I love Jolly's little power trip when nearly every single person slammed Verlander for Cy Young, then 4 seconds later wanted to switch him to ROTY

When Justin Verlander works for all 3 for Detroit

Fun fact: Al Alburquerque went 69.2 regular season innings before giving up his first career home run, but gave up a home run to the first postseason batter he faced.

Jolly tossing out hints like mardi gras beads.

Eckersley did win a Cy Young for the A's in 1992

Jolly pulling out the 'You're locked in rule' that nobody saw coming

Never thought I’d see the day the tigers get some love on this channel

I’m proud of myself for knowing to pick Scherzer for Detroit Cy Young leaving Verlander for ROTY and also getting Devin Williams for ROTY

Fun Fact: It would have been possible to put a reliever in as MVP for any of the three teams, and by extension Cy Young as well. For reference they are Dennis Eckersley for Oakland (1992), Rollie Fingers for Milwaukee (1981), and Willie Hernandez for Detroit (1984).

I really think you need to do a few seconds with the grid on the screen before they start filling it in for those who want to try at home before watching. At least enough for us to pause.

3:18 McGwire never won MVP with Oakland though, can't believe you let Jake get away with that.

you could do the Tigers one with all pitchers from the 2010s. Verlander won MVP in 2011, Scherzer won the Cy in 2013, and Fulmer got ROY in 2016.

What are we doing saying Whitaker and Kaline are “crazy pulls” 😭😭

If "big bird" counts for Mark Fidrych I would have gotten that within 30 seconds

I totally forgot Mets prospect Michael Fulmer won a ROTY those were challenging

So many people cucked themselves with Verlander at CY lol

It would be interesting to see some unconventional awards like Manager of the Year or Home Run Derby winner. Certainly a challenge but might be do-able with all the knowledge in the office.

Al Albuquerque was insane

My knowledge of Bobby Crosby winning ROTY finally came in handy! lol

Can’t believe no one said Vide Blue for Cy young

Tejada - Catfish Hunter - Bobby Crosby Yelich - Burnes - Braun Cabrera - Scherzer - Verlander I have no idea why on earth I remembered that Bobby Crosby was a rookie of the year over all those other famous A's

Was disappointed it took so long for someone to pull Mark Fidrych

Just read the new Rickey Henderson biography so I was ready to pull the deep-cut Walt Weiss for ROTY. The book is great by the way!

I might be the only person here who pulled Ben Grieve for A’s ROTY lol.

Jolly should’ve given Daulton Eckersly for the Cy Young. He won it in 1992

Don’t help them man These guys baseball knowledge is among the best in the entire country and you are giving them the years That’s weak sauce jolly and you know it sir

I could've sworn there were games where switching was allowed.

As a Tigers fan I appreciate the Al Albuquerque pull

The number of people who didn't say McGwire and Canseco was the most surprising part about this video.

Carlos Guillen was sick but he was a rookie with the Mariners

Nice Mark Fidrych pull

I was gonna comment that was surprised no Rickey Henderson shouts but until the end, also good shouts with Houston Street and Andrew Bailey

Lefty Grove-Vida Blue-Walt Weiss Robin Yount-Rollie Fingers-Ryan Braun Hal Newhouser-Max Scherzer-Lou Whitaker That's what I came up with before letting things run a bit. Had the most trouble remembering a Brewers ROTY, looked up Paul Molitor and turned out he came in second to Whitaker.

Giambi, Eckersley, Huston Street Yelich, Burnes, Braun Cabrera, Verlander, Fulmer The A’s have had three ROY winners in this century but all of them are so random: Andrew Bailey, Huston Street and Bobby Crosby

No one said the great Walt Weiss for A's ROY in 88'. I'm flabbergasted

Top row: Rickey Henderson, Barry Zito, Bobby Crosby. Middle Row: Christian Yelich, Corbin Burnes, Ryan Braun. Bottom Row: Miguel Cabrera, Max Scherzer, Justin Verlander.

