You do realize 30% of Palestinians are Christian right.

It's not a matter of religion. It is political. That does not mean Allah is not in charge. You are conflating 2 things here. Making it a matter of religion turns it into Muslims vs jews. And that is not what is going on.

@@abumansaray7 ههههههه مسأله فلسطين مسأله عقيدة والا فلسطين تعاني مثلها ايران تحتل اربع دول وتقتل في سوريا والعراق ولبنان واليمن لماذا لم تتكلمو اذن

@@abumansaray7it's defo a matter of religion, because we are so weak because we not practicing our religion, not because we are not protesting enough

@@wolf-qe5ol These are two different thins you are conflating. The situation of Muslims, yes. The conflict between Palestine and Israel is political.

thats crazy but its true. they mingle with the kuffars so much that they start to act like them.

Not praying Salah and begging the kuffar in public to save the Muslims. Can you imagine Abu Bakr, Umar and Ali may Allah be pleased with them running around Makkah crying and screaming for Abu Lahab to leave the Muslims alone?

Maybe some, which is wrong, but they were all dancing at the Jeddah concerts and that’s in the holy land 😱

That’s the madhkhali way unfortunately

His not right cuz he free mixing in park what is shamsi doing 4 Palestine people and kids don't protest is he gone mad I think

SHAMSI SUPPORT ISIS HAMAS DIDNT SHAMSI GO JAIL 4 TERRIOST A FENCES

He never did though they come to him, so he tries to advise them. If we want Allaah to help us then we need to go back to our religion.

I only SEE WOMEN CHANTING AND PROTESTING 95% ARE WOMEN AS FAR I'VE SEEN. WHERE ARE THE MEN????

Because shamsi wants the muslims to understand that they have to sort their own house out as it's in disarray due to their own negligence

People get super sensitive when they're told to analyse themselves. They get offended missing the whole point@@wiretrack

Madhkalis always are like that. They love giving the crusaders and colonists millitary bases from which to attack neighbouring Muslim countries who ressist the crusaders and colonists. According to the Quran that is clear nifaq but they don't mind because they care more about what some so-called 'scholar' on the Saudi payroll says instead of what is in the Quran.

He conveyed the message of islam more than any in the park to non muslims, look the amount of people who took shahada

We have to focus on the enemies within us the most, Then we look at the enemies from outside

Lol Those who criticise the leaders they live in Europe

It is a disgrace that your brother quotes the Verse of the Qur'an, but you humiliate him.

اين العثمانيين الان لم يبقو

​@@lilalila1464where is rashidun

And because of their shirk they didn’t. They got humiliated and crushed completely in the end 😂

He IS a madkhali

Just remember he is not giving his opinion. He quotes quran and sunnah upon the understanding of the salaf.

​@southernrealist5789 was the march from Dar Al Arkam to the Kabah a protest or are we going to play semantics ?

@@hiroshi-kun8216 that never happened. It is a fake hadith. Look for the article "Did Umar bin Al-Khattāb really gather the Muslims together and protest in the streets of Makkah?" Unlike the jews and Christians, Islam is preserved through chains of narrations for quran and sunnah. Our dean is complete. No room for innovators to play with Islam and make up the religion to suit their desires.

Stop speaking with ignorance. Literally all scholars of ahlul Sunnah warned us harshly of protests. The reason why speak like this, is cus you lack knowledge brother. And how are muslims able to unite when majority of the muslims are missguided emotional kids who hate the Sunnah of our belouved prophet ﷺ. We only unite accordings to the Sunnah and not according to our desires. Return to the major scholars. They were warning us for years of this fitnah. If you wanna help Palestine do dua, study and gain knowledge, give dawah to islam and warn against Shirk and innovations. Only then Allah will give victory to the muslims. You see non practising muslims shout "free Palestine" but dont even pray. As Allah said in the Quran, he will never change the condition of a people until they return to Quran and Sunnah. Allah will never give victory to the current state of the ummah...

Madhkalis always are like that. They love giving the crusaders and colonists millitary bases from which to attack neighbouring Muslim countries who ressist the crusaders and colonists. According to the Quran that is clear nifaq but they don't mind because they care more about what some so-called 'scholar' on the Saudi payroll says instead of what is in the Quran.

