WHAT or WHO is truly INFALLIBLE?!

  Рет қаралды 851

Called to be different. REFLECTING CHRIST.

Called to be different. REFLECTING CHRIST.

8 күн бұрын

Standing on sola scriptura is more terrifying than most care to admit! If you PNLY stand on scriptures as infallible, then you have to admit you START your belief system off of "TRUSTING" in the Catholic church to assemble the Bible correctly. See the problem with that?
Surely you can see the irrationalness of Sola Scriptura if you use some common sense and drop the pride.
Love To You All and All To You Love ❤️
God bless! 🙏
#solascriptura #Catholicism #jesuschrist #god

Пікірлер: 294
@tim_w
@tim_w 6 күн бұрын
Imagine if everyone interpreted the constitution on their own without the Supreme Court? Utter chaos.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
🤣 RIGHT!!!
@Justyouraverageguy172
@Justyouraverageguy172 6 күн бұрын
Yet Protestants claim they alone are correct in their own interpretation while claiming to have the Holy Spirit. Such blasphemy and denial of Him and hardness of heart that is the unforgivable sin will not go unnoticed by God which is why as Catholics we have to pray for them to be saved coming into salvation and the fullness of Faith if we are to obey Jesus and love our enemies as he commands us to.
@voyager7
@voyager7 6 күн бұрын
Actually the vast majority do. And they generally speaking, get it right. The Supreme Court, and the judiciary at large, do not interpret legislation including the US founding documents, for citizens on a day-to-day life basis. They _apply law_ in cases where yes, a question of interpretation to specific application is needed. But they can also get it wrong, and one sitting of the Supreme Court can indeed overturn an errant decision of one previous, like what happened starting in 1517 ;-)
@rexlion4510
@rexlion4510 6 күн бұрын
Imagine if everyone who tried to interpret the constitution could hear from one of the original drafters of the document. That's the Holy Spirit, who inspired the Bible. Do you ever listen to the Holy Spirit? Or do you just listen to the church of Rome and let them fill the role that Jesus said the Spirit is supposed to hold in your life?
@junglequeen7386
@junglequeen7386 6 күн бұрын
@@voyager7 the Catholic faith has never changed on faith and morals.. Even with our schematic brothers and sister in Orthodox church. Its always been the same. Our tradition has been past down from disciples that were being lead by the Holy Spirit. 🥰
@ednewcomer
@ednewcomer 6 күн бұрын
You're honest and sincere. Your humble approach is refreshing.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
Thank you! I truly appreciate your kind words! God bless! 🙏
@tomwells3028
@tomwells3028 6 күн бұрын
I think this is your best video. Extra points for that little cutey.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
Oh Yay! 🤗 Thank you! Babies always make videos better! 😂
@discoverybricks3694
@discoverybricks3694 6 күн бұрын
Sami nails it right at the end. I love it. The gates of hell will not prevail over The Catholic Church! She looks right into the camera and says true authority is given to The Catholic Church. Yes!
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
🙌💯😁🙅‍♀️
@paulcapaccio9905
@paulcapaccio9905 6 күн бұрын
You are so right. That’s why there are over 45,000 Protestant denominations
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
And they say scripture is all they need! 🙄😳🤣 Crazy! Just crazy!
@Justas399
@Justas399 6 күн бұрын
Do the supposed 45,000 Protestant denominations have 45,000 different interpretations of the Scriptures? If so, can you show me just 10 different interpretations on John 3:16?
@randycarson9812
@randycarson9812 6 күн бұрын
@@Justas399 Your question simply raises more questions: Is John 3:16 the only "essential"? Or are there others? Like baptism? Do Protestants agree on what these essentials are? Is there a list of essentials in scripture? Does your church have a "Statement of Faith" that it uses to establish who does and does not belong to your faith community? Have you ever been asked to sign a Statement of Faith in order to enroll your kids in a private Christian school?
@Justas399
@Justas399 6 күн бұрын
@@randycarson9812 John 3:16 is not the only essential. Baptism is not essential to salvation. If it was, Jesus would have said so in John 3. All Protestants would agree that John 3:16 is essential. If a person denies John 3:16 then he cannot be true Christian. If he denies the Trinity or the deity of Christ he would not be a true Christian. No to your last statement.
@randycarson9812
@randycarson9812 6 күн бұрын
@@Justas399 Many Protestants would disagree with you. Here's why: *Verse #1:* _“Peter replied, “Repent and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins. And you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.” (Acts 2:38)_ Notice that Peter says nothing about believing or faith or saying the Sinner’s Prayer. Baptism is the door to salvation. He also wrote: *Verse #2:* _"..baptism now saves you…" (1 Peter 3:21)_ *Verse #3:* _”Jesus answered, “Amen, amen, I say to you, no one can enter the kingdom of God without being born of _*_water_*_ and Spirit.” (Jn 3:5)_ *Using **_Modus Tollens_** to Explain the Necessity of Baptism for Salvation.* *_Modus Tollens:_* If P, then Q. Not Q, therefore, not P. *Example:* If I am in Dallas, then I am in Texas. I am not in Texas; therefore, I am not in Texas. *FINAL APPLICATION:* If you are saved (P), then you will obey Jesus and get baptized (Q). If you do not obey Jesus and get baptized (Not Q), then you are not saved (Not P).
@HAL9000-su1mz
@HAL9000-su1mz 5 күн бұрын
Protestantism is founded on the human ego. It involves Christianity, but only as the individual ego prefers it.
@BARDOCK550
@BARDOCK550 Күн бұрын
And Catholics are founded by their pope it involves the written word of God but only as their pope prefers it.
@HAL9000-su1mz
@HAL9000-su1mz Күн бұрын
@@BARDOCK550 This is totally wack. Who told you this? Not even close.
@HAL9000-su1mz
@HAL9000-su1mz Күн бұрын
@@BARDOCK550 Oh, a childish reaction! Not even close to true. And it proves what I suggested: your EGO is in charge. Thank you!
