Whitney for me

@Alzzz Bozzz whitney

Whitney❤️

Mariah, but Whitney is still amazing. This video isn’t a great comparison IMO. You know there are about 2 octaves missing from this because Mariah is the only one that can hit them (higher and lower).

@@nadiner889 They never put them there because Mariah is superhuman 😂

Period

@@sionetonga6859 sorry for ask but what does mean period? I'm not a native English speaker

@@flyingbaloon6358 "period" basically means "end of story". 😉👍

@@eliletts5158 ending like a fact?

@@eliletts5158 thank you!!

That's cause of the technique she used.

@@THEE.apples which was?

@@shaniquacampbell1457 ur mum

@@urblack7954 you really using ur mom jokes in 2022? Get a life

Facts

Not just power, she also is a master of dynamics. She can produce the loudest most powerful sound but then in the same instance make the quietest most soft sound that can barely be heard. Compare the intro and outro of IWALY vs the climax for reference

@@onedollarbleach6891 Thank you, you read comments like this from Lambs who have no clue about Whitney...It is sad .. the illiteracy in the lamb community

Whitney wasn’t just power, only a fool would say that. Whitney’s tone was overall powerful, she couldn’t help that. Whitney had the runs, the riffs, the projection, the musicianship, the head voice, the beautiful creative changes of her songs, and the gospel roots to give her all of that emotion. You just don’t know what you’re talking about.

Whitney is just a basic cover singer with a beautiful voice. But she is overrated

@@honestperson3042 gtfoh being hater u a Mariah fan but hating on one of Mariah’s best friends gtfoh 🤡🤣you don’t need to tear somebody down to uplift your favorite artist that’s clown behavior especially when they were close friends

I also prefer the sound of Whitney's voice, but I prefer most of Mariah's songs. Her music has a lot more personality (in my opinion) than Whitney's songs do. I think Mariah is an underappreciated songwriter whose phenomenal voice has overshadowed her writing talent. Whitney was an extraordinary vocalist and vocal performer.

@@DavidMichaelCommer I've always loved Whitney's voice more than her actual material. A journalist in 1985 told her ON CAMERA that her voice was too amazing to be wasted on pop cliches. The contract she signed with Clive Davis sealed her misfortune (in terms of being relegated to the pop market) It earned her heaps of money and records but not much respect in terms of sheer artistry. I seriously wish Whitney had experimented with different genres of music (Much like Aretha had) bcuz her voice in it's prime years was simply too majestic and dynamic for pop music alone. Just imagine a young Whitney signing a hard rock song ! It might have caused an earthquake.

@@mastersuperblaster702 Yes, even if Whitney had to be relegated to music that is perceived to suit her image, the Jacksons set a great pop-rock precedent. I don't know anything about her private talents or musical interests, but she really had "the greatest voice of all," or at least some of the greatest vocal performances of all time. Mariah Carey's voice is a phenomenon, but I just happen to subjectively prefer the tone of Whitney's voice (if we have to compare) but very much appreciate that Mariah is a very talented and interesting songwriter, and when that is packed together with someone with such a vocal instrument, that's a true phenomenon. I do wish Whitney had had better material, but I don't want to take anything away from what she gave. I grew up with her music and it's part of the soundtrack of my life. I will always love it. :)

Whitney' s tone and live performance are so boring...

@@honestperson3042 Troll harder please. Obsessed lambs can't be taken seriously.

exactly

ni whiteny too

@@fnb8171 k

FACTS

To mimic the singing of Mariah Carey, you might have to put in some more effort than you would have to put on mimicking any other mainstream singer. Notably, the star sings within a particular register for long without undergoing vocal fatigue. Listen to ‘See Angels Cry’ and you will notice how enduring her voice is. Mariah Carey can hit high notes but what’s more important is that even at those high points, she still articulates the words amazingly well. What’s more, Mariah Carey can transition softly from head to whistle, chest to head and chest to whistle in a short time.

Mariah, Frank Sinatra, Steve Perry, there are many the voice, common name

@@DaniloStrever just like ur common

@@terencedavids3836 good one 🎬

Whitney is on another level without much competition. Her power and emotion is on another level all together.

Terrible comeback terrence

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/bpaFmMV-16_Yqps.html kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fquZaZl_2prMh2g.html kzfaq.info/get/bejne/id-ad5hpmKm2YHU.html kzfaq.info/get/bejne/eLyfm5h5ydmumKM.html kzfaq.info/get/bejne/rJpmiJuQ0tbYhmw.html

Mariah lacks what?

