more.

Nakba happened because the Palestinians and 5 other Arab states declared war and attacked Israel simply because it became a state. The Palestinians we're supposed to have half the land but they responded in violence. On top of that, 850,000 Arab Jews were expelled from their countries throughout the Middle East and North Africa soon after Israel got its statehood in 1948...because the Muslim leaders got mad about about Israel becoming a states. The Arab Muslims and Palestinians are not helpless little sheep like they portray themselves to be. It's a lie. They are lying to you.

There are more details to what the other commenter states. Nakba is still happening, and wrongfully! Keep learning my friend with an open mind, now that you know the basics.

@@brendasmart553 keeps happening because they keep attacking.

@@rasjidahmova the Torah forbids Jews from a homeland

How is it any worse than any other nation that formed?

De Valera 1945 german embassy...

I agree with you..Give the Palestinan's their homes and land back...it was not the UK or Americas place to give it to the German Jews in 1917...the Belfort declaration..

Balfour declaration