@BARDOCK550
@BARDOCK550 17 сағат бұрын
​@@HAL9000-su1mz I'm not a protestant LOL and everyone knows the pope is your daddy no way to hide the sun with a finger
@aaronmyers4665
@aaronmyers4665 6 күн бұрын
When we consider the history of Revelation, we note that in the beginning (Gen. 1:1-3), God’s Word was spoken, and yet nothing was written down. In fact, from Adam to Moses, a period of several hundreds of years passed with the Revelations given to Noah, Abraham, Joseph and others being passed orally. At least, we have no knowledge of anything being written. So, we see that there is nothing inherently defective with oral tradition, as Calvin seems to have thought in the Institutes. If God can guide the written texts, as the Protestant will admit, then He can also guide the oral transmission as well. And, in fact, if one believes the Bible, one must affirm that from Adam to Moses the Oral Revelation was passed on faithfully and perfectly to Moses and Joshua, because this is from whence arises the origin of the written texts. When we survey the Old Testament, we realize that the Patriarchs, all through Genesis, operated according to this infallible Oral Tradition, when God was not giving a new Revelation, of course. When Abraham built an altar, he didn’t have a book or written text to instruct him; he had the truths passed on from the time of Adam in the godly line of Seth, and whatever Revelations God spoke. He didn’t refer to “Genesis.”
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
Wonderful point! I haven't even considered this! Thank you for sharing! God bless! 🙏
@aaronmyers4665
@aaronmyers4665 6 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent the reformers invented Sola scriptura to establish an authority since they were excommunicated from the church's authority, but this authority proved in the Reformers day not to be correct because by who's interpretation of scriptures were doctrines formed???
@voyager7
@voyager7 6 күн бұрын
@@aaronmyers4665 I honestly wonder how people claiming to be Christian can make statements like this ("the reformers...") which are glaringly false; both historically and in the context of the theology of "the reformers" you slander. Ends justifying means though, amirite? Anyway, on the issue of oral tradition, you _are_ completely right in that divine revelation was for significant periods of time orally preserved. That's neither astounding nor conflicting with sola scriptura. Nor does it automatically validate anything brought to the table anew, claiming to be "tradition". We saw this in fact with the rejection of not only Gnostic traditions by the patristic fathers, but by Jesus Himself who chastised the Pharisees for effectively negating the word of God for the sake of their own traditions. Objectively and in fairness, this likewise is not to say that _all_ tradition is false, for there are many types of tradition. The (actual) Reformers fully and openly acknowledged this. In fact Martin Chemnitz dealt with this masterfully in his first volume of the "Examination of the Council of Trent"...which you'll no doubt surely have read, since you are well informed on "the reformers".
@PJ-go9jw
@PJ-go9jw 5 күн бұрын
It is equivalent to blinkers on a horse. They can only see what is in front of them and have no sight of things going on at the sides. Maybe they are afraid to remove the blinkers because they are concerned of what they may discover. Listening to converts to the Catholic faith it is very inspiring to existing Catholics who in turn highly respect such people because they know that it is a massive decision for them.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
I agree! It can be scary to question what you thought you knew, what you thought was true! Some will never take off the blinders because they are comfortable continuing being led, and some don't want to because admitting you may be wrong causes you to shed your pride.
@SurrenderNovena
@SurrenderNovena 6 күн бұрын
Catholicism is rich and every Catholic is wealthy - every Catholic church in the world is "ours," our home. We have the Bible, an immense source of true wealth, we have the Church Fathers and the Doctors of the Church (the youngest "doctor" is Saint Thérèse with a powerful teaching on how to love Jesus when one is weak and small (hint use an elevator to reach Jesus if the stairs are too steep and hard:). We have private revelation which, while you're not required to believe it, can adorn and enrich your faith and your life if you choose to believe. Our Catholic faith is a treasure that is always growing. We are truly richly blessed. Thank you, Jesus & Mary ❤🔥❤
@MythwrightWorkshop
@MythwrightWorkshop 6 күн бұрын
beautiful testimony. Have you ever considered a KZfaq Channel? The more the merrier! 😊 People the world over could benefit from knowing the Little Flower and her gigantic message of hope and trust. ADDENDUM: looks like you have one! Great Channel!
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
Yes ma'am we are! Thank you for sharing! God bless! 🙏
@SurrenderNovena
@SurrenderNovena 5 күн бұрын
@@MythwrightWorkshop Thank you!
@SurrenderNovena
@SurrenderNovena 5 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent God Bless you and your wonderful apostolate to share the Truth!
@Rich.-
@Rich.- 5 күн бұрын
Yes indeed! I don’t know how anybody could be more clearer than what you just said. Your truly a gifted Mom and wife. Protestants also must remember, the Bible did not exist until 300 years after the resurrection of Christ. And still, many souls were being saved through the word of God being preached vocally in public. This was truly the beginning of the early church, which was Catholic! One instance was 3000 souls were saved in one day, and that was without using a Bible! Acts 2:41. The church came before the Bible, it really is a no-brainer. Keep praying for our protestant friends out there. Keep teaching and preaching. People are listening!
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
Thank you for your encouraging words! You are absolutely correct! Scripture alone is not sufficient for understanding. If it were, then we wouldn't be so divided.
@petertherock7340
@petertherock7340 6 күн бұрын
Here is a question I have posed to Evangelical Protestants a number of times. I have never received even an attempt at a rational reply. Matthew’s Gospel records that after Jesus was born, the Holy Family fled to Egypt to avoid the tyrannical murderous intent of Herod. However, in Luke’s Gospel nothing at all is said about this flight. Luke gives an altogether different account after the birth of the Savior. So… if the Bible is the “sole infallible authority” for all Christians spread throughout the world, why this discrepancy? Is it an error? An omission? Or what? Therefore, the Church is needed to rightly interpret this difference between two of the Synoptic Gospels. But if the Church has no authority to infallibly resolve the issue, how can the myriad of competing Protestant sects resolve it? 🤔
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
That is a great point! That makes me think about books like Matthew and Mark, how the author never wrote who authored the book, but we lean on tradition of the early church fathers to tell us that is who wrote them... that's infallible enough for them, but everything else... trash 🚮 😂
@grandpahand7410
@grandpahand7410 6 күн бұрын
Great job Sami. 💚💚 When are you gonna get that cute little guy some hair? 🤣😂
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
Thank you! I'm trying! 😂 He has some peach fuzz!
