Watch the episode again carefully. C A R E F U L L Y... now... when Pinkie Pie realized the gravity of the situation and that her friends would just dismiss her as a clone she became sad and distraught. Even going so far as "... poking at the ground drawing frowny faces." according to Rainbow dash. It was the sad Pinkie Pie who gave Twilight the idea for a test, none of the other Pinkies would've known about it and Pinkie knew what was at stake. Once she knew what the test was and what it would take to win her friends back she was willing to go as long as it took to do so. Like you said in the video, Pinkie had to teach the other Pinkies who her friends names were. The clones couldn't possibly have had the strong emotional bond that the real Pinkie Pie had for her friends, they weren't around long enough to form that, only the real Pinkie Pie had that kind of love for her friends. Your honor, the defense rests their case.

Pinkey kept records of everyone in Ponyville and every party she ever threw. If the surviving clone were to discover these records she could read them and be able to rattle off information as if she had been there. A strong clue that she was a clone was the time in the Castle of the two sisters when she discovered that she could play the organ and hadn't known. Frankly, I'm surprised that that point wasn't mentioned.

if that wasnt the real pinkie the elements of harmony would reject her

I like the (grim) headcanon that while clones of a clone are single minded, and lack knowledge, the clones of originals are basically same as original and given time, they'd develop their own personality That would explain why Pinkies first clone acted so close to Pinkie prime... Which means that the last clone(or was it prime pinkie?) Twilight zapped was basically it's own pony, and Twilight killed em ... With no remorse, kinda grim

The real Pinkie Pie was the one who was suprised to see the other clones and was very sad because her friends didn't realize her. Twilight Sparkle was Pinkie Pie,s best friend and she knew her very well. She kept the test according to Pinkie Pie.

IF twilight would kill Pinkie she wouldn't exploud with confetti and her magic wouldn't go back to the pool.

I think the real pinkie lived

i was watching a funny clone meme and then for some reason i remembered this episode from my childhood from 9 years ago i aint even part of the fandom i remember when she made the real pinkie vanish and ive always wondered what happened after

I believe twilight DID NOT kill the real pinkie

I aways thought Twilight just did the test not ‘cos she thought she could find the original Pinkie but just so she could find the ‘perfect’ Pinkie. The one that she felt was the perfect version, who could stay focused the longest uk...

no she is still here

Even if this video was right, which it's not, you'd notice that in a later episode it is in fact revealed that twilight didn't get every clone.

I think that it is the original pinky because if it was a clone the tree of harmony would have known and the elements wold not have worked on he, plus if it was a clone pinky would have been hopping around and shouting fun all day.

When each clone is destroyed their memories and their tiny bit of pickie pick essence returned to the original so the original probably just used the memory she had the most of

If the real Pinkie was killed, then the tree of Harmony wouldn't have accepted the Pinkie Clone

The tree of harmony would not have accepted the wrong pinki pie and the element would not have worked

How come the clone could use the laughter element????!!!!😕... if she was one...

i would believe there is one flaw in that saying (that I noticed). None of the clones would have the desire to stay with the rest as much as Pinkie pie. They didn't have time to build that strong relationship with them. If there is one thing that Pinkie would do ANYTHING for it's her friends. The clones wanted to stay for the fun the world had to offer, Pinkie wanted to stay with her friends. The clones didn't have nearly as strong of a reason to focus as Pinkie Pie would've.

Don't forget the real one was all sad and the one that survived was the one that was sad

The real Pinkie is still live laugh loving

If pinky bibles are placed , how come she can talk so fluently when the others only talk about fun stuff

I think the real pinkie lived because the fake pinkies would never care of the real pinkie pies friends, but real pinkie would that's why she survived and she got sad because she was worried about losing her friends .

But if the surviving pinkie pie was an actual clone wouldn’t the tree of harmony recognise that it wasn’t the real pinkie? Like, I don’t think the clone could use the elements of harmony because I think the tree would’ve definitely recognised that it wasn’t the real pinkie pie

I think the pinkie we knew survived and escaped whille a clone lived, sping on the fake pinky in the interview. Then when the main six got captured by chrysalis is when the switch back happened, perhaps the real pinkie switched spots with the clone to save the fake pinkie from chrysalis. It's def not bulket proof but a cool theory.

