Vocal Coach Reacts to Shila Amzah - Listen｜國外聲樂老師的茜拉初體驗

Рет қаралды 147,756

2 ай бұрын

Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on KZfaq: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #shilaamzah #茜拉 #我是歌手 #iamsinger #beyonce

Пікірлер: 290

@stuartfit 2 ай бұрын

Her name is Shila Amzah, she's not from China but a Malay ethnic from Malaysia. She went into China market around 10 + years ago entering some singing competitions trying to create a market and branding for herself and she did achieve millions of followers, much more than what she could achieve back in Malaysia in such a short time. What's more amazing was Shila learned Chinese language (Mandarin) while in the midst of those competitions as usually 99.99% Malay people usually do not know Chinese language in Malaysia but fluent with English though. She's not at the levels of singers like Zhou Shen and many other top tier Chinese singers you reacted to but she's smart and dares to try breaking into Chinese market. She's now back to Malaysia but occasionally being sought after in China for some events. I know these detailed information because I'm a Malaysian who followed her some years when she was in China.

@yxuen3051 Ай бұрын

Calm down

@rolandtan9302 Ай бұрын

lol why u so angry...we all know she is not from mainland alamak u

@stuartfit Ай бұрын

@@rolandtan9302, unfortunately if you read that with an unsettled or angry mind then it will sound angry to you, try reading that with a calm and analytical mind then you will find the positive side of things.

@yxuen3051 Ай бұрын

@@rolandtan9302 I think this comment written by Shila herself 😂

@Benbbg Ай бұрын

Don’t understand why you point this out

@crazypig4212 2 ай бұрын

茜拉我很喜歡在歌手節目中很令人深刻印象實力派她節目中唱的rolling in the deep 和最長的電影超級好聽而且她給人的感覺也很可愛😊

@a-k1088 Ай бұрын

加1😄

@Melodychan0115 Ай бұрын

初中的时候在电视前追的，没想到这么快十年了，那一季真的是神仙打架，茜拉唱的每一首都好经典，再听十年也不腻！🥺

@kenchua5958 Ай бұрын

其實，Shila的唱功在馬來女歌手還不是最強的。Aina Abdul更厲害。

@user-oe2ko5oy2v 21 күн бұрын

@@kenchua5958 不認識總體還是shila 表情唱功最好享受音樂

@kenchua5958 15 күн бұрын

@@user-oe2ko5oy2v 既然不認識，為何還會認為Shila的唱功會更好？

@jasmanjunaidi302 12 күн бұрын

You put singers at a different level. Your comments are amazing. I like it when you point out where and how things are done in different places in the song. 🫡🫡🫡 And, you have an amazing voice!

@keys4321 Ай бұрын

Super proud of Shila!!! 🇲🇾🇲🇾❤️❤️

@ericlen0103 12 күн бұрын

I think listen has been covered by so many artists around the world, and Shila was trying to sing in her style and her way, and I liked it 🤟

@phantomreak 24 күн бұрын

She made her own rendition based on her capability....make it work ❤❤❤

@cheongnicholas3891 2 ай бұрын

finally omg i have been commenting in many videos now finally review her thanks a lot

@wlchin2 25 күн бұрын

Thanks for honest comments from coach rozette, love you!! Start to follow your live song , appreciate

@farrauyie8710 Ай бұрын

Dalam nyanyian, kita kena identiti sendiri. Sebagai vocal coach, setiap lagu yg dibuat untuk setiap penyanyi, mempunyai kekuatan vokal dan teknik nyanyian tersendiri. Shila menyanyikan lagu ni mengikut bersesuaian vokal dan teknik dia supaya lagu ini seperti lagunya sendiri...

@theresa601 Ай бұрын

Yala yala, kita tau MALAYSIA BOLEH...😂

@alvinacx Ай бұрын

老师真实的评语其实能让一位歌手学到更多～ ❤❤❤

@jaygames5470 Ай бұрын

well, its a damn competition, it would be boring if she's sang like the original. she has her own identity. its her own style. would love to see Ms. Roz sing it.

