Love all the opinions and comments guys! Great points all around! This is a fun convo.

Tyler Mane as Michael Myers is one of the scariest portrayals. You’re basically getting murdered by the 1997 version of Kane 🤣

Honestly, Michael in H6 scared the PISS out of me, even though I didn't really like the movie itself. He was just absolutely brutal and terrifying-that operating theater scene still sends chills down my spine. He just seemed so violent and merciless. But the OG Shape deserves a shoutout too, Nick Castle put in a hell of a creepy performance. Honourable mention: H18 Michael. The creepiness of Castle + the brutality of Wilbur=an unforgettable performance. James Jude Courtney was badass.

I think it’s now safe to say that “Halloween kills” Michael, takes the trophy.

The Curse of Michael Myers is a scary movie with a scary Michael.

When I was little, I watched that scene where Busta Rhymes talks to Michael Myers in Resurrection and I thought it was a comedy skit

say what you want about his movies but to me its RZ's michael myers. i would not want to be in a fight with the 8 foot tall behemoth that was tyler mane

Michael from the Rob Zombie movies is essentially just a mountain man with some serious mommy/daddy issues, which is about as terrifying as a serial killer gets honestly.

The guy who played Michael in H6 was the same one who played him in H4, maybe he was so angry in H6 because of the reactions he got from H4

H2 Michael was the most vicious. I would not want to deal with him

Halloween 2 Michael Myers was the scariest to me. He had that robot walk. The messed up hair. It was just creepy!

2018 Michael, aging predator who seems to WANT to prove he’s still got it. And he does. Full of rage, vengeance and the classic sick sense of enjoyment in what he does, 2018 Michael is exactly what we needed.

For me, rob zombies take on Michael himself was super scary for me. That hospital scene is crazy

Tyler Mane hands down! The size of that dude is unreal! While Rob Zombie's Halloween movies weren't that great, Mane's Myers portrayal was definitely one of the best areas of the movies.

Part 4 Michael has this one scene that makes him beyond creepy, which gets little recognition: when Rachel rams him with the truck and Michael literally doesn't move a muscle and eats the hood like he knows the truck can't hurt him. All the other Michaels would jump out of the way... Part 4 is just inhuman.

William Shatner is the scariest. Thanks to Halloween he never has to put on a mask on Halloween.

Halloween 6, he scared the shit outta me. He was pissed in that movie. Halloween 1, 2 and 2018 as well Edit: Halloween Kills tops them all. I ain't f***in with him.

I felt in Halloween 1978 he was very scary on how he loved to stalk his victims and he was realistic in that one. Halloween 6 he was like super shredder on how big and powerful he was almost like a monster behind a mask.

Yes! I totally agree with you regarding H6 being the scariest! You can really feel Jamie's fear while being chased by Michael when she escaped and hid in the bathroom at the bus station. George P Wilbur did an amazing performance. Rest In Peace George.

Halloween 6 was the scariest for me...that scene when he was standing outside just staring across the street freaks me out

Michael is at his creepiest in the 1st, 2nd and 6th film imho. The other movies were alright, but the masks were too clean and too shiny looking.

Halloween 6 might have been the 1st in the series i watched as a kid an it scared the shit out of me, so id have to go with that Michael

Halloween 2. Probably because it was the first one I saw as a kid...scared me to freaking death. When he is stalking Lori when she is trying to get back in the hospital....I crapped a brick as he slowly walked across the parking lot as she fumbled to get back inside. Scarred me for life...and I love it! :-)

Halloween 2. The whole hospital rampage...I still get chills when they're going through the basement.

It's an interesting psychological profile for each Halloween fan to say they like/find it more scary to see the "meaner myers" vs "the most indifferent and calm myers". I personally love H2 1981, he is sharp, clever, shows incredible strength with the scalpel, still stalks before the kill, and was shot like 15 times plus the eyeball revolver shots with no real damage taken.

I had a feeling 6 would be at the top since you guys grew up on that one lol! Rumors are flying as always but supposedly in Kills, Michael is gonna be very pissed after he got beat in the last one!

Halloween 6 is my fav movie all time for sure

michael was very calculated and precise with nearly everything he did in the original movie

Totally agree. Halloween 6 was my first thought as soon as you said scariest. Michael was brutal in H6

Nick Castle......the OG, I feel he'll make you suffer the most...