@pietropanetta3329
@pietropanetta3329 5 күн бұрын
I love your expression "putting God in a box." God is not confined by only one way of communicating with His creatures. Being almighty, surely God can guide humanity inspirationally, if He so chooses - rather than just by the written word. As important as sacred scripture is, God has the flexibility to try different ways of reaching us. What do you think? By the way, it's so lovely to see you with your child.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
Exactly! Seems silly to assume God must ONLY guide us ONE way. 🥴
@JWellsUp
@JWellsUp 6 күн бұрын
Protestants can’t see a church claiming authority to interpret scripture yet they go to churches where there are preachers who claim authority over scripture and they themselves claim authority too since they can disagree with their preacher and establish their own church.😵‍💫 There’s so much more outside of scripture that can help the faithful on their walk with Jesus like prayer,adoration,meditation/contemplation, books on saints even KZfaq channels. We must remember that Jesus was a prayer warrior and a missionary for the needy. And what does Bible alone really mean to the Protestant? How does it help their walk with Jesus Christ? How does it help them in discipleship/fellowship?
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
Absolutely! 💯 🙌 They seem to like sola scriptura because they get to be the boss! 🙄
@Justas399
@Justas399 6 күн бұрын
Yet the rcc has never infallibly interpreted the Scriptures. No such work exist. That means each rc must interpret the Scriptures for themselves and can never know infallibly what a verse means. That's crazy.
@Justas399
@Justas399 6 күн бұрын
Yet the rcc has never infallibly interpreted the Scriptures. No such work exist. That means each rc must interpret the Scriptures for themselves and can never know infallibly what a verse means. That's crazy.
@JWellsUp
@JWellsUp 6 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent I commented similarly on JDs channel that it has to do with pride and disobedience. And so much more that we live in a society where it teaches to be self made independent go getter be your own boss don’t let no one tell you what to do.
@darrellperez1029
@darrellperez1029 6 күн бұрын
@Justas399 how many times has your KJV bible been changed? DO you know? What is crazy is never being able to debunk my questions, so you left the conversation. That's crazy
@EsotericAugustinian11
@EsotericAugustinian11 5 күн бұрын
Martin Luther anathema John Calvin anathema John Knox anathema ulrich Zwingli anathema king Henry 8th anathema Mohammad anathema John smith anathema
@lvx4408
@lvx4408 6 күн бұрын
I am wanting to see your channel continue to grow. Good luck! Although I love your honesty, please remember not to be too harsh on Protestants, as it will only cause them to be nonreceptive to your message...and perhaps even defensive.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
Thank you! I truly appreciate your encouraging words. I'm sorry... sometimes I get too passionate... I love all protestants... I don't mean to sound unapproachable. Maybe I'm a little salty because I fed into the lies for too long and I desperately want others to see the truth too! Thank you for keeping me honest! God bless! 🙏
@paulcapaccio9905
@paulcapaccio9905 6 күн бұрын
Everyone please read from John Bergsma , Scott Hahn , Taylor Marshall and Joe Hecshmeyer. That’s lol one needs to
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
I listen to them! They use scriptures, the tradition, and the magisterium to teach. That's why their work is helpful and fruitful! 😆
@darrellperez1029
@darrellperez1029 6 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent don't trust Marshall
@SurrenderNovena
@SurrenderNovena 6 күн бұрын
@@darrellperez1029 I agree - don't trust Taylor Marshall. His videos from years ago could be okay but anything recent is not trustworthy. Put Trent Horn in the list instead.
@junglequeen7386
@junglequeen7386 6 күн бұрын
@@SurrenderNovena Amen! Thank you. ❤
@darrellperez1029
@darrellperez1029 6 күн бұрын
@@SurrenderNovena and Jimmy Akin
@kurtmurphy5994
@kurtmurphy5994 6 күн бұрын
Yes, I was protestant.I unders dand what is said Protestants claim they have no authority other than scripture. But then they believe everything their preachers Say. So they do have some authority other than scripture in my church of Christ When I was in that denomination, they claim Sola Scriptura 2. But in this case it wasn't a preacher that had the Authority it was the church board. The head of the board was our Pope had much more authorities than the Bishop of Rome Believe me He said jump and everybody said how high. So when people say they believe in Sola Scriptura They only do to a certain point. All protestant Churches have their pope.
@voyager7
@voyager7 5 күн бұрын
Anecdotal evidence. Sola scriptura is not the position that there is no authority in the church. It orders authority however from divine to human. If you are interested in understanding rather than just giving voice to something that is limited at best, false at worst, you might read Martin Chemnitz' work on the "Examination of the Council of Trent", specifically in Volume 1 regarding tradition and the various types of traditions.
@andythecrimson8877
@andythecrimson8877 5 күн бұрын
Hello sister, God Bless you.😊 Are you still catechumen? I'm catechumen too.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
Yes, I am! I'm glad you're on your journey home, too! God bless! 🙏
@darrellperez1029
@darrellperez1029 6 күн бұрын
One verse eradicated the Solas 2 Thessolonians 2:15.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
They skip over that verse 🤣
@darrellperez1029
@darrellperez1029 6 күн бұрын
@calledtobedifferent lol. And then they refer to Ephesians 2:8-9. Or they say "that's not what Paul means."
@Justas399
@Justas399 6 күн бұрын
Can you give me a couple of examples of a tradition of Paul not found in the NT and how you know?
@darrellperez1029
@darrellperez1029 6 күн бұрын
@@Justas399 after you.