@shawnngmc Ай бұрын

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fdh3dpemldjHZIU.htmlsi=K35UdkHxmALzQr3Y

@shawnngmc Ай бұрын

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fdh3dpemldjHZIU.htmlsi=K35UdkHxmALzQr3Y

@simoart2446 Ай бұрын

Mind you, the original will never be boring lmao. It's either u can execute it, or you'll just fail terribly, nothing in between. But i really like her rendition of the song though, except for 5:50, ruined the entire thing.

@affan9958 Ай бұрын

shila amza👍🏻👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻!!!!✨✨

@afuwok6969 2 ай бұрын

tq tq..cant wait to see what roz on shila

@kevTan88 Ай бұрын

Why u guys all so offensive , she didn’t even say anything hurtful , everytime she said something she didn’t like and immediately follow by saying something might not be necessary bad , I think she is being honest and kind , come on everybody. Open your mind . Don’t be so “glasses heart”

@theresa601 Ай бұрын

You're right, those ppl seriously can't accept a coach correct the problems to help a singer to improve their skill. I feel coach feedback is so true and sincere

@fayesua9629 Ай бұрын

Yup, if I were the singer i'd very much appreciate someone honest comments so I can improve.

@xavierhea702 2 ай бұрын

She is so much more strict this time round. Got a shock!!!

@leokmin Ай бұрын

i would say it’s not something she fancies about that’s why, as she also mentioned she likes the original version 😅

@pan5140 Ай бұрын

茜拉是真的非常厲害很棒的歌手

@sasaki550 2 ай бұрын

從這段就可以看出,她評華語歌手有多"客氣"了😂😂😂 論實力與技巧,Shila是贏過很多華語女歌手的

@dragon.slayer.. 2 ай бұрын

我也惊讶今天老师没了平时评论中国歌手时的那种客气，感觉句句都很直接

@kwoo24 2 ай бұрын

因为这首歌老师很熟悉，她也常唱。也cover过。还有就是，她们频道在Bilibili很有人气。为了中国市场，可能对于中国歌手还是会客气一些。而且，因为对于华人音乐的认识不够深，所以也不敢批评太严苛。通常唱英文歌的，老师会讲比较多话。

@jimmy4406 2 ай бұрын

因為不想得罪人民幣吧

@hc7422 Ай бұрын

我却觉得Shila的版本更生动了，有点让人期待她下一秒唱什么出来😂。因为原版太多人跟到一摸一样，大家都唱得好像复制机器人一样了。😂

@user-ce7yl3eq6i 25 күн бұрын

@@jimmy4406 ??? 有没有可能是她翻唱过这首歌，而身为声乐老师这么多年了她应该接收到了无数的人要她教唱这首经典歌曲呢？客观点，她又不去那赚钱

@qianchenliu6490 2 ай бұрын

Shila 表演过的歌曲, 想你的夜(原唱：关喆)，印象非常深刻，她唱得很好听很感动，请让老师看她唱这首歌。最长的电影和洋葱也不错，谢谢！

@a-k1088 Ай бұрын

真的…都好好聽😄

@user-bs5jb5ct8d Ай бұрын

這才是真正的點評很可愛的小女生我是歌手中喜歡的歌手之一她在自己的家鄉可是國寶級哦

@user-yo2se9ji3d Ай бұрын

現在沒有

@silentboomber 29 күн бұрын

别说国宝级，一线也勉强

@owo4619 2 ай бұрын

老師這麼嚴格完全不意外，她自己本身就有COVER這首歌了(在這個頻道)，想當然熟悉度基本上是最頂的；再加上老師本來就是忠於原曲派，茜拉的表現已經很好了哈哈哈~

@user-lt8nv6wl9c 2 ай бұрын

主要是原厂是厚嗓，茜拉不是，很多亚洲人唱欧美歌不合适就是因为亚洲人细嗓偏多，这是国内压喉撑大的人很多的根本原因

@user-sz3kq4eq8q 2 ай бұрын

@@user-lt8nv6wl9c茜拉在亞洲不算小嗓了😂

@yxuen3051 Ай бұрын

西拉版本確實是oversing了，張力不夠，聲線單薄，一堆沒必要的怒音⋯

@yxuen3051 Ай бұрын

@@user-sz3kq4eq8q 人家Morisette、Katrina、Charice這種才叫big voice，真正撐得起大歌，沒有一堆多餘的轉音和怒音，爆發力極強

