"Jacob, find someone else, mate." 😂😂😂 You will remember that

“Whose fantasy was this?” Stephanie Meyer’s. 😂

I think Bella went months in a depressive state, barely eating, barely sleeping- so I guess she kind of lost it and she starts hallucinating Edward whenever her body senses danger cause of how often he told her that he would always be there to protect her and that his job was to keep her safe 😭

To be fair to Jasper, he was in his home. He was comfortable around Bella, so didn’t feel the need to use his powers to be in soldier mode like at the ballet studio.. that’s why everyone was so on point. He can calm people down, influence them. That’s what was with the weird look he gave her when Alice gave her the dress at school. He was putting Bella in a more accepting mood for a gift/party. He also feels everyone else’s feelings… so when Bella started bleeding? He got their blood lust. Poor guy was going through it!!

I know that is part of the lore to make fun of jacob for never using a shirt, but in the books Billy told Jake to take care of his clothes when he transform because he wasn't gonna buy him anymore

I cannot believe you went through the entire movie thinking that Edward was actually appearing like a ghost all the time lol

People tend to laugh at Bella screaming in her sleep, but they forget that she was traumatized after being attacked and tortured by James. Before, Edward was there every night to take care of her while she slept. Now she is alone, if she has nightmares remembering that moment there is no one to calm her or console her.

Dude - you’re crushing it… first reactor I’ve seen that can critique the weak parts, do decent analysis of the relationships and, actually enjoy the good/creative elements. Well done and keep’em coming!

My absolute favorite scene out of all of the Twilight movies is Bella sitting in the chair,seasons changing, accompanied by Lykke Li's beautiful song...and then her ridiculous screams ruin everything 😅😂

I'm sure others have already mentioned it, but Edward's appearances in these scenes are Bella conjuring the image of him. He's not actually there - Edward did in fact leave her be and did not contact her during their time apart. The movies didn't convey that properly enough unfortunately 😂 I'm glad you're having fun with it, though I'm still hopeful you'll enjoy the next few movies (Eclipse especially!). Some parts of the story are actually quite good, so I hope you enjoy them moving forward!

Even if it’s a bit silly to watch, I really connected with the portrayal of depression in this movie, it was so accurate to my own experience. The feeling of just sitting and dissociating as the months and your own life passes you by, not taking care of yourself, not thinking about or feeling anything even when you’re aware that it’s not healthy.

“Edward!? Hey buddy…. Sparkly✨ I wanna call him sparkles!!” 😂😂😂

The deeper explanation for Bella's depression is actually that she's going through addiction withdraw. Edward explains in the first movie that his venon is made to attract people to them, changes their appearance, their smell, all of it, to make the hunt easier. She tastes the venon every time they kiss (reason why every time they kiss she basically attacks him), she's exposed to it every time they are near each other (making it easier for her to sleep if he's in the room with her). And then she is cut off from it. Like a drug addict being cut off from drugs. So she is in pain, she is having hallucinations, she feels like she can't survive without it. And then she starts her recovery process, and gets better, she learns how not to let that control her life anymore. It is a tiny bit deeper than just unhealthy codependency.

Jasper’s weird look at the beginning when Bella is upset about Alice’s gift is him using his power on Bella! He can control people’s emotions, so he made Bella feel better about receiving the gift

I think the fact that the book explains things in more detail and why things are the way they are is what they left out of the movies that makes them... a little funnier than intended. The reasoning for the vampires being sparkly is to lure in their prey (I get distracted by sparkly things all the time, would work on me lol) They could have *shown* this attribute with any of the human eating vampires and show it lures humans to them... but they kinda ditched all that and they just sparkle... sometimes... but mostly Edward.

Jaspers stare in the beginning was him influencing her mood so she would say yes

None of those 3 are healthy. They are all toxic. Jacob becomes more so as the movies go on. Charlie is the only normal character in this thing. Charlie is awesome.

Also the way Bella distances herself for months and is obviously going through a mental health crisis- and the SECOND she starts talking to her old friends again Mike tries to shoot his shot 😭

Last comment on this, I swear 😂 Edward wasn't appearing to Bella, she was so depressed and missed him so much she started hallucinating... She promised him she wouldn't put herself in danger so the "guilt" when she puts herself in danger helps the hallucinations... I FEEL REALLY WEIRD EXPLAINING THIS. It felt very normal when I first read/watched it, but yeah LMAO

You talked how she can’t live without the guys but the entire movie she is talking to Alice in unsend mails. Those two actually are good friends

Oscar saying that Jacob should find another girl to love makes me laugh, considering how the story progresses 🙈

I do think it’s kind of funny how so many people treat these movies like litmus tests for what relationships are supposed to look like… a story about teenage vampires and wolves… is not the standard representation for healthy relationships 💀 it’s a fantasy story.