Tejada - Zito - Mcgwire Yelich - Burnes - Williams Cabrera - Verlander - Fulmer

I’m really surprised as Yankees fans nobody said Giambi for A’s MVP

When I first saw the board, immediately called Verlander, McClain, Fidrych for the Tigers row

Mark Fidrych is a great pull. The Bird was the word. There is a Yankees game in the middle of the summer in a meaningless game, where the Fidrych party looked like game 7 of the world series. It's worth checking out. I think he's still the only pitcher to ever be on the cover of the Rolling Stone.

surprised nobody said Eckersley at all. One of the few A's trivia things I know.

11:30 caught me off-guard as a Tigers fan and the Phil Coke pull right after it

Tejada, Zito, McGwire, Yelich, Burns, Braun, Cabrera, Scherzer, Verlander

Props for the Fydrich shoutout!

Not me immediately thinking of Ben Grieve for Oakland ROTY 😂

Fun fact: Me. Fulmer was a Met who became a Tiger (along with Luis Cessa or Yankee Fan Fame) for.....Yoenis Céspedes.

As: Tejada, zito, Houston street Brewers: yelich, burnes, Braun Tigers: miggy, scherzer, verlander

You can fill all nine squares in only FOUR players. Canseco-Fingers-Canseco Braun-Fingers-Braun Verlander-Verlander-Verlander

Max Mannis supercut when?

The amount of people who whiffed on verlander ROY is incredible to watch

Thought I'd throw some love to Houston street for ROTY. Loved him growing up

Oh, man. Brewers AND Tigers in the same video. Time for a Fun Fact! Everyone knows about the legendary 1982 Brewers, right? Harvey's Wallbangers? Fun Fact: 30 years before he lead a team of Wallbangers to the World Series, Harvey Kuehn won the ROY... ...WITH THE TIGERS.

Somehow I pulled Mark Fidrych out of my ass for Detroit when I was born 21 years after he won. So glad I wasn't the only one to get him

Fun fact: McGwire never actually won MVP

Im screaming Bobby Crosby at my phone this whole video

Love me some A’s and Brewers trivia

I was surprised not to hear jack Morris

As: Tejada, Zito, Canseco Brewers: Yount, Fingers, Braun Tigers: Miggy, Scherzer, Verlander

The fuzzy shoutout🤣🤣

A’s: Canseco, Zito, Street Brewers: Yelich, Burnes, Braun Tigers: Cabrera, Verlander, Fulmer. The A’s and Tigers rookies I made tougher on myself than I should have 😅

Not being to switch was never a rule. I know people have switched

Rickey, Zito, McGwire Yelich, Burnes, Braun Miggy, Scherzer, Verlander

I’ve got SS Pat Listach for Milwaukee ROTY & McGwire was My immediate ROTY with 49HR’s when Jimmy was struggling I was going “ McGWIRE BRO , 49HR’s “ 😁 I should have trusted My spellings too

How can you not like Dalton!!

Thank god they finally did an episode with Detroit. Miggy, JV, Fulmer ezpz. Also, who tf calls him "Miggy Cabs"?

Giambi, Barry Zito, McGwire Yeli, Burnes, Williams Cabrera, Justin Verlander, Michael Fulmer Time: 2:14

my own grid OAK+MVP = Rickey Henderson OAK+CY = Vida Blue OAK+ROY = Mark McGwire MIL+MVP = Christian Yelich MIL+CY = Corbin Burnes MIL+ROY = Ryan Braun DET+MVP = Miguel Cabrera DET+CY = Max Scherzer DET+ROY = Justin Verlander

Only 6/9, ROTY was a huge struggle for me OAK-MVP: Jose Canseco MIL-MVP: Christian Yelich DET-MVP: Miguel Cabrera OAK-CY: Barry Zito MIL-CY: Corbin Burnes DET-CY: Max Scherzer OAK-ROTY: N/A MIL-ROTY: N/A DET-ROTY: N/A

Another idea could be something like who has thrown a no hitter for a team, or has hit 50 home runs in a season or 40 stolen bases for a team instead of just awards.

