In depth, detailed and amazing insights. Please provide your economic model to PM on the future plans to transform NEW INDIA into a superpower. Thanks Harshji

as a bengali i take pride on harsh's visionary mind...i really wish bengal gets a better governance

Very well articulated, no fluff, to the point, factual, put well into current perspective

भारत का दुर्भाग्य है कि हमने हमेशा परायो को ही सर पर बैठाया और अपनी ऐसी तैसी करवा ली। 1000 सालो की गुलामी ने हमे कही का नही छोड़ा। आज भी हम उसी दौर में जी रहे है। लोगो की आँखों में पट्टी बंधी हुई है और सब ऊपरी आवरण को देख रहे है। 70 साल की आजादी में हम अच्छी रोजगारोन्मुखी शिक्षा,नागरिक शिक्षा,पानी,बिजली और सड़क नहीं दे पाए तो क्या किया ,घंटा आज हम बेरोजगारी की समस्या को रो रहे है,इतनी जनसँख्या क्या मोदी ने बढ़ाई, क्या इंदिरा गांधी ने या मनमोहन सिंह ने? राहुल गांधी और मोदी एक बात में तो समान है कि दोनों ने देश की जनसँख्या बढ़ाने में कोई योगदान नही किया😊 दरअसल जब देश आजाद हुआ तो हमारी सरकार अंग्रेजो की परछाई या कहे गुलामी की छाया से बाहर ही नहीं आ सकी उसमे अपने देश के लिए कुछ सोचने की समझ नही थी। हमारे उस समय के नेता बंटे हुए थे और उन्हें सिर्फ आजाद होने की धुन थी,आजाद होने के बाद भारत कैसा होगा इसकी कोई योजना नहीं थी क्योंकि कांग्रेस उस समय भी उच्च स्थिति में थी और किसी का नहीं सुनती थी।और जिस प्रकार नेहरू जी के चर्चे होते है जो सत्य भी है ,उस हिसाब से लगता है कि आजादी के बाद शुरूआती सालो में भी अंग्रेजो ने ही हम पर राज किया नहीं तो क्या कारण है कि हम ये basic जरूरते भी plan नही कर पाए? आज हम नया घर बनाते है तो कितनी planing करते है कि bathroom कहाँ होगा,kitchen कैसा होगा,पानी की क्या व्यवस्था रहेगी,बिजली की व्यवस्था कैसी रहेगी।लेकिन यहां तो 1947 में देश का निर्माण हो रहा था तब ये सब क्यों नही सोचा गया? तब क्यों नही शिक्षा दी गयी कि घर की माता बहनो को जंगल में ना जाना पड़े,तब क्यों नहीं शिक्षित किया गया कि छोटा परिवार सुखी परिवार,तब क्यों नहीं ऐसी शिक्षा दी गयी कि युवा कुछ ऐसा सीखे जिससे उन्हें रोजगार मिले,तब ये शिक्षा क्यों नही दी गयी कि समाज में कैसे रहना है? हमारे देश की नींव बहुत कमजोर थी इसलिए पूरी इमारत हिली हुई है।एक आदमी के 18 घंटे काम करने से कुछ नहीं होगा। आज हर कोई मोदी और राहुल गांधी को गाली देने में लगा हुआ है।हम वो लोग है जो देश के राष्ट्र गान पर खड़ा होने में भी शरमाते है और कोर्ट में case लगा देते है। अगर मोदी ने UNO में 21 जून को योग दिवस घोषित करवाया तो कांग्रेसी होने के नाते हम उसमे शामिल नहीं होंगे,ये तो हमारे देश का ही नाम ऊंचा करने वाला काम था ना?फिर विरोध क्यों? देश के हर नागरिक को जात पात,वर्ग भेद से ऊपर उठकर देश के लिए थोड़ा सा contribution जरूर करना होगा,सरकार को गाली देने से क्या होगा? जय भारत

Very comprehensive and informative talk!

A very comphrensive end to end talk . Harha Gupta represents next gen economics who will play active role in india's economical progression.

A fairly good perspective on Hamiltonian/Listian/Shimomuran economic view. But this is a complex topic and hence there is plenty to disagree and supplement in the talk. Failures in education and health apart, not boosting the judicial numbers is also a big failure. 3.3 crore pending cases and counting. Having an adequate judiciary is in his terms, the level of Hobbes, not even Locke. Saying that we're getting past the level of Locke is probably disingenuous there. I straight out disagree with the blending ethanol proposition. It's much better to create a parallel methanol/ethanol fuel cell infrastructure and incentivize the fuel cell cars at the same level as electric cars.

