+Gunnar Einarsson yeah, fallout 4!

Tomb raider is a better game, WAY better.

+FizzzyFizzz Lol nah it isn't sorry m8

It's comments like these is why God doesn't talk to us anymore

+MrKiron12 i am still around

It makes sense, because it's not the same person reviewing it.

Yeah, both games are entirely overrated

+DJ L00dBoi uncharted 4 is great! It deserves a 10/10

+Willoben I agree 10/10

u want it to go higher then 9.3 cause then others can say.. uncharted 4 higher then witcher wtf. Stop complaining a 9 is a great score

I agree 100% with you on that! :D

Beastgamer07 :)

4.2? Lmao.

Ryan Fanstone Nah Uncharted 1 deserves 8.1 not 4.2.

Uncharted 3 shooting was crap. If the enemy was moving you couldn't shot him. In my opinion Uncharted 1> Uncharted 3

Big oof we meet again big oof

@Big oof ok boomer

@᯾ ok boomer

@᯾ ok go play terraria

@@perrychirpy4504 the game is a 6 at best

It's just too similar to other iterations

+TheBowser701 No it's not.

+Vic Vinegar lol ok

+Vic Vinegar grappling hook isn't enough to warrant it being changed

At times the game had a sense of "been there, done that" and there isn't really an action part that sticks out next to UC 2 or 3. Only flaw of the game tho; would be a 10/10 if it was the first UC game i had played

exactly

+try2bcool IKR

+try2bcool Didn't he get fired or something?

+Rotten Cheese no he quit to start his own company. KindaFunny

ethan Hagee I see, thanks for the info!

Ummmm it's supposed to be a game not a movie

Adam McMillan agree

Adam McMillan and the amazing final boss

Agree

Cry some more about it

apart from the multiple flaws it has.

@@avasti3866 it doesnt have any

@@vaibhavagrawal3083 horrific pacing of story structure is a huge flaw.

@Bobby Papoutsis this is blind fanboyism at its finest, factually and objectively speaking, the game is flawed in many aspects. But you can believe what you want.

@@avasti3866 i agree but there was never a game totally flawless , witcher 3 got 10s accross the board and it have 10 times the flaws Uncharted 4 have .

Final Fantasy XIII...

+Gabriel Medina Alien isolation says hello!!!

+Gabriel Medina This isn't a long game... It's a drawn out linear game is what she is saying... I kind of agree, because I have just gotten to the end of the game and the jungle part did seem a little drawn out... Overall a 9 out of 10 is a fair score.. It's a great game, but it is flawed...

+Diesel Metal Gear Solid 4 had exact the same problem, the last act was just way to long, but IGN gave that 10. The third act features the resolution of the story and its subplots, of course it will be long. Its the last game EVER, they need to wrap it up.

+The Cabal Jusf give us Greg Miller back IGN lol

+spooby It's a game m8

Uros L It was a joke dipshit I was immitating the tomb raider fans when they have nothing else to come back with.

+Pretty Flacko' I like Dark Souls, Uncharted, and Witcher. They're all awesome.

Not charted enough.

TootToot shes reviewing what was HER OWN expierience

But she didn't review COD

She didnt review call of duty you dumbass

It's one point higher, so what?

Killah Zayn that wasn't her! It's pointless to compare the reviews because they are of different games and reviewed by different people with different opinions.

I think every cod review from IGN gets the uncharted comparison now to show how ridiculous they are 😂

@@joeyzyk2334 that was the point I was making. Not to be mean but you basically just repeated this comment to me.

Hahaha. The person giving this review was trying to find things to complain about.

Haha good one!

+Band1t have you just commented this on every comment?

Band1t You're joking right?

I watched again it so I could hear the words "Third Act" 12 more times.

TheGamePlayerM sonycuntsbois are pissed 12/10

Ha lmao

Ps fangirls in a nutshell

Uncharted 4 deserve a 10

Really?you complain because it got 0.1 score differences? that is moronic, why?Does that difference makes Uncharted 4 less great in any way? People nowadays.

Well this is awkward.. I thought my comment was clearly satirical.

lmfao..of all the games ,she had to say that.

InFam0u5Drag0nArmageddon53X at the jungle section yes go back to uncharted two and three and you'll see where they kind of took a bit of it from but what can you expect from a forth iteration of a game i mean they gotta use something

That's a completely valid reason lol

Literally says nothing but bad about the game NINE OUT OF TEN Lmao

I mean, they gave pubg a 9,5 and gave fortnite a 9,3 but this is a 9

awesome comment is awesome

+IGN Hahaha nice response

Only in games do people take a 9/10 as an insult, it's crazy.