@Justas399
@Justas399 6 күн бұрын
@@darrellperez1029 I know no traditions of Paul outside the NT. No one does.
@rexlion4510
@rexlion4510 6 күн бұрын
By the way, are you sure that little man is warm enough? Small body mass = low ability to retain heat, can easily become chilled. I don't know the temp in your house, but you don't look like you're sweating or anything... be careful! 😊
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
I appreciate your concern... he is 5 months old though, so he is not affected like newborns are. I promise he is very well taken care of! We live in North Carolina so our house temp can rise over 75°F during these hot summer days! Thank you for your comment! God bless! 🙏
@scotthurban8200
@scotthurban8200 4 күн бұрын
The Protestant Churches are like the Samaritans during the time of Jesus. The Northern Kingdom broke away from the Southern Kingdom of Israel and seperated themselves from the temple. As the women at the well told Jesus, they set up new places of worship in the hills apart from the temple. The Samaritans became polluted by the influences of the pagans. Just as the Samaritans seperated themselves from the Temple and their source of atonement ( obedience to the Torah), the Protestants have cut themselves off from the sacraments, so needed to conform to the image of Christ. Many of them have become polluted by misinformation and their own pride to want to worship God THEIR own way. They have set up THEIR own churches and ask God to conform to THEIR image of Him. Still, there are good people among these churches, just as Jesus spoke of the good Samaritan. The good Samaritan was good because he did right based upon the light he was given. The Levite and the priest in the Good Samaritan story were judged for not living up to the light they were given. So we as Catholics have the light and must live up to the light we have. At the same time we must reach out to the good samaritans (Protestants) who need to come home to the temple ( Catholic sacraments) and 'taste and see that the Lord is good.' Many of them worship God from afar out of ignorance. For those Protestants who perist in calling good evil and evil good, pray for them, but wipe the dust from your feet. Let the Holy Spirit do His work, and if they do not change, they will get their reward based on God's grace and judgement.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 2 күн бұрын
So true! Thank you for sharing! This is so encouraging to hear! God bless! 🙏
@user-pm3mw8xw8d
@user-pm3mw8xw8d 15 сағат бұрын
One problem people run into is finding something outside scripture they like, but not realizing it contradicts something in scripture. A hypothetical example would be someone claiming, or a nonbiblical tradition that says, Mary is a mediator or a redeemer like Jesus when the Bible clearly says there is only one. If you decide some parts of the Bible aren't true you have no standard left to judge doctrines and beliefs by.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 13 сағат бұрын
The scripture is... "There is one GOD, and ONE MEDIATOR between God and man, the man CHRIST JESUS, WHO gave himself as a RANSOM FOR ALL." Now, if someone reads that verse slowly, they will see why Mary would not apply here... but could, in fact, still be another type of mediator. She's not THAT mediator... she never gave herself as a ransom for all. Jesus is a SPECIFIC mediator.... he is the ONE who gave himself as a ransom for all. Someone could imply that Mary can't intercede for us, but that person reads into the text what they think it says. P.S. no Catholic ever has called Mary a "redeemer."
@markpoweski3470
@markpoweski3470 5 күн бұрын
John 21:25 tells us that scripture is incomplete
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
Incomplete ... I would say no... I see what you are trying to get at. I wish I could use this as proof, but to say they are incomplete seems misleading... I would lean more towards... it proves there were unwritten mysteries. Crazy how Paul spoke about new things that were not recorded in the gospels... almost like he received new revelation / understanding from The LORD after he was chosen by Jesus to be a part of the apostolic succession. Jesus chose him, and then Paul chose those after him.
@SuperFernandinho7
@SuperFernandinho7 5 күн бұрын
💯
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
Thank you! God bless! 🙏
@prophetcentral
@prophetcentral 5 күн бұрын
I will tell you that the most concerning thing isn't that the church is trusting in the Catholic church for scripture, but it is that they are not relying upon the Holy Spirit who is the authority of distributing God's word. Thank you for speaking up. Sola Scriptura is anti-protestant, and it is anti-Christian. The Spirit of God is the authority behind any word that was written in scripture that belongs to God. If a man gives a word and it is not done by the gift and power of God's spirit, then it is not God's word. Moreover, when you ask protestants what the word of God is, most will equate it to the Bible. The Bible becomes an idol of God's word, or rather a graven man-made image of God's word that cannot allow for any more word. As you said, God is put into a box. God's words and acts cannot be contained in this world if they were all written down. I do believe that the Bible contains a great measuring stick for God's word. God isn't going to speak contrary to a word that he has already given, but that doesn't mean that God hasn't ceased speaking and giving more revelation and word that is useful for us today. They claim that we don't need more revelation for salvation, that the Bible is enough, but the Bible doesn't save us. The Word saves us. Jesus Christ saves us. Jesus Christ is the Word of God, not the Bible. We need to cease Bible idolatry. God's words have been written down in many other books. The apocryphal writings contain God's word. The Book of Mormon contains God's word. Records of many native American people contain God's word such as the Mentinah Archives. God may even speak through a homeless person on the street. We should have God's word written on our heart in order to transform us into his children and his body. The Bible is not infallible, inerrant, and holy. Jesus Christ is infallible, inerrant, and holy. If we rely upon another man or a "magisterium" or church to tell us what the scriptures mean, then we are relying upon the arm of flesh and denying the spirit to be our magisterium. Many have been led astray by the precepts of men that wrest the scriptures and deceive many. This is why we must be truly born again and be immersed in the fire and spirit of God in order to feast upon truth. God bless.
@joyinHim
@joyinHim 6 күн бұрын
Great video! Your baby is super cute! I wish I could be there and play with him too!😍
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
Thank you! God bless! 🙏
@Swish82
@Swish82 6 күн бұрын
Thou art Peter and upon this rock I will give you my Bible which contains everything you need to know about relig........ oh wait. No, it doesn't say that does it?
