What if the Jedi built the Death Star and Anakin over saw it??? What if PLO Koon trained Anakin? What if Shaak TI trained Anakin? What if commander fox stunned fives because he believed him?

What if Quinlan Vos or Mace windu trained Luke

Hey what if super earth (helldivers 2) was a 3rd faction into star wars the clone wars

60k. Let us know the winner tomorrow

Okay, so this is a weird thing, but I remember the whole 'Darth Jarjar' thing and had a thought. What if Jarjar Binks (Darth Ful? Rekle?) and Darth Plagius were rivals? Jarjar lost his fight against Plagius, is sent to Naboo to die with the people of that planet, but runs into the Jedi. He 'helps' them because it keeps him both safe and close enough to manipulate their path. Even comes across 'the chosen one' that was birthed by the actions of Plagius and Sidius, and is in a position to manipulate them.

So, if this occurred...almost certainly Anakin would not have been trained at all after Qui-Gon's death. It wasn't just his final wish that convinced the council to allow the boy to be trained by Obi Wan, but also the return of the Sith and the fact Anakin seemed to be the chosen one. Without that...Anakin may get shuffled off to the agricultural core, but otherwise would go untrained...ripe for Sideous to manipulate and pluck him away from the Jedi much sooner

@@thelasthunter7906or he could just tell the council and they keep their mouths shut about it

@thelasthunter7906 not necessarily. Knowing the council would probably refuse to train a child so old, He could have just opened with I'm indebted to him and will take him as my Padawan. Then before his death ask obi-wan as normal. He would have to be in on it too. All that's left is to fake his midichlorian count and cover up his roll in the command ship.

Good one!

I thought Anakin's age and/or potential were the reason for that. Qui-Gon had to explain why the Force brought the two of them together, and perhaps he knew that Anakin's age would be an issue, so he was trying to drill home just how important it was that Anakin be trained. Sadly, the Council didn't bite until it was too late, and against Yoda's better judgment. Honestly, seeing how much more personality people like Yoda would turn out to have, sometimes I wonder how the Council could be so stuck up during The Phantom Menace. Maybe there's something in Tales of the Jedi that the clips and summaries just don't cover, but I don't want to give Disney my own personal money if I can help it because I disagree with some of their values and decisions in recent years.

Accurate

Qui-Gon: force damit

Between that and years of being around Qui Gon, it would be weird for him to stick with Palpatine.

Had the Jedi went the peacekeepers route, and withdrew from the Senate, I doubt Dooku would have left the Order

a banthabummer, even

That changes so much of the timeline that the Clone Wars might not even happen.

@stephenwells6434 it's a what if so we can assume that it doesn't change too much if we so wish.

@@TonyAncom Deciding that the premise of the scenario doesn't change much defeats the purpose of doing a "What If" scenario.

@@stephenwells6434 you're not understanding my point. I'm saying we can state it doesn't change the past much while it does indeed heavily affect the era of the clone wars.

@@TonyAncom No, I get that. I just don't see a point to it.

Taking out Padme’s death is a war crime tho 😔 anyway very tasteful, I’m very pleased with how it turned out. I’ll send you more as I write them haha. Again thank you for bringing this to life for me I really appreciate it

Nu-uh . I sent the email

@@Joshua-gc8sg docs.google.com/document/d/1-foEP78hwKM5NuCg5CQxJOByBRQ1SAnjxTMINcemN5g/edit I GOT THE RECEIPTS SLEEMO

It was me stop lying

Congratulations

This plz

10,000 Jedi vs the population of near half a galaxy? Even the most effective agents of peace and justice would only be a drop in that ocean. So what do you imagine their job is? The Jedi weren’t perfect, but they were trying. It was the government of the Republic that ultimately failed its people. Palpatine took advantage of the corruption that already existed.

@@eirrenia More like if they separated themselves from the Republic, and did their peacekeeping job, like saving slaves and helping people like Anakin with their emotions.

@@terrat0mere Except that, while they have a religion/philosophy that does encourage compassion and aid for others, it is from their position granted them by the Republic that they have legal authority to act as peacekeepers. If they withdrew from the Republic, yes, they would be freer to choose when and how to intervene. But they also would have far less _ability_ to intervene because they would have no legal backing for their actions. If they tried to behave as they currently do they would be seen as at best vigilantes, at worst as outright criminals themselves. Nor could they do much about slavery because while it’s illegal within the Republic, it isn’t illegal within other nations, and ultimately it’s only legislation outlawing it followed up by effective, authorized enforcement of those laws which could stamp it. The Jedi were simply too few in numbers to police the Republic, that was the job of the government and it failed. As for Anakin, yes they made mistakes. Mistakes were inevitable given that he came to them fully steeped in a dramatically different culture; and Jinn burdening him with the “chosen one” label didn’t help. Big deal, parents make mistakes raising their kids all the time; the vast majority do not then choose to become mass murderers. The Jedi’s “job” was not to be omniscient gods. Anakin made his own choices over and over, and chose to _conceal_ those choices over and over. You can’t help someone who doesn’t want help. Palpatine’s gaslighting was a factor, but Anakin’s Fall was his own choice, and a culmination of the choices he made along the way. Again, I’m not saying the Jedi were perfect, they weren’t, but neither were they negligent.

He has already done that one

Leigha lol. I’m pretty sure it’s Leia.

If you listen, he said that they kept their relationship mostly professional. So who's to say Luke and Leia don't end up coming around later

Omg u killed Shaak Ti.

What?

​@kinglukethe7th524 I think he said "what if the yotububer who posted this video was sent into the star wars canon"

:/