@user-sz3kq4eq8q Ай бұрын

@@yxuen3051 你以為我不知道嗎🙄🙄我衹是說她對比別的歌手絕對不算小，我沒說大，而且R&B本來就有很多轉音，沒有多餘的轉音和怒音....🙄🙄不會欣賞就閉嘴好嗎？你的自以為是真的煩人，那是她的看家本領(轉音和怒音)，你回家聽你的甜蜜蜜吧，一點轉音也沒有，肯定適合你

@janque2547 2 ай бұрын

I think it is not fair to judge and compare her to Beyoncé. She is a great singer on her own merit..If everyone sounds the same then how boring it would be…

@singaporechickenrice2484 Ай бұрын

shes being compared to beyonce cause beyonce's technique is proper and also u will always be compared to the original when doing covers,its a given. she is young and inexperienced in this video and all the runs shes doing is basically to save breath and cover up her lack of stability in holding the longer notes

@Benbbg Ай бұрын

That’s normal if you hear the original version, but not compare with Beyonce. Either you better or about the same level if you pick a big and popular song like this

@tagbee51 25 күн бұрын

We luv shila amzah.😊.🔥

@keungchan9174 2 ай бұрын

在我是歌手節目當中鄧紫棋說過,相信要學習两百年唱歌也不及茜拉,而茜拉好似成為马來西亞國寶級歌手,相信茜拉唱功及個人特色都非常優秀,已沒有可挑釁評論,只有喜愛不喜愛😂

@soonaikchong7939 Ай бұрын

其实shila声线还是不够power去呈现这种大气凶猛的歌所以这位洋女老师给的意见是对的

@stanleyyap2006 Ай бұрын

她的確是馬來西亞年輕一代很會唱的馬來女歌手，其實馬來西亞還有很多很會唱的歌手，只是機會太少。。。

@keungchan9174 Ай бұрын

@@soonaikchong7939不夠力量只是你個人覺得,連老師也沒評力量不夠,最尾也得到老師讚賞,其實茜拉技巧反而非常全面。這老師用原唱比較有些不同意,歌手不只是技巧,還有個人魅力風格,只有喜愛不喜愛之分🤣

@younwui4977 17 күн бұрын

我超喜欢西拉演绎。就是很绝

@wvincent5018 2 күн бұрын

当时的西拉其实不及Jacklyn Victor的技巧，她才是真正马来西亚唱歌机器，但先说，这两个单独拿一个出来基本上都是地球上的神仙唱将

@user-hr8cf7gx1h Ай бұрын

老師的表情很有趣，nice!

@lisawinston1548 2 ай бұрын

Shila, I love her too ❤

@wilsonZhao674 2 ай бұрын

茜拉唱的很好，嗓音没有那么粗，只能这么演绎。而且说实话一些音的改变更符合亚洲人的审美。尤其最后一个音，原版总觉得好像没唱完的感觉。

@jkco82 Ай бұрын

Shila full of emotions ahhhh

@jamesgu2575 Ай бұрын

老师唱得很好：）

@Peppermt 2 ай бұрын

Would love for Rozette to also review more Southeast Asian singers... Could start with Stefanie Sun and Tanya Chua since they sing Chinese songs, and Stefanie has recent live performances. Her 逆光 has also been covered by Zhou Shen

@silentboomber 29 күн бұрын

i think she did for Stefanie Sun, she likes Sun

@orlylieza1360 Ай бұрын

love your honest comment.. yup not everyone like her interpretation of this song but it's ok. thank you

@joskinglaw9855 2 ай бұрын

期待

@qwertyuiop9227 Ай бұрын

Shila Amzah vocal is more powerful now. Do watch her performance u will see how she improving.