@revelation1215
@revelation1215 6 күн бұрын
That would’ve been cruel as the vast majority of people were illiterate. He should have said thou art Peter and under this rock I will build my printing press so that you can all interpret scripture according to your own understanding. Oh and be sure to underline everything I say in red. 😂
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
🤣🤣🤣 y'all both got me rolling!
@Swish82
@Swish82 5 күн бұрын
@calledtobedifferent or how about, Thou art Martin Luther and upon this Luther I will build my church 15 centuries from now. Until then, theologians, Saints and church leaders will be devoid of the Holy Ghost and will be incapable of interpreting my Word......" wait. It doesn't say that either does it. Hmmmmmm.
@BARDOCK550
@BARDOCK550 12 сағат бұрын
1 John 2:27 Jesus says: you need the Catholic church to teach you....oh wait it doesn't say that LOL
@Swish82
@Swish82 9 сағат бұрын
@@BARDOCK550 talk about taking scripture out of context there.
@yunusahmed2940
@yunusahmed2940 6 күн бұрын
Even if you disagree with the Catholic Church on some things and dont consider their Church "the one true church" that doesnt mean you have to disagree on their canon. (And actually protestants do disagree with their canon for the OT.) If you were to look at the available books for the NT in the early church and were to try to reassemble a canon you'd get much of the same books that exist today for the NT. There were only ever a few that were ever disputed (I.e Revelation). And you dont need the entire NT canon to know what the gospel is and be saved. Here's a good video on the methodology for determining the canon from Mike Licona kzfaq.info/get/bejne/qZZydtBjyLjcaas.htmlsi=YhWgXSZMq6QIl8xi
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
Martin Luther considered removing 7 NEW TESTAMENT books... strangely, these books went against what HE taught... He thankfully wasn't successful! But in 1825, the reformers chose to remove 7 OLD TESTAMENT books, and those were known to be scripture up until they removed them. If that's not concerning, then I don't know what is. If protestants don't think humans were given authority, then why do they accept the bible that said people assembled, and why do they think they have the authority to remove scriptures? Sola scriptura is ludicrous! Outlandish! If you stand by these, then you have lost your marbles! 🤪
@saviocoimbra7286
@saviocoimbra7286 6 күн бұрын
​@@calledtobedifferentVocê tem razão. 👍
@yunusahmed2940
@yunusahmed2940 6 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent There were different OT canons among the Jews. The protestant one is one of the most common ones. Protestants do believe humans were given authority, they just put the Word of God above any human institution. We are fallible, the Bible is not. Also, I dont know if you do the silly thing in every comment but It can come off as condescending. I wouldn't recommend it if you genuinely want to convince people to catholicism.
@perilousrange
@perilousrange 5 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent On the topic of NT canon... Although I very much like the book of James, I'm surprised that it survived. It violates Sola Fide. I would have thought that would have gotten it cut. History and tradition are important. For example, Romans 13 is pretty awful, if taken literally, without context.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
​@perilousrange It was added because the bible doesn't teach faith alone.... works are part of us cooperating with God... Jesus said if we love him we will do the Fathers will, aka... works. Protestants read "faith alone" into the bible... in fact Luther added the word "alone" into the German translation so his teaching would be true... that's terrifying. You can't change the word of God to match what you want it to say... If you don't believe in works at all then you have to skip over passages that tall about taking care of others and helping the poor... Luther wanted his cake and he wanted to eat it too... Satan convinced him he was right and he was so blind that he thought he was. If there is not authority then there is no church, only a book... a book the many interpret incorrectly.
@ThePjakes
@ThePjakes 3 күн бұрын
As far as I know, IVF treatment is not in the Bible, so who decides whether it is ethical or not. Protestants are divided on this very important issue.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 3 күн бұрын
Depends. Are you a Catholic? Then you follow what Catholics teach on this... if not, then you do whatever you want to do because there is really no standard in protestantism.
@ninjason57
@ninjason57 6 күн бұрын
Sola Scriptura is claiming that the scriptures are the sole infallible rule of faith. Not that the scripture is the only source of knowledge of the faith. You're just repeating classic Catholic talking points without even trying to study the background of the topic.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
So what do you do when you have a disagreement in the church and scripture doesn't settle it?
@ninjason57
@ninjason57 6 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent who's claiming it doesn't settle it? Jesus and Paul gave instructions for how handle disagreements amongst believers. If you're trying to insinuate that division doesn't exist in the Roman Catholic Church then you need to get the beam out of your own eye.
@revelation1215
@revelation1215 6 күн бұрын
According to wickedpedia: Sola scriptura (Latin for 'by scripture alone') is a Christian theological doctrine held by most Protestant Christian denominations, in particular the Lutheran and Reformed traditions,[1][2] that posits the Bible as the sole infallible source of authority for Christian faith and practice.[2]
@cal2224
@cal2224 6 күн бұрын
Each individual person can interpret the Bible so 10000 people 10000 pastors. Crazy but I have been told we aren’t biblical
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
If you don't like the idea of the pope... but you are down for 10,000 wanna be popes... go protestant! 😂
@BARDOCK550
@BARDOCK550 Күн бұрын
​@@calledtobedifferentwe don't like the idea of going against scripture
@BARDOCK550
@BARDOCK550 Күн бұрын
Okay you mention interpretation? What does Mathew 23:9 mean to you? What's YOUR interpretation of it?
@bigd1643
@bigd1643 6 күн бұрын
My understanding of Sola scriptura is Acts 17:11 Now the Berean Jews were of more noble character than those in Thessalonica, for they received the message with great eagerness and examined the Scriptures every day to see if what Paul said was true. We test the word of man and make sure it aliens with scripture. All Catholics say tradition. Jesus spoke about tradition and how it was wrong. The Pharisees condemned our Lord and Savior. In light of that I won’t take the pope’s dogma about things that arnt in the scripture. Everything you need for salvation is found in the Bible. Now Lutherans do have traditions most based in the catholic tradition. Like marry I believe in a virgin birth but I don’t believe she was sinless. If it was necessary for salvation God’s inspired word would say that.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
The Berean's were more noble because they didn't cause riots, and they cared to receive the oral revelation from Paul... not what the thessalonians did... they got rowdy and didn't investigate... But here's the kicker... PAUL WAS REVEALING TRUTH TO THEM! AKA...Oral truths from God! You can't point at that and say sacred tradition is trash when it is obviously being used here by Paul! Thank you for your comment! God bless! 🙏
@bigd1643
@bigd1643 5 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent so is the fact that they fact checked Paul looking back to the scripture not what this passage is saying? Does God want us to have the blind leading the blind it want us to read and study his word? Our scripture does not include the apocrypha and yours does. But Jesus does not call them scripture. Our tradition of scripture predates the Catholic Church.