Halloween 2 Myers scared me the most. Any time I’ve had nightmares about the character, it’s always that version that’s trying to kill me. The way he walks, the robotic movements, the relentless conviction he has. He sort of has that “It Follows” thing going on, where you just know that he’s going to find you no matter where you try to hide. Also a little bit of a “Five Nights At Freddy’s” thing, where he feels a lot like an evil animatronic. The way he roams the halls…very creepy. Rob Zombie’s version is probably second scariest just because of how intimidating he is…if this guy corners you, you’re dead, you have no chance. The way he stands behind Lindsey when she’s watching tv is creepy as hell. After that I’d probably go with 2018 and Kills Michael. He’s kind of a combination of the two above, without being extreme in either category. The scariest part about him is that he kills in such painful ways. Next would be the OG. He definitely has the creepy ghost factor, but I don’t really find him physically intimidating. He’s scarier from a distance than he is up close in my opinion. Creepy, but doesn’t outright scare me. After that I guess would be Part 6…sure From then on…I don’t know. None of them are scary at all from this point.

Original Halloween 2 is the scariest version by far, the way actor Dick Warlock walks as Michael is chilling, plus the mask is the scariest one out of all movies

I have to go with JJC from Halloween 2018 and Halloween Kills, however definitely a close second to George Wilbur from Halloween 4: The Return Of Michael Myers and from Halloween 6: The Curse Of Michael Myers, amazing work

It still shatter me when michael got shot on the eyes twice but Halloween 2 from 81 still creeps me out especially the robot walk and stalking

My favorite movie is Halloween 6 lol yes I'm one of those! But halloween 2 has the scariest vibe and the scariest Myers! The music in halloween 2 is so mysterious and keeps you on the edge of your seat the entire time,chase scene is amazing! The strongest Myers though is in 6 for sure!

MM is my homeboy. But I constantly have nightmares about him. It’s always the original Mike

Man it’s been hard to watch KZfaq this morning but you’re guys humor never fails to cheer up. RIP Kobe & Gigi bryant and the rest in the accident 🙏🏽🕊

Okay, take it back, Rob Zombies Halloween is my first pick now, dude had hands the size of dinner plates, and he was almost 7 feet tall.

Halloween II does it for me. He felt so unstoppable and just relentless and robotic he reminded me a lot of the Terminator. Just absolutely relentless and never stopping like you could never ever outrun him. That to me is scary as fuck knowing that no matter how many times you try to kill him he just won't fucking stop, before all the bullshit curse and stuff mixed with the bad portrayals and masks. The Halloween II mask was actually scary too because it wasn't just white, it was weathered and mean looking.

H78, H18, and H6 were scary, but honestly, RZ's Michael was terrifying. Love them all, but Tyler Mane brought a sense of confidence to the role that freaked me the hell out lol. Here's my list: RZ's Halloween Halloween 6 RZ's Halloween II Halloween 2018 Halloween Halloween II Halloween 4 Halloween 5 H20 Resurrection

In terms of physicality it definitely goes to the RZ Shape played by the massive Tyler Mane. Otherwise, it's JJC in Halloween Kills. That movie shows Michael being about as brutal and evil as one could ever imagine. So many insane kills in that one. Plus him being an old man by that point kinda adds to the scariness for me.

Halloween 6 was badass I know a lot of people didn’t like it because of the storyline, but that Michael Myers was the scariest and I thought he looked awesome. That movie had the nurse picked up and slammed on that spike, Jamie on that shredder machine and one of the most iconic Myers scenes of all time when he kills all those medical workers in that one room. I love the Curse of Michael Myers so much it’s scary haha. “Look mommy it’s raining, it’s raining red”. 🔪🩸🩸🩸

halloween 5 for me. man that version scared the fukk outta me watching it when i was a kid 🤯. idk how ppl dont like the mask. 🤨 its my top 3 masks 🤷‍♂️

Curse of Michael was the scariest

I gotta go w Halloween II. Warlock was not messing around and he seemed more demonic than any of the other portrayals 🤔

The scapel lift was my favorite kill.

Tyler Mane is probably the scariest Michael

I dont wanna be killed personally! 🤣

Hands down I would go with Halloween 2018 that mask was awesome.

HALLOWEEN 2 (1981) 🎃 Warlock owned that character like no other.

