Understanding Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, 40 years after Op Bluestar:Abridged Ep 1197

  Рет қаралды 45,794

ThePrint

ThePrint

7 күн бұрын

On 40th anniversary of Operation Bluestar, watch ThePrint Editor-In-Chief Shekhar Gupta narrate his first-hand experience of interacting with Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, who built a huge radical campaign without needing to utter the ‘K’ word. Episode 1197 of #CutTheClutter, originally published on 5 April 2023.
Tune in to ThePrint KZfaq channel for Part-2 tomorrow morning.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our KZfaq Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

Пікірлер: 439
@devindersingh7673
@devindersingh7673 2 күн бұрын
Sant ji in hearts! Many people in India never understand punjab!
@samratkundu9269
@samratkundu9269 3 сағат бұрын
really, who lectures to kill Hindu for bus and tries to kill the Nihang and name dhari.
@gurpreet6612
@gurpreet6612 5 күн бұрын
This is attack on every Sikhs hearts
@Voice_Of_Rights
@Voice_Of_Rights Күн бұрын
No any criminal case was registered against Bhindrawala till the date of Blue Star but the government of India have no answer that why Indra Gandhi ordered Military attack on holy place of Sikh community.
@kaveripoompattinam
@kaveripoompattinam 5 күн бұрын
I was in Punjab from 1980 till 1994 . Extremely tragic . It is the posting of K.P.S.GILL that made the bitterness absolutely bitter. Had always cursed the armed forces , both the Army and police . I was in Hoshiarpur and I know first hand the tragedy. i am a Hindu and not a Sikh, but the excesses by the uniformed men bleeds my heart. one full generation of youth wiped out. Any young Man was eliminated. you journalists never highlighted the blatant human rights violations and custodial murders and disappearance. You are praising him now - K.P.S.GILL IN A CLUTTER. Had the highest respect for you but praising K.P.S. GILL IS A SHAME. Khalistan WAS WRONG BUT BHINDRANWALE WAS NURTURED BY DELHI. STILL HE HAD TO BE ELIMINATED. BUT WHY THOUSANDS OF INNOCENT YOUNG SIKHS SUBSEQUENTLY. you were the best journalist in Punjab giving a fair view those days. but why praise "THE BUTCHER OF PUNJAB- K.P.S.GILL.
@navjyotsingh007
@navjyotsingh007 2 күн бұрын
Thank you for understanding❤
@mTrader1
@mTrader1 2 күн бұрын
Bhindranwale didn’t ask for khalistan
@parmindersinghparm
@parmindersinghparm 5 күн бұрын
The 18th centuries sikhs were terrorist for mugals and Afghanis, and Gadri babbey for Britishers, so as sant jarnail singh for ganga jamuni hindus. The irony is all those so called terrorist attained utmost respect in the hearts of sikhs. And the legacy will keep on going till political sovereignty of Punjabis.
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
Khalistan Zindabad 🦅🦅🦅
@jetank2016
@jetank2016 8 сағат бұрын
Bass karo Fukra Singh ji. Ainni feeling ta Ottoman Empire and British empire and Ashoka Empire aale ni lainde. Bhindrawala was a Fukra and got what he deserved. Such an idiot will never rwch where he was allowed to reach. Study well, come out of trucking and small Jobs in Canada travel and live in India to know what’s India.
@shokivarma7134
@shokivarma7134 Күн бұрын
According to me the most brainless, most cruel, was the attack on the Golden Temple by the Army. This was worst than Gen Dyers attack . Could the generals Brar and Sunderji have forgotten 1. One never attacks a religious place2. Chose the time- not during Gurpurb. 3. Did not study the " Grounds, both physical and on reason. The blackest mark on the Indian Army.
@jatinpandey5653
@jatinpandey5653 Күн бұрын
Sant Bhindranwale zindabad ❤
@sahilk6500
@sahilk6500 9 сағат бұрын
Asli naam se aa Musla hai ya sikhda tu
@hardeepsingh-sg2kz
@hardeepsingh-sg2kz 7 сағат бұрын
@@sahilk6500 tu to lindu hai na?
@Pyasa.shaitan
@Pyasa.shaitan 5 күн бұрын
Indian courts need to work harder, this 15+ year waiting time for a verdict is embarrassing.
@crazyindianguy3134
@crazyindianguy3134 Күн бұрын
Khalasthan zindabaa
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj 5 күн бұрын
The Indian soldiers casualties are highly questionable. Gupta says 136 soldiers were killed but Kuldip Brar says between 300-400 soldiers.
@ranjitpal9937
@ranjitpal9937 2 күн бұрын
India Does not Hide Soldiers Killed in Combat as Our Pollution is Huge
@veer832
@veer832 Күн бұрын
Rajiv gandhi said 700
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj Күн бұрын
@@veer832 Okay & the Governments’ White Paper said 83!soldiers killed. No one truly knows expect the state & the armed forces. All in all the military casualties were heavy.
@karndhillon2018
@karndhillon2018 15 сағат бұрын
Wallpaper said 90 soldiers in one interview Brar said 85 and in his recent, he said 350 something but But it’s near thousand. It is it is questionable because it is not easy to accept that. How come 100 untrained with simple guns had killed thousand soldiers in a few hours
@luv_preet
@luv_preet 8 сағат бұрын
@@karndhillon2018ਜਰਨਲ ਸੂਬੇਗ ਸਿੰਘ
@amritpal4964
@amritpal4964 2 күн бұрын
Shekhar Gupta Venom Oozing Snake against the Sikhs 🦵🏻🦵🏻
@AmritpalSingh-cz2ec
@AmritpalSingh-cz2ec Күн бұрын
We all know when state want to kill someone who beloved by people then state trying to discredit their reputation and assassinate their image, also called him as terrorist. But after 4 decades, Sant ji still lived in our hearts. His character, personality and tales incourage our youth for fight for injustice and their rights.