@randycarson9812
@randycarson9812 5 күн бұрын
Sacred Scripture represents the letter of God’s Word; Sacred Tradition represents the meaning of God’s Word. While anyone can quote scripture to support their personal opinion, the question is: what does the scripture actually mean? Sacred Tradition provides the answer to that question. Verses _I praise you for remembering me in everything and for holding to the traditions just as I passed them on to you. (1 Co 11:2)_ _And what you heard from me through many witnesses entrust to faithful people who will have the ability to teach others as well (2 Tim 2:2)_ _We also constantly give thanks to God for this, that when you received the word of God that you heard from us, you accepted it not as a human word but as what it really is, God’s word, which is also at work in you believers (1 Th __2:13__)_ _So then, brothers and sisters, stand firm and hold fast to the traditions we passed on to you, whether by word of mouth or by letter” (2 Th __2:15__)_ Scripture tells us we are to hold on to both scripture and to oral tradition.
@randycarson9812
@randycarson9812 5 күн бұрын
@@bigd1643 In Jesus' time, there were different groups of Jews who recognized different collections of books as canonical, with some collections having indistinct boundaries. It's more precise to refer to these as different canonical traditions rather than distinct canons. Four prominent traditions were: 1. Sadducee/Samaritan Tradition: This included only the Torah or Pentateuch (Genesis to Deuteronomy). The Sadducees, therefore, rejected doctrines like resurrection, which are found outside the Torah. The Samaritan tradition was similar but used a different version of the Torah. 2. Pharisee Tradition: This tradition was still evolving and was similar to the canon later adopted by rabbinic Judaism (Protestant Old Testament). There was debate about the inclusion of specific books until at least the third century. 3. Septuagint Tradition: Also still forming in Jesus' day, this tradition resembled the canon later used in the Christian church, including deuterocanonical books, though its exact contents were debated. The books were mostly written in Hebrew or Aramaic. 4. Qumran Tradition: Used by the Qumran sect (possibly the Essenes), this tradition's closure is unknown. It was similar to the Pharisee tradition but included additional books like 1 Enoch, Jubilees, and the Temple Scroll. These traditions coexisted in first-century Palestine, with many individuals likely adhering to other variations now lost. The New Testament indicates that Jesus and his followers used the Septuagint tradition, which they transmitted to the Christian Church.
@bigd1643
@bigd1643 4 күн бұрын
@@randycarson9812 Jesus did say that the Old Testament was Genesis though the prophets. Even the catholic guy who translated the apocrypha in the 200-300 said that it was not scripture but it can be used for teaching. Catholics added the apocrypha into scripture during the reformation around 1542. There are doctrinal contradictions in the apocrypha to the Bible. So Jesus or the apostles never quoted from the apocrypha. Everyone other book on the 66 book Bible was referred to in the Bible.
@rexlion4510
@rexlion4510 6 күн бұрын
Maybe we should set aside "infallibility" for a moment and just ask, "What is the _best_ source of authority? What is the source of authority that is most trustworthy and most constant?" Wouldn't you agree that the Bible qualifies as the best, most trustworthy, most unchangeable source of authority? If so, then we should measure any church and any dogma against what we read in the Bible; we should not assume that everything which a church (any church at all) pronounces is correct. Especially not when the church has a track record of getting some stuff wrong. It's a problem when we put a denomination up on a pedestal and treat its statements as equal to (or greater than) the Scriptures. Here's a brief quote from Justin Martyr, "On the Resurrection": “The word of truth is free, and carries its own authority, disdaining to fall under any skilful argument, or to endure the logical scrutiny of its hearers. But it would be believed for its own nobility, and for the confidence due to Him who sends it. Now the word of truth is sent from God; wherefore the freedom claimed by the truth is not arrogant. For being sent with authority, it were not fit that it should be required to produce proof of what is said; since neither is there any proof beyond itself, which is God. Can we honestly say that the Catholic Church "endures the logical scrutiny of its hearers"? Can the RCC which sold indulgences for profit and which applauded the martyring of many sincere disciples of Christ through the centuries "be believed for its own nobility"? I don't think so. Popes and cardinals make mistakes on some of the biggest issues sometimes. They decided it was best to shelter pedophiles and molesters. They don't rise to the same level of authoritativeness as the Bible.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
It is equally ignorant to point fingers at what is corrupt and statement it all as worthless. Are you aware that Martin Luther and John Calvin called for their followers to stab and murder those who disagreed with their teachings. Do I need to point fingers at those men and make a blanket statement saying all protestants must be this psycho 🤔 NO! That would be ridiculous, yet that is what you are doing. Pointing at the corruption in the church and saying we should throw it all away because if there is something bad, then surely there can't be anything good. Satan loves division, but it was Jesus who said a house divided cannot stand! There are over 40,000 denominations! Seems pretty divided to me. There will always be a Judas I'm the group, but that doesn't mean we throw out the other 11 apostles and refuse to listen to them, too! Please reconsider your approach and dive deeper into the churches history. Most indulgences did not require money, yet prayers and what money they did call for were for those who could afford it, and it was very inexpensive. @shamelsspopery has a great deep dive into the topic of indulgences if you care to learn. I'll link it here.. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/ichyfaanx6y2kp8.htmlsi=KlVcvz8zTKQwoU6e God bless! 🙏
@rexlion4510
@rexlion4510 5 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent It's disappointing to see you repeating a junk statistic like the "40,000 denominations" one. The same group in CA that came up with that number also said there are hundreds of Catholic denominations; that should tell you how silly and wrong they were. If you're going to have a channel and make videos, you need to be accurate; eternal lives may depend on it. Try to look at the issue this way: how do you regard the Bible readings when they are read in church? Don't we say, "The word of the LORD" when we've heard them? Now I ask you: do we say "The word of the LORD" when we hear a Catholic Church pronouncement? We do not. Shouldn't the Bible, the word of the LORD, have primacy over all other authorities? Why do you bring up the imperfections of Luther or of Calvin? I freely acknowledge that no denomination is perfect, that no human being is perfect, and that no denomination has the same authority as the written word of God, the Bible. I admit it! Why can't you? You sound as if you practically worship your Roman denomination. You promote the Catholic Church like a sideline cheerleader, pom-poms and all. Do you ever stop to notice that I am not cheering for any denomination? I am cheering for Jesus Christ, for Him alone. Isn't that the essence of the Christian faith: to follow, serve, and lift up Jesus? So why do you devote your channel to lifting up a hierarchical earthly institution? Think about your priorities.