Excellent HarshGuptaji, keep it up

No Imitation 👍👍👍✌️✌️✌️🕉️🕉️🕉️🤺🤺🤺💃💃💃🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🔥🔥🔥only Bharat Nomics..... 🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🌹🌹🌹🔥🔥🔥Jai Bharat Mata kee 🇮🇳🌊🌫️

Brilliant!

Excellent talk, Is this talk also available in Hindi ?

enjoyed this talk a lot

Well analyzed, well presented

2 very good points I did not expect while starting the video but may be that's why I feel they were really important, 1-someone actually pointed out the actual damage that was done to the economy by Mrs.Indira Gandhi. 2- the development that needs to be done in education sector specifically in terms of opening up the higher reduction sector, which needs to free people from this kind of a license Raj in higher education interms of the only degrees valid in India now are through ugc approved universities

Hearing it during the time of COVID-19 pandemic, his assessments about China-India, US-China relations are becoming damn true

Great insights

Yes tariff are very much needed

Very nice talk. Thanks to Harsh. I have to say '100 % education' point I don't get. How is it correct ? Need more details and proof. Will try to look up myself as well.

My analysis about Indian poverty. 1) Stringent taxation policy. Indian government is a tax sucking agency, which only knows how to suck tax and fill the gold reserves. I have thoroughly studied the Vodafone tax evasion case, where supreme court gave clean chit to Vodafone company when it gave heavy taxation as the reason why it used a subsidiary in the third nation to move its shares without paying a bit of Capital gain tax to India, as per vodafone's report Indian government sucks almost around 35% of a company's earning as tax, and rest 65% of the profit has to be deducted in operating costs, interests, and dividends to the share holders of the company and nothing gets spared in the end for a company to even think of future expansion and growth. This is the reason why many international companies refrains from doing FDI investments in India and India do not get growth. 2) More than 50% of Indian population still lives in the villages and they don't even know how to write their names leave alone being educated, I don't know who gave you the data of India being 99% literate. 3) Indian youth is young and with a lot of energy but very useless at the same time, Youth is completely unskilled and according to a research 35% of B-tech graduates dont even know how to reboot a computer. India is a factory of fake degrees and fake education. 4) Indians have been least trained in moral values as a subject, their tendency of becoming corrupt and criminal is the highest in this world after Pakistan and few countries in Africa. 5) You were talking about woman and gender inequality in India........why women are better in Europe? and why gender ratio is better there? Answer : After 1914 this whole world got doomed into two consecutive world wars, which as per estimate wiped out almost 70% of young men population between 16 years -40 years from Europe, Russia and Japan, and the remaining had become either handicap or mutilated and useless. As per post two world wars estimates the ratio of men in Europe, Russia and Japan almost plunged to 1:3, where there was only one man over 3 women. At this point of time India remained least affected as not much Indian men were lost and were still more in ratio when compared to women. Women took the responsibilities after world war and worked in European industries day and night including in Russia and Japan. The reason why we get to see so Powerful ladies in Europe like Angela Markel, Theresa May and Margaret Hilda Thatcher etc .......Just like in India women in Europe were also treated like a commodity before 1914, but their real value was felt after the heavy loss of millions of young men. It was a coincidence for them.

good economic thought.

THANK YOU MR. HARSH GUPTA...!!! HOPE...ACTION ...QUALITY IMPLEMENTATION...WITH LONG TERM GOAL...EASY ACCESSIBILITY FOR CORRECTING POLICIES AND REPAIR OF INFRASTRUCTURES , BOTH LOCALLY & NATIONALLY...!!! THEN IN THE GLOBAL LEVEL...!!! FOR UNITY & QUALITY, REMOVE THE DIVISION IN NORTH-- SOUTH MENTALITY IN ORDINARY PEOPLE TO STATE AND NATIONAL LEVEL, GOVERNING AND EDUCATIONAL BODIES...!!! PLEASE GET RID OF THE RELIGION FROM POLITICS...AND FREE THE PEOPLE FROM RELIGIOUS BONDAGE, BY NOT ALLOWING RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS TO HAVE ANY AUTHORITY OVER PEOPLE & EDUCATION...!!! LET VEDIC WISDOM GUIDE US ...WITH NEW INTERPRETATION ACCORDING TO THE SITUATION. TIME, SPACE AND ENVIRONMENT...!!! NOT ALL "" OLD IS GOLD." AND " ALL THAT GLITTERS IS NOT GOLD "...!!!