@georgeabraham5672
@georgeabraham5672 5 күн бұрын
I was 8 years old when Blue star happened... We were inn far away Kerala... Every day i waited for the indian Express to come and my father would read what was happening... It really made me interested in history and politics... Thank you for the great journalism which inspired my generation... You, Talveen singh, Prannnoy roy, et,
@HarishankarPM
@HarishankarPM 5 күн бұрын
Then there's me waiting for Balarama every week at 8 years old.
@georgeabraham5672
@georgeabraham5672 5 күн бұрын
@@HarishankarPM true... I remember that... Especially Mayavi story in it and Boban molly clippings
@gurmitsingh4415
@gurmitsingh4415 4 күн бұрын
it was Genocide
@rajx7120
@rajx7120 4 күн бұрын
Nobody seems to talk about the Hindus killed in Punjab, at that time, by these Khalistanis.
@fussikor5488
@fussikor5488 4 күн бұрын
No talk of Hindus been threatened and taken out of buses and killed. Bhindtawala was 5th pass, what do you expect of his IQ level, just pure fanatic.
2 күн бұрын
Correction- In 1978, 13 person killed by Narankari sect belonged to Akhand Kirtani Jatha. That sect is different to Brhindrawala, even though they always had mutual respect inspite of differences.
@sandhukanwaljot7325
@sandhukanwaljot7325 2 күн бұрын
this guy had some respect during my college days.
@vicky7100
@vicky7100 4 сағат бұрын
Wish more of ThePrint’s other journalists follow Shekhar sir’s Integrity Sensibility and substance in their respective journalism…Shekhar Sir u are inspirational 🙏🏻
@PUNJABREGIONKHALISTAN
@PUNJABREGIONKHALISTAN 5 күн бұрын
You guys never can understand Sikhs and Punjab Godhi media 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
@ranjitpal9937
@ranjitpal9937 5 күн бұрын
Shekhar Gupta Ji , What was Bhrindrawale View on Persecution of Sikh in Pakistan
@kanteya108
@kanteya108 5 күн бұрын
Bhindranwale won't say anything about his jija
@vish3161
@vish3161 5 күн бұрын
I distinctly remember Bhindranwale telling a respected Muslim scribe in India "you are a Muslim. If we Sikhs and Muslims get together we can easily subdue the Hindus". So that should answer your question Iam sure Shekhar remembers this ...
@Vdbail
@Vdbail 5 күн бұрын
Good one. Bhrindrawale loved his Paki paymasters who massacred the SIKHS from 1945 to 1947.
@kanteya108
@kanteya108 5 күн бұрын
​@@vish3161 he was a simp, dhimmi and a useful idiot for them
5 күн бұрын
@@vish3161 It is the wishful thinking of Muslims too - today.
@Jugaantor
@Jugaantor 3 күн бұрын
Shekhar ji is reliving his fanboy moments
@ranjitpal9937
@ranjitpal9937 2 күн бұрын
IT'S Strange that Shekhar Ji , Is Unable to Say a Simple Question " What's was the View of Bhrindranwale of Pakistan 🇵🇰 and Muslims "
@nitee2100
@nitee2100 2 күн бұрын
​@@ranjitpal9937stop trolling each comment
@RangerV8
@RangerV8 5 күн бұрын
Nice anecdotes…could listen to it endlessly with a glass of ginger in rum
@neutrality_456
@neutrality_456 Күн бұрын
Bhindrawale Ji Zindabad....❤
@DikshaK-lo5sf
@DikshaK-lo5sf 5 күн бұрын
Ironically Indians have still not understood punjab and sikhs…. If thy had issues would have be resolved ling ago….
@neerajtyagi6470
@neerajtyagi6470 4 күн бұрын
Your reference to Bhinderwale is like the reference of the lady in IC 814 when she told the media that she was offered burger or something else.
2 күн бұрын
Wondering if you ever mentioned attack on 74 gurdwaras, including 39 historic gurdwaras and why? Basbies as young as few days old were shot at point balnk range.
@yehscam
@yehscam 3 күн бұрын
Old hat at his best!!! Bravo.... No biased half witted kids can match! Long live pada likha jounalist!!
@prakhar6962
@prakhar6962 5 күн бұрын
shekhar gupta is obssessed by bhinderwala, this episode i dont wish to c.....mr gupta hold this brutal radical in very high esteem
@sandeepr2087
@sandeepr2087 5 күн бұрын
He was an Frankenstein monster created by Congress to combat Akali Dal. Well got his comeuppance due to Superb Indian Army.
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj 4 күн бұрын
@@sandeepr2087This conspiracy that Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bindranwala was a creation of the Congress (I) is complete nonsense. Firstly go & get a confirmation from that party & confirm this. He was no creation of the Congress (I). Firstly when he emerged in 1977/78 Indira Gandhi was serving time in prison for her implementation of the emergency. How could she do this from a prison cell? Secondly the the institution that Sant Bhindranwala herald from was first established by the Tenth Guru. A line of Sants has continued. The first 2 in the 1700’s defended Sri Harimandar Sahib from Afghan invaders & attaining martyrdom. Sant Jarnail Singh followed that tradition.
@powerofnature4799
@powerofnature4799 4 күн бұрын
Yeah bcs। u dnt knw him, u r being told dat he is dat brutal radical
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj 4 күн бұрын
@@powerofnature4799 If he was such a brutal radical than why were there always people inside Sri Harimandar Sahib up until June 1984. Domestic & international press were always there.
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj 4 күн бұрын
@@sandeepr2087 What you mean suburb Indian Army? The military lost a huge amount of soldiers. The 136 soldiers Gupta quoted are questionable figures. Kuldip Brar who led the operation for the army was interviewed by ANI & when asked he told the reporter they army lost between 300-400 men. I believe the figure is even higher than that. Not to mention the mass human rights violations that the military committed in immediate aftermath of the operation.