Pinkie pie is probably a clone, but not to mention.The test would be boring for anyone and anyone would tried to distract themselves.The test was to sit still and literally watch paint dry I think anyone would try to distract themselves especially pinkie pie She is basically a pony with ADHD that test would be boring for anyone And pinkie pie can be distracted easily in serious situations. We see that a lot in the show so. If I had to rewrite the episode I would be like every pinky pie is from a different dimension or that something is a little wonky on them like their face or cutie mark That test. Would have been boring for anyone though. So I think it's safe to say she is probably a clone Because I think everyone would try to distract themselves a little if they were forced to sit down and watch pink literally dry And if you move an inch, you get theblasted with magic and sent back to where you came from. Or even die

If she wasn’t the real pinky, the element of harmony will reject her

To be honest, I didn’t even like twilight before she became a princess but now her à la corn for with the wavy hair, I kinda like I’m not like a big fan of her old style but in G5, I actually really like how she’s drawn and many years when she has the flowing Main

If the Original Pinkie pie Would use the Laughter Element Then How did it Work?????!!! On Clone Pinkie pie

The pinkie we have is the original pinkie pie because i don't think the elements of harmony would work without the original pinkie

Watching the episode I was Just saying I would Die there I have ADHD. And I Would Have no choice because My ADHD Trys to Murder me

1. Pinkie sense the clones wouldn't have that... 2. Elements of harmony wouldn't chose the clone.

if this Pinkie was a clone how'd she know to write a letter to Celestia at the end of the episode?

she is still alive. I agree.

The only problem with this theory is that we saw when clones try to use the elements of harmony (when the evil 6 tried to) the tree knows it’s not them and kills them and pinkie used the elements multiple times after that

When Twilight got all the pinkie pies ,Rainbow Dash put the sad pinkie pie in the back (which was the real one ). Then we see how the one in the front left but real one in back Survived.

RIP Pinkie Pie 😢💔

Just because there are clones of Pinkie running around Equestria doesn’t mean the real one is dead

There’s a theory called The Swamp Man, where (I can’t remember exactly I’m doing this off the top of my head so don’t blame me if I mess up a little) a man in s swamp (idk why he’s in a swamp) gets struck by lightning and he dies, completely spitting up the atoms in his body as a result. The atoms then (I’m sorry but I can’t remember why) reform into his exact shape, a 1:1 replica, every atom, possibly in a different place on earth bc I think it had something to do with teleportation,which means his brain is still the same, he has the same memory, same personality, everything, is he the same man as he was before? This is just a theory that I heard on the internet but I think it’s interesting to think about and really questions this video.(actually it mostly just questions the pony with the eye glass thing but you get he point)

she did survived since she went away then came back cause we see the clone that did survive in the episode when the opening of rairitys mannhattan boutique

Let's state the obvious first. Clone massacre is completely inhumane. Regardless of wheither the original pinkie survived, Twilight is a monster way worse than half the villains she fights. Arguments supporting that pinkie's a clone: -Sunburst's story about pinkie diving in the pool. It's clear as day only clones do. -Theory of probability. Given clones are different, which is why some of them survived longer, it's very likely the real pinkie pie died, especially considering(as already spoken in video) that pinkie gets distracted at all the important moments Debunking the arguments supporting pinkie's real: -"Well actually, the experiment was genius because only pinkie could sit and live for her friends..." except the clones also had a very strong desire, I bet they did not want to die. -"Pinkie would not remember stuff that happened before". She remembers everybody's birthday and many other stuff, I hardly doubt memory alone is doing the job. Provided she immediately decided to rest, she could easily learn the basics from all the stuff pinkie has. Then she would only need to simulate well enough until eventually she wouldn't need to(nhansen197 explained it pretty well) -"The elements of harmony wouldn't work". Except pinkie's element of harmony is laughter. Arguably, a clone is even better than her at it. Furthermore, it may percieve clone as a real one, since there is no physical difference(that we know of). "BUT CHRYSALIS-" chrysalis' clones and pond clones are completely unrelated, probably work completely different, so that proves nothing Overall: There is no direct proof. Theory probability means pinkie is LIKELY to be a clone, but it's not a guaranteed chance. Sunburst could be mistaken. Maybe he understood pinkie wrong, or something else. As usual with complex moments, there is no way to tell for granted, "yes" or "no". I stand with no, because it's more funny and exceptionally fucked up to the point of nightmare fuel(look at fan-made alternative ending, kek). And also way more likely statistically

No we all know that's true because On nightmare night you know how on the first Episode They fried luna And then on NightMayor night Stay or thigh it was I Nightmare moon so that's true She is not the real pinky

I agree that the pinky we know had a cloned body, but I feel if twilight actually killed the real pinky her soul and all of her memories would’ve gone into another one of the clones and transitioning until there was one surviving and if twilight killed the last pinky surviving pinky would be actually dead

rainbow dash also have a fault in pinkie pie death, because she distracted them

I think the real Pinkie wasn't killed both because the duplicates were idiots unlike the original who is just naive, and because she remembers Maud and all her sisters the Duplicates had none of the originals memories the duplicates even needed to be reminded if her own name once even more she could still wield her element when they later faced and took out Tirek.