​@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj was the march from Dar Al Arkam to the Kabah a protest or are we going to play semantics ?

If you think that was a protest then you are ignorant. So you reject all the major scholars who have a million times more knowledge then us? Allah said in the Quran to follow the scholars. You speak from your desires@@hiroshi-kun8216

All these things are according to sunnah what brnefit have protesting done,they are still attacking

Samiri wasn’t athari. Athar simply means track. It refers to the track of jibreel. In this verse rasul is jubreel. Read any tafseer its not prophet. Read surah taha 96

Protesting is not from the Quran and sunnah...Also when you protest you are trying to get the attention of the western government in the country you are in..what are they going to do? They're working with Israel.

Saudi's involvement in what? Which scholar said protesting is halal?

Stupid comment again

No it's about Quran and sunnah!! The help ultimately comes from Allah. If u abandon Allah and His teachings how do u expect victory? Through marching in the streets with signs, screaming, dancing and singing and free mixing? Is this how u wanna seek Allah's help? Is this how Rasool'Allah and the sahaba behave when the quraish persecuted them for 13 years?

Albani states that you can openly criticise a ruler that openly goes against the Shariah. Shamsi conveniently left out that information when attacking Daniel the other day. @@ponderingspirit1475

ماذا فعل شمس الدين لكي تحكم عليه أنه ضال .... كيف يضل و هو ينصحك باتباع الدين الحق

​@@user-bg2fe2jy5hدين الحق

شمسي من لاحسي احذية طواغيت العرب له من الله ما يستحق .يكذب ويقول أن كهنة آل سلول يحاربون العهر والفسق يكذب فهو كذاب اشر.

@@MrHtjet البينة على من إدعى فصاحب التعليق قال عن شمسي ضال فليبرهن على ذلك و أنت تعلق و تتعجب كيف أني قلت أنه يدعو لدين الحق فعليق المجيء بما يدل عكس هذا و أنا متابع قديم لشمسي و بعض الدعات لذى أعرف منهاجه و لم أرى شخصا يعارضه يكره أو ينتقده إلا كان شيعيا أو صوفيا أو قرآنيا أو قديانيا أو أحمديا أو شخص يحمل الإسلام بالإسم و أنت ربما رأيت مقطع واحد و حكمت هناك فيديوهات كثيرة له شاهدها و خذ فكرة شاملة عنه و السلام و نحن لا ندافع عن الشخص بل عن صاحب الحق

@@user-bg2fe2jy5h والله و لا عندي نية اقرا حتى التعليق ولا اريد الخوض معك في نقاش بائس تعيس يزيد الشرك و مع هذا انت اخي في الدين و تركيزي غير تحياتي

It's called giving dawah. Public company cannot be controlled.

There's a difference between mixing due to necessity i.e. dawah in this case versus mixing without any necessity

Go to his Ytb channel « DUS Dawah ». They also manage to blurr women. Also, he always advices sisters to stay on one side and the brothers to stay on the other side to avoid this free mixing

But you still agree free mixing a huge fitna as mentionned Ibn Taymiyyah and is to be avoided in absence of necessity ?

@@Unknown_F50 have you heard of daroora? There is a qaaida in fiqh that says necessity is measured by the level or extent of the particular mas'ala.

People like Shamsi and the imans of sunnah. Look for the video Why the imans of sunnah refute innovators more than non Muslims By Shaykh Salih aal-alshaykh

i cant believe you are defending protesting while lying and slandering about another Muslim.

@@NamaRauqos04595 👍

@@jarirmuthana5642 no dont raise your thumbs. what you did isnt good. delete your comment or apologize because Shamsi speaks up for Palestinians a lot but he also tells us to first return to Quran and Sunnah.

@@NamaRauqos04595 he also, like all madkhalis supports the tyrants who are the number reason for the corruption of this ummah.

Prove it

@@confusionbhai let him define it first. Give him time to Google

@@confusionbhai the proof : personal opinion

@@confusionbhai according to "shamsi logic" : shamsi is a khariji because he didn't have bayat on sheikh hasina !!

