The healing situation may just be because of the length of the battles and coincidence however they were only 10 seconds or so longer but twice the healing 🤷🏼‍♂️

I’m actually not bothered about taking severely wounded units, I’m more concerned about causing more severely wounded units to the enemy in the shortest time possible, however if this effects the healing power of your ranged march then Defence seems the way to go? If the healing wasn’t effected by these stats then I’d just keep attack attributes

Hi my friend ;) Due to my 3 KvKs experience fighting with Margaret / Babur and actually with Margaret / Gonzalo and Gajah Madah / Babur, it depends on how far is your city from the fights. Margaret / Gonzalo have lack of defense / health and Gajah Mada / Babur have 70% passive health but single target.

When unit difference is high SV taken is higher, when few units remain SW taken by both sides is increased. Meaning D/H should give more turns with high unit differential and a low march. Meaning more SW in total but less when considering time.(Proberbly)

The thing with defense and health is that you will lose less troops each counterattack you take, but the enemy as well loses less troops with each attack. They should balance each other out but, when you add healing to the mix, it doesn't care how many troops the enemy has, only how many troops you have yourself. So the healing will be bigger when you have more troops, despite how much damage you dealt to the enemy. Another thing to consider is that all stats have diminishing returns. The more you have of one particular stat the less relevant it becomes, and Crystal tech gives a lot of attack. That's why people always recommend health and favor health runes even over the attack+defense one, because the other two stats are easier to get than health in most equipment and armaments.

That’s surprising, might have to try some research with this as well

I think health might be the best. Because it adds the percentage of health of the siege which makes the “all damage” higher since their is more to the troop

i will pick attack bcs im n th longest range i want to deal more damage

I mean if you look at amount of healed troops it's the same but with defense and health heal pops off more often so there are 2 possibilities: 1. it's huge coincidence 2. defense and health somehow makes chances for heal higher.

Es na rentable que sea asedio o otra tropa?

im thinking maybe attack for Marg+Cordoba, since Cordoba's AOE doesn't give counter dmg(?), and health for Babur and Gajah... not sure am i correct

Should I go for babur cordova for my first siege march?

Watching the tests, looks like the heal just has a probability to occur, but those differences in troop stats don't seem to have a measurable impact on the heal amount of each occurrence. no equipment test: you healed 6 times for 2,816. first heal was weak since you were almost full hp. 1st attack test: you healed 3 times for 1,182. first heal was also weak since u were almost full hp. Looks like it starts healing around 550 when your march is at full stats/capacity, and decreases as your march's remaining stats/capacity decreases. Probably best to focus on equalizing defense & health to minimize damage taken from counter attacks, so that you have a higher troop capacity for each heal. More troops alive and rehealed means more troops contributing their attack, defense, and health to the march for a longer period of time. Better for single target trades or fights far from your city where you want to refresh troops less frequently (Duels, Ruins, Altars, Pass openings). Maybe attack for situations where you can hit multiple targets with Cordoba's AOE - since the extra AOE damage you deal will make up for the extra damage you take from counter attacks. Better for AOE trades or fights near your city where you can reload your damaged march more quickly (Murder balls, Frontline territory fights).

Hi tôi muốn lên một cặp chỉ huy công trình đầu tiên thì lên bộ đôi nào ❤❤❤❤

Sorry, but you are completely missing the point here. the reason people generally say "attack is the worst stat, health is the best" is not because of the inherent game mechanics, but because of the diminishing returns you get for each percent point of stats. And once you look at the stat from that perspective - in KvK (which is the situation where commanders are actually relevant), you get a ton of attack bonuses from crystal tech.

attack