What does Whitney lack?

@@skip031890 The whistle register, for instance. lol

@@skip031890 her lower register is not that developed compared to Celiné or mariah.

Whitney probably made mariah.

Whitney also was not only a singer but a musician too... She arranged her live performances each time... It was not her following the orchestra but the other way round... If you see her 1989 Grammy performance you can see her hands conducing the orchestra while singing 🤫🤫🤫

Whitney is on another level. She is a true artist and had musicality and a voice that had never been seen before. Mariah is great too in her own right but not on the same level.

@@jacocharzukanamericanautho2422but she can’t write songs by herself

Rich or not... Mariah has the most beautiful tone I' ve ever heard, the texture of her voice... her buttery tone and her superior resonance are something else. There are many similar voices to Whitney not to mention Belinda Davids, Mariah's voice is more unique

Bom eu ñ diria em voz em diria que Ambas tem seus pontos fortes Nenhuma pode copiar a outra

Whitney the voice Power agility :)

@@alivanferreira9624 Mariah is literally known as the agility and melismatic queen for a reason tho

​@@alivanferreira9624lol no.....

Mariah is known for her agilty

Naa

Naaaaa

Most definitely singing is about feelings and Whitney makes you feel everything she sings

@@honestperson3042 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/iK6nnZqbrrzUiXk.html Mariah definitely didn’t.

@@The_Truth- Whitney was worst than anyone though kzfaq.info/get/bejne/j66AksqUvpm3oqs.html kzfaq.info/get/bejne/qdyaaMSe16fcf6M.html kzfaq.info/get/bejne/o8iTlLyJvKfVd2Q.html

I like Whitney, but she can't move me the way Mariah does.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/fcp4m5ynx6iciZ8.html

Amazing

If you like women that can go low, check out Toni Braxton and Lalah Hathaway. Similar to Mariah but a lot more depth IMO.

@@noirjack7 Mariah has more depth than any one,..

@@darinsmith3791 That’s your opinion… Leave me alone and enjoy your weekend…

Some of her lowest and highest only been heard during warmups by her background singers

Rich?How?Buttery maybe,Whitney is richer

More like Whitney's voice is far more rich while Mariahs voice is more buttery

Listen to I am changing by Whitney Houston. And know part of the reasons

Exactly!

omg u are blessed

@@ervis6926 Yes blessed and old 😅 however they were incredible moments, I will never forget them

@@vocalslover2131 you are so lucky

Which performances of Mariah did you see and what year? 😊

Ooo pls you’re a Mariah Fan and not a Whitney fan… stop lying

This is the explanation of how I feel . You can take bits and pieces from each singer and conjure up your own , opinion . For example, I love Whitney’s catalog & vocal agility a bit more than Mariah’s (because I know more whitney songs than Mariah) but what I love about Mariah and how she inspires me is her production , songwriting , musicality , wide range & tone more. Mariah is a better artist but I love both singers for different reasons

@@JaeElise Yes.. This is exactly it. It's so amazing to see that we think alike! 💗

JAUREGUlIS Technical vocalist Mariah? 🤦‍♂️ Are you okay? Mariah is a mediocre vocal technician with a small and underdeveloped instrument. And her range is bullshit. Every mosquito 🦟🦟 has a wide range full of air.Christina Aguilera, Ariana etc ... real vocal technicians have maximum 3 octaves, evenness of sound, huge chest voice and head voice, coordination etc ... Mahalia Jackson destroys Mariah.

@@fzpe856 lmaooo , you’re pressed about Mariah , Christina , Ariana having larger ranges than Whitney ?? They all deserve their spot , of course whit and Mariah better than both but they legends in their own way ( all of them)

@@fzpe856 this comment... im hoping this is us being trolled.

. Mariah is better than Whitney.No matter how mad and angeed it makes you it's proven fact

@BlackMamba The vocal coach opinion will be more valuable than yours anyway , as it is enlighted by her knowledge of vocal pedagogy unlike you.Anyway professional'l claims prevails over the opinion of fans

Facts

Jay Walker99 it does...

It's harder to sing in full voice like Whitney did compared to mariah.

@@THEE.apples No.Mariah's singing is harder

@@hyomalitsukikagye5249 it's not about singing harder. Whitney had complete freedom with her range. That's why she is the voice. Mariah had to obviously modify her vowels to sing her runs. Mariah may have a higher range but she is lacking basic tonal quality.