@angelakodicek
@angelakodicek 4 күн бұрын
I think His Church is perfect but the people who are part of It are human beings and extremely imperfect. We try to destroy His 8:28 perfection on a daily basis but He tells us we will not prevail in the end.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 3 күн бұрын
Huh? Please explain...
@angelakodicek
@angelakodicek 3 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent Look it up on Catholic Answers.
@ChrisSadowski-pp1np
@ChrisSadowski-pp1np Күн бұрын
All you need is the Bible an your good. Most sins involve breaking the ten commandments.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent Күн бұрын
I would respectively disagree! This has gotten a lot of people into false teachings and has led some astray. Jesus left us with his church for a reason. Matthew 16:18-19 Jesus established the church as a public institution to identify, support, and oversee those who believe in him. Jesus also declared, "I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it". Matthew 28:16-20 Jesus gave the disciples the Great Commission, which outlines the church's mission and purpose. The church is called to make disciples by baptizing them and teaching them what Christ has commanded. Ephesians 4:14 The church teaches biblical doctrine so that Christians can be grounded in their faith. Romans 12:10 The church is a place of fellowship where Christians can devote themselves to one another, honor one another, and more. Hebrews 10:24 Christians should go to church to encourage one another to love and do good works.
@ChrisSadowski-pp1np
@ChrisSadowski-pp1np Күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent As for Matthew 16:18 Peter was the small Stone. John 1:42. Jesus was the rock. Matthew 7:24, 1st Corinthians 10: 4. First that selling it's 5:21 says to test everything that is said in the spirit of the bereans act 17:11. That's what every believer should do. Infant baptism is not biblical. That didn't start to the 2nd century. And everywhere a structure it says you should believe first, Matthew 28:19, Mark 16:16, acts 2:38 and all the places in the Bible where someone believes before they get baptized acts 8, 9, 10, 16.Confessing your sins to a priest is not scriptural. Hebrews 4:16 says we can boldly go the throne of our gracious God. John 20:23 refers to proclaiming forgiveness to someone who accepts the good news. That's what The binding and loosening in. Matthew, 16:19 and 18:18. 1. Timothy 2:5 says there's only one God and one meat eater that can reconcile God and man and that is Christ Jesus. Purgatory is not biblical 1st Corinthians 3 :10-15 is referring to people in the ministry and 2nd Maccabees is not scripture. Exalting Mary is not scriptural .Yes, she was blessed. Luke 11:28 and she was a wife of noble character. Proverbs 31. But she was not born with that original sin. Luke 147. She didn't remain a virgin Matthew 1:25 and had additional children. Matthew 12:46-50, Mark 6:1-4, John 7, acts 1:14, Galatians 1:19 . She didn't avoid death, only Enoch Genesis 5 and Elijah 2nd Kings chapter 2 did that that. There was a woman in the Bible in Luke 11:27 that tried to exalt. Mary and Jesus shut her down. 1. Timothy 3:15 does not support the Catholic Church because that was started 300 years later with Constantine. And 2nd Thessalonians 2:15 doesn't support the encyclicals from Rome.
@ChrisSadowski-pp1np
@ChrisSadowski-pp1np Күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent Peter is the small Stone John 1:42, Jesus is The Rock, Matthew 7:24 and 1st Corinthians 10:4.
@BARDOCK550
@BARDOCK550 12 сағат бұрын
Amen, Jesus is the only way to the Father. Jesus said he is the way the truth and the life and no one comes to the Father except through the Catholic church?? NO! Except through JESUS.
@ChrisSadowski-pp1np
@ChrisSadowski-pp1np 12 сағат бұрын
@@BARDOCK550 yes, too many false teachings.
@phoenixaz8431
@phoenixaz8431 2 күн бұрын
Sola scriptura is dumb as can be. ''Well, Purgatory was never mentioned in the Bible'' Well, neither was latte, yet you're enjoying one right now. How can that be?😂 And where in the Bible is *sola scriptura* mentioned?
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 2 күн бұрын
🤣 💯🙏
@ChrisTian-tz3eq
@ChrisTian-tz3eq 6 күн бұрын
Non-believing Orthodox Jews don't believe in sola-scriptura either... And yet Jesus rebuked some of their Religious "Oral Traditions" as doctrine too. ( Matt 15 .. Mark 7 ) Was He wrong?? ...
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 4 күн бұрын
Those washings were done based on tradition ALONE and in no requard with the scripture teachings from Exodus 30:19 and 40:12... What sola scriptura means is scripture alone... but you are implying that if tradition is involved at all, it is wasteful. This doesn't make logical sense. You see, Jesus rebuked them because it was THEIR PERSONAL tradition. When we speak of the Catholic Church tradition... all traditions are held in unity with the scriptures, not apart from them. You see the sacred scriptures, sacred traditions, and magisterium work in unity together, not separated like you're implying. Your statement is very dectiful and misleading. Shame on you.