+IGN IGN while i don't always agree with you in the slightest. a 9 review is a WONDERFUL review. I always take your opinion to heart when i buy any game. THANK YOU IGN for helping me in my buying decisions. if it wasn't for you i wouldn't know the good games from the GREAT games. for years i have always looked to you for guidance in buying games if it wasn't for you i would have wasted THOUSANDS of dollars on crap games. so keep giving me your opinons while i don't always agree it does HELP!

+IGN Why would people dislike for a review score? Is a review not supposed to be an opinion? lol

masta wayne

LMAO

Yeah i know

Why? Great review.

True that and she even says it's lacks imagination and creative stuff wtf!

That’s why chapters 11 is my fav

The Madagascar level was incredible

@Big oof Jesus why you commenting the same thing over & over again?

Big oof why are you commenting the same thing always?

@Big oof I'm sorry man even though I don't agree with the fanboy comments, you seem to have the dumbest take out of all of them.

Big oof I’m all for a longer Uncharted if it’s well paced, the jungle section of Uncharted 4 was a bit boring. I love the characters and I wanted to spend more time with them, but the third act dragged on without going anywhere for way too long.

Get that Australian lady in front of a computer screen and force her to watch the Making of Uncharted 4 documentary because that showed me how much effort they put into the game.

+HamzahGaming its called opinion dude

true

+HamzahGaming Pretty sure TLoU and had the same sort of 'slow' moments but those are some of the best parts as you start to explore both the game's environment and the characters personalities, which you can't do as effectively in action paced sequences.

+AmazingJoe96 if it was based on opinion then so many games would get 10s

ShadowSparks no they wouldn't

***** ....... I thought she sounded like nadine

I don't think he got the joke.

that's a good one. I'd rate it 3/10 if u know what I mean

John Fleming You're joking right?

+SuperSaiyan3985 it's an uncharted reference

U4 is definitely not a 10, it's not better than U2.

Nephtis doesn’t mean it’s not a 10... U3 was better than both.

@@aLbotTV its not a ten. U4 has a lot of pacing issues and repetitive tasks (move a box, climb it, find another box climb etc) Scotland and parts of Madagascar (towards the end) are examples of that. Uncharted 3 was another mess, had a lot of plot-holes, boring characters (Talbot being an example) and suffered from pacing issues as well. Uncharted 2 is the best game in the series, and Uncharted 2 and TLOU part 1 are the only 10/10 games they have ever made. Everything else is a 9/10 and below.

Nephtis It’s all a matter of opinion and I disagree with you.

@@aLbotTV hey im still a big uncharted fan and i've been apart of the online community since U2. But your opinion is still fine with me.

no it shouldn't

i_johnny royale how come

I think that overwatch deserves goty

i gotta say iw is better than this game and i hate iw. The game is slow and boring with shallow charactors showing no difference from the previous titles. The only naughty dog game that should get recognition is The Last of Us, did everything better in one game

i_johnny royale yes it should

For a 90$ plus game in Canada there should be a 30 hour single player campaign with a complimentary ice cream

Tell me about it, this was a lot of value packed into a single player. The longest I've played, Naughty Dog really impressed me.

no let's face facts its because she gave it a 9 instead of a 10 that you're fuming.

jdbruiser That's not it dude. Im not a Uncharted fan. I was just saying that I wish more single player games were 15 hours. That's all.

ok sorry I misunderstood you, just assume ign haters would be all over this review, which is sad really.

ya wtf

Maple Miles splatoon deserved a 1 that game is trash r u like 5?

+trigui fedi so what?

you cant say that bo3 is better than best game ever called Uncharted 4

+Jack Meyers who cares about splatoon, its made by nintendo and everybody knows they make crappy games now and if they make actually make a decent game its always overrated. play plants vs zombies garden warefare ps4 instead. a much better game

It sure is boring. It's almost a David Cage title with some bad shooting sections

@@trblemayker5157 you bad in game

Agreed

Game play is crap. Story and characters are on the level of cheap, cheesy, b level action movie.

​@@hododod246 you are so wrong its painful.

😆

.......well that backfired

Lol u get it

bf 1 5/10 ccod infinite gayness 10/10

+TehReelSanic thats exactly what will happen i bet

They gave dynasty warriors 8 and 8.7....8.7......wow.... That's .3 points away from uncharted 4. Btw dynasty warriors 8 was so garb. You could do more in dynasty warriors 4.

and the sales figures prove it thou lol cod lasts for months, uncharted one weekend lol

+Rodolfo Sial and that is exactly why I am so damn salty about their review

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

+Anass TOUISNI hahahaha

Different reviewer

.....different genre? Different reviewer? It's not as though IGN is one collective hive mind....