@sidhusworldtourssidhu4667
@sidhusworldtourssidhu4667 4 күн бұрын
A good representation of events.. Sant Bhindrawala was not afraid of vijayanta tanks or Russian commands.. he fought till his last blood.. Army has great failures of history.. and cunning Indira got nothing but shame shame 😅😅
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
Its BS, SG portrays a biased picture, he tries to please Hindu majority
@varinderjitsingh9272
@varinderjitsingh9272 Күн бұрын
We shall avenge 1984 for sure
@AHUJASS
@AHUJASS 3 күн бұрын
Excellent job done to help clarify the situation about the attack by Indian Army.
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj 4 күн бұрын
Sant Jarnail Singh never believed he would win on that night when the battles commenced. He knew that martyrdom was the first steps in a very long war. In Sikh history going to the Gurus the Sikhs fought huge battles against very powerful armies.
@mithun6977
@mithun6977 2 күн бұрын
He was a coward who sacrificed the lives of 100s of sikhs instead of coming out and surrendering to Indian forces. Only delusional fools support him
@importantsomeone153
@importantsomeone153 2 күн бұрын
look mirror u will see your biggest enemy keep on hating hindus blame hindus and forgot about others
@AjayPatil-gf7jz
@AjayPatil-gf7jz 2 күн бұрын
Biggest joke comparing gurus with a terrorist...
@drakonosdrake4927
@drakonosdrake4927 Күн бұрын
​@@AjayPatil-gf7jzu ppl elected the butcher of gujrat as pm what can be expected from u
@mrfreshman521
@mrfreshman521 5 күн бұрын
History repeats itself.
@ravisb123
@ravisb123 2 күн бұрын
They are making sure people do not forget him...by making such videos
@Ynotbehumanfirst
@Ynotbehumanfirst Күн бұрын
Thank you for sharing your experience
@bruceborges
@bruceborges 5 күн бұрын
Wow!! Excellent Episode
@Aleksandr_Gelyevich_Dugin
@Aleksandr_Gelyevich_Dugin 5 күн бұрын
SG's analysis on Punjab's politics, economics, separatism and the complexity is the best....LITERALLY MOST INTERESTING AND PRECISE ON ENTIRE KZfaq.
@ranjitpal9937
@ranjitpal9937 2 күн бұрын
It's Strange that Shekhar Ji , Unable to Say a Simple Question " What's was the View of Bhindranwale of Pakistan 🇵🇰 & Muslim ?
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
Also, false. He says what Indians want to hear
@BilluBadshah-kh1gd
@BilluBadshah-kh1gd 5 күн бұрын
Shekhar Ji , Govt & Non Govt Organization Should Also Highlight That The Holy Golden Temple was Rebuild Not Destroyed and Raised to the Ground and Mother of All Agitation Why
@YuvrajSingh-hi6ke
@YuvrajSingh-hi6ke 5 күн бұрын
Bhindrawale's ideas, radicalism in Punjab, and separate state idea is already understood. I do not support it, But people don't talk about the sufferings and atrocities of the government and police given to the common people of Punjab, I understand some of its credit can be directed towards Bhindrawale and his supporters but what about fake encounters, inhuman police tortures, Op blue star casualties resulting in thousand of common people deaths, genocide in Delhi of Sikhs and racism during Asian games 1982. The fact that the justice for these things and official confession and maybe an apology of the wrongdoings is pending and this is indeed the reason that religious leaders like Amritpal Singh get support in Punjab. The government needs to face the facts and solve the problems of Punjab. It should be started with an official apology by the government for the atrocities faced by the common people of Punjab and Sikhs of Delhi. Till then nothing is gonna change.
@assran66
@assran66 4 күн бұрын
Santji not asking for separate state he never mentioned in any of speech. He was asking for state rights as per the promise by first PM of India. Please read history
@jess-qe5ed
@jess-qe5ed 4 күн бұрын
Bhindrawale is a terrorist, No if or but
@userxyz783
@userxyz783 4 күн бұрын
Lol keep voting congress and expect justice from them
@assran66
@assran66 4 күн бұрын
@@userxyz783 they are all same read the book ( My Love My Country)by LK Advani in it he clearly mentioned that RSS &!BJP pushed Indira for the attack. Little knowledge is always dangerous . Listen to Shekar Gupta/ on The Wire a renown journalist.
@rajx7120
@rajx7120 4 күн бұрын
Has the Congress apologized? You only vote for your killers. And then for some strange reason, you want to hate Modi. And there is lot of anti-Hindu vitriol from apparently Sikh handles. Sometimes, it's hard to believe if they are even actual Sikhs.
@padmak10
@padmak10 4 күн бұрын
We r blessed to have ppl like you to tell the tales ... First hand... thanks for bringing these stories... only hope it does not inspire more ppl to follow BW
@gurpindertoor4347
@gurpindertoor4347 3 күн бұрын
After attack on golden temple i think now its just matter of time that when will Khalistan gonna came to existence sikhs not gonna forget attack
@mdirtydogg
@mdirtydogg 5 күн бұрын
Thank you for this exceedingly interesting episode.
@drnirmalmaakhewala1497
@drnirmalmaakhewala1497 Күн бұрын
Sir, if possible please present a report on the relation between conditions of punjab in 1970s, 80s,90s and the current huge debt on punjab.
@manoharreddy290
@manoharreddy290 5 күн бұрын
Why this obsession with Punjab for you mr shekhar gupta
@BilluBadshah-kh1gd
@BilluBadshah-kh1gd 5 күн бұрын
Because He and His Loved Once Stay In & Around Punjab & Delhi ❤
@Pyasa.shaitan
@Pyasa.shaitan 5 күн бұрын
If punjab separates, it will brake the union. As punjabi’s make up second largest ethnic group in the military
@hotfun07
@hotfun07 5 күн бұрын
Because none of us wants another Kashmir! Also, for North Indians from Punjab and neighboring states, Sikh issues and Hindu Sikh relations matter.
@WhatsInAName222
@WhatsInAName222 5 күн бұрын
Because Punjab matters.
@jasha9sandhu
@jasha9sandhu 5 күн бұрын
Because shekhar is a Punjabi himself.