@ChrisTian-tz3eq
@ChrisTian-tz3eq 4 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent ... No, it's not shame on me, dear.. and neither am i being deceitful... ( I forgive your false accusation. ) ... Yes, the washing ritual was/is an "add on" by The Jewish Fathers, to the Commandments of God... But notice in the context of Matt 15 & Mark 7, that -That - was Not the only "tradition" Messiah had beef with... They had also made null & void the Commandment to "Honor Father & Mother" ( Exodus 20 : 12 ), in the keeping of the man-made tradition involving "corbin" ( as it pertains to adult children not being obligated to financially care for their aged parent(s), when they instead, choose to give extra offerings to the Temple.) ( Much exactly like what some of the "Fathers" of the Church had also done, in either "changing" or "making void" The Commandments Of God, in order to keep non-biblical "traditions of men"... (i.e. making void the 7th day sabbath-rest, for the 1st day - Exodus 20 : 8 - 11... Making & bowing down to graven images within the House of God - Exodus 20 : 4 - 6, in the presumption & justification that "the temple of Israel had em in the Most Holy Place, so it must be ok for us to have em too" .. (even if many of the images had once actually been images of pagan gods before being "christianized" into the Church etc.. with even the very latest, being "the pachamama incident in the Vatican") ... And you misunderstand my position on tradition... Both Hanukkah and Purim are non-obligatory traditions, that do not violate The Commandments of God... Some traditions are fine... It's when men place them over & above the Commands given in Sacred Scripture, (Torah & Prophets & Gospel) is when we have the problem. And Notice also when Messiah was being tempted by Satan in the wilderness ( Matt 4 )... Not Once did He Quote "Sacred Scripture & Oral Tradition", in the rebuking of Satan... But Quoted Sacred Scripture ALONE, Every time... "It Is Written" ( Matt 4 : 4) ... "It Is Written" ( Matt 4 : 7 ) ... "It Is Written" ( Matt 4 : 10 ) 2 Timothy 3 : 15 - 17 "And that from a child thou hast known the Holy Scriptures, which are able to make thee wise unto salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus. All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is Profitable For Doctrine, For Reproof, For Correction, For Instruction In Righteousness: That the man of God may be Perfect, Throughly Furnished Unto All Good Works." (Praise Be To God, HalleluYAH And Amen!!! )
@beespeech
@beespeech 5 күн бұрын
It's sad to see someone moving in the WRONG direction. No creeds, only Christ.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 5 күн бұрын
Do you realize that creeds were created to guard against heresies? I would completely agree...but unfortunately it is Protestants that are moving in the wrong direction. 😕
@croft5941
@croft5941 6 күн бұрын
Sweetie im really worried about you. You're always quoting the same talking points every catholic apologist uses when depfending your faith. Please dont be brainwashed by a organization that has left Jesus and maybe they never knew Jesus. This is said with love of course
@junglequeen7386
@junglequeen7386 6 күн бұрын
There is only one truth.. This isn't Burger King, "have it your way"
@eddardgreybeard
@eddardgreybeard 6 күн бұрын
The Church didn't leave Jesus, protestantism just acts as though they're the first in Christian history to read and understand scripture.
@lvx4408
@lvx4408 6 күн бұрын
Not worried about her at all
@junglequeen7386
@junglequeen7386 6 күн бұрын
@@lvx4408 She's being fed solid food, not milk.
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 6 күн бұрын
I appreciate your concern. I think we all sound the same because we are all defending the same doctrines or fighting against the same false doctrines... and therefore we cover the big issues that protestants have with the Catholic church.... if I could show you that the Catholic church is the church Jesus intended for you to be in... would you become a Catholic? If not then our conversation is over. If yes then bring me your issues and why you say the Catholic church is false. GOD bless! 🙏
@DavidTheZealot
@DavidTheZealot 3 күн бұрын
#makesundaysholyagain let's make this hashtag viral
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 3 күн бұрын
On it!
@DavidTheZealot
@DavidTheZealot 3 күн бұрын
@@calledtobedifferent wouldn't it be lovely?! I've been told before 1984 businesses weren't allowed to be open on the Lord's Day
@calledtobedifferent
@calledtobedifferent 3 күн бұрын
​@DavidTheZealot I grew up in the country... nothing was open on Sundays... wasn't until they started building developments did they start opening stores up again. 😢
WHY Catholics REPEAT PrAYeRs! #Catholic  #protestant #Jesus #bible
10:15
Called to be different. REFLECTING CHRIST.
Рет қаралды 1,3 М.
Why Sola Scriptura is true - KingdomCraft
24:06
Redeemed Zoomer
Рет қаралды 73 М.
OMG😳 #tiktok #shorts #potapova_blog
00:58
Potapova_blog
Рет қаралды 4,2 МЛН
Stop Forcing Your Faith On Me!
6:12
Just Like You & Me
Рет қаралды 634
Sola Scriptura is SCARY! #religion #catholic #protestant #bible
0:58
Called to be different. REFLECTING CHRIST.
Рет қаралды 3,5 М.
Prayer Bible Dangers (BEFORE I knew what a "Prayer Bible" was)
18:52
Crazy Simple Truth Ministries / Bible Study /
Рет қаралды 31 М.
Muslim Convert to Catholicism
2:49
St. John's Indy
Рет қаралды 10 М.
What each Christian denomination LOOKS like
5:22
Redeemed Zoomer
Рет қаралды 166 М.
My Conversion to Catholicism & Why
12:46
The Momma Diaries
Рет қаралды 25 М.
Catholics vs Protestants - 18 Differences
10:36
Nerd Robot
Рет қаралды 1,9 МЛН
Vulnerable TRUE Catholic CONVERSION! #scotthahn #Catholic #protestant #conversion #books #bookreview
13:26
Called to be different. REFLECTING CHRIST.
Рет қаралды 2,3 М.