Ningning has always said that she prefers to dance and she likes upbeat songs, she lovesss to perform ❤️ Maknae Ning is no more when she's on stage lol And she loves to rap as well, she always said that she wanted to, and every time she's asked what's her favorite part of Aespa's songs she always says Giselle's parts 😂😂❤️ I loved her solo stage! Main slayer 💞 Everyone's solo's suited them well 🥰

Ningning was my favvv❤️‍🔥

NingNing Queen🛐🛐

Karina solo proved my theories that she is ready to debut solo, everything about her performance is spectacular. If you are non-mys, and you watched her stage, you will think she is already a professional solo singer.

all I know is that NINGNING slayed HARD!! a born performer🔥🔥🔥

I really love Karina’s performance for this concert, not just the solo part but the entire concert.. of cos her solo was also very impressive to me. Like damn, she can do anything from singing to dancing to rapping, and in any concept.. one moment she is all out to slay like a queen, next moments she’s such a sweet cutie 😂

With Winter's solo, I do think it was shaky but on their second day, she did so much better!!! It also depends on the fancams because I had different opinions based on I was watching. Also, NingNing is literally ready for when she becomes a Soloist cause wtf!? 😳 Honestly all of the performances was amazing.

I love your reaction to karina’s performance

Aespa é um grupo que pode explorar muito seu potencial. NingNing arrasou!

Karina💙

Karinas solo was my favv

Karina ♥️♥️♥️♥️

And I would love to see more Asepa contents..

In my opinion, KARINA got the best stage 🙌

Winter vocal so beautiful❤❤

they sang live at the end of year performances and cochella

Now I'm waiting for the reaction to other songs. Especially girls. Because it was a special dance break. And Aenergy was the most impressive performance.

why you guys keep asking is it Live, like what are u doing, its annoying, just imagine if u are them, standing, dancing and singing for 2-3 hours straight, and u expect them to sing it live in all section? dont be rude boy. you dont even pay to watch their performance. i'm glad and thankful to make some reaction video, but just be more respect. to make this clear, their Mic is On.. but some of the performances using huge backtrack sound. so please keep your words if u just make us feel uncomfortable

Actually I just love your videos very much..

aespa slayy

It’s hard to gage the performances when it’s on fan cam. The audio quality is just too bad. I seen the concert when it was steaming and they sounded good. Winters solo sounds much better with good audio. Karina even had a problem with her mic during one of the songs and you could tell it was off. They recovered good from that but it proved that the mics were on.

Aespa videos and performances in which they are actually singing live because you asked about it: /It won't let me to link the videos so I will just leave the title and the channel that they are from/ -[앵콜캠4K] 에스파 'Savage' 인기가요 1위 앵콜 직캠 (aespa Encore Fancam) | @SBS Inkigayo_2021.10.24. from 스브스케이팝 X INKIGAYO /savage encore stage in which they didn't even had earpieces so /in case you wonder/that's why they kept on covering one of their ears to hear their voice better/ -aespa - Illusion + Girls @ CCMA (Circle Chart Music Awards) from holyizhuo /illusion+girls live performance/ -aespa 'Dreams Come True' (Recording Ver.) from AESPA DAILY /short video of dreams come true recording behind the scenes/ -aespa live vocals from hey winter! /short video of them singing on radio shows/ -aespa live vocals pt. 2 from hey winter! /short video of them singing on radio shows/ /maybe you can merge the short ones into one video if you plan on reacting to them/which please do because I would love to see your opinion/ or maybe even combine all of the videos in one if you want a mini marathon with aespa's live vocals/ Ok guys I love your honest reactions and I am wherever there are live vocals so as a singer myself I'm also going be honest/as always/. Only Winter sang live during her solo stage/the audio from that phone was awful but it's nothing new for a concert recording so anyway/.She was a bit shaky during the beginning but she was never off,also want to point out that the song was on the quieter side so that open sound that you wanted is not because she can't do it but because that's simply not the way that the song goes/the lyrics and the message are actually really sad but anyway that's not the point/. Might not sound like it to a person who doesn't have the knowledge but the song is definitely tricky to sing.Their songs in general are definitely more vocally demanding and challenging than most of the 4th gen groups/not taking away from the other groups,just stating the facts/ but it sucks that they are not performing live as often as I would like them to,because they are such a capable group and I can't believe that there are still people who doubt the SM vocalists and aespa in particular...Hopefully you guys will check out the videos that I have linked above and see it for yourself! Also about killing voice/it's live and programs/shows like that-I just want to make it clear/if it's not already/that what you hear there are still not live vocals because there is definitely pitch correction on the mic while recording and processing after it is recorded. So if you want to listen to actual live vocals you either /1/have to find videos of that particular group singing on a radio show /like aespa did in 2 of the short videos from above/ but it's sad because nowadays some groups are lip syncing even during the radio shows/*cough* ive *cough*/ or /2/you have to find recording behind the scenes /there is one for ''time after time'' and idk if you know this song but it's from the SM winter album and Ningning is in it so you can hear her raw vocals there/ or /3/simply find live performances from shows/concerts/award shows /like the aespa ones from above/ but most of the times there is still a backtrack during those performances so it's iffy. DAAAMN I'M SO SORRY FOR THE LONG COMMENT Y'ALL,once again THANK YOU for your HONEST reaction!!!

They will release their 3rd Mini Album "MY WORLD" on May 8.

THANKS for this video

❤❤❤❤

YEEESSS

I can't express myself in English. But I tried to explain to you as much as possible. I am interested in other people's opinions about aespa, so I would like to get more reactions about aespa.

Honestly I prefer Ningning's dancing much more than karina's, I don't know karina always repeats the same movements and I can detect some flows in her dancing, not a bad dancer but.... she's just dancing I don't think she was performing a song but just dancing? I don't know lack of stage presence??? I don't know she was just a lip syncing dancer, now compare her to Ningning, Ningning is the full package like really I can see a real singer who can dance and rap, a real artist? A real performer, Ningning was the best in everything singing and dancing

judging a perf by fancam audio is tacky anough. Try to view the perf in other fancam, some of them has better audio, lens fancam audio specifically is not clear enough. I too thought winter perf was out of tune, but looking at other fancam she sounds fine. not perfect but not bad as the lens fancam. props to her for singing 100% live tho.

if you want good audio should have paid to watch the stream and support them

Again I'm the first

More

*aespa's 'Hold On Tight' (Tetris Motion Picture Soundtrack) Visualizer* : kzfaq.info/get/bejne/nNykrb13zdivfHk.html

its live with back track

SECRET NUMBER just dropped their japanese debut music video call LIKE IT LIKE IT!!! You have to check that out!!! I’ll be waiting for your reaction video

Please reaction SECRET NUMBER DEBUT JAPAN, LIKE IT LIKE IT M/V

again, for solo and for SOME unreleased songs, it’s all lip sync. for soft choreos (having fun, but with SOME choreography) REACT TO EVERY PERFORMANCE ESPECIALLY GIRLS! YOULL BE SO SURPRISED!

Sounds, even the music in these videos are horrible, like a bunch of white noises of all kinds being put in a box an sent by train right in front of you, hoping the original audio would somehow get to you.

Winter did not do her best

SECRET NUMBER has dropped their japanese debut song!!! You have to check that out too!!! I’ll be waiting for your reaction video