I think you definitely should watch @CinemaTherapy’s breakdown of the Twilight relationships once you finish the movies. They talk about it in detail from a psychological and filmmaker perspective

Since its all out "Jacob find someone else" It hits so different when you know what happens

The imaginary Edwards are exactly that. Imaginary. He’s not popping up on his own accord. It’s Bella’s brain showing him to her.

These are notes and responses to you that I typed up while watching your reaction. It’s been a while since I read the books, but I think her nightmares all center around Edward being nowhere. She dreams of the places they would go and he’s never there. When he left, he hid all the gifts he gave her under her floorboards. She doesn’t even have pictures of him. It must have been described in the book better because I remember feeling like her nightmares were so impactful and meaningful and how horrifying it would be to experience that but as I type this, I can’t fathom it that way. The screaming seems excessive. LOL time and distance, I guess. In the book she didn’t ride a motorcycle with a stranger. All she did was cross the street until she realized they weren’t the same people then she turned around and went back to Jessica. I think they wanted to make it more dramatic and visually interesting for the movie. The relationship with Jacob was not about getting Edward’s attention. She was trying to do things that were dangerous because when she did, she would hear Edward’s voice telling her off and she didn’t experience the same level of emotional trauma from that as she did from actually thinking of him and talking about him. In the book she never saw him until she was in the water. She never wanted Mike to think she was interested. She wanted the movie thing to be a group thing but everyone else got sick. Mike was sick at the movies and in the book, Bella spent the next 24 hours on her bathroom floor also being sick. I agree these relationships are toxic, but I think they were less so in the book. They seem to amp things up for the movie. Jacob became a wolf for the first time the night of the movies. Bella was not thinking about wanting a relationship with Jacob. She was thinking about how much it hurts that Edward is gone. She was thinking about what she had lost. She never really considers Jacob as a serious relationship option. Edward is not reappearing. That is all Bella’s imagination. He has no control over it. Nor does he know it’s happening. In the book Jacob thought it was Carlisle on the phone. That scene with the red cloaks at the beginning wasn’t a dream. It was just the movie showing what would happen later. Don’t know why they thought that was necessary. In the book when she stops him from showing himself, he thinks he’s dead and they are meeting in heaven. It takes a few seconds before he realizes that they are both still alive. In the book there was no fight when they were with the Volturi. They just talk and threaten a lot. Obviously, the movie people wanted more drama and visually stimulating stuff. I don’t remember the leading-on of Jacob being so blatant in the books. I feel like she was pretty clear that she wasn’t interested and only wanted to be friends. He just wouldn’t accept it. It’s possible I’m just not remembering clearly. It’s been a long time.

I think that they never explain it, but the reason why Jacob (and the other werewolves) are always shirtless is because his body temperature is higher than that of a normal human, so he is always too hot, and also because when he turns into werewolf, his clothes get ripped, so wearing less is better. Another thing that didn't translate from the books to the movies is that Bella is not feeling comfortable as a human, that's why she can't even fit with her friends, and when she discoveres the vampires, she feels like this is the right life for her, this is what she was born and destined to be, a vampire, and she can't wait to live her real life and be her real self. Her gift also hints that she is meant to be a vampire, not a human. And last, the relationship between Bella and Edward is not really love, but more like a supernatural drug addiction, both of them. Edward even said that she is like his personal heroin. They are supposed to be the perfect prey and the perfect predator, attracting each other more than anything else. It's not a normal, human love and relationship, but an uncontrollable supernatural physical attraction dangerous for both of them, but they try to make the most of it and survive. They are like a juicy fly and a colorful carnivorous flower, not a two lovebirds. Loved your reaction, you seem to get it all right and I laughed a lot with you.

There's A LOT of explanation missing that is in the books about why the feelings all around are so intense. It kinda makes me sad because I think that's where a lot of the mocking comes from. And yes, Charlie is the best - dad goals 100% :)

There are some awesome HIGH QUALITY short films about each character’s life. The complexities of the more grim looking vampire is actually the most kind and they essentially broke him away from his wife and offed her. She was almost a sort of shield to the others influences around him which made him a threat in Arro’s mind. It’s a long long beautiful story. Arro was also supposed to be like 17 but they made him and older man lol. that actor plays a great role in the series called Omen as well ❤

Charlie is the BEST character in the whole series.