What is unemployment rate right now? With 35 crores more added to work force, work getting reduced due to automation where shall we find work for all. It's like assume we will be rich and then how life would be question is how to get there.

Modi has to add some smart people for his economics team and politics in general. So many boneheaded decisions and still he will win next election as long as Rahul is his appointment. He should do much better in the next round else expect new leaders in Rahul’s position next election. So it might be challenging.

Bengal Subah in the early 1800s had one of the highest living standards and real wages in the whole let alone Britain and it's worth was 12% of the whole world's GDP...The eastern part of Bengal was globally prominent in industries such as textile manufacturing and shipbuilding, and it was a major exporter of silk and cotton textiles, steel, saltpeter, and agricultural and industrial produce in the world.Its capital Jahangir Nagar, today's modern Dhaka, had a population exceeding a million people. Please share the reference where you got it was 30% of the Brit's GDP. It was only after the British conquered it led to its deindustrialization & economic downfall.

BJP government is stuck in a spiral, As the previous (UPA) government had a proper failed tax revenue stream for the Govt. 1. India Post Payments Bank needs some good money to be implemented. See the movie "Swades". 2. Ayushman Bharat needs atleast of 35000 Cr Rs per Year from the Government (GOI) & rest of from State Govts. 3. Swaach Bharat Needs some more amount for payment of new infras. 4. Trump- China- OPEC- Turkey- Russia Tussle is making $ - other currency with Increasing oil Prices. 5. Iran-Russia Sanctions made us oil sick, The actual Value of $ to INR is around or should be around 90 INR per $. but as we are a heavy oil importing country we suffering on that point. Compare other countries 29 Aug 2013 00:00 UTC USD/INR close:68.82995 to current status 72.10 USD/INR just a 4 rating drop. 29 Aug 2013 00:00 UTC USD/JPY close:97.74066 to current status 111.01 USD/JPY over a 13 rating drop. 29 Aug 2013 00:00 UTC USD/CNY close:6.12269 to current status 6.84 USD/CNY over a dropped 10% of value like if INR/USD 75.71. & compare with any other countries you want. Now My Take: Govt should reduce Taxes on the Petroleum Prices by 1/2 because we Indian public are not mature enough to understand what are the future projections, They just look for the short gains & not longterm benefits. Not in power is not a good thing. They should do a reshuffling of taxes increase taxes on Alcohol by 300 % more + 120 % on the Luxury vehicles, tobacco products & cigarettes with 300% increase in the tax they will make remaining tax gap. This will make EV & Luxury in the same price range.

Absolutely agree and appreciate ' Indian / Bharat school of Economics is what must happen.

Primary education should have been the major investment point after independence, the speaker rightly pointed out on the caste angles but did not dig deeper. Only and only proper world class primary education at no charge to all sections of the society would lift the country's fortunes. All the developed countries have one thing in common and they realized it long back - Free and quality Primary and secondary education.

I can't believe that Mr. Gupta says (at 13:10) that literacy of children and young people under 18 is 100%. Did I hear it right? Maybe he is talking about urban India. We have vast swathes of our population, particularly the tribals and the lower socio-economic classes in rural India and in urban slums that are illiterate or barely literate. That, along with the pathetic state of public health delivery, especially in rural areas, has been the biggest failure of post independence India. The population exploded from 347 million to 1.3 billion but there was hardly any commensurate growth in human index parameters for most of the population. I hope the policies of Modi government in conjunction with state governments will address these asap.....

Rightly Fully pointed out , education sector is in deep shit !

I never understood what was Nehru's vision from history.

unstructured presentation.

Abki baar phir Modi sarkar....

Great presentation. Just imagine for one second if Modi loses next election. We will be back to stone age.

Modi is big target of leftists Modi for 2019

He is totally thinking in western model(framework). We should also try to find solutions from our ancestor's knowledge and combined that with current pool of knowledge.

Lot of good points but at general level and with good hope but totally oblivious of divisive politics & corrupt politicians India suffers from. I am shocked that he doesn’t seems to know hides destruction economy and society by Islamic invasions. In late 17th century most of Wealth was owned & or controlled by 665 families while rest struggled to live and carry on.