@preetsingh6993
@preetsingh6993 4 күн бұрын
" Long Live Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale " 🙏 He made our head honorable ❤
@userxyz783
@userxyz783 4 күн бұрын
Terrorist sympathiser
@MackyMehra
@MackyMehra 4 күн бұрын
Sant Jarnail Singh ji Bhindrawale Zindabaad 🪯🚩
@anjalidastur7132
@anjalidastur7132 5 күн бұрын
Very interesting indeed!
@chetanbs8734
@chetanbs8734 4 күн бұрын
Thank you Sir ❤
@Roohandisoojh
@Roohandisoojh Күн бұрын
ਹੁਣ ਤੂੰ ਕੀ ਕਰੀ ਜਾਂਨਾ ਪਿਓ ਦਾ ਪਤਾ ਹੋਵੇ ਤਾਂ ਹੀ ਆ
@malkitsingh3748
@malkitsingh3748 2 күн бұрын
Sir ji abhi jamu m shardhalo ko mara gia hum us ko galat bolte yeh nahi hona chahida....sant ji vare ....subra suaami kya kahte hae us pr vi vat karie
@harindersingh1153
@harindersingh1153 2 күн бұрын
Shame on you Shekkhar for spewing such cheap venom after 40 years when the individual you are targeting is not here to defend himself! He was, is, and will remain in the psyche of every Sikh till last one of us is alive.
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
Well said 🙏🏻
@tanmayparmar2208
@tanmayparmar2208 5 күн бұрын
Sir thank you
@sukhpalsinghji
@sukhpalsinghji 10 сағат бұрын
any interview from you of Gen. Sinaha . any angle from narankari prospect .
@samip3124
@samip3124 4 күн бұрын
India stands with Sikhs ♥️
@gpsingh7389
@gpsingh7389 5 күн бұрын
Sir, those were bad days. I was a teenager then. May Almighty bless us with better times . Violence is better a voided.
@knowledge_forever
@knowledge_forever 4 күн бұрын
Bhindrawales son in serving as IPS in Bengal. Under a different name, and father's name.
@ustroop771
@ustroop771 3 күн бұрын
U fanatic hindu Mr Gupta don’t worry we have been facing enemies like u for 300 years
@userxyz783
@userxyz783 4 күн бұрын
Bhindranwale = Festering Fingerprint Vyke (only Elden Ring players will get the reference)
@ajeetrayakar7582
@ajeetrayakar7582 5 күн бұрын
Great ❤
@ranjitpal9937
@ranjitpal9937 5 күн бұрын
Hope in Your Next " Episode 2.0 on Bhindranwale " Shekhar Ji You will CTC on Bhrindranwale's View of " Muslim Torture of Sikh Guru's "
@powerofnature4799
@powerofnature4799 4 күн бұрын
U shud also ask about hindus betrayal to sikh gurus😅😅😅
@rugervv
@rugervv 3 күн бұрын
They were mughals not regular Muslims & what about H1ndu pahadi kings who betrayed with our 10th guru
@ranjitpal9937
@ranjitpal9937 2 күн бұрын
@@powerofnature4799 OK Taken 👍 But What's Bhindranwale View / Said About Pakistan 🇵🇰 and Muslims
@rugervv
@rugervv 2 күн бұрын
@@ranjitpal9937 are u stupid? Why would he say anything about them? He was not born in pakistani Punjab As majority of the sikhs decided to came to India with the promises made by Nehru and gandhi
@veer832
@veer832 Күн бұрын
​@@ranjitpal9937he said sikh become good sikh.... Hindu become good hindu .. Muslim become good muslim
@Desiforever
@Desiforever Күн бұрын
“Hindu state “
@amanpreetsingh7202
@amanpreetsingh7202 Күн бұрын
You've got no reference of his good deeds and is influenced by what is taught in your belief about him. He aided numerous Sikh and Hindi married women being troubled for dowry to get settled in their families. Your reference is just coming from core ignorance
@SherSidhu-xt6jm
@SherSidhu-xt6jm 3 күн бұрын
In a book written by Shekhar Gupta and Tavleen, Butcher KPS Gill writes a forward that sheds light on Shekhar's background. Gupta, NC Menon, and Giri Lal Jain were among the leading propagandists for the Hindutava state (regardless of the political party in power). They were accountable for casting aspersions, slandering, and eventually inflating the narrative and fabricating falsehoods to support the premeditated attack on Darbar Sahib. Sikhs have a deep admiration for Sant Bhinderanwale, who, together with about 100 other Sikhs, bravely defended Darbar Sahib with their last breath and bullet. Despite facing overwhelming odds from a 70,000-strong Nazi Hindu invading army, he never gave up.
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
Sant Ji forever ❤️
@starxust3827
@starxust3827 2 күн бұрын
Pain
@jaspalsingh2075
@jaspalsingh2075 5 күн бұрын
Es program nu Punjabi yaa hindi vich translation karke v pesh kitaa jawe benti hai ji 🙏🙏
@shanmugasundaram8517
@shanmugasundaram8517 5 күн бұрын
By the time I reached 0:51, I decided it was the fact the Amritpal Singh and Eng Rashid got elected in the MP election that is the most troubling issue right now.
@BilluBadshah-kh1gd
@BilluBadshah-kh1gd 5 күн бұрын
Many Current MLA are Serving Their Area from Jail
@jasha9sandhu
@jasha9sandhu 5 күн бұрын
Bhindrawaley was a illiterate radical rat cultivated by Indira who tirned Frankenstein & brought misery & mayhem to Punjab. I as a someone from Punjabi Jat Sikh family condemn Khalistani scourge that he unleashed & still continues to afflict punjab , exploited by India 's enemies even now.
@jaibirkang5345
@jaibirkang5345 5 күн бұрын
Were you not bothered when sadhvi pragya was elected as MP ? Or when Lalu prasad yadav selected as railway minister ?
@KaliYugaSurfer_
@KaliYugaSurfer_ 5 күн бұрын
​@@jaibirkang5345i was now what
@ornament_of_throne12346
@ornament_of_throne12346 5 күн бұрын
​@@KaliYugaSurfer_lil bh@ng! listen You didn't do shit on that nor did ur agencies , nor was there any outrage by self proclaimed progressive tolerant secular hindu majority.