@@confusionbhai however I am against "shamsi logic" because he do not have sufficient knowledge to issue fatwas. He should concentrate on giving dawah to non-Muslims, only for the sake of Allah.

If you have no evidence against him from quran and sunnah then why write this comment?

Nah he just speak passionatly about our deen

Who ever reads this message I hope it finds yous in good spirits and may Allah SWT grant us happiness peace success contentment and may Allah SWT look after all our affairs in this life and the next may Allah SWT protect us from harm and oppression and being oppressed may Allah SWT grant us the Rizq which is meant for us may Allah SWT grant us all a righteous spouse may Allah SWT make our kids of the mojahedeen and the pious ones ❤️ and may Allah SWT forgive us for our sins we committed in private and in public and may Allah SWT protect our Muslim brothers and sisters who are being oppressed around the world Allahumma ameen

Allah knows what is in hearts, not you stop liying

No he is just passionate do not accuse him its his style.

Protesting is haram. Bring one scholar who says it's halal. If you're referring to Hamas, the scholars such as Shaykh Al Albani and Shaykh Muqbil warned against them. And obeying Bin Salman or Bin Zayed or any Muslim leader for that matter is in line with the hadith where the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم said hear and obey, even if he flogs your back and consumes your wealth.

You: I put lies in my brothers mouth.

​@@ponderingspirit1475can't just use that one verse to say its okay to call them your leaders if they already sold there souls to the american dollar

​@ponderingspirit1475 was the march from Dar Al Arkam to the Kabah a protest or are we going to play semantics ?

Shamsi is speaking about them in this video. This is raising awareness. Nothing stopping you from telling people about the injustice too. The most important thing is prefect your prayer and do dua for them. The power of dua was used by the prophet salahallah alaihi wasallam in circumstances like this. You can tell others to do the same. Protest is not from islam

@@southernrealist5789 And you think people nowadays are not praying? Brother we are not Prophets Allah forbid, we are normal humanbeings, if we do not speak or do protests, nobody would know what is happening in GAZA. SO SPEAK UP! It is the necessity of todays world !

@@Happy_Potato0 what did the prophet salahallah alaihi wasallam do when he was in Makkah and being oppressed by Quresh and idols were being worshiped in the kabbah. Did he protest or did you tell people to be patient and kept teaching them the dean. Who did he rely on for support. He relied on Allah the Exalted. Are you better than the prophet salahallah alaihi wasallam. You rely on protesting to who? The ones who support Israel and the destruction of Palestine. Where from the quran and sunnah upon the understanding of the salaf do you get that protest is permissible and the way? When you testify you worship Allah the Exalted, you are following his guidance as part of that worship, which means not following your desires if it goes against his guidance. May Allah guide me and you

@@southernrealist5789 Just answer my two Questions, 1 : Do you think in the Western World and Non-Muslims who do not know what is Happening in Palestine, how would they know then first of all? (I am not talking about their governments, just the people) 2 : Secondly, Does Allah not ask us Muslims to "Speak and stop the injustice, if we cannot stop it with our hands then do it with our tongue, And if we cannot even speak on it then atleast condemn it as it is wrong in our hearts" ? So your saying to not protest at all or condemn, where are you getting that from?

@@southernrealist5789 Also at the time of our Prophet SAWW IN MAKKAH, There were no Muslims in neighbouring areas, Islam was starting, or do you think if there were muslims elsewhere, they would have not gotten the knowledge of our Prophet SAWW being persecuted or come to His aid?

Madhkalis always are like that. They love giving the crusaders and colonists millitary bases from which to attack neighbouring Muslim countries who ressist the crusaders and colonists. According to the Quran that is clear nifaq but they don't mind because they care more about what some so-called 'scholar' on the Saudi payroll says instead of what is in the Quran.

