long time no see!~ i like it too on that latest insta live she was giving it all for those sustained belts @4:16 lol there’s also that looong B4 but it got a bit messy with the sustaining so i decided to not include it ahah

the ranking update is taking all my time every time i’m editing lol i was also looking for some interesting vocalists to do that showcase but most of 4th gen girlies don’t have enough yet unfortunately, guess i’ll have to go back a few generations if i want to keep it up eheh have a good one~ rest well!

@@sootzubae No need to rush it~ It also looks like another big year for 4th gen is coming so take your time watching over these 4th gen girlies ahaha take care too 💟🙌🏿

Her lows r pretty average, better than most 4th gen vocalists tbh lol

if you knew i’ve been told she was bellow Winter🤣 to be fair i don’t think anyone, including me of course, was aware of her best material lol

love it too! i feel like there might be more one or another Eb5 that still carry adequate development but that’s probably her better one

@@sootzubae Ahh really ? Sounds very promising !!! Love the vid as always bæ

@@YEOUN_channel she is very promising, overall thanks really much for stopping by~

and Ningning is way more constricted in the 4th octave, ik everyone gives Ningning C5/C#5 but she struggles too much in the 4th octave to have anything more than B4/C5 😭

@@aeivyyydoes that mean ningning does truly only have B4/C5?

@@tsukiology i would say she only has B4/C5 yes

​@@aeivyyyagree, she has shallow moments even on Bb4 tbh, her coachella performance was a good example

@@liftedb9591 almost think ningning should go back into average 😭 she’s definitely the absolute lowest in A-AA unless you count BoA as A-AA atp

Especially at 2:50

Yup I hear it too haha, even that final Eb5 was reminding me of Wendy.

no i hear it too, i remember other users said it so too on the Swan x Ning x Jungwoo video

They are indeed similar in tone wise and some of her clips here really reminds me of Wendy's whininess attempts.

I thought that too but I take it back since Wendy has never opened up like that at all 😂😂😂

thanks!~ i’m lol, why?

@@sootzubae I didn’t realise lol, but I kind of became a Pablo Vitar fan recently. Do you know him?

@@SoulVelvet not a fan but they’re very popular here so i know them, yes. me and BigMama Fan discoursed a while ago, they’re around high A - A to AAish if you’re curious ahah

Lily supported A5 in hv? Could you drop a link, please?

@@arwakhalil8054 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/rN2BeaRe0pO5caM.html here but I still hear some sense of a bit pushed on her A5s in HV but still support tho and yeah it's her usual.

Your "supported range" is all over the place for Lily. A3/Bb3-C#5/D5-F#5 for consistency and A3-Eb5-G5 are more than enough for Lily who has a really underwhelming chest coordination in the 4th octave compared to Jungwoo. They are pretty close, Jungwoo def does better than Lily between G#4-C#5, above that Lily has better placement and more ease, Jungwoo also has better lows, while Lily has better head voice. Its really not that big of a gap

@Liftedb don't know about lows and hv but lily really showed she's consistent with eb5

@@liftedb9591 Oh coming from the one who tend to discredit/overlook on Lily's best vocal moments and consistency but just simply bubble the words that is unparalleled bogus and misinformation here in this section. And first of all, did I just comment "supported range" where I just exactly put "consistent range" as part of her consistency. Plus Lily's chest development is pretty decent considering she's typical of balanced belter but more on lighter coordination especially in her midrange (4th octave) and there's nothing wrong with that approach, it's for her vocal preservation and health .But still Lily is a bit better than her(Jungwoo) due to she's still shown to be more reliable in the 5th octave (better consistency with quality or even sustainability) as her ease approach And yes ,Jungwoo is definitely better when it comes to G#4-C#5 area as she showed more connected and grounded with better and bolder quality of support than Lily in the midbelt.

I don't think any of them have any of the basics of support aside from Sihyeon (that's how you write her name?

@@andinho6372 it's shiyeon

@@andinho6372 i am rooting for mia she seems to have some support going on her mid range and i think i need more materials from E:U

@@Forever_2424 it’s actually Sihyeon and i agree with Andinho, none of them but Sihyeon have a consistent grasp (hers already being almost no existent).

@@sootzubae ohh thanks i hope their company will some vocal line to eu to prove her singing

Jihyo has G#3/A3~Bb4/B4, she is mid average

C#5/D5

@@sootzubae thanks

all of the notes are supported. the last D5 can be argued but it carry sufficient support for me personally.

@@sootzubae it had quite good vibrato

Yes

yes