Yess

You should corrected crazy stupid love, because in the last chorus it's mina with dahyun not with tzuyu :)

Where is momo's lines in ready to talk???

thanks for your hard work

Mina has more lines in Catch a Wave

And ended up in 9th place 💀

​@@slaaaayyy23hi slaaaayyy23

YESYESYES

Finna file a mf complaint to jyp and twices managers.

she should be 4th and Chaeyoung 3rd tbh

@@stanbtsforaclearskin chaeyoung just a main rapper and sub vocalist while jeongyeon is lead vocalist and she's the 2nd best vocalist in twice so she deserve to be 3rd:)

@@saiiishaz Chaeyoung is also Twice 5th best vocalist so she sings and rap, she should be 3rd imo and Jeongyeon 4th as a lead vocal. Chaeyoung is MAIN rapper and that's just as important.

@@stanbtsforaclearskin but nayeon is also a lead vocalist so its okay to place chaeng over jeongyeon but not nayeon? that doesnt make sense

@@firewouldburnwood cuz nayeon is jyp’s favourite and also, first she’s a visual, fotg, center so 2nd place is normal, she also dance well so

Fr

Lines ≠ positions. Jeongyeon is the second best Vocalist and Chaeyoung is better tan Mina.

@@maximolucafigueredo the position of main vocalist means they are going to be singing the most often, if momo had the most lines consistently she should be the ‘main vocal’. Main is not synonymous with best, I think it makes sense to give positions out based on what is in the music.

@@isaacmahoney5947 it's based on skills lmao, not who sings the most.

Tysm!

​@moona_k what do you use to create line distribution

@@joycemcneal5244 all song (video like this) or normal distribution

@@moonakline I mean what app

@@joycemcneal5244 flourish studio in google chrome

Good for mina but she should be like 5th😅

Jeong lead and Mina lead NaHyo Main in line distribution

🙄... Ok then lets give Mina's soft vocal parts to Jeongyeon. Jeongyeon is only a leadvocalist. Meanwhile Nayeon is Centre, lead dancer & leadvocalist fotg.. So it's understandable the amount of lines she gets. Mina's most parts of the songs are bridge or prechoruses.. On the previous comebacks Jeongyeon & Tzuyu are singing Prechorus.. Jeongyeon also sings one or two Chorus. Also another thing that i want to say is no one knows the story behind the line distributions. Maybe Jeongyeon is comfortable with less lines.. Jeongyeon even refused to sing the highnotes and most parts in Jihyo's composed song cactus and that parts were given to Nayeon.. So most songs have stories behind that.. So why making like Nayeon & Mina are the only ones who gets treated like main lead.

@@aidentai5867 in reality only Jihyo is Main Vocalist according to the original positions and 2yeon are Lead Vocalist

@@amala7156 My comment was not with the intention of offending anyone, nor the girls. although it is true, we do not know what is behind the distribution of lines of each song but it would be good if the positions were respected a little or for example, (Without doing less to Nayeon) there are several lines that give "unnecessively" to Nayeon but they don't decide, maybe the songs are still a masterpiece 🫶🏼

@@amala7156 💁‍♀️💁‍♀️🙄

No

BRO WHY ARE U EVERYWHERE

​@@Rxnan23_ I get summoned everywhere

Becoz no one knows whats behind the line distribution The members can refuse to sing parts too.. Like Jeongyeon could've got the most lines & highnotes in Jihyo composed song Cactus but she refused to sing the parts & that where given to Nayeon..Nayeon maybe a third best vocalist but she's a centre, lead dancer lead vocalist.. she's gets most lines its understandable.. Jihyo also gets much lines in there songs. Its not like Nayeon always get 1st in all songs💀...

Nayeon being "3rd best vocalist" is very subjective you know

​@@Utaeru nah, that's objective. It's a fact that Jeongyeon is the second best Vocalist in Twice

@@maximolucafigueredo And what proves it ?

​@@UtaeruCheck their stage and see for yourself who the second best vocalist is.

oh, sorry i put the wrong video there, so sorry about it

@@moonaklineoh it’s perfectly all right, I understand how hard it is to create videos! Keep up your hard work!