Lol😂

Not the best artist for sure. She had little to none artistry.

@@philipcohen267 what?

Mariah is better vocally and artistically. What a joke 🤣

No ma'am...The devil is a lie

Range doesn't matter tbh. Whitney's range is just amazing a 2 octaves of even scale with a well controlled voice.

@@razzil2414 It does matter though. Mariah had full mastery of her seventh octave. She could control her seventh octave like no other you would have seen.

@@philipcohen958 If that would be the case Georgia Brown, Adam Lopez, Nicola Sedda destroys Mariah.

@@razzil2414 No they aren't. They never showed the crazy skills shown by Mariah in the whistle register. Mariah has been consistent with whistle AND has mastered fioratura abilities in whistle. Minnie Riperton and Chante were the only ones who could show somewhat of a mastery, yet not close to Mariah.

Obviously. This video was probably made by some Whitney Stan who doesn't want to disfigure his idol

Mariah songbird Supreme PERIOD

that makes no sense. You mean her sound.

No, this really makes sense for someone who is a good connoisseur.

@@CRF_Breno19 BAHAHHAHAHAHA CONNOSISSEUR ARE YOU KIDDING ME

@@CRF_Breno19 everything else. What do you mean everything other than technique singing is technique THAT"S ALL THERE IS. TECHNIQUE.

@@yesyes3392 no, i'm not.

So grateful we had both. I’m more of a Mariah fan but I can never say she outsang Whitney. I cannot choose. I will not choose. I think it’s who’s voice the listener most identifies with, that’s who they’ll think is the better vocalist. I choose both.

Not really. lol.

Whitney owns Mariah

this is not even Mariah's full vocal showcase because her range is unlimited during her prime idk about whitney

They both does?

not true

Are you even familiar with Mariah’s music?? Why on EARTH would you even include songs like “Obsessed or I know what you want” ?? Like do you only know her singles??? Those are some of easiest vocals!! Those could’ve been replaced with “Can’t let go” “So Blessed” or “If it’s Over”

Is this your verzuz battle list? 👀

Also vocally by far

Mariah is better vocally by far

@@DaniloStrever nah

@@thetruth.7858 nah

@coreyflemming9424 perfectly said

bridget o. this was never meant to compare their tone. It's their vocals. And whether you like it or not, Mariah is technically better than Whitney

@@appanoodles ...Its ok 🤰👶 Stay 💪 We all know that Mariah is "technically" better. And not just because I prefer a smoother controlled sound over a loud hollering and screaming sound.. No ma'am...Its just Facts... Guinness 📖 of records...Umm Mariah is 👸....🙋

@@appanoodles....I'm not sure what you speak... but I'm sure it doesn't change the facts...🙋

@@appanoodles ....💁Hey listen I get it.. However if Kevin and myself are speaking about FACTS💆...And 'YOU' don't understand...🤔It's sounds like your the one with the problem😒 But let's cut this short even though the back and forth is cute🙇..This is simple.... It doesn't matter who you compare with who...😇Whitney was a powerful singer and a true Lamb🐑 would never disrespect 😇Whitney but when it comes to 😇Whitney and 👸Mariah....Facts are Facts.... PERIOD..🙋

@@appanoodles ...I said what I said...and it only hurts so much for you because my original comment was based on Facts and not an opinion like yours...Period Pooh...and I'm done with it

She still had a fantastic range and I agree bigger range doesn't mean better.

True

@BlackMamba Lol Really ? And is that why you Whitney's fans often claim that your fave is the greatest ??? Mariah is better than Whitney, that's my point. Don't bring other singers to make a point. Aretha Franklin is the Queen of Soul, she's better than Mariah on singing soul , Mariah is the queen of Christmas, of whistle register, of melisma, R&B, of Pop/Hip Hop, she's better on singing these all genres than Aretha, as well as innall these vocal techniques and skills..As for Maria Callas , she is a classical/ operatic singer ,she cannot be in comparison with mainstream singers .Next try

@BlackMamba Vocal coaches opinion ? Even their statements would really be only their opinion, It's still better to take theirs thanbthe ones from delusional biased fans.Theirs are not partial and is based on their grounded knowledge