@gurpreet6612
@gurpreet6612 5 күн бұрын
a sikh always carry weapon to protect himself and otherself
@tamashbeen6610
@tamashbeen6610 5 күн бұрын
A Sikh should also carry common sense and humility.
@gurpreet6612
@gurpreet6612 5 күн бұрын
@@tamashbeen6610 Sikh also carry sense but you don't
@gurpreet6612
@gurpreet6612 5 күн бұрын
@@tamashbeen6610 Hindus used to hand over their daughters and sisters to the Mughals after getting married, and the Abdali Hindu girls were taken as slaves, and then the Sikhs used to free them with weapons. When Where was your this sense & Humility also?
@gamecampus4594
@gamecampus4594 5 күн бұрын
​@@tamashbeen6610 tum logo ne hatyar rakhe hote aaj ram mandir ka randi rona naa rote 😂
@vish3161
@vish3161 4 күн бұрын
@@gurpreet6612 Please stop living in the past all the time.
@twisha1985
@twisha1985 5 күн бұрын
Shekhar ji kindly suggest some best reads on the subject
@fsckool6894
@fsckool6894 5 күн бұрын
then you will only get the prospective of state, and you will never understand what is going on the ground
@rajanpreetkaur121
@rajanpreetkaur121 5 күн бұрын
Just try to find out banned books or articles maybe it's close to reality.
@anilraghu8687
@anilraghu8687 4 күн бұрын
Books are dead because of piracy.
@cb9461
@cb9461 5 күн бұрын
Anand pur resolution was given a very shoddy treatment by hindu nationalists of that time the Indra and her coterie . It could have been atleast discussed in democratic manner and some sane hindus could have tried to understand sikh concerns but alas it was simply put aside. Some points could have been taken others discarded atleast it would have assuaged sikh feelings to certain extent. When sikh radicalism is highlighted one shouldn't forget behind that is always reaction to majoritarian radicalism.
@ornament_of_throne12346
@ornament_of_throne12346 5 күн бұрын
Well said
@mithun6977
@mithun6977 2 күн бұрын
Indian Hindus are just reacting to global majoritarian radicalism of Muslims Christians and Sikhs
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
Agreed, SG annoys me
@mithun6977
@mithun6977 2 күн бұрын
Hindu radicalism is a reaction to global majoritarian radicalism. Of Christians muslims and sikhs
@malkitsingh3748
@malkitsingh3748 2 күн бұрын
Sir ji...1984 m harimander sahib t Ikela hamla nahi tha.....70 guruduwaro m indian armi n hamla kia tha..ham usko ab vi using tra dekhte hae Or apne bacho ko vi bitate hae Kya kabhi is akhoti secular n kiha...k jo hua galt hua....sivae general sinha.....hamla vi us waqt jab hamare 5 guru ka shahidi divas ko mana rahe the.yah ham kabhi vi nahi bhulege yeh sikh kom da ithas aa....delhi or jgah jo katleaam hua jinda jalandhar gae....jo logo ko bhulna nahi dega....us ka jumewar kon
@ajitnadgouda6079
@ajitnadgouda6079 3 күн бұрын
Shekhar Gupta is telling a story how Bhindranwale was martyred and how he was shot dead. And before that, how he killed more than hundreds of Indian Army people. Before glorifying him so much, Mr Gupta you should tell how Indian Army people died. They had instructions not to shoot. So they just walked into the open ground without firing and thereafter Bhindranwale people, who were hiding in Akal Takht shot all those people down. Thereafter Army in-charge Mr Brar called Indira Gandhi in the midnight and then Indira Gandhi instructed to send tanks and stop all that nonsense. Why didn't you tell that? Enough of your glorification of Bhindranwale and his Khalistani movements. Hypocrite journalists like you glorify such people like Burhan Wani or Bhindranwale or Afzal Guru.
@heirapparent3433
@heirapparent3433 5 күн бұрын
"Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep's clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves. You will know them by their fruits. Are grapes gathered from thorns, or figs from thistles?"
@santsaransingh8708
@santsaransingh8708 5 күн бұрын
Later I lost my parents in 1984 riots. This was an unforgettable era.
@Manish_Kumar_Singh
@Manish_Kumar_Singh 4 күн бұрын
Sorry for the loss
@SoilofMartyrs
@SoilofMartyrs 3 күн бұрын
No justice for us in india.
@Manish_Kumar_Singh
@Manish_Kumar_Singh 2 күн бұрын
@@SoilofMartyrs It's sad, all I can give is best wished and that the sikh genocide will never be forgotten.
@Ynotbehumanfirst
@Ynotbehumanfirst Күн бұрын
It was not riots it was genocide of Sikhs only Sikhs.
@rajanpreetkaur121
@rajanpreetkaur121 5 күн бұрын
If sant ji teroiust then what is defination of Robinhood
@hotfun07
@hotfun07 5 күн бұрын
Shekhar Sir, Why NO PROGRESS ON ANANTPUR SAHAB RESOLUTION? NEITHER AKALIS NOR CONGRESS, NOT EVEN NEWCOMER AAP HAVE DONE ANYTHING TOWARDS ANANTPUR SAHAB RESOLUTION!
@lalsinghdhaliwal-oh1gy
@lalsinghdhaliwal-oh1gy 5 күн бұрын
It’s indeed “Anandpur Sahib Resolution”to spell correctly. My apologies if you feel offended for this grammatical correction.
@tamashbeen6610
@tamashbeen6610 5 күн бұрын
Anandpur Sahib Resolution will make very good toilet paper for my dog. Get over it. Punjab doesn't belong to only Sikhs.
