Love that intro with the black and white filter and the wonderful camera angle of the engine. Great review!

Awesome loco and an amazing review! You might be fascinated to know that one of these type of locomotive came to Trinidad to work on the Bronte Sugar Estate. At the end of its career, it was converted into a mobile boiler ( only the boiler and firebox) and now, is plinthed on a driveway of a private home.

15:20 it's the bullman cow again moooooo!!!!!!! I NEED that Caledonian engine it looks incredible

Really love the intro music of Scott Joplin ragtime. Great review again Sam. Excellent. Many thanks.

Didn't even think of getting one until I watched your excellent review, now she is on order and can't wait to get her!

I like at the beginning you show the engine going around the rail way! Keep up the good work!

What an adorable yet beautiful loco... I'm at school right now and you really made my day!

Its so cute!! fantastic review Sam! I love this review, like all your other reviews!

Terrific review for such a nice looking engine. Well done Sam and ty

I am just astounded with what Hatton's has accomplished with these two locomotives. They are breathtaking.

I love that. such a beauty! Well done again Sam!

Just bought this loco after watching your review last year, really happy with it cheers for the recommendation mate

Wow, this loco blows my mind, for such small loco to be of such great quality and detail is astounding to me. I absolutely love the Caledonian cobalt colour and white with the maroonish running board. Great video as always Sam, Cheers.

Good Evening Sam, Onces again, that was really sweet of Hattons, this time sending you the brand new Hattons Andrew Barclay Saddle Tank just before they release them next month. The Hattons Andrew Barclay Saddle Tank in Caledonian Railway Blue livery looks fabulous, the wonderful detail and the running performance is flawless. The Andrew Barclay Saddle Tank Engines were built in Scotland. I've seen a full size Andrew Barclay Saddle Tank Engine, Katie at the Churnet Valley Railway awaiting restoration to full working order, I'm planning to pre-order the Hattons Katie in red livery by early March. You should do a special running session on St Andrews Day on Friday 30th November 2018 by running Steam Locomotives that worked in Scotland such as Caledonian Single No.123, No.4472 Flying Scotsman who hauled the Flying Scotsman Express Train to Edinburgh, the Hornby J36 Maude, LNER D49 4-4-0, LNER A4 Pacifics, the LMS Coronations, Princesses & Royal Scots & not forgetting the Hattons Caledonian Railway Andrew Barclay Saddle Tank. I know St Andrews Day is a long way. Back to the review of your Hattons Andrew Barclay Saddle Tank, onces again fantastic. 5 stars 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 10/10 😊

A superb review indeed Sam! They simply are quite stunning! Been looking forward to the arrival of my ones ;) Hattons really have done a superb job indeed. Must admit the CR livery really does suit her quite well. The detail on the logo is outstanding! That slow running is amazing! Perfect for the real machines. Love the CR Running session :) Keep up the great work!

This was definitely one of the most amazing liveries on a locomotive i have ever seen, this loco was worth the wait, great review, sam :-)

Very very nice loco and the livery is brilliant. The cab detail is just exquisite. I just love these little locos being produced these days, makes me want to build a micro layout while I’m stuck indoors.

Such a cute little Tank Engine Sam looking good!

Great review Sam! That is an amazing locomotive! This weekend I’m actually buying my first ever Hornby HO/OO train, I’m getting the West Coast Highlander set for 99 US dollars. I’m so excited and can’t wait to finally start investing in the hobby. Keep up the great work!

Hi Sam. What a beautiful livery! Also, I really love the fact that the saddle tank is not perfectly hemispherical - it just makes it so much more interesting.

Great review of this lovely little model of the Andrew Barclay 0-4-0ST in Caledonian Railway blue livery mate ; )

great review. i have the GWR one on order. cant wait to get it

Hey Sam. Really great to see that some makers are finally noticing your reviews and asking you to review their new efforts. Excellent loco. Had my 8f hauling goods and my 0-6-0 austerity doing the same at the pub layout tonight!

What a great loco and review! Never clicked so fast on a video 👍🏼

Loved the video Sam! Im quite happy, as i've just gotten the bachman thomas HO scale set, plus another straight track to make the circle an oval, then another oval with a 1/3 track so it doesnt collide. Loving the set rn. so happy I could finally get an HO scale train :D

A very stunnig loco. Awesome details !! Cheers Onno.

One of those closing shots with the pair of CR saddle tanks coming up the line side by side was beautiful! Have a similar soft spot for my hornby saddle tank (although mine predictably is in lms colours) glad the Hattons engines are doing so well!

Lovely little engine. I’ve got a black one on order, can’t wait!

Beautiful and unique locomotive pick Sam very nice with the blue livery you always get the best model train picks

Awesome review! The Barclay is absolutely beautiful!

