The fact that BBD’s drafted team has a grand total of 1 more homer than the 2023 Braves and 2019 Twins really shows how insane those line ups performed.

been internally screaming barry bonds the entire video and just remembered it was only al east players

2021 Semien has to be a first round pick

This was very fun with everyone taking it seriously. Some of the trivias have been kinda annoying with Jimmy and as much as I like him, Joez basically half trolling the videos.

JOLLY could you hit us with any behind the scenes stats? best possible lineup? position with the biggest HR disparity? that’d be dope

This is absolutely hilarious, would love to see this with other divisions/stats - RBIs would be fun, Ks for hitters where you want big numbers would be fantastic

BBD's strategy worked for what he was trying to do: he won 4 of the five infield positions. Ultimately not effective in the game, since he was unable to turn in a solid outfield. Interesting case study in maximizing for the wrong goal.

I really like this format. I want to see Jolly compete in an NL East version

Crazy no one picked the 2021 Marcus Semien

Donaldson 2015 was is always so slept on

I have to imagine people forget because he's remembered moreso as a 90's guy or something, but Carlos Delgado's 00, 01 and 03 were all ~40 HR seasons

Honorable Mention C 03 Jason Varitek (25 HR) 1B 07 Carlos Pena (46 HR) 2B 21 Marcus Semien (45 HR) SS 21 Bo Bichette (29 HR) 3B 15 Josh Donaldson (41 HR) OF 09 Adam Lind (35 HR) OF 09 Jason Bay (36 HR) OF 03 Vernon Wells (33 HR) DH 03 Jason Giambi (41 HR)

Lucas should ALWAYS be a part of any game played on this channel.

Perfect video. Can’t wait to see the other five. Pitching wins maybe a good idea too. Jolly if you show the best possible lineup at the end that would be really cool. Well done as always.

I really enjoyed this. I love all the JM personalities in their own way, but these 3 really try hard every time and take it seriously and I love seeing that.

This was a lot of fun! I would love to see more content just like this. 🙂

Jolly comes up with the best ideas. Keep up the good work!

Absolutely love this game! Can't wait to see the other divisions

Love this!! Can't wait for the other divisions

This was a fantastic idea for a trivia game. Y'all are straight killing it lately on the content. Playing along, was proud of my myself for getting the Bag Papi best year, nabbed the good Soriano season, and if you don't use A-Rod at third, snuck a lucky Longoria 31 HR in 2011.

This is a great concept, loved the video, now you can do all the divisions!🔥🔥

This format is great would love to see more

Love this style, so many possibilities you can do with this

Very cool episode. Loved it

Love these types of drafts! I’ve seen some other channels do a penalty for guessing the wrong year (like -10 and guess again) I like the stakes it adds for those guys who maybe only played a year with the team. Great video though, I hope there’s more to come!

The videos are so much better when you get insane competitors together like this

was screaming marcus semien

This is am amazing game format. Looking forward to more of these

This is an awesome idea! Great vid

I absolutely love these trivia videos!

Absolutely need more of these

Great video. Good job all around boys

This is a great idea. Good job Jolly

Love the format of this one

I think this is the best team possible for this: C Gary Sanchez (2019) 34 1B Chris Davis (2013) 53 2B Marcus Semien (2021) 45 3B Alex Rodriguez (2007) 54 SS Gleyber Torres (2019) 38 OF Aaron Judge (2022) 62 OF Jose Bautista (2010) 54 OF Mark Trumbo (2016) 47 DH David Ortiz (2006) 54 Total 441

Would love to see the wild guesses that come out once yall leave the AL East

This game is GREAT! A specific division too makes it durable for five more - bravo!

This is my new favorite series

i love watching these videos!

Do this next time with Joez, Lucas, and whoever you want as a third. Joez would be getting so pissed at lucas for his knowledge he would think he was cheating and it would be hilarious entertainment. Joez is a legend

Love this, it’s gonna be hard to do this for different divisions but will be easy to do for different stats, most Ks most loses RBIs most Fwar that would be great

This was a brilliant game. Absolutely fun.

I love this idea do Al west next

Please do more of these!!!! Let me do one with the guys!!!

Bill Simmons used to do the NBA drafts with the same kinda idea, I think he’d treat it like wine vintage. Mr. Fancy. Love the vids guys!!

Love the Arron hill shoutout. Used to be my favorite Jay back in the day before we traded him to the D-backs

Weird, I mean Semien's second baseman's single-season HR record just set like 2 years ago, but no one picked him as the 2B😂

I would love to see this again with the other divisions.

Loving the Dan Flashes phone case from BBD

Great format! Excited to see more of these for other divisions!

2021 semien was the easy no Brainer choice for second, hit the most homers for a 2b in baseball history, I was surprised Donaldson wasn't chosen either

More of this please.

I caught Nelson Cruz’ home run off Jon Lester on opening day in 2014, his first as an oriole

👍 Do more of these...all the divisions.

We need more of this format for the other divisions

More of this please

As a Jays fan, I was thinking 2010 Bautista right after Judge was taken. After Bautista went, I began fixating on 2015 Donaldson. Good catch with Edwin, he somehow slipped my mind with all my brain power reminiscing on Donaldson’s MVP year. I was also surprised no one went early-mid 2000s Manny

This video is awesome. Would be cool to somehow float the remaining positions or score counter as the game is going.

Like this format

This is an amazing idea

Great game!

Please more videos like this!!!!!

Great vid idea

This is a fantastic idea

BBD, jake, lucas is a fantastic combo

I think this would be cool to do not only limited to one division across the last 20ish years, but just the entire league last year, maybe with a 4th person to spread players out a bit more, but I get the format is kinda set on 3 players. Even with perfect knowledge, outside of the top few picks, there would be an interesting strategy as you dont necessarily want to pick the player with the most homeruns, but the player with the most homeruns over the next player at that position. And of course without perfect knowledge, youll have some fun off the wall guesses to make the game entertaining.

Love this draft

Best mlb lineup since 2000: C 2021 Salvador Perez - 48 1B 2006 Ryan Howard - 58 2B 2021 Marcus Semien - 45 3B 2019 Eugenio Suarez - 49(since you cant use arod for 3B and SS) SS 2002 Alex Rodriguez - 57 OF 2001 Barry Bonds - 73 OF 2001 Sammy Sosa - 64 OF 2022 Aaron Judge - 62 DH 2017 Giancarlo Stanton - 59

my lineup C Matt Wieters 2012 - 23 1B Carlos Pena 2007 -46 2B Jorge Cantu 2005 - 28 3B Josh Donaldson 2015 - 41 SS Bo Bichette 2021 - 29 OF B.J Upton 2012- 28 OF Jacoby Ellsbury 2011- 32 OF Hideki Matsui 2004 - 31 DH Jonahton Schoop 2017- 32 total 290

I love this game

10/10 idea!

Do more of these! Even do it by only allowing a decade at a time ! Or you could break it down to only a decade and only a certain division !

Great format! I was shocked nobody said Semian or Donaldson

Good stuff

Would be cool to see this with starters and strikeouts

Woulda been so on brand for Lucas to take ‘61 M+M boys as his outfield

Nice to see zunino get some love

Dang why just AL East? Do this video for each division! Also, if they guess the player but during a year where they were in another division they should have to move on from that player until their next turn and give someone else a chance to guess the correct year if they want

Fun game!

Great game kinda like BDGEs fantasy drafts. You should do HRs by division from the 80s to Now

Feel like you should be given the players best year if you can't guess it but otherwise love this concept

I really love this game. My line up will be C Christian Vazquez (Red Sox 2019) 1B Logan Morrison (Rays 2017) 2B Brandon Lowe (Rays 2021) SS Derek Jeter (Yankees 2001) 3B Evan Longoria (Rays 2011) OF Austin Meadows (Rays 2019) OF Trey Mancini (Oriols 2019) OF Adam Jones (Oriols 2013) DH Josh Donaldson (Blue Jays 2015)

I want y’all to do it again

Manny Ramirez not being in the first few rounds is WILD

Is there a way next time at the end you could tell us what combination would yield the highest score? Or am I gonna have to do it myself😂

Gotta do every division now

Brandon Lowe was one I was upset wasn’t included. Easily best 2b year for homers

This is tough due to the years

Thinking about Dozier

I wanted to see Manny Ramirez and a fun Brady Anderson snipe haha

Lucas going for Aaron Hill was quite the deep cut.

I was yelling Marcus Semien for 2021 the whole time.

Donaldson 2015, Lowe 2021, Semien 2021, Betts 2018 was in my mind the whole video and they never picked them😭😭

Was screaming carlos pena 07. I thought he broke 50 but knew he was a monster in 07 The Show.

I wish these trivia videos weren't so heavily biased towards Yankees fans

Jake bragging about his Mike Zunino pick but everyone else already drafted a Catcher so he could have just saved that for later.

21 semien, 21 salvy, 17 stanton all should be top picks

i feel like if you guess a player that wasn’t in AL east you should be forced to pick a diff player instead of giving of a second shot at the year

Im shocked semien 2021 wasn't the 2nd overall pick, such an advantage at 2nd base

2021 Marcus Semien has left the chat