Yes

Yeah😢

the app is a bit error so the app detect the feel special album distribution as feel special audio because the file name is almost same

the app is a bit error so the app detect the feel special album distribution as feel special audio because the file name is almost same

she literally sang the whole post chorus

​@@seeyadsy227 but it's not a part of the instrumental?

she sang the "ooohh oohhh" in the post chorus

@@itsnotskyy___ So why didn’t count 38sec in Mina’s lines Catch a wave

@@luxu8824 idk

flourish studio in google chrome

the app is a bit error so the app detect the feel special album distribution as feel special audio because the file name is almost same

Its wrong she only has 20 - 30 second in strawberry Based on the live

@@moonaklineNo, she has 50-60 seconds as she does back vocals in most parts. Just because she didn't sing it live doesn't change that

@@moonaklineshe sings all the “ttalgi” and the post chorus parts

Actually overall Sana has more lines than she deserves, so I don't think anyone will scream that she needs lines. Honestly Chaeyoung and Tzuyu should get more lines than. Chaeyoung alongside Jeongyeon should also get more lines than Mina.

Imo the line distribution should be 1. Jihyo 2. Nayeon ( considering that she is the centre and fotg) 3. Jeongyeon 4. Chaeyoung ( same level as Mina in vocals and is a rapper too) 5. Mina 6. Tzuyu ( at least her vocals are relaxed compared to bottom 3) 7. Dahyun ( since she is a rapper) 8. Sana 9. Momo ( she doesn't rap much so yeah)

oh you're right about reducing their lines! momo is the main dancer so she can get dancebreaks and center, dahyun can keep has standout rap lines, and sana and tzuyu can stand there doing nothing and be backup dancers💞 (because momo is the only one who gets utilized as a dancer fairly well) hey, i have a CRAZY suggestion. i know you aren't going to believe it, but MAYBE, jeongyeon can get some of nayeon's lines? then jihyo would get more than nayeon and show that she's the main vocal, and jeongyeon could finally show off her vocals? just a CRAZY, SILLY idea i know

She is a sub vocalist with the worst technique in the group. Her voice can be nice if she sings in falsetto or sings in her lower register but anything else is just not healthy, she already shines with dance and rap, just leave it at that

​​@@victjsofjsmdngor She is not only a sub vocalist She's also a great rapper and in the past (2016-2019) She could get more rap parts. Luckily she's getting now, but mind aside 3mix other vocal tecnique's pretty the same

@@pinklamborghini6446 they should just leave her with rapping and dancing then, i’m sorry but she has regressed one of the most in TWICE (almost all of them have a bit). Predebut she was a better singer than Tzuyu, Sana, and Dahyun, and could’ve possibly supported but JYPE forced her the nasally route which she has went too far with and now her voice is damaged from that technique rather than her bold and possibly supported old technique. She should really be pushed as a rapper and dancer (which she already is).

@@victjsofjsmdngor it's not like that for all the songs and her voice is not damaged lol. Her voice in songs for her melody project recently and the recent songs with her singing the middle register is quite good.

@@yeonjundani well she can recover but you can’t deny that singing in a poor technique has caused her voice to regress.

everyone make mistake, no one is perfect, even if i make many mistake in this video i can make an updated video, and i need to tell you something, making this kind of video is not easy and it was really hard, so if there were mistake, it is because i didn't focus, so hard to make this video, sometimes i need to check the line distribution is correct or not, and sometimes i can't find the correct distribution, so now you know the reason why this video had mistakes, and now i can activate "just ignore this channel comment, because she was a hater of us that can make great videos"

Yes. Nayeon is really main Vocalist

@@mr.farkhan563main vocalist isn't the one with most lines it's the best vocalist of the group and it's clearly jihyo...

jihyo is main vocal

@@mr.farkhan563 no, jihyo is

STOP say JIHYO main vocalist NAYEON is If JIHYO is main vocalist, jihyo should get more line than nayeon