A's: MVP Miguel Tejada Cy Young: Barry Zito ROY: Bobby Crosby Brewers: MVP Christian Yelich Cy Young: Corbin Burnes ROY: Ryan Braun Tigers: MVP Miguel Cabrera, Cy Young Max Scherzer, ROY Justin Verlander

Canseco/Zito/McGwire Yount/Burnes/Pat Listach Verlander/Willie Hernandez/Fidrych Took me about 30 seconds

I know its in the thumbnail bit would be nice if you showed the empty board for a sec before jumping right into the answers so we can pause and play. love the vids tho

Random choices: Mil ROY Pat Listach Det Cy Young Willie Guiliermo Hernandez

Just now watching this and I don't know why in the deepest part of my mind I was screaming Bobby Crosby for A's Rookie of the Year.

Crazy that Verlander won all 3 with the tigers

I might be the only person that immediately went Pat Listach for Brewers ROTY

You guys should post the answers in the description, I want to play this with my dad.

I know Jolly be shopping at Target cause that’s the second time he’s worn something I have in my closet

You should do a grid where one of the answers could be the 3 guys at Jomboy

Only thing I'd like is if you could give us the sheet like 5 seconds before they start answering so I can try on my own.

I had: Henderson-Zito-Canseco Yelli-Burnes-Braun Miggy-Scherzer-Verlander I had to switch Verlander to RotY because for the life of me I couldn't think of another

McGwire, Braun, and Fidrych all seem like automatic picks for ROY.

A's ROTY in 09 is Andrew bailey

oakland : donaldson (does that count even tho he won it in TOR ? if not then canseco), zito, ooh beats me milwaukee : yelich, burnes, braun detroit : cabrera, scherzer, verlander

McGwire never won MVP but he gave it to Jake lol

Surprised people didn't remember Fulmer beating out Gary Sanchez (because he didn't play enough games even though he went crazy)

For some reason I’ll just always know that Michael Fulmer won rookie of the year

I had Mark “The Bird” Fidrych in the chamber the whole video, but did not think I’d hear his name called!

OAK: MVP: Reggie Jackson, CYA: Catfish Hunter, ROTY: Mark McGwire. MIL: MVP: Robin Yount, CYA: Rollie Fingers, ROTY: Ryan Braun. MVP: Hank Greenberg, CYA: Max Scherzer, ROTY: Justin Verlander. I would love to be apart of 1 of these and/or ref guess 1 time

Here's an idea for one: do the same kind of things with awards. Do MVP, World Series MVP and Roberto Clemente Award winner. Do it for teams who haven't won one in a while (maybe Pirates, Orioles, Twins). It would be tough since there's only two or three options for each but they're mostly franchise greats so it is possible x MVP WS MVP Clemente PIT Cutch Clemente Stargell Bal Frank Robinson Brooks Robinson Ripken Min Mauer Viola Cruz

Giambi, Zito, Street, Yelich, Burnes, Braun, Miggy, Scherzer, Verlander 1 minute, 40 seconds

Funny to think Allen Trammell has more notoriety than Lou Whittaker

Tejada, Zito (same year), McGwire, Yelich, Burnes, Braun, Cabrera, Scherzer, Verlander ez

Eckersley, Catfish Hunter, ? Yelich, Burnes, Braun Cabrera, Verlander, ?

I’m going old school for Detroit Cy Young - Denny McLain.

Watching all these Yankees fans make the Verlander mistake is too funny

A's MVP Tejada CY Zito ROY Mcgwire Brewers MVP Yelich CY Burnes ROY Braun Tigers MVP Cabrera CY Verlander ROY couldnt get

eckersley also won cy young with oakland

Tigers ROY Mark “The Bird” Fidrych

I completed this grid in 53 seconds