@lovedeepsingh8729
@lovedeepsingh8729 5 күн бұрын
​@@tamashbeen6610only if you had read it before commenting. Basic research would go a long way in dispelling misconceptions
@lalsinghdhaliwal-oh1gy
@lalsinghdhaliwal-oh1gy 5 күн бұрын
@@tamashbeen6610 I would suggest you to get educated by reading through this document first prior to writing such a trash. Adhering to civic sense, please avoid using such insipid words because it’s not a war of words. Adopt argumentative approach. Be sensible and use parliamentary words. Therein lies greatness of a good human beings such as you, I and all in our social milieu. Please don’t get offended unnecessarily as I’ve never used any derogatory language. Kindly be mindful that “Anandpur Sahib”is a place of Khalsa Sajna by Dasam Pita- Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji who passed on guruship to AN ETERNAL GURU-Sri Guru Granth Sahib (The Holy Granth). FYI, it’s this place wherefrom Guru Gobind Singh Ji requested His Father, Sri Guru Teg Bahadur Ji to go to Delhi for sacrifice for the sake of Kashmiri Pandits. Thus, let’s argue logically and in a friendly manner to develop better understanding in order to create a cohesive and environment full of respect in the larger societal interests. My unconditional apologies if you got hurt, so let me know as to what’s your concern and we can resolve amicably minus toxic terminologies. Sincere Regards!🙏🌹
@hotfun07
@hotfun07 5 күн бұрын
@@tamashbeen6610 Some CLAUSES in Anandpur Sahab declaration are NOT EXCLUSIVELY ABOUT PUNJAB. THE PUNJAB BJP AND CONGRESS AND AAP MUST TAKE LEAD AND FORCE SGPC AND 'FRINGE' TO DROP IT AS THEIR SOLE POLITICAL PREROGATIVE.
@Star-ds4sd
@Star-ds4sd 5 күн бұрын
? How Golden Temple or Any Sikh Religious Place are Being Checked that Another 1984 Does Not Happen Again .Please Tell Us in Episode 2
@expiredparacetamol
@expiredparacetamol 5 күн бұрын
I don't get what you mean
@Star-ds4sd
@Star-ds4sd 4 күн бұрын
@@expiredparacetamol How the Punjab Government Taking Steps to Make Sure Sikh Religious Places are Not Again Being Use to Store Lethal Weapon like " 1984 Golden Temple "
@mg.f.9023
@mg.f.9023 5 күн бұрын
स्वतंत्र रूप से काम करने वाले पत्रकारों से क्यों डरती है सरकार ?
@rogermilla2358
@rogermilla2358 5 күн бұрын
"Topiwalas won't be able to withstand us" - LMAO, how'd that turn out...?
@fsckool6894
@fsckool6894 5 күн бұрын
yet indian army lost the most men
@gurpreetdhillon2
@gurpreetdhillon2 5 күн бұрын
150 militants dying and over 700 Indian soldiers - confirmed by General Vidya Real numbers are probably higher
@justicebat2304
@justicebat2304 5 күн бұрын
Army lost approximately 15,000 army soldiers. More than half, in the end they had to bring Vijayanta Tanks to deal with him LOL
@gurpreetdhillon2
@gurpreetdhillon2 5 күн бұрын
@@justicebat2304 yeah these are the more correct numbers, but they wouldn’t believe unless you told them it’s was one of their own generals. Which is still wrong number tho. 15,000 vs 150 gives Saraghai vibes
@rogermilla2358
@rogermilla2358 5 күн бұрын
@@gurpreetdhillon2 Yea fuckin right LMFAO, why not 9999900000 Trillion? Sikhs love to make up fake numbers.
@SuminderpalSingh
@SuminderpalSingh 5 күн бұрын
Now there is GodiMedia, back then there was CongiMedia. Shekhar Gupta was part of the toolkit of the CongiMedia strategy. India Today was known for its bias and everyone knew about it. Till now Shekhar regurgitates from the past memory. He still has not updated his knowledge as more revelations have come from GBS Sidhu and BD Pande memoirs. Shekhar-ji, this time around, please read and review above referenced work before releasing next 3 videos.
@user-po4xb2lt5x
@user-po4xb2lt5x 5 күн бұрын
Gbs sidhu clearly said that bhindrawla was a congress stooge...
@ahirbhairavorai7793
@ahirbhairavorai7793 5 күн бұрын
How is the que for visa to visit Kartarpura ? Atleast during the era of GodiMedia we dont need visa for Ayodhya.
@manpreetmannu1428
@manpreetmannu1428 3 күн бұрын
True ..congi media nd godi media ..both enemy of punjab ….bjp rss nd cong …anti sikh nd anti punjab parties
@fsckool6894
@fsckool6894 5 күн бұрын
what do you expect when you can't address basic issues.
@amiteshsingh5033
@amiteshsingh5033 5 күн бұрын
Too early for khalistani bots😂
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
Hindu bots are spamminh 🤭
@AasraTeraa
@AasraTeraa 10 сағат бұрын
Excuse me, sir, you call a man that said, a respect of women and their sanctity of their honoring dignity and to let everyone be true with their faith and religion. As long as they respect eachother considering each other's holy books and human rights. You call him a extremist or radical. It's not u speakinh mmg it is the puppet master s behind u telli gnwhay lie to spewi language that you are speaking. The people that are putting the strings in the background that I don't know. I'm having to speak in that language as wellong. Live, this is Des I's having respect compassion for DEsi. Yes. I's no matter wha a faith,or commonalities. We have and could we all should share?Protect your culture in your language.Not be little each other and Cartwright.More division under a foreign power that you're getting even though I live in a foreign country and I don't have anything.Yes, anybody I respect the lens.I live in and I do speak that foreign language as well.But I don't believe anybody should or deceive.Or loot anybody else .jai insaniyat jai punjab jai bharat say no to colonial oppresion name not given by us jai Baaharat Jai Ahkaal ka istan
@amanpreetsingh7202
@amanpreetsingh7202 Күн бұрын
You got this completely wrong on that old lady trying to touch his feet. As per Sikh principles touching feet of somebody outside your family out of religious piouty is completely banished. Once he jokingly asked a women trying to touch his feet saying what'll you get out of this let others also see. You've got it completely wrong on various terms on educated being banished he himself was well versed with our Baani and was held highly for his santhiya. Quite a shameless disclosure
@Rt7op7
@Rt7op7 5 күн бұрын
Abhi Bhindiwala bots aate honge
@crazyindianguy3134
@crazyindianguy3134 Күн бұрын
Hello hindu rastra atankwadi
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj 4 күн бұрын
It’s interesting that today Gupta says that Sant Jarnail Singh Bindranwala never mentioned the “K” word meaning he never mentioned Khalistan but his publication India Today still says that the Sant was head of Khalistan.