@mweieros 2 ай бұрын

wow, diva rosette to sing the song at the end

@TheFrankYang 2 ай бұрын

聽到母語的歌曲老師嚴格是正常的，都會聽的專精一點~ 不管怎樣我覺得我每次看影片都能學到一點技巧感謝老師~ 還有CZ Media

@kjz713 Күн бұрын

我也非常喜歡西拉，她在歌手的合輯聽n次，她的音色跟唱法很搭

@afuwok6969 2 ай бұрын

thanks ms. rozette for this detail analysis of shila 's singing..would like to see if ms rozette do a blind listen of Shila's mandarin song delivery would be ? just a sidenote.shila's dad ND lala is quite a star during the 80's guess the art pass through the blood..

@pecochia8833 2 ай бұрын

Why must sing same as original version?

@jackmak9941 Ай бұрын

I don’t think you actually distinguish the “fact” and “opinion”, it’s not a “must”, it’s just her own preference according to what she said. She also clearly advised that there’s no “right” or “wrong”of how Shila sings.

@zarifzailan6586 Ай бұрын

i love her version more rather than the original version, well arranged, anyway first thing first you need to know her vocal range are totally different from beyonce

@nuagecloudchan 25 күн бұрын

有料歌手的演出，老師的評價也比較technical ❤️

@baddmeeloo Ай бұрын

Don't mind the comments coach. You're telling the truth, Shila sang the song, to match her vocal range and technique, obviously she can't go higher like your vocal range, but she's actually doing a great job for not copying the OG and present the song in her own rendition.

@HarryHo02 Ай бұрын

马来西亚的骄傲❤

@younwui4977 17 күн бұрын

这个listen 是我听到最棒的版本！西拉真的是厉害，完全改变了

@tamakinavyra930 Ай бұрын

She did it her own version. And it was good.

@grandpasandwich7740 20 күн бұрын

I remember performing with her and she's the real deal

@akimjeremy Ай бұрын

U need to react to AINA ABDUL -any videos of her live performance.. one of the best female singer in Malaysia

@b7699629 2 ай бұрын

已经有rea过shila 的青藏高原一次了，这次listen算第二次听了。

@ClubZeroMedia 2 ай бұрын

這個是更早的庫存

@HAW200 22 күн бұрын

Shila anak Malaysia ❤

@jaykwok4731 Ай бұрын

Shila is the coach

@jessie7472 8 күн бұрын

超好笑的還OK啦然後滿臉的不以為然我真的笑出來了.... 哈哈哈

@natsukun1808 7 күн бұрын

Nice✨ please reaction more shila Amzah sing

@huang4759 2 ай бұрын

來個charice 吧🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

@Dess0821 Ай бұрын

现在听还是会起鸡皮疙瘩

@ericlo6370 2 ай бұрын

Coach you are really obsessed with the "H" bash LOL~ Shila is skilled and with emotion, I like her when she and GEM joined "I'm a Singer" in the same season! You interpretate it way better though, kudos!

@subilikhwan8144 20 күн бұрын

let her sing in her own style coach

@theresa601 Ай бұрын

Sheila 来自我的国家马来西亚，她是马来人!老师点评到很好很正中问题，其实她就是在中国被捧红，因为中国人只要是个"外国人"唱英文都很容易喜欢，听到外国人唱华语更惊讶到不行!其实她唱歌太过刻意和加入很多不必要的东西!