Joey Velarde well, would you give the worst game ever made (ride to hell) a 9? (i just watched ihe hates review scores, so make this quick)

Agree

And the best game for PS4 of all time

@@nathandrake4140 game is great but not the best

Ayyyeee

I Know now THX

Aye brother

This guy. First time playing these games. Beat all 4 in order. My reviews are 8, 9, 9.5, 10. I have no idea how they only gave this a 9.

Inka Gamer74 Yeah for the quarantine deal but Uncharted 4 is the free game on PlayStation Plus this month

+Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens: 9 is considered amazing! We absolutely loved it.

+Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens: Yeah an arbitrary number given to a game by a human is a magnificent phenomenon and we've all got to argue about it.

Yeah that's why every cod gets 9 cauz its great rit?

+IGN COD got 9.2 A 9 means nothing

+IGN COD got 9.2 A 9 means nothing

Tell that to her.

yes yes please .. i get this from my friends all the time !

yeah like what were you expecting then xD

Go and play Uncharted 3.....u would know what a good balanced uncharted game is(right amount of climbing,shooting,puzzle solving n dramatic cutscenes)..........this review is correct.......towards the end of the game.....it drags for far too long.

Yasha The Same happens with Mario, no?

Also it’s a series. You are supposed to atleast understand what happened prior to play the last instalment in the franchise

👍👍🏻👍🏼👍🏽👍🏾👍🏿

@᯾ ok boomer

Why not get a ps5

@@TA-qo2nv Don't need one and I've got a Series X.

@@TA-qo2nv easier said than done lmao, plus the prices are still jacked up from resellers

If you want to play a game with visuals that will blow you away, play Horizon Forbidden West - this game has nothing on that

​@kxndyyy maybe but overall this game is better story gameplay combat stealth climbing swinging

yes!

God forbid they give an honest review instead of just scoring it based on other scores.

Why? Uncharted is a linear cutscene lol

So now they are the best reviewer. When they rated last of us an 8 they were the worst review channel ever that should just die.

+Shane Stewart Same happened with Batman Arkham Knight iirc. People being stupid like always, nothing new.

THANK YOU

Knurdyob have you played the earlier installments if not please indulge yourself in uncharted two you'll notice where it kind of becomes a little bland even though this game is genuinely greay

The 3rd act was long, but it was amazing. By dropping so many truth bombs, and character development for Nate & Elanie. This was one of the few single player games I spent full price on!!

@@toomuchritz I have played all of them, loved the second one is particular as well, I mean the last act of that game changes settings drastically going from the snowy mountains to shambala, but in u4 the story was kept so engaging that the fact they never left the island until the end of the game didnt bother me, thus I really can't agree that it felt bloated, especially considering it's the last game in the series, needed time to end things properly

Skatoony I loved Skatoony

Lol

dont watch their reviewers ever again than.

+Acrobat don't react to someone's comment ever again.

8-bit Hotel : Home of bonus round! I was joking with you.

+Acrobat i only visit to dislike them and it is fun

different reviewers have different opinions. they never let naomi review. if so, this would get a 10

Metal Gear Solid is just shooting a bunch of guys with a ZZZ gun to the head... any other method is unecessary... And if you haven't noticed, MGS V is an unfinished game... yet it still got a 10/10... And can you tell me what was so special about MGS V? You were killing/kidnapping people with no identity and all around it was soo repetetive that I was bored near the end of the first chapter... Boss fights were so boring, especially the Skulls, but nobody mentions it... It almost seem like we are forbidden to criticise Kojima's game... Metal gear solid was a 7,5 at best... And I'm sorry, but in your opinion it has great gameplay, but does that justify a 10/10? I really dont think so... If a game is to get a 10, it should be perfect... Perfect gameplay, perfect story etc... MGSV repetetive mission structure and poor story definitly don't deserve a 10

Every "act" in that game was bloated lol one repetitive mission after another.

Chris Redfield Still better than mgs V which was a major disappointment.

The Devourer of Worlds Not really. MGSV may be unfinished, it still has the best stealth gameplay we've seen in years. Not only that but the background and themes are definitely unique and it's still leagues beyond everything Naughty Dog ever did... This doesn't mean Uncharted 4 is bad, it's just that it's the same old action adventure game we've been used to since Uncharted 2. MGSV dared to broke the boundaries of its own franchise and of the gaming industry as a whole, at the risk of disappointing its own fanbase. This is what puts MGSV on a whole other level than UC4...