For my mom, it was those darn Harlequin romance novels that I found so cheesy when I read through some of them when I was a teenager. I thought that the books were ridiculous! Now, here I am with these darn Twilight stories! I love your approach in your reactions to these movies! I find myself laughing along with you! My guilty, cheesy pleasure! You're the best!

cinema therapy is the name of the channel who analyzes twilight! and you’re completely right, they’re all unhealthy and toxic

I laugh each time when Jacob tries to warn Edward about the treaty when he was the one that broke the treaty in the first movie when he told Belly about what the Cullens were.

I love the possibility song where Bella is on the chair and seasons passed. I think we all have experienced a broken heart before

I love The Twilight Saga with all it's camp and flaws. This series gives me comfort. I came upon your reaction to Twilight by accident. I'd never watched a film reaction before. I enjoyed it so much, I immediately watched the next one. Excited to see you react to Eclipse! Notifications are turned on!

"Jacob, find someone else mate." 👀👀 37:17

"OH, SHIVERS!" is my new favorite line

I definitely recommend checking out Cinema Therapy's take on the Twilight series, but I would watch the rest of the films first... Cinema Therapy is awesome, btw. For those of us who can't afford it in real life, that channel does a pretty great job of providing some therapeutic gems while also analyzing really great films.

Opening quote is from "Romeo and Juliet" Thess violent delights, have violent ends...

I love how you always genuinely enjoy the movies and how on point your reactions are, not overreacting nor emotionless, but real and authentic; and how you get to understand the characters instead of judging. I’m loving your channel.

I literally stopped what i was doing and said ooh i gotta watch cocoa couch's new reaction now!! ❤️❤️❤️

The most confusing apart about the fight at the beginning, is HOOOOOOOW was Jasper allowed to go to school everyday if he was that incapable of containing himself. Lol

In the book after Edward broke up with her she kept running after him because she knew once she stopped she would never be able to find him again and she would have to face the pain…. Then after all those months every night she had the same nightmare. She was running in the woods after Edward until finally she couldn’t remember what she was running after.. that black nothingness is what made her scream every night to the point where her Dad gave up waking her. So sad and so dramatic and so perfect

25:34 - "I think about jumping, off of very tall somethings, just to see you come running, and say the one thing I've been wanting but no"

As a fan of these movies, it is refreshing to see someone who is positive and just having fun. Very nice good times.

I love the way you approach every movie/series with sincerity, even if it might be kind of a silly series like this one. Silly in the sense that, like, there are memes and goofs about it. Your reactions are always so genuine!

🐺 1) The reason Jacob and the guys are always shirtless is because animals like dogs wolves have higher body temperature. 2) The wolf pack, in animal form, share a "hive mind" and can feel, know everything each other is thinking, feeling. 3) Edward's not really there. It's all in Bella's mind because she was too desperate to still feel him.

Mmm....Cheesy Goodness! Although I love the movies, I also know they're not perfect. If possible, I would probably change most of the cast, dialogue & some story changes. Charlie is the best! My favorites are actually the last 2 movies: Breaking Dawn I & II. Thanks for reacting!

Bella's dreams weren't just "im screaming cause Edward is gone", she was having nightmares associated her near death as well as Edward being killed.

Michael Sheen who plays Aro in these films..very clearly had an absolute blast playing Aro... Just every time you see him he looks like he's having so much fun. Love that for him tbh. And he does speak fondly of his time filming these films.

I stand by what I said on the previous reaction. I still like them after all these years. They are a huge guilty pleasure for me. My favorite line " As soon as you put the dog out" Love it .

I used to be a Jacob girl, grew up and fell in love with Robert as an actor, then circled back around to watch the movies again and realized they’re all awful and toxic af. (Still love the movies tho cause DRAMA 😂)

I always thought that Bella's depression would've been better if relationships with a vampire created a type of bond that, when broken, makes the partners feel like this. As if being around vampires causes some sort of physiological change the longer you're exposed.

I love your reactions. You're attentive, your thoughts are on point everytime, you do not overact, and you really immerse yourself into the movies you watch. I enjoy watching you)

I love your reactions, thank you for this!!!