3:56 I will never on unsee that 😂 And RZ Michael Myers scared the living shit out of me when I first saw it when I realize how big he was and how he was moving around so light lol no man that big should be tiptoeing around anywhere

Halloween Kills Michael laughs at your list

As a kid it was Halloween 2 for sure. They way he stuck the scalpel in the nurse and lifted her in the air was scary. The rest of the movie was terrifying!

For me it would forever be Halloween 1978 only because just the character study of how he’s kind of a mysterious man with no background at all and because of the way his mask looked because it was so unpredictable of what he wanted to do next and that is what his mask did. But your list is also amazing

I love you guys I really thought I was a crazy obsessed Michael fan. Keep it going guys . Love from Sealy Tx . Yal brighten my days dudes .

Bro, Michael Myers isn't a clumsy, beastly savage. He's an extremely intelligent,, cunning, ruthless, Legendary Master Ninja immortal embodiment of pure evil. He's even more vicious, ruthless, and evil in 2018. That's why the mask didn't disintegrate over time. It became a part of him by the end of the first movie and evil never dies. Halloween Kills shows him becoming more powerful after each kill and the town of Haddonfield realizing the truth that Tommy Doyle said all those years ago. "You can't kill the boogeyman".

Everytime I hear "Kung Fu Busta Rhymes" I think of Halloween Resurrection and Def Jam Fight for NY

Halloween 4 honestly is my favorite Michael and to me he’s the scariest

H6 Michael Myers and RZ's Michael Myers are tied for the scariest Michael in my opinion as they are the worst and most brutal Michael Myers to fight for your life/ run from. Will you guys do a similar video for Jason from Part 2- Remake Jason?

I think Halloween 6 curse is the scariest Michael Myers. He twisted a dudes head open with his bare hands!

I think h6 is the most dangerous but h1 is the most scary.

Halloween II (1981) for me. Dick Warlock was terrifying as The Shape. Just seeing him walk down the halls of the hospital or creep down the stairs or sneak up behind Ms. Elrod. He had an otherworldly presence.

H6 myers was a whole different level of monster man. He was absolutely insane. What sucks is that the kills in the theatrical version were amazeballs, but the story of the directors cut was where it was at. To have the best of both worlds!

Even though it isn’t my favorite movie I’m going to have to say Halloween 4 Mike is the one I wouldn’t want to face and I think it’s because he just seemed so indestructible and overpowered and didn’t show any signs of weakness.

I read the video title & immediately thought to myself, “H6.” Glad you both agreed. He was terrifying. From scariest MM to least: 1. H6 2. H II 3. H original 4. H2018 (old) 5. H5 (pretty vicious, but bad mask) 6. H4 (wearing pillows & awful mask) 7. Resurrection (busta rhymes, mask looks like makeup) 8. H20 (tiny, awful mask) I don’t consider the Rob Zombie versions.

1. Tyler Mane (RZ 1 & 2) 2. George P. Wilber (6) 3. James Jude Courtney 4. Dick Warlock 5. George P. Wilbur (4) 6. Nick Castle 7. Don Shanks 8. Brad Loree 9. Chris Durand

I was 6 when H6 came out so he frightened me as a young confused boy coming up in this scary cold world

Part 6, That was a real angry, brutal Michael. He was like a terminator Michael !!

The most scariest Michael Myers is... Halloween Halloween ll Halloween 4 RZ Halloween Halloween 2018 Halloween 5 Halloween 6

Hey what did the skeleton say to the surfer 🏄? Lend me some skin 😂 😂 😂

I would not wanna fight Halloween 2 Michael Myers he literally got shot in the eyes with a revolver and was caught up in an explosion and he was still up

1-27-2020: Nick Castle was the most badass followed by James Jude Courtney. Those are my 2 favorites in that order...but Dick Warlock was the creepiest Shape to me. That zombie like walk after getting shot 6 times and falling off a balcony did a number on Mike, but that's when the evil kicked in. Instead of choking his victims he fell in love with plunging that Lammy (is it still considered a Lamson in the OG?) and scraping the bones beneath. That desolate hospital setting was unnerving to say the least. And the Blood Tears was an awesome touch to a sinister Shape who was ready to step into the fire and fall into an ancient slumber, well, for a decade at least!!

I wouldn’t really care which Michael Myers was after me as long as he choked my bag 😂

I'd say the top three would be the first, the last, and part 6.

