No the show has horrible writing you think they can foreshadow the Ghost doesn't even know them

​@@randomgeekcrap At this point (almost ending Season 3) the rivalry between Alyssa and Shannen was full-on. The writers prepared in every way for a sister to die because they didn't know which of the two would leave the show, which is very noticeable since Death Takes A Halliwell. The tones started shifting towards death, loss, grief, not losing each other. This was definitely foreshadowing someone's death

​@@fsxvids100100% agree.

@fsxvids100 why do you all over exaggerate about this “rivalry”, you guys talk like they were car fighting, throwing stuff across the room, bitch slapping each other day on set

​@@fsxvids100 I think it was more prue. Even though shannen didn't knew she was going to be fired, the writers made sure that there's a lot of elements that prue would be the one to go . You can see in episode death takes a Halliwell where prue cries at the end feeling like her time is coming to an end, or in the wedding episode when pheobe tells prue that the Charmed thing is going destroy her something like that or more at the end of the Season ( all hell breaks loose) when prue says that felt a chill before the demon attack wich mean that she felt death and that she's going to die. You can see that the decision of keeping Alyssa on the show was already Taken by the showrunners in the halfway of the Season.

And she looks down...

I've thought about this and cats are the only ones who are known for having multiple lives. Which made me think of possible warlocks that could easily shed their sole life by attacking the Charmed Ones only once. In that case, they'd probably have to be banished to the Astral Plane or Oblivion like a demon in Season 8 or Matthew in Season 1

They did it again in season 4 during that murder trial. Phoebe need Piper and Paige during that too. It probably takes a lot of power to bring someone over from the dead. Which shows how powerful Wyatt is cause he did it by himself...in the womb.

@@BlackGirlMarvel Thanks for reminding me. I almost forgot that it took the Power of Three to summon Melinda Warren back from the dead in Season 1 to fend off Matthew Tate.

But there was one spell that only took 1 to cast - the one Piper used to summon Grams in the Season 4 premiere.

​@@johnvincentcarillogomez3159 I think that spell only work for halliwell bloodline that why piper can do it by herself. The spell on season 1 bring Melinda back in flesh and they new to the craft back then their power still grown.

By the time all of this things made sense. 😂 not anymore

Not trying to defend the writing, but apparently being stabbed by a magical being is not the same as being stabbed by a mortal. The box cutter kill by Piper is even more outrageous, because it's an accidental kill. Regarding the shoe throwing, I wonder if it's a clapback to the actresses fights off-screen.

​@@diegoiunou❤

@@diegoiunou That's just wild fan speculation. Nowhere does it say this, or even remotely imply this. In fact there were "mortal" demon hunters on the show, a few times, so if anything it'd be the opposite. Whoever wrote the episode simply didn't think it through. A better explanation to write in would be, for example; the public suicides would draw attention, the body would go missing, the person could be seen alive etc. This way is secret, quicker and a lot less messy.

One of the best episodes tbh

Love this episode! this one and the one where the witch turns pure evil so all the sisters powers turn evil. So good

That's what I was thinking she was. Thanks for the clarification.

They are turned if they betray their witch. There may be regret and he wants to die before he turns immortal.

@lolamagenta I know that. She literally just explained it. I said how would the cat even know that it can turn into a worlock

@@andreaharris4683 It is warlock, btw. A familiar is a supernatural being that is both guardian and assistant to their witch. So, they are aware of what happens. No need to get your hackles up.

@@andreaharris4683 It is warlock, btw.