Downloading now hopefully I have the same reaction haha

@@mitchs4125 How'd it go?

yup

Hahahahahahahaha t

+Shane Bovell Why would you do that? She game the game a 9, that's an amazing score.

Diego Cortes my issue was never with the score she gave.

Shane Bovell So what was the issue then?

+Derek Chambers what makes you say that?

"M-m-muh masterpiece didn't get a perfect score! She only called it amazing! She gave it a mere 9/10! She must hate the series!"

+Derek Chambers lol you dumbass. she didnt review the game. she is reading the ign article created by a ign critic. She is just the voice.

For the other uncharted's are 7s and 8s

+The Golden Apple nope

There is no lack of creativity and bloated third act, they are just trying to find something to blame

Imo uncharted 1: 6.5/10 uncharted 2: 10/10 uncharted 3: 8.5/10 uncharted 4: 9/10

Uncharted 1: 5/10 Uncharted 2: 8/10 Uncharted 3: 7.5/10 Uncharted 4: 8/10

Uncharted 1: 9/10 Uncharted 2: 10/10 Uncharted 3: 10/10 Uncharted 4: 20/10

+MicrowaveBackground Seems about right. Uncharted 3 felt a lot like Jak 3. ND cared more about missions/setpieces than the actual storyline.

uncharted 1: 7.5/10 uncharted 2: 10/10 uncharted 3: 9.5/10 uncharted 4: 10/10

An excellent observation to this review well done.

+Umair Khan If she played the others she would know that near the final act felt like uncharted 1 which I loved by the way. That was the intent

thats kind of what uncharted is...

Joey Velarde No that's called "too much gameplay for me".

+Umair Khan I don't mind the stealthy or shooty parts.... I actually quite enjoyed them. It was just all the same after the second act. - Mark your foes - learn the layout - stealth kill the first 6 foes - clean up the map - next Thank god the multiplayer made up for the gameplay. The story was flawless... Without a doubt, amazing. The gameplay.... Once you you lock the secrets... It's set em up, knock em down. At the hardest level, it's "take your time.... Now set em up and knock em down." Sure it's exciting.... But cmon, just move on!!

yolo different reviewers, and different genres of games.

She wasn't the one who reviewed it though tf

Just remember that BO3 & U4 are both different geners reviewed by different people. Just let that sink in....

OMG what a joke🤣

to be fair, bo3 has better multiplayer, gameplay, content, zombies and overall more stuff to offer which usually drives more attention and longevity than amazing story and graphics. not trying to bash U4, which is an amazing game but they are not really comparable

they are both wildly different.

+Alexander Wright look son! A cod fanboy!

+Memeslayer don't you mean uncharted fanboy

Sahil Hussain I didn't freak out and say "WTF?"

+Alexander Wright I hope you are aware that IGN is not one person.

+Biniam Gaming how about the gameplay? the gameplay is boring af tho

+Francis Kim When ign give mediocre games such as BO3 a 9/10, and they give this masterpiece the same score then there's a big problem.

+Francis Kim Yeah and I'm just giving my opinion. If crappy, shallow Cod games get a 9/10 then surely uncharted 4 should get a 10/10. I'm not in the wrong to disagree with this review. I found that some things that she said such as "it lacks imagination" are completely wrong so I left a dislike as I didn't think her points were explained well.

+SungLung I'm just saying that I highly disagree with this review, I'm no fanboy.

Yep... its bad these days? I rate it 9/10... Its not perfect and Im a PC gamer not biased at all.

to be fair ign rarely gives anything from any medium not limited to video games lower than a 7/10. So a 9/10 is basically average by their standards.

Uncharted 4 deserves a 10/10

@LUCAS HOUSE 20k now

Me

+Gol. D Rodger Wasn't reviewed by the same person.

Not even a similar genre.

+Gol. D Rodger she gave tomb raider 9.3 thou. Reviewers that do both games all gave UC4 higher.

+Dilan Lahiru It's still shitty of IGN to keep giving COD anywhere close to a 9. The games don't deserve it. They don't push graphics and they don't push shooters forward. Uncharted 4 is doing things a game has never done before in some aspects.

Paladin Joe Seriously, who cares? It all comes down to personal preference. All that matters is what you think of the game. Plus getting a lower score than COD doesn't mean UC4 is not a good game. Plus everyone needs to get off this reviewers back. Learn to respect other people's opinion. Whether good or bad...