@BlackMamba And don't put words in my mouth please, I never said Mariah was the Queen of head voice neither of power lol, even though she has a beautiful head voice that she doesn't use as much as other singers, and that her is powerful , there's other notable singers that demonstrate more vocal power. And yes, Mariah is the queen in the other areas mentioned and even more. Queen of remixes, Queen of vocal transistions, Queen in vocal versatility and technical diversity, etc...Mariah shine both vocally and artistically/ musically, Unlike Whitney who is a very one-dimensional singer who is a belter who can be only in comparisons about belting , Mariah is a melismatic singer, a belter, a whistler, etc...while other singers can be found in comparisons involving only belting and vocal runs. No wonder why unlike Whitney, Mariah has been in video comparisons about the best melismatic singers, the best whistlers , the best low register singers ( Toni Braxton, Nina Simone, etc) ,the best growlers, the best falsetto singers, etc

Mariah Carey SLAYING In Every Register and Techniques. The most versatile and complete vocalist that has ever held a mic, hands down ! kzfaq.info/get/bejne/bJ2qkplluNmyqqc.html

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/iK6nnZqbrrzUiXk.html not according to this.

@@The_Truth- you do know that is out of her prime right?

@@takemyhand1988 Sure, but there are people older than her out of the prime who wouldn't do that.

@@The_Truth- yes she damaged her voice faster.

@@takemyhand1988 Yes , I know but she didn’t need to pump out that many albums in that short amount of time

U right!

Such a foolish thing to say... there is no comparison of Whitney and Mariah even icon status. You can easily create a whistle register but vocal prowess is a God given gift

@@LettingGo757 recite my statements on where I compared them for the other to be deteriorated.

@@LettingGo757 The whistle register is the hardest register to access. Controlling it the way Mimi does is on a whole other level. + Mimi has shown is still vocal Legend when she doesn't use her upper register. They both legendary, have several seats.

@@LettingGo757only a fool would say what you just said. you can easily create a whistle register? I know for a fact you were dropped as a baby 😂

Whitney minie reperton Aretha Celine :/

I did not instantly fall in love with her. However, I instantly fell in love with Mariah. Different folks, different strokes.

@@spanishlessons4075 Good for you. When Mariah can deliver flawless un-dubbed live vocals and captivate an audience like this, we’ll talk. 👇🏾 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/gdiAo7yTrp6wYYk.html

@@spanishlessons4075You’re right. I instantly fell in love with Whitney and not Mariah. 😂

@@thewayofway1 I believe you. We're different individuals with different taste for music. I love Whitney, but Mariah is the only one that can reach deep into my heart.

I totally agree. I felt that Mariah had the better songs, but she wrote her own material and I liked Whitney’s voice better out of the two

Whitney is the better singer, Mariah is the better artist, Céline is the better performer

She didn’t in this video, Whitney just overpowers on almost every note. Her notes are so clear and powerful

Colatura abilities?How?U will only have colatura abilities if u have developed head voice

yes, and Whitney’s too

🥊🥊 Knuck-if-You-Buck. "Declined Mariah is compared to Prime Whitney" You must've been huffing on paint fumes in the twighlight zone when you wrote that. At no point in Mariahs career has she ever been as consistent, powerful, creative (live on stage) as Whitney. Having a higher octave range means a hill of nothing in the grand scheme. Ariana Grande has a bigger range than Whitney, does that make Ariana better than Whitney? Don't even answer that rhetorical question. Whitney excelled in so many other areas where Mariah would fail miserably (or fake it with her famed lip syncing presentations) Try as best as you can to absorb this-- possessing a bigger octave range doesn't make you superior, it simply means you have a bigger range...nothing more. What matters is how you utilize what you have. What so many of you Lambs fail to understand is aside from natural ability/talent, the most important aspect of singing is the ability to reach through the listeners heart by delivering a song with feeling, depth and emotion (something Whitney truly excelled in) not how high/low you can sing, or how many acrobatic transitions you can do. This is MUSIC, not the Olympics. As far as I know, The Olympics have yet to unveil a category for big octave range vocalists. Keep in mind Whitney grew up singing Gospel while Mariah grew up LISTENING TO soul/R&B Records, then used her "5 octave" bag of tricks to lend her best impressions of it when she landed herself a record deal. Never compare a gospel rooted singer to an imitator with a bigger octave range.

Mariah better technique and vocal abilities. She was the most skilled vocalist ever

@@TheMastersuperblaste excellent post

@@TheMastersuperblaste You my friend speak perfect sense. To be honest Mariah over sings notes. You do not need to sing 10 notes when one is enough. The America is beautiful live performance as good as it was , is IMO oversung. You can't even understand what Mariah is singing about in half of it.

when your last name is carey... we know what you'll spew