All talk, talk & talk. Everyone talks no-one works hard without talking. for the modern nation-state there are 2 main things. First we must have a culture of hard-work & ethics. And secondly we must have a good ecosystem that is capable of innovation. We have neither. Cry my beloved country

Lets see Modinomics, is it protectionism, nationalism? The truth is India can never compete with China because Indians are complacent like all the poor countries. Chinese, Japanese, Koreans and Vietnamese are highly intense with a sense of urgency and this allows them to manufacture cheaper than everyone else, these countries will increase their control of manufacturing and even high tech they will dominate more and more. India can only compete if the population become alert with high sense of urgency, see kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fJ-Yqcl9za6VmoU.html

Employees who don't fear for their jobs are more likely to perform at a higher level and feel greater commitment to an employer. However, job security works best as a motivator when employees see a connection between job retention and their own performance. His last point ruined the whole talk.

Send Foodgrains in my Capacity to Kerala

good insight, however 1- India being 100% literate is factually incorrect , 2- Policies such as bankruptcy ( e.g. quoted Bhushan Steel was okay).. will give clearer exit by debt ridden corporate .. and lead to corruptions with collusion. Jayeee group noida, studied that?..

Sir all these talks will always remain a joke for a person like me. It'll always be related to politics in this failure system. The politician who lives on the next block where I live has accumulated wealth of 300 crores. Not lying as my father is in real estate and he knows many big shots. Property and money of his combined has given him this. There are 1000s of others like him who are voted by people of the slums. Then a friend of mine who is lower caste got a government job and within 3 years he has bought himself a 3bhk apartment for 1cr. How can a country improve with shit like this?

Hahaha lol

70 saal ki independence ke baad hod lagi hai sab jation me ki vo pichri jaati ke hain aur congress unko incite kar rahi hai aur padalikha chatukar mmsingh chup

gulam mansikta ka pratik mmsingh exposed, illiterate better than padalikha chatukar kzfaq.info/get/bejne/o66Zoc2KnMicdY0.html

Modi aim only to make Adani and Ambani richest and as on today both these persons income is 1100 crores a day

I am pro Modi guy but, I am not sure how a Fund Manager can have perspective about Economy. I mean anyone can, no issues, still Fund Managers are all about making Profits in Finance. And Dalal Street doesn't and shouldn't be an index for economy. Let's see, I am judging the book by its cover, will edit this comment at the end of the talk.

Gupta says that India was in decline economically for thousand years which is factually incorrect. India had the second largest economy after China in 1800 AD.

Janitor in gujarat has a pick up truck.....

Modi is fool

World recession has knocked every country, Modi is doing well

What a load of BS..! This guy pulls numbers and statements out of thin air with no basis...

We r killed with Taxes and modi deserves honours for that.

Isko bolte hai Baniya jhut kitni chaliki se bolta hai

Ha ha. Why am I watching this s**t. Blocked

Why he is not talking about 2004 thru 2014! Living outside of India I visited India most during this time period sometimes twice a year and every time observed amazing uplift in the living standards of everyone - my family and friends and even their help and the people on the street. It was more than obvious India and Indians have progressed on exponential level in this 10 years compared to earlier time and rightly the credit must be given to Manmohan Singh Ji who happened to be a world renowned economist!! With Modi to give him any credit for economic growth is just a farce specially with a blunder like demonetization and their effort to hide the realities under tempered data and new formulas to calculate GDP!! I understand Modi even distorted the GST model of UPA and implemented it very inefficiently in a unbelievable crude manner!! Looks like under Modi the emphasis is publicizing every little or normal progress to the nth level and the epitome is when PM try to showcase 9 km of highway in the level as if Indian astronauts have landed on moon!! What ever Modi is propagating he has done or what this guy is trying to imply in subtle way was done more before Modi came and more efficiently and very noticeable for anyone to observe even if they visited India within 6 months!! If India can go back to economic growth achieved during Manmohan Singh time, it certainly would be fortunate for every Indian!! But for that Indian need leader with proper education, vision and substance and not propogaters and lie spreaders whose primary occupation is self image building and electoral campaigning using ugliest of the ugly tactics of polarization of nation, blame games and hate speeches!!

No economists is better without data and examples.. Boring.. feels like reading headlines of economic times

It's an insult to economists by coining economics after an illiterate Modi.....Manmohan Singh was an extraordinary economist so it's called Manmohanomics

There is no economic policy by this GOVT. FEKU