@nitee2100
@nitee2100 2 күн бұрын
It all started since then
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj 2 күн бұрын
@@nitee2100 No. Your comment is excuse for really bad journalism. Journalism that follows the states’ narrative & not free & independent which is what these media outlets try & hoodwink their audiences with. Gupta days this today because he is pitting one against the other. Bhai Amritpal Singh is clear when he says that he wants Khalistan. So hence people like Gupta say but Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bindranwala never demanded Khalistan or has Gupta says never mentioned the “K” word. This is real reason why Gupta says this. His than publication stated this all along. Typical scheming Hindus. Never trust these people.
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
I do not like SG's talks on Sikhs and Panjab, he always tries to portray Indian Hindu point of view and not a neutral talk, I listen to him to see how low he can stoop down to pleaae Hindu majority
@NoName-jq7tj
@NoName-jq7tj Күн бұрын
@@ajeebdastan1152 This is typical of Indian journalism because the Hindus are the majority & they have to be appeased to keep the audiences & the advertising revenues keep coming. What’s honesty go to do with anything?
@bm19411
@bm19411 Күн бұрын
Modi and his fully supported religious fanatics are more radicals than Amritpal Singh.We better at least try to understand this newly elected MP.
@jaspalsingh2075
@jaspalsingh2075 5 күн бұрын
Kachha nahi ji kachhehara kaho ji
@ravinderrathore2656
@ravinderrathore2656 Сағат бұрын
what reality hideout.. what story we listened by story tellers its different topic but what did prime minister gandhi and sant bhindrawala.... we seen the result... 2 communities divided for forever (sikhs and hindus) ... its bitter truth... present govt and future govts have cure for punjabis but i cannot expect any hope to them.... but if majority in hindus and sikhs trying by himself.. they can fill gap which build by political structure
@driasalta4834
@driasalta4834 5 күн бұрын
Akali Dal's bad performance will have Consquences, we already see Amritpal singh winning by 1 lakh votes, they need to start becoming relavant again before we start extremism rise again
@expiredparacetamol
@expiredparacetamol 5 күн бұрын
Akalis got in power cuz of Sikhs supporting them but kicked them right back so don't expect akalis for 2 decades if i say the least
@expiredparacetamol
@expiredparacetamol 5 күн бұрын
Also there's two type of extremists in Punjab in 1900s one was motivated attacks on whosoever doesn't likes khalistani ideology which was on very low scale than the fake encounters, oppression, fake cases kidnapping rapes that were committed by the govt . Just because someone in power did it doesn't make it right
@nitinpatel1039
@nitinpatel1039 5 күн бұрын
People like amritpal getting elected what more indication u need where that state is headed
@bassih9797
@bassih9797 5 күн бұрын
The state fairs much better when the center has no influence. Amritpal has reversed the nonsense inflicted onto the ppl of panjab. Hindu families whos sons are affected by the drug issue have also stood my amritpal, so open your eyes, you know nothing about the state.
@paramchahal6440
@paramchahal6440 3 күн бұрын
What about sadhvi pragya thakur, modi, Amit sha?
@mithun6977
@mithun6977 2 күн бұрын
​@@bassih9797Sikh extremists like Amritpal are Hindu hating bigots. Go fool someone else
@udayveersingh8238
@udayveersingh8238 2 күн бұрын
​@@paramchahal6440 now Patels Asss is shut..they don't talk about its Hindu Terrorist Regime, Rapist, Politicians, Sanddh Gurmeet Raping their Daughters n they Celebrate it by giving him palores..
@udayveersingh8238
@udayveersingh8238 2 күн бұрын
@NitinPatel..if you don't know about Punjab, Amritpal, n Sikhs don't talk what ever Terrorist Godi Media putting in your Brain Go Punjab learn about it from Sikh Hindu in Punjab...then talk.. Amritpal not asking that Khalistan the one you get feed by Indian Terrorist Regime Agencies...he is talking about Khalsa Raj.....Educate yourself or you too young or dumb
@ravisehgal.2694
@ravisehgal.2694 5 күн бұрын
In 80s I was in College , joined Armed Forces immediately after Op Blue Star. Considered myself NOT to be influenced by any Religion but on listening his speech accidently & found myself wavering. The Same style of all Religious preachers to influence Public. One is likely to be carried away.
@parmindersinghparm
@parmindersinghparm 5 күн бұрын
Then you should also condemned book Gita as well because that was dictated to arjuna and he start killing his own relatives ruthlessly.
@ravisehgal.2694
@ravisehgal.2694 5 күн бұрын
@@parmindersinghparm If you care to understand, Bhagawat Gita is comparable to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The speeches of Late Sant were NOT limited to discourses from Shri Guru Granth Sahib.
@ravisehgal.2694
@ravisehgal.2694 5 күн бұрын
@@parmindersinghparm : I shall add to my reply. Arjun fought with those who had wronged him and his brothers . In war both sides have chance to survive. Whereas in 1984 and during the period those who were killed from both Religions were innocent victims and NOT warriors.
@rajx7120
@rajx7120 4 күн бұрын
​@@parmindersinghparmDon't bring Gita into this. Those relatives were also ready to fight Arjuna. As a soldier, it was his duty to fight, and be sincere towards his job. As a real life application, if a policeman's brother is a criminal, then the policeman must catch the criminal, because it is his duty, and not side with him, because he happens to be his brother. Gita teaches you sincerity.