Bro why is your clone smarter then you?!

It all just sad... pinkie was my 2nd favourite character in the show and plus you know what pinkie pie said " I just ad to be with my FRIEND'S she didn't say "I have to have fun" or something like that.

A clone could have just spoken to someone about hopping thru the pool at some point no?

4:35 - 5:23 In The Hall of the Mountain King

NOOOOOOOO PINKIE😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🐴💗

In one episode we saw a pinkie clone so i think that should be considered too

Plausible, but unlikely We know for sure at least one clone survived, but even if the original did die, who’s to say her spirit couldn’t just poses the surging clone? We have the phrase “it’s Pinkie Pie, don’t question it” for a reason

Actually this is wrong the main 6 knew that pinkie pie missed them

I understand the possibility but no it is impossible that pinkies an imposter because a clone got apple Jack's name wrong after being teached😊so what is the likenieness that a inposter could rember etherthing and act it to Wich I think means pinkie pie would have to do a lot more teaching any way it was less then a day I doubt some clones even got the lessons also pinkie pie wrote a letter to princess celestial after woulds I do not believe pinkie pie mentened sending letters to a princess And how would some clone think to write to a princess she has never seen.?❤

2:25 sine and cosine, CLEVER!!

Im actually ailve! The clones was vanished because I told twligh a idea that none pinkie would know. Im glad @thecwiggum knows too.

I haven’t watched Sawtooth since his channel started to grow. Did he delete his channel? I can’t find it anymore

Ooooorrr.....the writers just forgot exactly what happened...butt.....either way.....sure...

I think if the clown Pinky goes to the pool again maybe the real Pinky will come back again so the real Pinky isn't dead

The real pinkie is NOT dead okay. There is NO way the real pinkie is dead. Pinkie has adhd and she would do anything for her friends even if it means staying in one place. It was life or death. Besides the last pinkie was sad. EVERY OTHER PINKIE WAS HAPPY

6:59 YESSSSS uhh wait i mean wait what do i say again?

the element works for pinkie so she is the real one when the queen of the changlings made clones of the mane six the elements did not work so if the clone was left then the element would not work for her :)))

Pinky per just said a single yes that she was pulled out of the pool all of Twilight sparkles cleverness will go down in the sand no more purple pony princess

wilson weaveing yourself into the lore?

FINALY SOMEONE WHO AGRES

1 Year, lol!

Watch the episode again rainbow dash throw the pinkie at the ground and the pinkie pie that servived was the pinkie that rainbow trhow at the ground and that pinkie was the real one because she didn't run for fun

5:48 can someone tell me what is this sad background music🥺

Twilight I like did not kill the real Pinky 😟if you want to know so you have to watch the episode again

5:00 Sine is getting distracted Edit: desperate*

Hopefully the real pinkie lived

7:07 twilight is my fav dont you dare try to do anything

HELP WHAT..

Remember when the video was came out and i watched it

But didn't one clone escape? Sunburst could've interacted with that pinkie about the mirror pool for Celestia's sake

You’re right she did friends I know like what like 1000 years but he also did see what can happen to dream. I don’t have a magical key like a person coming into dream to dream is a different world.

She is living If it the clone then how Do You know everything about the elements So she is alive

-Fun fact:- pinkie died of diabetes not beacuse of the cloning situation

disagreed, remember that TWILIGHT USED A SPELL TO BRING BACK THE CLONES IF SHE HIT THE REAL PINKIE PIE IMAGINE WHAT WILL HAPPEN

I actually saw that

She’s… dead..? 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

where was real pinkie sitting?

Or sunburst is a clone 😂

THE PRIME PINKIE WENT TO ANOTHER WORLD. I realized that when pinkie first ‼️dived‼️ Into the water, she became the "clone" that the second pinkie pulled out. Then the rest was pulled out as the prime and second pinky created another set of clones. And so on This theory i might have made up means that prime pinkie IS alive but her friends are clones!!!9£!@#&(_;£)91!

is that a chicken

Same

Pinki did

I don’t care what this video says clone or not Pinkie pie is fine just the way she is all the mane six had to do was get rid of all the clones but leave one intact

I don’t get it

This doesn't. Look if that's the clone pinkie pie then what happened to the real pinkie pie?! Huh?!

How come the clone use the element

Can you look into the my little pony horror series

NOOOOOOOO😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😊

It makes no sense 😕😕😕😕😕😔😔😔❤❤❤

It' is not ture

I dont think so she killed the real Pinkie

...

😂😂😡😡🥹🥹😭😭

🌈🌈✨✨🎈🎈

😥😥😥😥

Lie