Halloween 2 1981 would be terrifying to go up against. Being in a hospital plus that mask was creepy as fuck man😬

Lol...he ran a lil bit in Halloween 6 when he was chasing the Tommy and Kara and the doctor in the tunnel.

Busta Rhymes didn't bitch him out. He went to kill the girl in the Garage that was filming everything. He also told him he left the back down unlocked, so he went to block it.

I needed this video today, severe depression today no sleep.

RZ Halloween is the scariest to me. Tyler Mane was a beast, but Halloween 6 is a close second! 🎃🔪

H6 for sure , that flashy/bloody/ killing the cult members scene stayed in my head as a kid for months after .. "Kills still got a better Edge" ..

Tyler Mane IS the scariest one hands down. But the Halloween 6 version is pretty scary too.

If you’re talking scariness of the movies it’s easily 1978 If you’re talking scariest Michael Myers it’s still 1978 And if you’re talking based on his kills and brutality 2018, it WAS Halloween 2007, but Halloween 2018 was just far more brutal with the 1978 element. 2007 just felt like a raged Michael doing everything because he was bullied, which works, but the idea that this is the same Michael 40 years ago and he’s MORE pissed than ever and had much more creativeness to him (carrying Teeth, carving faces out of pumpkins, smashing heads) it’s hands down Michael 2018. All the other ones aren’t as inventive for me or scary. Halloween 2 was pretty creepy looking, but it really looks like 1, also the movie just wasn’t that good to me.

That scene with Busta yelling at him... I always felt like Michael probably thought it was his inner self yelling at him giving him advice or just telling him where to go to kill Tyra Banks character. I mean that's where he went and when he got there he probably was like "Hey my inner gangsta was right, there is some bitch here to kill...thanks inner gangsta".

The scariest and serious Dick Warlock . The most pussified is Ressurection

Least scariest? Halloween 5’s MM. His look kills me, in that is the least intimidating or menacing. Most scariest? Toss up between OG Nick Castle in Halloween and Dick Warlock from HII. When I think of Michael Myers, he automatically comes to mind: the slow but deliberate walk, an unstoppable force.

After Halloween kills, I’m going with James Jude Courtney as the scariest Michael myers…

In Curse, Michael chops old lady Deborah in the chest with the axe. He put the sheet in the washer and she was found hanging upside down by Kira. The head in the dryer was at the beginning of Resurrection. 😉

Halloween 6 and Halloween 2018 is the scariest he's been in my opinion, he's more creepy than scary in Halloween Halloween 2 and 4

damn, you guys just gave me quite the revelation. you could argue, that scene where he cries with jamie in the attic is where the series officially lost track of Michael being the shape. in that moment, you clearly see that he is human with emotions. it feels like it took away every piece of mythos that sam had built up for the character at that point. and how many serial killers rock manbuns?? seriously? i hate halloween 5 so much and you guys made light of the biggest reason why. thanks for the therapy og's.

Year later Halloween Kills is out and now I'm terrified of Michael Myers in HK

H6 Michael walked like a peek level Karen, definitely don't want any part of that shit lol

Halloween 6 Michael and RZ Michael hands down

was another fun clip watched. michael myers not being able to be killed in any of the movies is a scary element of him in general.

Og H2 is number one for me. He was a juggernaut in that film. Takes six shots, falls off a secondary story balcony, and is still destroying people. Then he takes another five shots and gets right back up. Fuck that guy.

It's not about Michael's size but more so about how he moves. I actually don't like a really tall Michael like Tyler Mane (not taking anything away from him) because it takes away his mystique. I think when you have a average person playing Michael, they have to rely more on movements rather than physique.

!978 version is the scariest. subtle, unseen, and strikes. skilled in the craft.

Halloween 6 is my favorite scariest. Brutal. Also the first one I ever saw as a kid (around 9 years old) Watched it in a abandoned rent house that people trashed and pissed before they left. When I watch #6 (curse of Michael) I still feel like I’m being watched afterwards for a day or two 🤣

When life gives you lemons, just say fuck the lemons and leave.

You all have it wrong. The scariest and best MM was in Halloween 2 played by the late great Dick Warlock. MM is supposed to be a force not a man and warlock nailed it with the robotic walk. Alot of people disagree but by far the best and scariest MM.

H6 was the most brutal and scariest MM. The bedroom kill, strope light scene, then the actor who played MM killed his dad by pushing him through the gate. I don't want nothing to do with that dude he was pissed off.