Who are nuclear weapons scientists? | Hugh Gusterson | TEDxFoggyBottom

  Рет қаралды 29,146

TEDx Talks

TEDx Talks

Күн бұрын

Most people study nuclear warfare by studying the new developments in the weapons themselves. Hugh Gusterson takes a different approach. Instead of studying the weapons, he studies the nuclear scientists who created them. He took to the TEDxFoggyBottom stage to share what he learned.
Dr. Gusterson’s research focuses on the interdisciplinary study of the conditions under which particular bodies of knowledge are formed and deployed, with special attention to the science of war, the military, and nuclear weapons.
His research addresses the problem of how to understand knowledge as a cultural formation, and how to analyze the historical and structural transformations of science and technology. He asks questions such as: How do cultures of science initiate and shape participants? How can we critically assess universalist claims about scientific and military “truths?” How do scientists justify their complicity with the projects of nation-states?
This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at ted.com/tedx

Пікірлер: 53
@benjaminmyers5299
@benjaminmyers5299 5 жыл бұрын
This video is full of half-truths and bad information. For example, the missile he showed at the end and purported to be equipped with "several" nuclear warheads was an old Titan II, which had a single, large warhead, and was withdrawn from service more than 30 years ago, in the 1980's. The Peacekeeper (MX) has been been withdrawn from service, and the remaining Minuteman III missiles have all been offloaded of their multiple warheads and now carry only 1 warhead each. These people need to check their facts before they adopt these pseudo-moralistic virtue signalling positions if they want to have any credibility; I can tolerate sanctimony if the signaler has a decent argument- if they don't, I have no patience for it.
@wilhelmheinzerling5341
@wilhelmheinzerling5341 4 жыл бұрын
Little detail such as that photo detears you from seeing the big picture?
@CHAOSTHERAPHY
@CHAOSTHERAPHY 4 жыл бұрын
Thanks 👍
@evanr4575
@evanr4575 8 жыл бұрын
Nice Video
@justinserra4844
@justinserra4844 6 жыл бұрын
Well he lied/mislead about the Arnold part, it's to study Fusion for creation of energy, and yes that is what a hydrogen bomb is but you use lasers to create electricity instead of a fission bomb to fuse hydrogen.
@Inertia888
@Inertia888 5 жыл бұрын
an intentional lie. I expect higher standards from Ted. this talk is a let down.
@frankieromnimon5898
@frankieromnimon5898 5 жыл бұрын
justin serra No he did not. The cover story is that NIF tries to develop inertial confinement fusion for energy production, while the reality is that the conditions at the time of implosion are the same as inside a hydrogen bomb when it lets go. Much cheaper to study and design advanced thermonuclear weapons using NIF's lasers than by trying to break in secret a signed international treaty.
@r.c.1881
@r.c.1881 3 жыл бұрын
Even if the NIF had nothing to do with nukes, the DoD people can come and ask for the results of their experiments whenever they want to. The datas collected in there will make their way to a wapon's lab anyways.
@WaterTea22
@WaterTea22 3 жыл бұрын
It's enough to look at the lab goals (on their website...) to know that it isn't true. yeah, their research will contribute sometimes to fusion research, but that's not their main goal, nor a minor one (at least that's what I think). Also, the main research needed today to get fusion to work is plasma-related research (how to control and stabilize it for long periods), which is not what they are doing. you want to make fusion a reality- go work on iter or something.
@Eldooodarino
@Eldooodarino 2 жыл бұрын
@@r.c.1881 DoD isn't involved in the design and production of nuclear weapons. That is the DOE's job.
@vishalk1985
@vishalk1985 5 жыл бұрын
Wow ...... He had such an easy access to nuclear scientists and workers . God save them from spies
@Eldooodarino
@Eldooodarino 2 жыл бұрын
spies are everywhere. They wouldn't have been telling him stuff that's classified.
@server1ok
@server1ok 2 жыл бұрын
The're just a bunch of fragmented software developers. What you want is the weapon or access to a Military facility. In this case, I bid you good luck and farewell 🥲
@WormholeJim
@WormholeJim 7 жыл бұрын
My take on the NW-building scientist was that a common trait would be patriotism. I'm not entirely convinced that that isn't the case, but it is really surprising to me that they should think they are ensuring peace down in those labs. And it really, really doesn't strike me as a savoury logic, especially not when put forth by people who you'd think would be able to pick up on the inherent absurdity. Perhaps if put on edge, it will become clear: We need nuclear weapons to prevent nuclear war. That's the logic of the statment. Insane.
@CarbonGlassMan
@CarbonGlassMan 5 жыл бұрын