@ranjitpal9937
@ranjitpal9937 2 күн бұрын
IT'S Strange that Shekhar Ji is Unable to Say What's was Bridhawale's View of Pakistan 🇵🇰 & Muslim
@user-yn2hn6jc6t
@user-yn2hn6jc6t 4 күн бұрын
Indian still not understood punjab
@ganeshadsul656
@ganeshadsul656 5 күн бұрын
Shekharji we know that west is funding these people and congress is supporting the same we are not blind to understand
@aravindbt007
@aravindbt007 5 күн бұрын
Why do you praise a person who had hated peaceful Hindus, he was like any other radical who believes he.and his community is superior
@gurpartapsingh6209
@gurpartapsingh6209 Күн бұрын
This so called hater of hindus had built a temple for hindus, paid for court cases against people who burnt Ramayana, helped settlement of hindu girls who were victims of dowry. His image was totally distorted by the media in those days. U won't believe but he didn't even demand khalistan. The demand for khalistan came into existence after his death and post blue Star period
@Vdbail
@Vdbail 5 күн бұрын
AAP and Congress playing the same deadly game of late 70s and early 80s.
@assran66
@assran66 5 күн бұрын
Even BJP
@powerofnature4799
@powerofnature4799 4 күн бұрын
Dis time bjp is playng dis game through their it cell . Labelling every sikh as a khalistani frm last 3 years. And now result is in open. People in punjab proudly starting to accept dis labell
@Vdbail
@Vdbail 4 күн бұрын
@@powerofnature4799 : Come on. Sikhs gave support for Muslims during brainless CAA protest. Its from this point the situation started deteriorating. Eventually by joining hands with khalistanis who will suffer. The people of punjab will suffer. Its like saying my friends are drunkards and I am also being called a Drunkard and so I also decided to become a drunkard...ROFL
@powerofnature4799
@powerofnature4799 4 күн бұрын
@@Vdbail ok if u see it without ur chashma of hate. U ll see alot of hindus even more dan sikhs, supported dat protest . U cn call dem left liberal hindus. But every society has all type of people. But u nafrati people just judge a whole community on a small incidents. Sometimes u start even hating a whole community. And u r talking nonsense. U r threatening the people of punjab ll suffer? Now u have come in dis position to threaten other people? Or declare other people as anti-nationals. But in reality u have never done a damn thing fr dis country. U hateful people accepted mughals supression , whereas we fought dem. U den accepted british rule even den we fought dem. But now on the basis of voting numbers somehow u hateful people came into power. Now u r showing ur true colours
@anilraghu8687
@anilraghu8687 4 күн бұрын
Inevitable
@srikantpadma3573
@srikantpadma3573 5 күн бұрын
I lost my love my beloved brothers because of this guy but it has returned. Please protect your religion. Journalists have always given bad guys the platform they didn’t deserve. SG is giddy and sounds like he was in love with a woman way above his class.
@anilraghu8687
@anilraghu8687 4 күн бұрын
How it's only one side?
@paramveersingh5621
@paramveersingh5621 5 күн бұрын
Raj Karega Khalsa
@Vdbail
@Vdbail 5 күн бұрын
Thanks Sekhar ji for sharing the details. Looks like this fellow Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale was an arrogant, egoistic, conceited gang leader. Guess that is what he was. A mobster who fooled innocent rural folks. Bhindranwale died like a rabid animals and also took along the lives of so many hapless people. Wish the political class of the day was more mature and did not allow this serpent to grow.
5 күн бұрын
At that time, the whole country was awed by the bravery of Sikh soldiers in 1965 and 1971 wars. In those days, Sikhs were addressed with a honorific 'Sardar'. Bindranwale brought an end to all that when he portrayed Sikhs as religious zealots who wanted to fight the Hindus and Sikhs in India with terrorism.
@vaibhavbatra4613
@vaibhavbatra4613 5 күн бұрын
He sounds a lot like a contemporary "Supreme Leader" we all know 🙃
5 күн бұрын
All these religious demagogues think that they are 'Supreme Leaders'. That is the tragedy; for them and their followers.
@justicebat2304
@justicebat2304 5 күн бұрын
Comparing Modi to Santji is shameful on your part. Google ‘Greatest Sikh/Sikh Martyr of 20th Century’
@vaibhavbatra4613
@vaibhavbatra4613 5 күн бұрын
​@@justicebat2304I never took anybody's name. Lol.
@hardeepsingh-sg2kz
@hardeepsingh-sg2kz 7 сағат бұрын
@@vaibhavbatra4613also the supreme leader needs to grow some balls first
@Desiforever
@Desiforever Күн бұрын
550 Hindu hatred showes
@ManOfSteel1
@ManOfSteel1 4 күн бұрын
you don't do videos for free shekhar, what's cooking? amritpal winning election from Assam jail while shyam rangeela is not even allowed to file nomination. is shah preparing bindrawala 2.0 with this dubai return truck driver amritpal? they definitely won't fallout like Indira because thousands of spg protecting the ministers these days and no one to stop them manuplating the system. something is cooking big and this might be once In a lifetime opportunity for you since you always like to be at the centre of things. ambition runs beyond money looking at a silent godi I can feel it.
@RamRamaswami
@RamRamaswami 3 күн бұрын
Why on earth would anyone want to perpetuate the memory of a misguided terrorist who probably was under foreign influence too? Disappointed. He did not even have the minimal respect towards his own religion or temple, and made the Golden Temple an inevitable target. The less we even mention such people, the better we and the world would be.
@ajeebdastan1152
@ajeebdastan1152 2 күн бұрын
Sant Ji was not a Terrorist
IS THIS REAL FOOD OR NOT?🤔 PIKACHU AND SONIC CONFUSE THE CAT! 😺🍫
00:41
Super gymnastics 😍🫣
00:15
Lexa_Merin
Рет қаралды 99 МЛН
Just try to use a cool gadget 😍
00:33
123 GO! SHORTS
Рет қаралды 74 МЛН
How India silences critics in the US and Canada | Fault Lines Documentary
24:52
IS THIS REAL FOOD OR NOT?🤔 PIKACHU AND SONIC CONFUSE THE CAT! 😺🍫
00:41