The Munafiqeen were pretending to be Muslim but inside they were actually kaffir. Don’t use the wrong analogy

The Muslims were defeated in Uhud because of one act of disobedience to Allah. How do we expect Allah to give us victory now while we are drowning in disobedience

@@mrboss9105 yes munafiqun are worse than sinful Muslims…..in the end the Muslims won. There will always be sinful Muslims until the day of judgement. Regardless of your sins you must defend your Muslim brothers and sisters when they need your help

Exception don't make the rule

@@ikka489 fire reply

Shouting and free mixing protests isnt what muslims should do, shamsi is advising them

@@MuhammedfayizK i understand where he’s coming from , but you can’t make these kind of rules while living in a western society . So people in the West have no choice but to mix in with women and w/e group .

You don’t understand Islam. That’s why the Muslims are attacked because people like you act from desire instead of Quran en soenna.

Brother, shamsi has already said don't make palestine your standard of right and wrong but quran and sunnah, it's not like he loves seeing them oppressed but how can they benefit from those who go out to protest, if you have money give out to charities that reach them, if you have time pray for them, and keep firm on your deen is all our brother is saying, Allah subhanahu wa taala won't give victory to those who have forgotten their deen and are going against Allah's commandments. The only way to help now is to do duaa for them and to help them financially, talking in public about people in power and muslim countries rulers will only cause fitna between people, if a civil war happens because of that, only those who are against islam will benefit, Palestinians won't benefit from muslims fighting each other, we are divided enough already, people should not blindly follow their emotions without thinking, alhamdu lillah our islam encourages people to think and ponder and make sound and reasonable decision. May Allah forgive and guide us all.

Unfortunately, when the Ottoman Empire, at the end, they were far away from the Deen, they began to imitate the kuffar, Allah humiliated them, they were defeated, all those countries that they ruled, the kuffar divided them between themselves and Palestine was one of them. The Muslims can NOT even defend themselves against shaytan, how on earth are they going to defend Palestine. The Prophet Muhammed, peace and blessings be upon him, said, when you engage in Riba, and you are satisfied with this dunya, and you abandon Jihad, Allah will send down humiliation upon you, no one can remove it, until you go back to your *Deen* .... Allah says, O you who have believed, if you help in the couse of Allah, Allah will help you and make you steadfast. Allah also says, So do not become weak (against your enemy), nor be sad, and you will be superior (in victory) if you are indeed ( *true) believers* ... And other verses and ahadith. We know the solution. War is very complicated and very awful, so the Muslims need to be prepared, their 'Aqeedah, their Eeman needs to be strong, their weapons, they have to do Jihad Nafs against the evil soul and against Shaytan, becouse if your Eeman is weak or your Aqeedah is corrupted, you will flee from the battle and it is over, Allah would never accept the repentence from such individual. And you can not possibily fight a man with airstrike while you have a sword. You need to have what they have.

​@@adhamhalabi7472You are mad for this statement, Shamsi is clearly in the wrong. First he miss represented what transpired at the treaty of Hudiabiah. Now he's doing what he does best, telling u verses from the Quran and the Sunnah completely out of context. I ask u were in the Quran and Sunnah is it halal to financially benefit from the genocide of Muslims? Where is it halal to work with kufirs that are murdering Muslims by the day? Whos corrupted Aqeda are u nutcases following? Read Surah Al Maeda ayat 50 and continue 7 ayats and after u read that then tell me how these rulers yall defending are not manafiqs. Cuz spoiler alert Allah says the actions tooken by them are clear actions of nifaq in those verses stated. And there is a hadith associated with those verses to help u understand.

Which scholar said it's haram to make peace treaties with the Zionist state? You're claiming it's not permissible by your statement, so you surely must have ulama with you.

سبب الحروب هو الدين

Madhkalis always are like that. They love giving the crusaders and colonists millitary bases from which to attack neighbouring Muslim countries who ressist the crusaders and colonists. According to the Quran that is clear nifaq but they don't mind because they care more about what some so-called 'scholar' on the Saudi payroll says instead of what is in the Quran.

If that was the case. You would see masajid full every salah. Rather than the streets full every protests

@@mrboss9105 Yes Alhamdulillah the Masaajid are far more busy than they used to be, more and more youth coming to the prayers

Dis you even pay attention to what he is saying?