That is sound logic. We need nuclear weapons to prevent nuclear war, precisely because other countries that do not like us have them. My uncle use to get picked on in school because he was small, so he decided to live in the weight room. After a year of eating brewers yeast and cartons of eggs and lifting weights every day, he was pretty big. He said "I wanted to be big enough that I didn't have to fight." And that worked out very well for him. Before he was large, he fought all the time because he was attacked all the time. After he got big, he never fought again. That is the exact same logic and we use it all the time.
@atwaterpub
@atwaterpub 6 жыл бұрын
"Prepare for doom." - Zobo the Clown
@ccosborn2000
@ccosborn2000 8 жыл бұрын
Nice video -- would be better with some sound.
@Czeckie
@Czeckie 8 жыл бұрын
What strikes me is the high proportion of religious people among nuclear weapons scientists. I know, this is quite a shady area, but numerous studies about religiosity among scientists are consistent with their findings, that only a small proportion of them are religious.
@asieriths2850
@asieriths2850 7 жыл бұрын
I believe studies in the US put religiosity at around 64% christian
@nutellapatella1396
@nutellapatella1396 4 жыл бұрын
Watching this while playing fallout 4
@swissneutro2648
@swissneutro2648 2 жыл бұрын
There is no justification for nuclear weapons. (Not even for uranium ammunition.) This decoupling - annihilation at the push of a button - virtually, without being there oneself, without visible blood on the hands, should never have taken place! So millions can die and nobody feels responsible. The poor civilians in the two cities served as a playground, where two different bombs could be tested, and, as the main reason for the operation, to show the Soviet Union where the hammer hangs. Because the defeat of Japan was already certain. As if that were not enough, the alleged victors came into the country and examined the contaminated people like laboratory rats. There was no help. Thus they rejected any humanity from themselves. No people, only objects of investigation! Ergo, humanism has no value, geostrategy undermines everything else. Also a common sense, which enables us all in the everyday life to live together. Otherwise the bombs would not have fallen.
@oliversharpe2689
@oliversharpe2689 Жыл бұрын
I get what you are saying about nuclear weapons nowadays, and although Japan was bound to lose, a full invasion would have taken more casualties from both sides. The two bombs dropped were justifiied.
@JernejJerin
@JernejJerin 7 жыл бұрын
I absolutely agree and share the same belief, nuclear weapons are the ones responsible that there hasn't been a WW3 already.
@leodarksam6230
@leodarksam6230 6 жыл бұрын
Jernej Jerin Yeah while the USA gets to destroy and steal the resources from entire countries that don't possess nuclear weapons (Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan).
@CarbonGlassMan
@CarbonGlassMan 5 жыл бұрын
@@leodarksam6230 Liar. We didn't steal anything from them.
@lawrencetate145
@lawrencetate145 Жыл бұрын
That's a pretty passive-aggressive career... isn't it?
@junkjunk81
@junkjunk81 Жыл бұрын
There seems to be an attitude in the video and the comments of "but what are the scientists *real* motivations?" The motivations are simple and exactly what all of them say it is: peace. They are scientists. They rely on data, and the data for nuclear weapons says that such weapons have prevented major wars. Without such weapons, it is virtually impossible to imagine a scenario where World War 3 doesn't break out between the NATO and Warsaw Pact countries.
@casualBob7
@casualBob7 Жыл бұрын
it's not his only point. if ww3 happens millions or tens of millions will die. if nuclear war happens (most likely mistakenly which it almost did 3 times that we KNOW off) hundreds of millions if not billions will die. The scientist say they think they are creating peaceful tools since if they couldnt live with themselves if they thought otherwise. so they cope/lie to themselves which is a natural behavior
@aliceinwonder8978
@aliceinwonder8978 Жыл бұрын
That's all lies. If you know the history of nukes you know its fraught with many doomsday close calls. And its only a matter of time before they get used again, and then god save us all. More power to destroy the world doesnt prevent war. Nukes have already been used many times, and people killed from them both in testing and war. To be for them is lunacy.
@annettah13
@annettah13 2 жыл бұрын
2122
@zitstif
@zitstif 2 жыл бұрын
Ted talks are jokes
@alexanderpersson4824
@alexanderpersson4824 2 жыл бұрын
scientists in church?
DAD LEFT HIS OLD SOCKS ON THE COUCH…😱😂
00:24
JULI_PROETO
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН
ВОДА В СОЛО
00:20
⚡️КАН АНДРЕЙ⚡️
Рет қаралды 30 МЛН
Pleased the disabled person! #shorts
00:43
Dimon Markov
Рет қаралды 27 МЛН
Playing hide and seek with my dog 🐶
00:25
Zach King
Рет қаралды 34 МЛН
8 ways the world could suddenly end: Stephen Petranek at TEDxMidwest
22:52
Nuclear fusion within reach | Michel Laberge | TEDxKC
14:02
TEDx Talks
Рет қаралды 427 М.
Crows, smarter than you think | John Marzluff | TEDxRainier
22:14
TEDx Talks
Рет қаралды 1,2 МЛН
There Are Some Fates Worse Than Death: Mike Drowley at TEDxScottAFB
15:49
DAD LEFT HIS OLD SOCKS ON THE COUCH…😱😂
00:24
JULI_PROETO
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН