If it involves money, then I can't afford it. But I will continue to watch your KZfaq videos, especially your music videos.

I hope you continue to post on KZfaq. Some of us can't afford another monthly fee to join anything.

I was really looking forward to seeing updates about your new home... 😔 I don't have any social media at all so KZfaq is the only thing I see you all on. I'm going to miss you all!🥺❤

I am the kind of person who (when I follow someone I like) will watch your video (the same one) on FB, Instagram and KZfaq b/c I know that the views help you. But everyone is trying to get more now. Everyone wants you to pay per view. We have plenty of bills each month. We just don’t have more to give for something that quite frankly is not necessary. I have enjoyed watching Claire, Carson, June and Millie growing up. But I just don’t feel great about all of the new subscriptions on KZfaq. And I mean ALL of them. Not just this channel. I was touched by Dave’s surprise for Ashley. I watched as they worried whether they’d be able to get water or not. I was looking forward to seeing Ashley’s new dream house. But if that is paid subscription only, I guess this is where the road ends for me. I wish you guys well.

I’m not a fan of the paid subscription. It’s nothing personal, I’ve followed you for a long time and your family is delightful…I’m a wildlife photographer and several big photographers are doing this subscription thing. Money is tight…I’m not doing this for anyone I was following…that fee adds up to pay it for each you were following. I catch you when I can on utube….love you guys, good luck and blessings on your new adventure ❤️❤️❤️

I would love to see the extra content and updates, but unfortunately I don't live in the US and the conversion rate at the moment makes it more than double the cost for me, and not something I can afford. I hope you continue to share on here and Insta/Facebook so we can still hear the music and fun family times, and the house building progress ❤ Have been following you since Claire was 3 😊

Hmm... so while we've seen a bit less of you than we used to (& there was a block not long ago where you seemed totally missing), suddenly you'll be doing more? So how does that work for you with your time? I hate it when every channel I follow goes to a special subscription club, making the rest of us feel 2nd class. There's those of us who are pensioners & can't afford anything extra (I've just last night had to cancel some things from my budget). There's also a Cost of Living Crisis at the moment (with Australia in a 'recession' of sorts). Plus, there's those of us not in the US (eg I'm in Australia), so not available to see regular live streams (although I have spotted part of a few, because I was up during the middle of the night, still). It'll be good for you guys to raise some more income for yourselves. It'll be good for US followers who can afford it. But for me, looks I'll be a 2nd class follower on here, too, despite following you from just about the beginning of Claire's start to her singing career. Good for you for this new initiative, but don't forget the rest of us loyal followers. And please don't make us feel 2nd class as every other channel does who decides to do the exclusive membership route. I want to see more of Millie as she grows - she's an absolute cutie. Anyway, good for for you & those in the US (ie time-wise) & who can afford it. Please don't neglect us who can't join up, especially when content seemed to dropped off not long ago this year as it was. 😢

KZfaq is all I follow, I am just getting to old to try all the other platforms so please keep us updated on the house here. I have been following Claire since she was three.

My thoughts as a loyal fan since day 1. 1.this feels like a sellout. You already don't post your weekly videos anymore, how will you keep up with this? 2. Is this more content from you, the parents.. or are the kids being pushed to perform? If so, do they get paid? Family vlogging in general is being more scrutinized these days. I've always supported you saying, not the Crosbys, they don't ever exploit their kids. I don't like this idea at all. It lumps you in with those other families... How about you just have a shop where you sell your sheet music, etc? Then it's not about the kids. I love all of Ashley's posts on social media, I hope they don't end or sit behind a pay wall. You said when this all to lol off you didn't want your kids paying the bills.. Please tell me they still won't be.

Sounds exciting❤

I’m sad…I’d love to join & see house updates and all the other stuff but just can’t take on anymore monthly expenses.It’s not much what you’re asking for but I’m drowning just with my basic rent,utilities & medical expenses & I’m very sick and unable to work I just can’t add more even as much as I’d really like to but I have no doubt many others will be able to. I would if I could.

I was looking forward to updates on your new home build. But, I can't take on any more monthly charges.

Ashley: you look STUNNING! You have soooo come into your own, you BEAUTY!

Soooo exciting

I hope you still post on KZfaq. I don’t have Instagram or TikTok and can’t pay for your membership right now but I love watching your content.

I sure miss you all!! I miss any updates on the house too. You both are awesome. You have done great with the kids. Merry Christmas Crosby family! ❤

Your children are truly wonderful. Your family is also. Everyone is really enjoying playing their instruments and, singing. So, I'm always impressed.

Best wishes Crosby Family

I’ve been watching Claire when she was little … been always excited to watching your videos …😮

You guys are my favorite! Me and my best friend would watch Claire when she was little and my friend was actually named Claire and we would sing her songs and catch up on all her videos. My dream is to meet you guys because you seem so sweet and such an original family!

Please keep posting any updates on KZfaq too 🥲 I don’t have Instagram or TikTok, I always miss when influencers post cool things like this lol

You know, timed are tough for everyone right now. Some of is use social media to release stress. But now people like yourselves start charging to watch. It's sad really. I used to enjoy your content, but not anymore

I am sorry to hear this.

I'm so excited

I love watching all of your new and uploaded video's.

Hope to see more Crosby family band content

This is great. I've been watching Claire since you were on Ellen

All the best! blessings!!!

genialísimo familia 😆❤️ saludos desde Chile

Thanks guys! Love you!

Sounds awesome

Yes, to the diversity of ideas and creativity, we are with you and for you always.

Oh my gosh!! I’m gonna try and sign up for sure!❤❤❤

This is the first time I’m commenting but I just wanted to tell you guys-I’ve been watching your videos since Claire was 3 and I don’t follow anyone else on KZfaq. I don’t have insta or any social media because it’s not in my value system. At first I was (and still am) so impressed by the talent God has blessed your family with, but the reason I keep watching is I am more impressed by the beautiful character traits your children have and I always hope to learn some indirect parenting tips for my own kids and even marriage tips from you guys. (I know there are plenty normal hard moments missing from videos but there are certain aspects a family can never edit or fake) I’m not going to subscribe because I think I wouldn’t want to be too invested to KZfaq.. but I wish you the best of luck always! Keep to your beautiful values, thank you for all the inspiration and entertainment, God should bless you always.

Done with your family!!! I feel so sad, because June is the coolest. ...but monetizing, is living off your kids. I do wish you well!

Love you Crosbys

nice idea guys❤❤❤❤

Sheet music!!! 🤩🤩🤩 backing tracks!!!!! 🤩🤩🤩

Count me in!

You are the in ‘The Club’ God Bless 🙏

I always thought I was supporting your family by watching your videos as it gives you an income..that’s all I can do. Would love to learn the ukulele and have sheet music but I will have to rely on the free content elsewhere

Great you can do this. However it has been do disappointing to have so many you tubers starting up “for pay” channels. So many things i have been watching have gone this route which would cost me a ridiculous amount of money. My response eventually is going to drop it all.

I have loved you guys since lockdown

I'm sad because I don't have money and i'm gonna miss you guys

I can't wait already joined you guys are really creative and inspiring

Yay I love you guys so much!! And good luck:

Yay….. I’ve been watching you guys since Claire was 3 and was on little big shots!!!! Were it all began❤

Love seeing how far your family has gone since the Moana video. Word puns definitely intended 😊

Wow! You have come a long way! I’m so very, very proud of you Crosbys.

The smell of money changes people. It's sad. 🙁

woah!!!!

This is soo exciting..! 🤸🏼‍♂️🤸🏼‍♂️🥰✨

It sounds great!!❤❤

Can’t wait yay ❤❤❤❤❤

❤❤❤

❤

I really hope I win this time whenever you guy's have it.