+Samuele Paiuscato I agree with the review Uncharted 4 9/10 Uncharted 3 10/10 Uncharted 2 11/10

+Sean Dennis but uncharted 2 is the worst one!

+Oi m8 no ITS the first one. Dont worry. ITS all right to mispell 1 and 2. :-)

+Oi m8 uncharted 2 was game of the year - are you serious?

***** dude i said the first one is the bad one. I like it, but it is the worst. the second game is the best

True

+thegamingnerd 123 nooooo way, its 9/10 at best ! what an overrated game

That's only a score MGSV can get. Not uncharted 4

+Casioo24 i know right?

+thegamingnerd 123 Who's Nuff?

+Alpha Slick I think people do know, though people getting upset at a review are just morons. It is an opinion and 9 is still a great score

+OniLink97 All of the gaming critics gave this game a 10 but no IGN tryna look cool and give hard work a 9

+Alpha Slick Rubbish, proves you haven't read many critics, gamespot gave it a 10. Vidoegamer gave it an 8, most of the critics gave it 9's, just google it. You are being childish, you can't accept someone else's opinion. Stop moaning and go play the game

oshogbo weed

@@tochukwuudu7763 see this guy😂😂😂

Hhahaha tru

No no no the game is not garbage IGN is

+xTRUxGxBEBEx You don't understand his joke...

+Maksim Makso Don't listen to IGN, the game is a masterpiece!

+Avenged Gunner777 Don't listen to IGN? Okay, so this game isn't amazing like they say. Good to know.

THIS!!!!!

It's not that the score is bad, it's the reasoning behind giving it that score

Andrew Forsythe If it's his opinion, he's entitled to that. I tend to lean that the guy who reviewed Uncharted 4 from the washington post was stating his opinion. But I'm skeptical a little bit if he's just hating just for the sake of hating because of some of his other reviews regarding Dark souls 2, and Red dead redemption. If he is just hating for the sake of it, just to get attention, then I can justify taking the review down.

the Washington post guy was just incorrect. he has a pretty shaky history too...

It was click bait, plain and simple.

I agree with you. The third out of the three combat zones after you meet up with Sam on the island (not a spoiler to any trigger happy friends out there, was in the trailers prelaunch) was the only time I went "another one?". I loved everything about this game and I'm about to jump into multiplayer because I need more.

Totally agree. The third act didn't feel bloated at all. Even if it did so the game gives you more to do in its third act - how is that a bad thing? :P

Lucy O'brien will probably give Uncharted: The Lost Legacy 10/10.

spiniest should be 6/10

should be 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000/10

@@flawlessgaming3787 yo but like why

agree

unless you played the last of us. I guess they hold this to a higher standard. criticism will be harder on people looking for any kind of flaw in naughty dogs perfection

Lmao calm down kid its alright

+hilyfe01 I thought Uncharted 4 was better just because of how beautiful all the environments were and how perfect the action was:.. The last of us no doubt top 5 of all time

True

Its a PEFECT game. Easily GOTY imho.

+nathan fenner Just want some consistency. They go on to give games like CoD and Battlefield who haven't grown on at all recently, scores of 9 or 10's without even blinking. But when Uncharted has actually grown, they blast it. It's just not a consistent review system

Mujhtuba Baksh I disagree with the score cus I loved the game and I agree that some facts should be in place to create a score, but I would say that an 8 or above for this game is a good score based on facts, the other 2 points are all opinion. The game has great graphics, runs well, good controls the plot is well structured and the characters are well developed. The other two points come down to weather you had fun and found the plot enjoyable.

Mujhtuba Baksh IKR? It's almost like they're different games with different reviewers or something...

They both do really.

I agree

I can't believe you get mad over an added .1 score, each game can get different reviewers dumbass, a game like MGSV got a ten and The last of us got a ten too, and people would think that MGSV is just as good as the last of us even though it ended up being a little disappointing but both reviewers had their own different opinions, you're a waste of life

overly long third act!?

I'm not sure about that but still an amazing game

uncharted 2 was better but uncharted 4 is not a bad game

+TheStealthRevenant I agree uncharted 4 was a good game but uncharted 2 was much better. More action, better story, better antagonists and in general a faster paced game.

Christoher Scolpini i was really hoping for some supernatural thing yo happen or a monster

I'm dead 😂😂. #VIEWS

+upth3punks XD #views

Technically she gave the campaign 8.8 while giving Rise of Microsoft 9.3

views was trash

+somalianb0y I don't know bro, I really liked it.

Little Larry nah only online multiplayer