Nice review stunning loco. After having a look at the different liveries available I think this is the best overall, good choice.

I love watching you and seeing all you're trains

What an amazing little model. That's two models made by hattons now both completely stunning. Looks like Hornby, Bachmann and Oxford Rail have a lot to learn.

Hi mukka, the handle you had difficulty identifying on the back of the cab is the locomotive handbrake which is used when stabling. You will often see the same type of handle on the tender of a steam locomotive which serves the same function. Cheers from Oz. Gaz

It looks beautiful, especially with those coaches. I love Hatton so much.

Great review Sam, I want one.

That is a nice smal 040 tank loco! Good video Sam!

great vid sam it looks wonderful in that livery good choice : )

OMG... I LOVE this engine, it looks sooo beautiful!

I'm thinking about getting the same one as you have, would go nice with the railway children coaches.

Excellent review as always! I might order one too!

Hello Sam, again a great review of a really very beautiful small loco. Superb. Cheers, Norbert

great video. great model i will pre order the blue one right now.

That slow forward was sooooo smooooooooooooooooooooth! Outstanding model with so many tiny & accurate details!

Great video mate. I loved it!

Yay finnally the Barclay I love this loco although I haven't bought it . That transition from black and white to color is amazing

Loved the review of the CR Barclay Iv seen the real engine in CR black and work along side it. Its is very nice to see but didn't run that much in CR blue it only was in that because of a visit from another CR engime

What a stunning engine Sam

They really do seem to be making really good little models. Great video. :)

Amazing video! Also I like the black and white filter because it makes it look old.

Wow, what a little gem! Hatton's really has to consider bringing you on staff in the repair and marketing departments!

Sam that looks great I wanted to make a card board model of this engine but I didn't know what paint livery to give it and this Caledonian railway blue it's perfect!

Great video Sam

Beautiful model Sam!

I half expected silent movie type subtitles on this episode because of that intro. XD This model is gorgeous. I'd have a look at the different versions, but I'm pretty sure I'd end up getting exactly the same as yours because of how beautiful she is

HI Sam grate review its helped to make my mind up on getting the same one you have. I hope it will nicely with my Hornby blue Peckett w4 as they are both have excellent level of detailing.

What a plucky little locomotive! It's always good to see a new manufacturer enter the fray and keep rival companies honest. Thanks for the review Sam!

Nice one Sam, worra a nice model, glad to see they are doing versions in both GWR green and BR western region black, The GWR had a fair few othese shunting the docs at Swansea and Newport. I think she would be able to handle a lot more than three coaches, I reckon she could do 20 mineral wagons easily!! All the best Jon PS sorry I've not commented for a bit, had IT issues and been off like for a couple of weeks

Okay, that's another locomotive to add to my Wishlist of locos to buy in 2018. Great review, and I have to say Hatton's does a great job with locos like this 0-4-0. Though I'm not sure which version I'll get...maybe I'll get two or three of this class. :)

I just love this loco, I absolutely have to get one!

BRILLIANT Seeing as I work on Caley 828 that livery is amazing it reminds me of the actual engines

Nice review Sam👍🚂

Definitely looking forward to this! There's two of these locos local to Me, bon-accord at the royal dee side railway and Mr therm at Seaton park!

The Andrew Barclay 0-6-0 is trundling along then all the sudden, the Caledonian single wheeler's are like COMING THROUGH!!!!

It's so cute! Good choice Sam

Great review

6:45 Wow it’s sooo tiny! It’s wheelbase is as big as the front bogey of the Caledonian Single!

Just beautiful the loveliest engine I’ve seen And it looks like there’s really no motor, like it’s real Personally I would have 10/10

The hattons line of trains are stunning!

It’s engines like this that kickstarted the preservation movement. A shame they rarely see service today. Still a fantastic model accompanied by a brilliant review. Kind Regards. Cameron

Heya Sam As always great video and review! Such an interesting prototype/s, such interesting lives for little loco's! I should imagine that they used the vast array of loco's that have been preserved for reference materials, but that is an awful lot of travelling. That Caledonian livery really is stunning, but I'm gonna (hopefully) get Katie as she is preserved (well stored) at the Churnet Valley Railway and compare her with my Peckett. With the view to pulling my brake van trains. Olly

I'm glad that Hattons is making their own. Since discovering their site (thanks to you, incidentally), they're my new go-to place for model railway stuff. Already got my eye on this and the cute little 0-6-0s. When I get ahold of one of these, I'll go with a Dark Green one and see if I can manage to modify it via Transfers into a Great Western engine (not accurate but I'm going for a GWR theme). I'm looking forward to other things Hattons may come out with.