Need to pay for that land and new house! Good luck. I'm not interested but I'm sure many will be.

well i am crying because watch her went she was 2 and i deaf and love watch her my break because watch good things and it take way because of money love you guys

Immagino che ci abbiate pensato molto, prima di prendere questa decisione, poiché siete persone intelligenti e attente. Avrete chiesto consulenze, valutato i pro e i contro, ne sono sicura. Quindi avrete messo in conto anche di dare una delusione a molti di noi, togliendo naturalezza ai vostri video familiari. È comprensibile la vostra intenzione di monetizzare, ma lo è anche la nostra di non voler/poter pagare un abbonamento per qualcosa che fino ad oggi aveva il profumo della simpatia anziché quello del commercio. Buona fortuna a tutti ❤

Membership is not an option for me, a retiree on limited income. I’m glad you still plan on doing the regular videos because I can’t afford the membership and extras that come with it. I’m sure there are plenty of those who can get this membership and have the extra $$.

good luck with club Crosby

Keep posting updates on her aunt’s land which you purchased 3:00 and your house build

💜❤️💜

Please recommend Claire to perform "the thousand years" song Whenever she wishes.... She would be perfect for it...

You haven’t given any info about where or how to join, or how much!

Yes, 😢 this is very sad for all of us who can't afford to follow you anymore. Some of us are so far away from our own kids and grandkids. We love you all so much and just feel so sad we can't be a part of your family anymore. Please don't let money be a factor here. We all need our family. We will continue to pray for you...just don't forget us lonely grandma's.

omg i need

Your kids are so fricken cute and adorable.

Joined! So excited especially for the sheet music!

This sounds awesome. Can you tell me a little more about the ukulele lessons . This really interests me. Thank you in advance

same here only have you tube. plus i too far away to meet in Australia.

I have followed you from the beginning and part of the reason for that is that from the beginning you always said that your channel wasn’t about making money. In Australia the monthly charge for the new club is $7.49. That’s nearly $1.90 a week. In the current climate of a cost of living crisis I cannot justify that when I can buy 1L of milk for less than that. I guess I’ll just have to settle for whatever crumbs are thrown the way of those of us that can’t pay.

I love the fact that you keep innovating! I can’t wait to check out your new content and participate in some of the live events, too! I’ve loved your family ever since I saw tiny Claire sing (in her perfect pitch)with Dave on Tv. You have such a beautiful family, with glorious hearts, and you’ve given me an amazing amount of joy over these years. I’ll be here with you!!

I would love to join this but I'm 13 so my parents won't let me join any memberships unfortunately

Hey guys! well what has happened to the weekly videos I WAS A BIGGGGG FAN SINCE I WAS ONLY 4 YRS OLD!! I WOULD ASK MY MOM FOR FLUFFY DRESSES JUST TO BE LIKE CLAIRE I was so happy of you guys weekly and cute family trips every friday now you never upload and you never EVER post to you're fans who has been there for like half of you guys lifes! well maybe next time post for us you will be missed and I will be sad for like my whole life have A NICE LIFE FAMILY!! I was grateful for you back then but now I think I wont be seeing you guys till next month but by have a nice life!.

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Will the lives be added to watch at later times as I live in the uk and am always sleeping when lives happen in the USA?? As would love to join the club but don't want to miss out on aspects x

I like you as a family does your kids love doing music etc or is it what you both want them to be

If you go on tour, how will you guys know if we are a member so we can have the meet and greet

So disappointed with you guys for doing this. Ive enjoyed your family since Little Big Shots. Can't afford to pay. Budget has been cut as much as i can. Good luck in your new adventure.

When and where are the meet and greets ❤

One of your number one fans, have been following from the Part of Your World video. But I am on a fixed income and can't afford this. 😕

Love it! Congratulations! I´ve been watching you since your first appearance on Ellen and Little Big Shots. I trust it will be another success for you as a family. Infinite love and blessings always dear Crosbys.

"The juicy stuff" "The juicy stuff, what do you talk about?" Burgers, big sloppy juicy burgers. Yum!

wish I could join sounds great. More content is what I really want for this epic fam

If you want to see updates....money is the answer. 💰 always opens more doors.

Where’s the link to look at pricing ?

So how much is it going to cost???

Well, Dave and Ashley, I'm done. Followed you the last six or seven years. Bye.

Does it cost a fee??

How Do You Get In The Club

How do I join.

*that is so cool*

I want string and wind instruments for my song and I want to add my own instruments on top of that. Can you send me some sheet music of your arrangements.

How do we join?? Is there a join link somewhere or coming soon? Let us know! Love y’all!

Who came here when they first posted it 👇

This video is very sweet and kind.

I live really for in England/ Dorchester sorry

Claire has her dads face😳