Madhkalis always are like that. They love giving the crusaders and colonists millitary bases from which to attack neighbouring Muslim countries who ressist the crusaders and colonists. According to the Quran that is clear nifaq but they don't mind because they care more about what some so-called 'scholar' on the Saudi payroll says instead of what is in the Quran.

Yeh. Plus protests aren't forbidden - in fact the Sabah did so when they marched from Dar Al Arkam to the Kabah. Madkhalis just making stuff up again

@@hiroshi-kun8216 name one scholar that has claimed protesting to be halal.

well one can speak to the people in power if he has access to them, engage in debates in an organized setting, make beneficial videos explaining about the cause, have beneficial discussions in groups in the mosque related to the cause. these are some of the halal ways that i am aware of that one can stop evil with their mouth.

You just went astray because of reinterpreting what bro Shamsi saying. English and Arabic is not even my second language but I understand what he said well and clear. 1. He never said devout muslims have rights to protest. 2. You heard him. 3. He doesn't say ALL that you said and muslim countries should have diplomatic and trade relations with Israel (may Allah curse all the zionists) 4. Palestine have been oppressed and their oppression only increased after each protests / militia stunts by the iranian jews. You did judge and misquote him for his naseeha then have the audacity to "That is between us and Allah. Do not Judge". ask about evidences from Quran and sunnah again while clearly and publicly opposed it? fear Allah and may Allah guide you. my advice to you is do not unite upon misguidance and always on strive to rectify ourselves, pray and ask help only to Allah may he grant us and the palestinians victory.

@@ndhikaatube So please do tell what exactly is his position. I am still not clear after your explanations. Also other than praying for Palestine what strategic directions does Shamsi ( or you have ) for all of us not so enlightened Muslims. I would genuinely like to know. I want to be corrected and guided by people who understand Islam much better than me.

Madhkalis always are like that. They love giving the crusaders and colonists millitary bases from which to attack neighbouring Muslim countries who ressist the crusaders and colonists. According to the Quran that is clear nifaq but they don't mind because they care more about what some so-called 'scholar' on the Saudi payroll says instead of what is in the Quran.

What are the arkans of salat 😂😂

Mocking your muslim brother?

Khariji jahel

​@@yassinyazid6556calamity 😂😅

Allāh said : He [i.e., man] utters no word except that with him is an observer prepared [to record]. Qaf, Aya 18 You’ll stand before Allāh, justify yourself and be judged equitably for what you’re saying to Shamsi

Cope you Rafidi Mushrik.

Madhkalis always are like that. They love giving the crusaders and colonists millitary bases from which to attack neighbouring Muslim countries who ressist the crusaders and colonists. According to the Quran that is clear nifaq but they don't mind because they care more about what some so-called 'scholar' on the Saudi payroll says instead of what is in the Quran.

shamsi never said Palestinians couldn't defend themselves fear allah regarding slandering, But obeying rulers is in accordance with sunnah even if they are tyrants

It has been narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: It is obligatory for you to listen to the ruler and obey him in adversity and prosperity, in pleasure and displeasure, and even when another person is given (rather undue) preference over you. -sahih muslim 1836

@MuhammedfayizK no its not. Sahabah clearly rebelled against Hajaj in Jamajim, and they know more about Islam then you or your Saudi payrolled so-called munafiq scholars will ever know. Also don't talk about slander when all you madkhali dogs do is call this one a khariji and the other one ahl al bidah. You madkhalis are dogs and the best treatment for your kind was what we saw in Libya when your boys who were supporting another wannabe-tyrant Haftar got sent to jahanam via Turkish bayraktar drone.

"People don't like the truth"

Actually, only now I started to understand him. And I now agree on some of his points. And I understand him.

Shamsi destroyed Daniel and people like you are so blind. May Allah guide you to Quran and sunnah

Is it okay for women to be protesting in the streets?

@@mo-nf4crneither men or women should protest if you want to help Palestine make dua turn back to the Quran and sunnah purify our soul by staying away from sins and most importantly let’s establish TAWHEED shouting and screaming like a chicken without its head isn’t gonna do anything how would they feel if their mother got brutally murdered and peoples form of support is dancing and screaming in the street Wallahi it should make u angry