Hi Sam's trains I'm a new viewer and already I'm liking your videos some of the trains that you reviewed I'm actually pretty interested in some of them. Keep up the great work From True Bob cat😀

They're back! Woop woop! Batch 2 announced

The paintwork looks so good on that tank engine

Aah! It’s so cute! To be serious, I love the Barclays. Their short, stocky look has such a unique charm to it. Keep up the good work Sam! And could we see the Barclay and the P double-heading?

I can't stop looking at this beautiful locomotive

If I had the right scale this would be my first purchase! btw love the Video and the running session. Kind regards Gally

Hatton's Andrew Barclay 0-4-0ST in CR livery looks to be a superb model. Barclay's were a Scottish company, based in Kilmarnock. The "slidy thing" attached to the piston rod is known as the crosshead. Regards, Alan.

Well, I presume I'm quite late on making a comment with this little engine, but I've got to hand it to Hatton's Model Railways. Their locomotives are produced with quality in mind, as well as the modeller's financial capabilities. Performance and detail go hand-in-hand, and the wide variety Hatton's is producing for both the 16 and 14 cylinder inch diameter variations, not to mention the accuracy on the liveries and cabs as well. I've managed to get my hands on the GWR shirt button "705", and have been delighted with his performance ever since his arrival several months ago; one thing I wish there would have been was a size comparison between engines (I did one on my Twitter; had plenty of laughs myself showing it against Bachmann Branchline's 9F "Evening Star"), but I think seeing it run with those coaches and your other Caledonian Railway engines should have helped with that. Seeing as you're a fan of the Caledonian Railway blue, do you plan to purchase Bachmann Branchline's McIntosh 812 class locomotive they've announced? I know I will, which means this gorgeous little Barclay may join my fleet alongside the 828 once it's arrived.

Wow those ex Caledonian coaches are just as finely detailed as the engine pulling them. Hattons are making some great models

Excellent. Can't do much about performance over points as it is so small. The paintwork looks so smart.

Lol. I keep seeing that Bull on the flatbed in most of your videos. Nice little tank engine btw, blue is my favorite color.

sam i love your videos pls make more and do a review on the lordnelson 850 that would be awesome

What an adorable little engine.

It's really interesting to see that Hatton's has only done industrial-ish type tank engines so far. Hopefully we'll see more of this in the future so we can get locomotives which are aren't popular compared to your average Jinty or J50. Maybe we'll see some pre-grouping locos too! Who knows!?!?! Great video as always Sam! - Ben

I'm ordering a Barclay this week: just need to decide which one! What made me chuckle is the fact that, for a genuine pre-1923 Caledonian Railway Loco, the Hornby 'Pug' is the most accurate one there! No.123 was modelled by Triang in her post-1923 (As Preserved) Condition, with the safety valves atop the firebox as opposed to Drummond's original position on the dome. The LMS Rebuilt her to this shape, so even the full size one is in an inauthentic livery! Hattons' Andrew Barclay shows the loco as preserved in the 1990's at the preservation-era Caledonian Railway, as the real loco was never owned by the original CR. Still, fantastic model, and even more reason why I need to get on and order mine. I'll be ordering an SECR P too, but the Original Wainwright Green ones aren't due out until May, so that gives time for the bank account to recover!

It looks amazing

Really Nice! A very impressive model, like the P Class which I plan on getting! Very clever of Hatton's to tap into the new 'small industrial loco' category, which Hornby opened up with their Peckett. The Caledonian Livery, although really nice, isn't really prototypical for the pre-grouping era, given that the livery was applied to this loco first in preservation!

I love those locos and I'm hoping to get the Andrew Barcley in red or blue with wasp stripes.

It looks awesome

Really nice Sam . The Caley Blue I think is a preserved livery. There were never any actual Caledonian ones . I think I fancy the red one . With a short 0-4-0 wheelbase I think some point stuttering is almost inevitable

Spot on rating Sam 👍

Now that's a nice little one! I'm thinking of getting one for my coal yard. And i have a suggestion, you should do a video about how to capture model trains! All the best, Peter

Cute looking saddle tank

The Andrew barclay is the most adorable little engine you have ever reviewed. Next to the p class, I can see them double heading a train sometime in the future. I also saw Lowmac cow, London transport pannier, class 03, or, was it 04, and that little green engine, thats not british, looks more foreign, looks nice with those coaches.

God it’s beautiful 😍 and also some small Engines like this is a little more detailed than the big ones

superb loco! one I am definitely going to pick up at some point probably number 6 in the NCB green, hattons are properly giving bachmann and hornby a run for there money. there is also a video on hattons of one pulling 10 to 15 wagons up hill without slipping!

Really love the loco and you've done a good job with the review. I can't remember the name of it but I would love to see it beside the other tank loco from Hatton's (the grey one) for size and just because I think they would look nice together.

I just think this engine is so cool I can't help looking back at the thumbnail