Thank you for doing this so quickly!❤

Just wanna say I was a Jacob fan who shipped him with Bella, a lot lol Although I did like Edward too, but yeah. Jacob can be even more toxic than Edward, btw!! 😂 "Sorry I shouldn't be laughing, this is serious" LMAO (proceeds to giggle right after). SHE'S SCREAMING LIKE KATNISS DID AFTER THE FIRST HUNGER GAMES you're gonna KILL ME ahahahaha Charlie is best character for real. JACOB TAKING OFF HIS SHIRT IS GREAT OK LOL It was one of the scenes released before the movie and everyone was freaking out. I read the book before watching the movie and I was simply freaking out. And Im so sorry for live commenting but this is just too good, I love this movie AAAAAAAAAAA

The worst part is Edward can't do out-of-body projecting. Which means Bella's literally having symptoms of psychosis! 19:54 Also, you're just pickin' up on that?? 😂

22:20 I don’t know if it’s the same video but there’s a KZfaq channel called Cinema Therapy where a film director and therapist reacted to their relationship and it was definitely a fun watch

I subbed cause of your reaction to Twilight - and now watching your reaction to New Moon it was worth it! Absolutely love your reasoning and how you find some parts really hilarious. Can't wait to watch the next 3 with you!

In the book, Bella was in a catatonic state: meaning she was under so much "stress" her mind shut down. I like to think of it more as "withdrawals" from Edward. Remember, everything about him invites others in. He's like a drug that she's being weened off of. Hence the hallucinations and risky behavior. Jacob was correct when he stated that Bella would have moved on if EC had stayed away a bit longer. Personally I'm Team Alice!

i just had a really bad day and watching this video made me feel so much better. thank you so much, you are really funny hahah everytime you say shivers i don't know why it makes me laugh! can't wait to see the next reaction

SOmethiing they dont make clear in the movies is she always felt like she never belonged or fit in with humans, and so thats why she was so on board with becoming a vampire its also why her blood smells so good to vampires especially edward and its also why she already has a power, a shield, to protect her from other vampires powers.

I’m here for the Charlie of it all 👌 lol

Edward was NOT astral projecting!! Bella’s was just straight up hallucinating. It’s crazy to me that so many people think Edwards being manipulative. And side note: he was in the same clothes from Bella’s birthday when we saw him in Rio, barely eaten. He was very depressed also.

Not me coming to comments to explain why Bella was seeing Edward the entire movie hahaha. Everyone here beat me to it I guess lol. We may have read the books years ago, but the receipts come out when needed 😂 Love your reactions!

I actually find Bella’s depression kinda relatable as a teenage girl who had severe depression when this movie and book came out

Love the lighting, Oscar! Looks like a sunset setting behind you. Nice touch ✨

Can't wait for your reaction to Rosalie's backstory 🙏🙏🙏

If you ever find yourself struggling to watch twilight, just know that no one dislikes these movies more than Robert Pattinson himself 😂 The movies portray super toxis behaviour. Bella has no personality apart from Edward and I wish they didn't romanticize such codependant relationships among teenage girls. In my teen years I was in a relationship with a guy whom I made my only personality trait, I lost all my interests, hobbies and distanced myself. It took me 2 years to recover, find myself and get my personality back after the relationship ended. It was one of the hardest things to undergo. Cinema therapy's videos about twilight are very interesting, I definitely recommend watching them!

I completely understand! You get invested. The next one and the last one are my favorites. Keep going😎 you are so good at reactions! I enjoy them all. Can’t wait to see your next franchise! Have you done Back to the Future?

I'm looking forward to the Maze Runner trilogy next!! I was a teenager in the Twilight era and never liked the concept of relationship portrayed nor been obsessed over the characters, but it was hilarious to watch with friends 😂 so now seeing clips or reactions brings out some funny nostalgia.

Edward was not actually communicating with her- she was imagining him there and it’s much easier in the books to understand those scenes when Edward appears…. When he finds out she was doing dangerous things on purpose to “see” him, he is shocked and they skimmed over that part in the movie

Edward did actually leave her alone, she was hallucinating :p It's so much fun watching your reactions to these 😂 I can't wait for the next movies!!

“Whose fantasy was this?” 🤣😭 I have to admit, rewatching these makes me realize my brain was fried when I was 11 Lmaoo

I always knew it was a hallucination, I guess the vampire powers can confuse people, but they usually only have one.

Seeing you pop up on my feed. Bless 🎉. I feel better 😊 Ps: your lighting is better ❤

"Going through the stages of grief" "Sorry this is serious." That smirk after!! LOL!

i'm sure you know by now that Edward was never really there. He was conjured up by adreniline, (sp), pain, and desire. Only when Bella was in danger were all the ingredients there to make her hallucination or vision or whatever manifest. so it wasn't edward keeping her from moving on. the book explained this better than I did. it also explained that the more she was with Jake, the more she healed, and she does love him and is not trying to manipulate him. it's just that she is IN love with Edward, and it's not the same as what she feels for Jake.