@khaleefaaddy608 Ай бұрын

Hello, im Addy from Singapore, my 1st time listened to your reaction and i sincerely love it and ive already subscribed. Please react to an indonesian blind 17years old singer in agt audition and also her original Loneliness and Perfect Liar. She also colibrated witn Alan Walker and Peder Elias Who I Am. Her name is Putri Ariani. Thank you

@rafawu5668 2 ай бұрын

橘老師示範得超好聽的！這些歌手都輸橘老師！

@chhor5883 2 ай бұрын

Gary chaw 曹格 next please

@jennytung9746 28 күн бұрын

Yes yes yes

@ahmedalrashidi9654 Ай бұрын

星星☺️😘🤲🏻👍🏻💗

@raykang2150 2 ай бұрын

Charice Pempengco Listen Please🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

@user-wv5lt2qd1l 27 күн бұрын

一個是強烈堆疊情感，另含蓄表達情感

@user-zp8lc4tb9d Ай бұрын

覺得listen實在是一首非常難唱且挑戰性很高的歌，很開心看到老師這麼犀利的講評，另外覺得後面老師示範得很強，但是重點也太多了😂

@_DAIKO_ Ай бұрын

Please reaction to ernie ku bersuara she has perfect mix ever and for the facts she actually vocal coach as well,actress,singer and she also winning many awards contest too❤

@yuyuma1012 Ай бұрын

Yes please its was epic

@sheherify 2 ай бұрын

老師很嚴格的原因我想是因為，老師真的對這首歌曲很熟悉，老師自己也有出一個 cover，頻道裡面也找的到大家可以去聽看看。

@janiceleong3602 2 ай бұрын

同意你的看法。老师也许认为既然选唱这首高技巧的经典，但又没有在该发挥的时候表现，有点失望。老师示范的版本的确很好听。

@soonaikchong7939 Ай бұрын

@@janiceleong3602对的是因为她声线不够浑厚去呈现这样的大歌

@Amaniaan1314 26 күн бұрын

好難得看到實力如此深厚敢詮釋這首會唱死人的歌的😅❤👍⋯⋯轉音表達有些地方扣分了😢

@zewen9890 2 ай бұрын

看一下 KZ吧 Say something 还有 Rolling in the deep

@meatorfeed9051 28 күн бұрын

老師有要分析回春丹嗎?

@lalala-hz7tg 2 ай бұрын

Wish to see some reviews of IU too!

@kororosensei2443 Ай бұрын

As performer its better if u cover the song and make it with ur own flavour and not do 100% like the original...if u sing like the original then its better to call the original singer to sing the song....n there are some invalid critics....creativity is a must when cover the song and also be clever....but at the end of the day, u like it or not is really subjective....everyone has different opinion...and this one of my...

@rueyenho9728 2 ай бұрын

还有一首歌茜拉演唱的「洋葱」

@Bryancgc 21 күн бұрын

Can coach review Shila Amzah “天亮了”，“you raise me up”, “洋葱 ”or more video of Shila Amzah singing please~ she makes our country (Malaysia 🇲🇾） proud a lot! Your vocal coaching is being very honest and we can learn a lot of skill that you mentioned each time when you giving the comments. Btw thanks 🙏🏻 for coaching Shila Amzah. A big thanks from among all the Malaysian.

@royyang6583 Ай бұрын

Hoping that you can also check “Morissette’s rendition” of Listen(2017 version better). It’s closer to the original and showcases much vocal agility that you are adept at! I believe you would enjoy watching it

@wikilin 2 ай бұрын

很想聽-李玟「想念你」的點評

@SS-th7kr Ай бұрын

would love to hear your review on Shila Amzah new rules dua lipa. she recorded it on apple earpods

@stanleywh9796 Ай бұрын

She is good … I like her (Shila) performance… but is welcome to comment …

@ayell91 10 сағат бұрын

I watch many singers trying to sing like original. You can sing original in karaoke but its a damn competition, you should put your "mark" and originality that makes you different than original singer. Whatever your opinion is, i think shila makes a great decision to sing her own version. Thats makes her performance "unforgettable" untill this moment.