38:08 Why is it up to Bella to determine if a guy friend likes her too much? She has made it clear that she wants to be with Edward. As a female engineer, I have tons of guy friends. If they like me and just being my friend hurts their feelings then I feel like they should make that choice for themselves. If I had to guess how each of them thought & what they could emotionally handle, then I would just give up and have no friends.

I have to say again that I’m impressed on how well youve understood both these movies so far. You’re doing a great job and I’ll say it even for a guy lol I am very impressed. Except the only thing you did misunderstand was Edward appearing and disappearing. Edward was doing that he doesn’t have such a power. Bella was just so depressed that she would hallucinate him anytime she was in danger. So that’s why she figured she should keep doing dangerous things so she could keep on hallucinating him. So yeah not healthy at all.

Love your laugh man 😂😂😂

Yeah I'm 50/50 with this one like I love the werewolf stuff cause that's awesome but everything else is ugh but the next ones get better after this

I love seeing Mr coco coach flabbergasted by Bella's actions 🤣🤣🤣

"sorry i shouldnt be laughing, this is serious" took me OUT

I can't wait to see the rest of the series with you!! I think you should just take some days off work and binge lol...YAY!😊

This was very fun to watch! Next movie I would probably say is peak awkward when it comes to the triangle but the level of yikes can get even higher. However the score to the next movie was done by Howard Shore who did Lord of the Rings so that's something

So after about a decade I'm rewatching the entire saga. I sorta watched them through an idealized lens when I was younger since I was obsessed and I wanted to see how I feel about them now with a fresh set of eyes. Turns out, they're a whole lot less cringe than I was afraid of, and I loved New Moon this time around when I wasn't the biggest fan back then, mainly bc I was all about Edward and he was barely in this one. A lot of people may try to use qualifiers like "I know these are cheesy BUT..." but I say you don't even have to use these statements at all since we don't do that with most other movies. Just enjoy what you enjoy and let that be that. Can't wait to see you continue the rest of the series! It's gonna be a wild ride lol.

I'm Team Charlie! I have two daughters so there is the perpetual fear of failure as a parent. 😅

“parkour!” i screamed !!! 😂

Yay been looking forward to this one 😊 got a snack and I’m ready to watch this before I go to sleep 😊

Again, great reaction! I love that you`re having fun with these movies. That's what it's kinda all about. 😂 FYI: Edward is not really there in those scenes where he's appearing, Bella is hallucinating.

I AMM BEGGING YOU DO THE TWILIGHT PITCH MEETINGS

I am 100% loving your reaction. This is fantastic ❤ I actually was turned on to the book series by a coworker when I found out they were making the movie I was intrigued. I had a 18 hour trip to Hawaii she let me borrow the first book in the series and I got sucked in, no pun intended. 😅 I don’t know what it was about it but I just I couldn’t put it down. I was in Hawaii and every night before I went to bed I would read twilight. Finished twilight while I was in Hawaii on vacation went to Walmart bought new moon, but then got so angry at the characters not even halfway through new moon. I put it down and didn’t pick it up for three weeks. My least favorite book of the entire series it had to happen, but I did not enjoy it but the books and the movies to follow are absolutely some of my favorites. The characters grow the story grows you get sucked in it’s great.

The Twilight movies have a special place in my heart because I read the books all four of them six times! The movies really aren't that great but the books are incredible!

Yeeees I want you to watch cinema therapy video but after all saga because of spoilers. Those videos are fun to watch as movies😊 and I would love to also watch your reaction for those

Ah, one more thing. It's funny that you say she had more chemistry with Jacob. The actress dated Rob Pattinson irl lol. Maybe it's the directing? I think she had a rather sibling like relationship with Lautner on set though, he's apparently funny and easy going. Anyway, thank you again for this reaction and keeping an open mind! 😊 Glad your approach helps with making it through romanticized toxic relationships! 🎉

I personally think we all throw the word toxic around too much sometimes. It’s so easy to do, but sometimes it’s just horrible accidental situations. Big emotions and feelings can cause people to act in certain ways. Sure it could be classed as toxic overall. But I just imagine myself in each persons shoes and think.. I kind of get it really. I Love love love your reactions! 😍

Watching the commentaries on the dvds are so fun too. We learn so much

Please keep doing these this series is my guilty pleasure