@adamgaming5693 2 ай бұрын

look please Morissette Amon 2017 ASIA SONG FESTIVAL or Don’t You Worry Bout A Thing

@DFS-ODC Ай бұрын

*beyonce - listen live cover by Putri Ariani 2019*

@calvin._.b2uty335 Ай бұрын

Rolling in the deep 必须安排上！！！！

@jamiechuang1757 2 ай бұрын

剛開始聽茜拉唱歌好驚艷，但後來有點疲勞（會膩的意思），雖然唱功、音質、技巧很好，但是改了太多細節後，變得不像一首歌了，也有可能是自己喜歡的風格，但節目製作也有一定的關係。

@soonaikchong7939 Ай бұрын

讲的没错她唱歌的技巧一直一样听久了会腻

@derrickwan 27 күн бұрын

原版比较呐喊式，茜拉版表现她比较柔和有力的声线，茜拉从来不唱呐喊式，我都喜欢。假如要唱得跟原版一样，不如去听原版就够了。

@waikiankhoo8746 Ай бұрын

teacher was right about shila.

@awna5315 2 ай бұрын

請問哪裡能找到頻道會員訂閱？一直找不到⋯ 請問是有限制加入會員的數量嗎？

@bauerh7973 26 күн бұрын

點開任一付費頻道裡的影片，當你還不是會員時，裡頭就出現加入付費會員的按鈕了，不知道有沒有幫到你🤗

@Hehe20419 26 күн бұрын

I love your comments and it's true it's not as powerful as Beyonce like it is really good but I prefer the original one cz it gives more feeling if that makes sense? And Shila have good range but yes her voice is on the the gentle and soft side

@caitlinling6657 18 күн бұрын

She sang this song differently all the time depending on how her mood is

@rosmariamarry732 13 күн бұрын

You rise me up (shila hamzah) please 😊

@Mrczojpsm 2 ай бұрын

Please react to Katrina Velarde's SAVING ALL MY LOVE FOR YOU in her yt channel! Pls!

@ojisakha Ай бұрын

Next, Lyodra - I'll do never love again, indonesian idol

@ngwuiming2004 25 күн бұрын

Apa boleh buat lah yer... Itu komen sejujurnya 😊

@JasonPang19 Ай бұрын

Can you react to Jaclyn Victor’s when I fall in love in Malaysian idol grand final?

@leadtheway87 2 ай бұрын

"歌手"裡面是比較講究重新編曲和唱出自己的風格的。所以老師會聽到偏離原曲的唱法

@user-yo2se9ji3d 2 ай бұрын

歌手節目停播了嗎？很久沒看過他

@kwoo24 2 ай бұрын

雖然我很欣賞西拉的歌聲，但我能理解老師。像另一位網民說的，這首歌通常用來表現無敵高超的技巧，但西拉選了這首歌，在編曲和曲風上也沒做太大改變，卻在很多最難的位置，選用一些對行內人來說比較低端的技巧迴避了每個難度。我以前上聲樂課也特別去學這首，所以特別了解這首歌每個細節。我同樣在每一個讓老師鄒眉頭的部分小失望。因為這首歌很顯然是超出西拉的音域，所以她在很多高難度的位置來回閃避。我覺得西拉的聲音有她自己的魅力，這首歌不是最適合她的。如果真要選這首，建議改編曲風，不要近似原唱的唱法，不需要用Diva的epic磅礴風格。

@Dzldsm Ай бұрын

I totally agree with rosette where parts she handled not so well

@fengliu5762 Ай бұрын

She is the intersection between western and eastern. I do love Beyonce, but not everyone in Asia appreciates Beyonce's way of singing songs. I think that's why her version is less powerful. I have no doubt she could make it, but for Asian audiences, that's a friendly version.

@norhaniftalha5389 Ай бұрын

This really tasty than original..huhu

@Axroul 24 күн бұрын

If the coach knows how that era. They didnt like how her(Shila Amzah) do exagerrating like how coach want it to be now. Im still staying supporting how Shilas rendetion of the song great and totally occupied the season that time